The Classicality Gap: Why Decoherence Fails Without History Selection
Jonah Brent
Decoherence and thermodynamic irreversibility are widely regarded as sufficient to explain the emergence of classical behavior from quantum mechanics. Decoherence suppresses interference between branches of the wavefunction, while entropy production provides a direction to macroscopic time. However, neither mechanism alone explains why macroscopic physics exhibits a single, persistent, globally consistent classical history rather than fragmentation into mutually incompatible record sets. In this work, we identify and formalize this unresolved issue as the classicality gap. We show that in finite systems subject to nonzero noise and irreversible record formation, decoherence and entropy production are generically insufficient to stabilize a single coherent macroscopic history. Instead, absent a history-level selection mechanism, redundant records diverge and macroscopic identity becomes ill-defined. We present a general instability result demonstrating this fragmentation tendency and introduce history-level constraint restoration as the minimal structural mechanism capable of preventing it. This mechanism operates without new microdynamics, collapse postulates, or observer dependence. We derive qualitative phase boundaries separating stable and unstable regimes and propose concrete experimental protocols on NISQ-era quantum platforms that can falsify the necessity of history selection. Our results establish that persistent classicality is not guaranteed by decoherence alone, but requires selection acting on histories under irreversible constraints. Keywords: classicality emergence, decoherence limits, record inconsistency, history instability, quantum-to-classical transition, irreversibility, entropy production, information persistence, open quantum systems, foundations of physics
•Jan 22, 2026•0 citations