Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Springer eBooks

Cartwright’s Models are Not Adequate for EPR

Jacek Cachro, Tomasz Placek

Published Jan 1, 2003• 1 citation
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/978-94-017-2612-2_16

Related papers

On Cartwright's models for EPR

Jacek Cachro, Tomasz Placek

Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics•Sep 1, 2002•3 citations

The Principle of the Common Cause, the Causal Markov Condition, and Quantum Mechanics: Comments on Cartwright

Iain Martel

Nancy Cartwright believes that we live in a Dappled World-a world in which theories, principles, and methods applicable in one domain may be inapplicable in others and in which there are no universal principles. One of the targets of Cartwright's arguments for this conclusion is the Causal Markov condition, a condition which has been proposed as a universal condition on causal structures.2 The Causal Markov condition, Cartwright argues, is applicable only in a limited domain of special cases and thus cannot be used as a universal principle in causal discovery. I have no dispute with any of these claims here. Rather, I wish to argue for a very limited thesis: that the Causal Markov condition is applicable in the specific domain of microscopic quantum mechanical systems; further, that the condition can fruitfully be applied to the much discussed EPR setup. This is perhaps a surprising conclusion, for it is precisely in this domain that Cartwright's arguments against the Causal Markov condition have been considered to be the most successful.

Routledge eBooks•Jun 3, 2008•1 citation

The EPR paradox revisited

Cyrus D. Cantrell, Marlan O. Scully

Physics Reports•Jul 1, 1978•47 citations

Comment on `Is the EPR paradox really a paradox?'

Roland Onmès

European Journal of Physics•Jan 1, 1999•0 citations

Reply by Cartwright

Iain Martel offers a very nice model for EPR, an especially natural one for quantum realists because it takes the quantum state entirely seriously. The entangled quantum state of the two particles exists at the instant of measurement in both the left-hand and right-hand wings of the experiment. It, in conjunction with the operating apparatus, produces new nonentangled states for the two particles in each wing; it produces one state “with its left hand” and the other “with its right hand”. All that is strange is that a spatially extended cause acts “all at once” in two different places.

Routledge eBooks•Jun 3, 2008•0 citations

Correlazioni quantistiche e realismo causale

Alessandra Melas

This Ph.D. thesis is about causality in Quantum Mechanics, namely about the possibility to provide a causal explanation for quantum Einstein – Podolsky – Rosen (EPR) correlations.The well-known interpretation of the Bell’s Theorem by Bastian Van Fraassen, who inferred that quantum correlations cannot be embedded in any causal model, compels us to suppose that microscopic nature cannot have a causal structure and that causality is an anthropological concept.However, this interpretation is not commonly accepted and this doctoral thesis is the first general overview of some recent works about causal explanation for EPR correlations. Particularly, it analyses the possible causal explanations for the EPR/Bohm experiments by means of the Hans Reichenbach’s model, by means of backward causation models, and by means of models that imply a direct causal link. In order to do it, it pays particular attention to the Relativistic space-time features and it considers the studies in the History of Philosophy about the link between causal arrow and temporal arrow. Moreover, this work aims to endorse the idea that the best way to explain EPR/Bohm correlations causally is to adopt an indeterministic non-Reichenbachian common cause model, particularly Cartwright’sgeneral forksmodel.My conclusion is that causal models for quantum correlations remain viable, and that there is no contrast between genuinely indeterministic interpretation of Quantum Theory and causal explanation, with the philosophical implication that the Causal Realism is still acceptable.

•Feb 23, 2010•0 citations
Nancy Cartwright believes that we live in a Dappled World-a world in which theories, principles, and methods applicable in one domain may be inapplicable in others and in which there are no universal principles. One of the targets of Cartwright's arguments for this conclusion is the Causal Markov condition, a condition which has been proposed as a universal condition on causal structures.2 The Causal Markov condition, Cartwright argues, is applicable only in a limited domain of special cases and thus cannot be used as a universal principle in causal discovery. I have no dispute with any of these claims here. Rather, I wish to argue for a very limited thesis: that the Causal Markov condition is applicable in the specific domain of microscopic quantum mechanical systems; further, that the condition can fruitfully be applied to the much discussed EPR setup. This is perhaps a surprising conclusion, for it is precisely in this domain that Cartwright's arguments against the Causal Markov condition have been considered to be the most successful.
Iain Martel offers a very nice model for EPR, an especially natural one for quantum realists because it takes the quantum state entirely seriously. The entangled quantum state of the two particles exists at the instant of measurement in both the left-hand and right-hand wings of the experiment. It, in conjunction with the operating apparatus, produces new nonentangled states for the two particles in each wing; it produces one state “with its left hand” and the other “with its right hand”. All that is strange is that a spatially extended cause acts “all at once” in two different places.
This Ph.D. thesis is about causality in Quantum Mechanics, namely about the possibility to provide a causal explanation for quantum Einstein – Podolsky – Rosen (EPR) correlations.The well-known interpretation of the Bell’s Theorem by Bastian Van Fraassen, who inferred that quantum correlations cannot be embedded in any causal model, compels us to suppose that microscopic nature cannot have a causal structure and that causality is an anthropological concept.However, this interpretation is not commonly accepted and this doctoral thesis is the first general overview of some recent works about causal explanation for EPR correlations. Particularly, it analyses the possible causal explanations for the EPR/Bohm experiments by means of the Hans Reichenbach’s model, by means of backward causation models, and by means of models that imply a direct causal link. In order to do it, it pays particular attention to the Relativistic space-time features and it considers the studies in the History of Philosophy about the link between causal arrow and temporal arrow. Moreover, this work aims to endorse the idea that the best way to explain EPR/Bohm correlations causally is to adopt an indeterministic non-Reichenbachian common cause model, particularly Cartwright’sgeneral forksmodel.My conclusion is that causal models for quantum correlations remain viable, and that there is no contrast between genuinely indeterministic interpretation of Quantum Theory and causal explanation, with the philosophical implication that the Causal Realism is still acceptable.