Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

On the Supposed Conceptual Inadequacy of the Shannon Information

Christopher G. Timpson

Published Dec 30, 2001• 8 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

In Phys. Rev. A 63 022113 (2001), Brukner and Zeilinger claim that the Shannon information is not well defined as a measure of information in quantum mechanics, adducing arguments that seek to show that it is inextricably tied to classical notions of measurement. It is shown here that these arguments do not succeed: the Shannon information does not have problematic ties to classical concepts. In a further argument, Brukner and Zeilinger compare the Shannon information unfavourably to their preferred information measure, I(p), with regard to the definition of a notion of `total information content'. This argument is found unconvincing and the relationship betwen measures of information and notions of `total information content' investigated.

Related papers

Comment on "Conceptual Inadequacy of Shannon Information ..." by C. Brukner and A. Zeilinger

Michael J. W. Hall

It is pointed out that the case for Shannon entropy and von Neumann entropy, as measures of uncertainty in quantum mechanics, is not as bleak as suggested in quant-ph/0006087. The main argument of the latter is based on one particular interpretation of Shannon's H-function (related to consecutive measurements), and is shown explicitly to fail for other physical interpretations. Further, it is shown that Shannon and von Neumann entropies have in fact a common fundamental significance, connected to the existence of a unique geometric measure of uncertainty for classical and quantum ensembles. Some new properties of the ``total information'' measure proposed in quant-ph/0006087 are also given.

arXiv:quant-ph/0007116•Jul 31, 2000•8 citations

The Applicability of Shannon Information in Quantum Mechanics and Zeilinger's Foundational Principle

Christopher G. Timpson

Recently, Brukner and Zeilinger have presented a number of arguments suggesting that the Shannon information is not well defined as a measure of information in quantum mechanics. If established, this result would be highly significant, as the Shannon information is fundamental to the way we think about information not only in classical but also in quantum information theory. On consideration, however, these arguments are found unsuccessful; I go on to suggest how they might be arising as a consequence of Zeilinger's proposed foundational principle for quantum mechanics.

Philosophy of Science•Dec 1, 2003•11 citations

Information and The Brukner-Zeilinger Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics: A Critical Investigation

A. Shafiee, F. Safinejad, F. Naqsh

In Brukner and Zeilinger's interpretation of quantum mechanics, information is introduced as the most fundamental notion and the finiteness of information is considered as an essential feature of quantum systems. They also define a new measure of information which is inherently different from the Shannon information and try to show that the latter is not useful in defining the information content in a quantum object. Here, we show that there are serious problems in their approach which make their efforts unsatisfactory. The finiteness of information does not explain how objective results appear in experiments and what an instantaneous change in the so-called information vector (or catalog of knowledge) really means during the measurement. On the other hand, Brukner and Zeilinger's measure of information is derived basically from a definition of variance for a binomial distribution. This quantifies the dispersion of methods for putting N constituents of a system into two different groups and illustrates, principally, the distinction between the frequency of occurrence and the probability of occurrence of an event. So, it does not qualify as a proper measure of information.

•Jan 1, 2004•9 citations

Conceptual inadequacy of the Shannon information in quantum measurements

Časlav Brukner, Anton Zeilinger

In a classical measurement the Shannon information is a natural measure of our ignorance about properties of a system. There, observation removes that ignorance in revealing properties of the system which can be considered to preexist prior to and independent of observation. Because of the completely different root of a quantum measurement as compared to a classical measurement, conceptual difficulties arise when we try to define the information gain in a quantum measurement using the notion of Shannon information. The reason is that, in contrast to classical measurements, quantum measurements, with very few exceptions, cannot be claimed to reveal a property of the individual quantum system existing before the measurement is performed.

arXiv:quant-ph/0006087•Physical Review A•Jan 18, 2001•172 citations

The properties of the Shannon entropy are not violated in quantum measurements

PierGianLuca Porta Mana

Brukner and Zeilinger [Phys. Rev. A 63 (2001) 022113] have claimed that two properties of the Shannon conditional entropy are violated in quantum experiments. It is shown here that the analysis by which they support their claim is flawed by the fact that they mix (probabilities and) entropies relative to different contexts, i.e., different experimental arrangements. It is also argued that the context-dependency of the Shannon entropy has nothing to do with the quantum or classical nature of experiments.

