Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Routledge eBooks

Reply by Cartwright

Published Jun 3, 2008• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Iain Martel offers a very nice model for EPR, an especially natural one for quantum realists because it takes the quantum state entirely seriously. The entangled quantum state of the two particles exists at the instant of measurement in both the left-hand and right-hand wings of the experiment. It, in conjunction with the operating apparatus, produces new nonentangled states for the two particles in each wing; it produces one state “with its left hand” and the other “with its right hand”. All that is strange is that a spatially extended cause acts “all at once” in two different places.

DOI
10.4324/9780203895467-25

Related papers

Duality or Unity in Quantum Mechanics

Jonathan Deutsch

In the double slit experiment - - central to quantum mechanics and thus to all of reality - - when you LOOK at the particle, it always passes through ONLY ONE slit - - EITHER the right slit OR the left slit, acting like a particle. However, when you AREN’T looking at it, it somehow always passes through BOTH slits - - the right slit AND the left slit - - at the same time, acting like a wave. All of nature is now KNOWN to be both wave and particle simultaneously - - actually, one entity (“wavicle”), not two - - at the most fundamental level of reality. However, no one seems to have ever asked the question: How can anything, much less everything, be in TW0 places at the same time AND ALSO SIMULTANEOUSLY be in ONLY ONE place at the same time? The known laws of physics make this absolutely impossible. Therefore, at least one of our laws must be wrong. In some fundamental mathematical and physical sense, 2 MUST ALSO BE (- - EQUAL- -) 1: 2 AS 1. The right and left slits, seemingly opposite, must at the deepest level of reality be “married” to each other - - one slit, not two. Extending this argument to Schrodinger’s cat, life and death, seemingly opposite, must at the deepest level of reality be “married” to each other, 2 AS 1. Just as all apparent opposites, it must be true that ultimately, life and death must be one thing, not two. This, then, is an all-optimistic physics - - probably the first such theory ever. But it is based entirely on firm scientific fact.

•Aug 1, 2020•0 citations

Towards an Einsteinian Quantum Mechanics

Alireza Jamali

A rational approach to understanding quantum mechanics is presented in which one is able to account for the observation that two spinning particles, irrespective of their space-time separation, can be correlated in EPR-like experiments.

•Mar 1, 2021•2 citations

Realism in Quantum Mechanics and a New Version of the EPR Experiment

Karl Popper

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1985•36 citations

A realistic device that simulates the non-local PR box without communication

Sven Aerts

A black box with two input bits and two output bits is called a non-local PR box, if the XOR of the output bits equals the AND of the input bits. In a recent article, Cerf et al. show that Alice and Bob, using such a PR box, can effectively simulate entanglement without the need of communication. We show that an adaptation of a model due to Dirk Aerts, yields a realistic simulation of the non-local PR box without communication. Because the model is entirely realistic, it cannot violate relativistic constraints. Like a non-local box, it can be used to simulate the singlet state coincidence probabilities, but the time to complete the observation of the outcome will exceed the time it takes a photon to travel one arm in an EPRB setup. The model explicitly shows how to produce an outcome that is locally perfectly random, but nevertheless determines what happens in the other wing of the experiment, without communication taking place between the two wings. In this sense, it can serve as an accurate metaphor for the mechanism of entanglement. The model considerably strengthens the claim that no communication is necessary to simulate entanglement.

arXiv:quant-ph/0504171•Apr 22, 2005•13 citations

Generalization of Spin Operators

Moeen Kh. Srour, Munther T. Al-Mokayed, Abdalkarim N. Sahmoud +1 more

The study shall look to the group of generators SU(4). From these generators, a new group spin operator will be constructed. We will classify these groups into right handed groups and left handed groups. These two groups will satisfy all the properties of Pauli spin operators Sx, Sy and Sz with respect to the frame xyz. The analysis shows that the number of groups spin operators depends on the order of the group. This leads us to construct the theorem which defines the number of the groups spin operators. The analysis also leads to two kinds of frames: left handed frame (LHF) and right handed frame (RHF). The right handed operators will act on the RHF, and left hand operators act on the LHF. The study shall discuss the notion of spin squeezing for pure spin 3/2 system by using our new frames and new spin operators. It will show that our calculation is equivalent to the calculation by using Pauli spin operators.

