Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

AIP conference proceedings

A Numerical Procedure for Coupled Integro-Differential Equations of Irreversible Quantum Dynamics

K. Lendi

Published Jan 1, 2003• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

For the most general quantum master equations, also called Nakajima‐Zwanzig or non‐Markovian equations, we first define sufficient conditions [1] on convolution integral kernels and inhomogeneity functions in order to derive with mathematical rigor an upper bound on solutions, as required by the von Neumann conditions. The considered type of equations is of basic importance for general quantum dynamics of open systems with arbitrary couplings to environment and arbitrary entangled initial states. They are of particular need in time‐resolved studies on very short scales down to femtoseconds where Markovian equations fail to reproduce relevant dynamical details, as is due to time rescaling, averaging over the free evolution and subsequently taking the van Hove‐limit. The derivation is based on an equivalent coherence‐vector representation [2] in finite dimension n leading to coupled Volterra integrodifferential equations of second kind and convolution type in an (n2 − 1)‐dimensional real vector space. This formulation is particularly suited for setting up a numerical procedure for the solution of concrete problems. An effective algorithm is provided by a generalized Adams‐Moulton method [3] of order 3 which also allows to treat time‐dependent external driving fields. The related Fortran code is written according to similar conventions as used for programs in the nag‐Library. Number of iterations and convergence details are monitored for a desired final accuracy within double‐precision. Successful tests have been executed for analytically solvable cases for n = 2. All this is motivated by the fact that exact solutions can hardly be found but appropriate trial functions may provide a good semiphenomenological description of complicated quantum dynamics. Various examples will be presented as an illustration.

DOI
10.1063/1.1571340

Related papers

Quantum simulation of non-Markovian dynamical systems

Abtin Ameri, Arkopal Dutt, Hari Krovi

Existing quantum algorithms for simulating dynamical systems -- from Hamiltonian simulation to linear and nonlinear differential equations solvers -- simulate Markovian dynamics, in which the system's future evolution depends solely on its current state. We turn our attention to developing quantum algorithms for non-Markovian dynamical systems where the system's future evolution depends on its past history and thus has memory. Specifically, we develop efficient algorithms for linear Volterra integro-differential equations (VIDEs) with a convolution memory kernel that output a quantum state encoding the state description over a time interval or at a particular time. Given efficient circuits for the problem inputs, our algorithms achieve an exponential speedup in system size over existing classical algorithms. We develop an algorithm for general kernels assuming that $\textsf{M} < 1$, where $\textsf{M}$ characterizes the strength of the memory term relative to the dissipation of the Markovian part of the dynamics. We complement this with lower bounds for general-kernel VIDEs when $\textsf{M} \geq 1$, showing that the problem becomes intractable for a family of systems. However, by specializing to structured kernels which admit concise decompositions over exponentials, we develop efficient quantum algorithms even when $\textsf M \geq 1$ by converting the VIDE into a larger set of ODEs, a procedure which we call Markovianization. As an application of the overall framework, we discuss the Mori-Zwanzig formalism used in open quantum systems and fluid dynamics. Overall, our results expand the range of dynamical systems that quantum computers can simulate efficiently.

quant-pharXiv:2608.13533•Aug 14, 2026•2 citations

Nonequilibrium quantum dynamics in the condensed phase via the generalized quantum master equation

Ming-Liang Zhang, Being J. Ka, Eitan Geva

The Nakajima-Zwanzig generalized quantum master equation provides a general, and formally exact, prescription for simulating the reduced dynamics of a quantum system coupled to a quantum bath. In this equation, the memory kernel accounts for the influence of the bath on the system's dynamics, and the inhomogeneous term accounts for initial system-bath correlations. In this paper, we propose a new approach for calculating the memory kernel and inhomogeneous term for arbitrary initial state and system-bath coupling. The memory kernel and inhomogeneous term are obtained by numerically solving a single inhomogeneous Volterra equation of the second kind for each. The new approach can accommodate a very wide range of projection operators, and requires projection-free two-time correlation functions as input. An application to the case of a two-state system with diagonal coupling to an arbitrary bath is described in detail. Finally, the utility and self-consistency of the formalism are demonstrated by an explicit calculation on a spin-boson model.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jul 28, 2006•90 citations

Projection Operator Techniques

Heinz‐Peter Breuer, Francesco Petruccione

Abstract This chapter is devoted to the foundations and to the basic mathematical structure of the non-Markovian quantum dynamics of open systems. It gives a survey of the Nakajima–Zwanzig projection operator methods with the help of which one derives so-called generalized master equations for the reduced system dynamics. In the non-Markovian regime, these master equations involve a retarded memory kernel, i.e. a time-convolution integral taken over the history of the reduced system. The chapter also describes an alternative method of particular relevance in many applications, which is based on a time-local quantum master equation, and which is known as the time-convolutionless projection operator method. This method serves as a starting point for a systematic expansion in terms of ordered cumulants and forms the basis for a non-Markovian stochastic unravelling of the reduced system dynamics.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jan 25, 2007•19 citations