•Feb 6, 2003•1 citation

On the Brukner–Zeilinger approach to information in quantum measurements

Alexey E. Rastegin

We address the problem of properly quantifying information in quantum theory. Brukner and Zeilinger proposed the concept of an operationally invariant measure based on measurement statistics. Their measure of information is calculated with probabilities generated in a complete set of mutually complementary observations. This approach was later criticized for several reasons. We show that some critical points can be overcome by means of natural extension or reformulation of the Brukner–Zeilinger approach. In particular, this approach is connected with symmetric informationally complete measurements. The ‘total information’ of Brukner and Zeilinger can further be treated in the context of mutually unbiased measurements as well as general symmetric informationally complete measurements. The Brukner–Zeilinger measure of information is also examined in the case of detection inefficiencies. It is shown to be decreasing under the action of bistochastic maps. The Brukner–Zeilinger total information can be used for estimating the map norm of quantum operations.

arXiv:1506.07617•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Nov 1, 2015•18 citations
In Phys. Rev. A 63 022113 (2001), Brukner and Zeilinger claim that the Shannon information is not well defined as a measure of information in quantum mechanics, adducing arguments that seek to show that it is inextricably tied to classical notions of measurement. It is shown here that these arguments do not succeed: the Shannon information does not have problematic ties to classical concepts. In a further argument, Brukner and Zeilinger compare the Shannon information unfavourably to their preferred information measure, I(p), with regard to the definition of a notion of total information content'. This argument is found unconvincing and the relationship betwen measures of information and notions of total information content' investigated.
It is pointed out that the case for Shannon entropy and von Neumann entropy, as measures of uncertainty in quantum mechanics, is not as bleak as suggested in quant-ph/0006087. The main argument of the latter is based on one particular interpretation of Shannon's H-function (related to consecutive measurements), and is shown explicitly to fail for other physical interpretations. Further, it is shown that Shannon and von Neumann entropies have in fact a common fundamental significance, connected to the existence of a unique geometric measure of uncertainty for classical and quantum ensembles. Some new properties of the ``total information'' measure proposed in quant-ph/0006087 are also given.
Recently, Brukner and Zeilinger have presented a number of arguments suggesting that the Shannon information is not well defined as a measure of information in quantum mechanics. If established, this result would be highly significant, as the Shannon information is fundamental to the way we think about information not only in classical but also in quantum information theory. On consideration, however, these arguments are found unsuccessful; I go on to suggest how they might be arising as a consequence of Zeilinger's proposed foundational principle for quantum mechanics.
In Brukner and Zeilinger's interpretation of quantum mechanics, information is introduced as the most fundamental notion and the finiteness of information is considered as an essential feature of quantum systems. They also define a new measure of information which is inherently different from the Shannon information and try to show that the latter is not useful in defining the information content in a quantum object. Here, we show that there are serious problems in their approach which make their efforts unsatisfactory. The finiteness of information does not explain how objective results appear in experiments and what an instantaneous change in the so-called information vector (or catalog of knowledge) really means during the measurement. On the other hand, Brukner and Zeilinger's measure of information is derived basically from a definition of variance for a binomial distribution. This quantifies the dispersion of methods for putting N constituents of a system into two different groups and illustrates, principally, the distinction between the frequency of occurrence and the probability of occurrence of an event. So, it does not qualify as a proper measure of information.
In a classical measurement the Shannon information is a natural measure of our ignorance about properties of a system. There, observation removes that ignorance in revealing properties of the system which can be considered to preexist prior to and independent of observation. Because of the completely different root of a quantum measurement as compared to a classical measurement, conceptual difficulties arise when we try to define the information gain in a quantum measurement using the notion of Shannon information. The reason is that, in contrast to classical measurements, quantum measurements, with very few exceptions, cannot be claimed to reveal a property of the individual quantum system existing before the measurement is performed.
Brukner and Zeilinger [Phys. Rev. A 63 (2001) 022113] have claimed that two properties of the Shannon conditional entropy are violated in quantum experiments. It is shown here that the analysis by which they support their claim is flawed by the fact that they mix (probabilities and) entropies relative to different contexts, i.e., different experimental arrangements. It is also argued that the context-dependency of the Shannon entropy has nothing to do with the quantum or classical nature of experiments.
We address the problem of properly quantifying information in quantum theory. Brukner and Zeilinger proposed the concept of an operationally invariant measure based on measurement statistics. Their measure of information is calculated with probabilities generated in a complete set of mutually complementary observations. This approach was later criticized for several reasons. We show that some critical points can be overcome by means of natural extension or reformulation of the Brukner–Zeilinger approach. In particular, this approach is connected with symmetric informationally complete measurements. The ‘total information’ of Brukner and Zeilinger can further be treated in the context of mutually unbiased measurements as well as general symmetric informationally complete measurements. The Brukner–Zeilinger measure of information is also examined in the case of detection inefficiencies. It is shown to be decreasing under the action of bistochastic maps. The Brukner–Zeilinger total information can be used for estimating the map norm of quantum operations.