Journal of Applied Mathematics and Physics•Jan 1, 2022•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics and Physical Reality

Guido Bacciagaluppi, Elise Crull

This is a reprinting of Wolfe’s response to the EPR paper. Wolfe insists upon an epistemic reading of the wavefunction, arguing that, under such an interpretation, the EPR paradox dissolves.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 14, 2024•0 citations
Iain Martel offers a very nice model for EPR, an especially natural one for quantum realists because it takes the quantum state entirely seriously. The entangled quantum state of the two particles exists at the instant of measurement in both the left-hand and right-hand wings of the experiment. It, in conjunction with the operating apparatus, produces new nonentangled states for the two particles in each wing; it produces one state “with its left hand” and the other “with its right hand”. All that is strange is that a spatially extended cause acts “all at once” in two different places.
In the double slit experiment - - central to quantum mechanics and thus to all of reality - - when you LOOK at the particle, it always passes through ONLY ONE slit - - EITHER the right slit OR the left slit, acting like a particle. However, when you AREN’T looking at it, it somehow always passes through BOTH slits - - the right slit AND the left slit - - at the same time, acting like a wave. All of nature is now KNOWN to be both wave and particle simultaneously - - actually, one entity (“wavicle”), not two - - at the most fundamental level of reality. However, no one seems to have ever asked the question: How can anything, much less everything, be in TW0 places at the same time AND ALSO SIMULTANEOUSLY be in ONLY ONE place at the same time? The known laws of physics make this absolutely impossible. Therefore, at least one of our laws must be wrong. In some fundamental mathematical and physical sense, 2 MUST ALSO BE (- - EQUAL- -) 1: 2 AS 1. The right and left slits, seemingly opposite, must at the deepest level of reality be “married” to each other - - one slit, not two. Extending this argument to Schrodinger’s cat, life and death, seemingly opposite, must at the deepest level of reality be “married” to each other, 2 AS 1. Just as all apparent opposites, it must be true that ultimately, life and death must be one thing, not two. This, then, is an all-optimistic physics - - probably the first such theory ever. But it is based entirely on firm scientific fact.
A black box with two input bits and two output bits is called a non-local PR box, if the XOR of the output bits equals the AND of the input bits. In a recent article, Cerf et al. show that Alice and Bob, using such a PR box, can effectively simulate entanglement without the need of communication. We show that an adaptation of a model due to Dirk Aerts, yields a realistic simulation of the non-local PR box without communication. Because the model is entirely realistic, it cannot violate relativistic constraints. Like a non-local box, it can be used to simulate the singlet state coincidence probabilities, but the time to complete the observation of the outcome will exceed the time it takes a photon to travel one arm in an EPRB setup. The model explicitly shows how to produce an outcome that is locally perfectly random, but nevertheless determines what happens in the other wing of the experiment, without communication taking place between the two wings. In this sense, it can serve as an accurate metaphor for the mechanism of entanglement. The model considerably strengthens the claim that no communication is necessary to simulate entanglement.
The study shall look to the group of generators SU(4). From these generators, a new group spin operator will be constructed. We will classify these groups into right handed groups and left handed groups. These two groups will satisfy all the properties of Pauli spin operators Sx, Sy and Sz with respect to the frame xyz. The analysis shows that the number of groups spin operators depends on the order of the group. This leads us to construct the theorem which defines the number of the groups spin operators. The analysis also leads to two kinds of frames: left handed frame (LHF) and right handed frame (RHF). The right handed operators will act on the RHF, and left hand operators act on the LHF. The study shall discuss the notion of spin squeezing for pure spin 3/2 system by using our new frames and new spin operators. It will show that our calculation is equivalent to the calculation by using Pauli spin operators.