Nakajima-Zwanzig versus time-convolutionless master equation for the non-Markovian dynamics of a two-level system

Andrea Smirne, Bassano Vacchini

We consider the exact reduced dynamics of a two-level system coupled to a bosonic reservoir, further obtaining the exact time-convolutionless and Nakajima-Zwanzig non-Markovian equations of motion. The system considered includes the damped and undamped Jaynes-Cummings model. The result is obtained by exploiting an expression of quantum maps in terms of matrices and a simple relation between the time evolution map and the time-convolutionless generator as well as the Nakajima-Zwanzig memory kernel. This nonperturbative treatment shows that each operator contribution in Lindblad form appearing in the exact time-convolutionless master equation is multiplied by a different time-dependent function. Similarly, in the Nakajima-Zwanzig master equation each such contribution is convoluted with a different memory kernel. It appears that, depending on the state of the environment, the operator structures of the two sets of equations of motion can exhibit important differences.

arXiv:1005.1604•Physical Review A•Aug 18, 2010•95 citations

The Transfer Tensor Method: an Analytical Study Case

Marcel Morillas-Rozas, Alberto López-García, Gonzalo Reina Rivero +2 more

The transfer tensor method is a versatile tool for analyzing and propagating general open quantum systems. It captures in a compact manner all memory effects in a non-Markovian system through a straightforward transformation of a set of dynamical maps. Transfer tensors provide the exact convolutional propagator associated with a given time discretization over the past evolution of an open quantum system. Here we show that, for any finite time discretization, the memory kernel of the Nakajima Zwanzig equation deviates from the exact transfer tensors, although both converge in the continuous-time limit, as expected. We examine this behaviour in the context of an analytically solvable model: a two level atom resonant with a lossy cavity in the Jaynes Cummings limit. The atomic dynamics separate into two decoupled degrees of freedom -- the coherence and the population inversion. We derive exact expressions for the dynamical map, the transfer tensors and the memory kernel governing the coherence, and we relate them to their counterparts for the population inversion. As a function of the ratio between the cavity loss rate and the atom-cavity coupling strength, we identify regions of enhanced non-Markovianity in which the system can be described as fully Markovian for certain time-step choices.

quant-pharXiv:2603.08458•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Mar 10, 2026•1 citation

Extension of the Nakajima-Zwanzig approach to multitime correlation functions of open systems

Anton Ivanov, Heinz‐Peter Breuer

We extend the Nakajima-Zwanzig projection operator technique to the determination of multitime correlation functions of open quantum systems. The correlation functions are expressed in terms of certain multitime homogeneous and inhomogeneous memory kernels for which suitable equations of motion are derived. We show that under the condition of finite memory times, these equations can be used to determine the memory kernels by employing an exact stochastic unraveling of the full system-environment dynamics. The approach thus allows us to combine exact stochastic methods, feasible for short times, with long-time master equation simulations. The applicability of the method is demonstrated by numerical simulations of two-dimensional spectra for a donor-acceptor model, and by comparison of the results with those obtained from the reduced hierarchy equations of motion. We further show that the formalism is also applicable to the time evolution of a periodically driven two-level system initially in equilibrium with its environment.

arXiv:1702.04411•Physical Review A•Sep 11, 2015•25 citations
For the most general quantum master equations, also called Nakajima‐Zwanzig or non‐Markovian equations, we first define sufficient conditions [1] on convolution integral kernels and inhomogeneity functions in order to derive with mathematical rigor an upper bound on solutions, as required by the von Neumann conditions. The considered type of equations is of basic importance for general quantum dynamics of open systems with arbitrary couplings to environment and arbitrary entangled initial states. They are of particular need in time‐resolved studies on very short scales down to femtoseconds where Markovian equations fail to reproduce relevant dynamical details, as is due to time rescaling, averaging over the free evolution and subsequently taking the van Hove‐limit. The derivation is based on an equivalent coherence‐vector representation [2] in finite dimension n leading to coupled Volterra integrodifferential equations of second kind and convolution type in an (n2 − 1)‐dimensional real vector space. This formulation is particularly suited for setting up a numerical procedure for the solution of concrete problems. An effective algorithm is provided by a generalized Adams‐Moulton method [3] of order 3 which also allows to treat time‐dependent external driving fields. The related Fortran code is written according to similar conventions as used for programs in the nag‐Library. Number of iterations and convergence details are monitored for a desired final accuracy within double‐precision. Successful tests have been executed for analytically solvable cases for n = 2. All this is motivated by the fact that exact solutions can hardly be found but appropriate trial functions may provide a good semiphenomenological description of complicated quantum dynamics. Various examples will be presented as an illustration.
Existing quantum algorithms for simulating dynamical systems -- from Hamiltonian simulation to linear and nonlinear differential equations solvers -- simulate Markovian dynamics, in which the system's future evolution depends solely on its current state. We turn our attention to developing quantum algorithms for non-Markovian dynamical systems where the system's future evolution depends on its past history and thus has memory. Specifically, we develop efficient algorithms for linear Volterra integro-differential equations (VIDEs) with a convolution memory kernel that output a quantum state encoding the state description over a time interval or at a particular time. Given efficient circuits for the problem inputs, our algorithms achieve an exponential speedup in system size over existing classical algorithms. We develop an algorithm for general kernels assuming that M<1\textsf{M} < 1M<1, where M\textsf{M}M characterizes the strength of the memory term relative to the dissipation of the Markovian part of the dynamics. We complement this with lower bounds for general-kernel VIDEs when M≥1\textsf{M} \geq 1M≥1, showing that the problem becomes intractable for a family of systems. However, by specializing to structured kernels which admit concise decompositions over exponentials, we develop efficient quantum algorithms even when M≥1\textsf M \geq 1M≥1 by converting the VIDE into a larger set of ODEs, a procedure which we call Markovianization. As an application of the overall framework, we discuss the Mori-Zwanzig formalism used in open quantum systems and fluid dynamics. Overall, our results expand the range of dynamical systems that quantum computers can simulate efficiently.
The Nakajima-Zwanzig generalized quantum master equation provides a general, and formally exact, prescription for simulating the reduced dynamics of a quantum system coupled to a quantum bath. In this equation, the memory kernel accounts for the influence of the bath on the system's dynamics, and the inhomogeneous term accounts for initial system-bath correlations. In this paper, we propose a new approach for calculating the memory kernel and inhomogeneous term for arbitrary initial state and system-bath coupling. The memory kernel and inhomogeneous term are obtained by numerically solving a single inhomogeneous Volterra equation of the second kind for each. The new approach can accommodate a very wide range of projection operators, and requires projection-free two-time correlation functions as input. An application to the case of a two-state system with diagonal coupling to an arbitrary bath is described in detail. Finally, the utility and self-consistency of the formalism are demonstrated by an explicit calculation on a spin-boson model.
Abstract This chapter is devoted to the foundations and to the basic mathematical structure of the non-Markovian quantum dynamics of open systems. It gives a survey of the Nakajima–Zwanzig projection operator methods with the help of which one derives so-called generalized master equations for the reduced system dynamics. In the non-Markovian regime, these master equations involve a retarded memory kernel, i.e. a time-convolution integral taken over the history of the reduced system. The chapter also describes an alternative method of particular relevance in many applications, which is based on a time-local quantum master equation, and which is known as the time-convolutionless projection operator method. This method serves as a starting point for a systematic expansion in terms of ordered cumulants and forms the basis for a non-Markovian stochastic unravelling of the reduced system dynamics.
We consider the exact reduced dynamics of a two-level system coupled to a bosonic reservoir, further obtaining the exact time-convolutionless and Nakajima-Zwanzig non-Markovian equations of motion. The system considered includes the damped and undamped Jaynes-Cummings model. The result is obtained by exploiting an expression of quantum maps in terms of matrices and a simple relation between the time evolution map and the time-convolutionless generator as well as the Nakajima-Zwanzig memory kernel. This nonperturbative treatment shows that each operator contribution in Lindblad form appearing in the exact time-convolutionless master equation is multiplied by a different time-dependent function. Similarly, in the Nakajima-Zwanzig master equation each such contribution is convoluted with a different memory kernel. It appears that, depending on the state of the environment, the operator structures of the two sets of equations of motion can exhibit important differences.
The transfer tensor method is a versatile tool for analyzing and propagating general open quantum systems. It captures in a compact manner all memory effects in a non-Markovian system through a straightforward transformation of a set of dynamical maps. Transfer tensors provide the exact convolutional propagator associated with a given time discretization over the past evolution of an open quantum system. Here we show that, for any finite time discretization, the memory kernel of the Nakajima Zwanzig equation deviates from the exact transfer tensors, although both converge in the continuous-time limit, as expected. We examine this behaviour in the context of an analytically solvable model: a two level atom resonant with a lossy cavity in the Jaynes Cummings limit. The atomic dynamics separate into two decoupled degrees of freedom -- the coherence and the population inversion. We derive exact expressions for the dynamical map, the transfer tensors and the memory kernel governing the coherence, and we relate them to their counterparts for the population inversion. As a function of the ratio between the cavity loss rate and the atom-cavity coupling strength, we identify regions of enhanced non-Markovianity in which the system can be described as fully Markovian for certain time-step choices.
We extend the Nakajima-Zwanzig projection operator technique to the determination of multitime correlation functions of open quantum systems. The correlation functions are expressed in terms of certain multitime homogeneous and inhomogeneous memory kernels for which suitable equations of motion are derived. We show that under the condition of finite memory times, these equations can be used to determine the memory kernels by employing an exact stochastic unraveling of the full system-environment dynamics. The approach thus allows us to combine exact stochastic methods, feasible for short times, with long-time master equation simulations. The applicability of the method is demonstrated by numerical simulations of two-dimensional spectra for a donor-acceptor model, and by comparison of the results with those obtained from the reduced hierarchy equations of motion. We further show that the formalism is also applicable to the time evolution of a periodically driven two-level system initially in equilibrium with its environment.