Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.15898

Superradiant photon bunching in nanolasers: from a polarization-order hierarchy of the master equation to Dicke Markov chains

Matias Bundgaard-Nielsen, Jesper Mørk

Published Nov 11, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In nanolasers, a few to a few hundred quantum emitters share a single mode of light. Coupled identically to the mode, the emitters do not radiate independently but form collective bright and dark states, producing superradiant bursts and strongly bunched photon statistics below the laser threshold. We investigate to what extent this behavior can be understood as random jumps between collective Dicke states. From the laser master equation, we derive a hierarchy of models defined by the polarization order, i.e., the number of photons involved in the coherence between the emitters and the light, and include the coherence to various orders. With all of the coherences eliminated, we obtain a Dicke Markov chain, a stochastic jump process over the photon number and the Dicke states, in which collective effects enter only through enhanced or suppressed transition rates. It predicts superthermal bunching and a strong even--odd dependence on the emitter number. It recovers about 80\% of the bunching in the most coherent regime, where conventional rate equations predict no superthermal bunching. Keeping the first polarization order, i.e., the optical polarization, and eliminating the second order, i.e., the two-photon coherences, yields a population-polarization model, which recovers the bunching of the full master equation almost perfectly. This hierarchy of polarization orders is an alternative to the cumulant expansion and, unlike it, recovers the master equation at the highest order. As a numerically exact reference, a symmetry-reduced master equation extends the simulation range all the way to 34 (24) emitters below (above) threshold. The Dicke Markov chain can be solved directly for hundreds of emitters and sampled for thousands of emitters, further extending the range of numerical methods. We compare the numerical performance of the methods in detail to guide the choice of technique.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2611.15898

Related papers

Modeling Quantum Noise in Nanolasers using Markov Chains

Matias Bundgaard-Nielsen, Gian Luca Lippi, Jesper Mørk

The random nature of spontaneous emission leads to unavoidable fluctuations in a laser's output. This is often included through random Langevin forces in laser rate equations, but this approach falls short for nanolasers. In this paper, we show that the laser quantum noise can be quantitatively computed for a very broad class of lasers by starting from simple and intuitive rate equations and merely assuming that the number of photons and excited electrons only takes discrete values. While the approach has seen previous success, we here derive it rigorously from an open quantum system master equation, whereas it was previously introduced only on phenomenological grounds. We further show that in the many-photon limit, the model simplifies to Langevin equations. We perform an extensive comparison of different approaches for computing quantum noise in lasers, identifying the best approach for different system sizes, ranging from nanolasers to macroscopic lasers, and different levels of excitation, i.e., cavity photon number. In particular, we show that below the laser threshold, stochastic fluctuations in the numerical solution to the Langevin equations can drive populations to unphysical negative values, requiring the introduction of population bounds, which in turn skew the noise statistics, leading to inaccuracies. The Laser Markov Chain model, on the other hand, is accurate for all pump values and laser sizes when collective emitter effects are excluded.

quant-pharXiv:2511.13622•Physical Review A•Nov 18, 2025•0 citations

An analytical approach to collective effects in nanolasers (Conference Presentation)

Emil C. André, Игорь Евгеньевич Проценко, Alexander V. Uskov +2 more

Traditionally, the active material in a laser is modelled as independent emitters, but in recent years it has become increasingly clear that radiative coupling between emitters can significantly change the characteristics of small lasers. Collective effects in free space such as superradiance have been studied extensively [1,2], but the effects of inter-emitter correlation in micro- and nano-cavities need further examination to be put on firm theoretical ground. Several studies of collective effects in nano-cavities have been made [3-6], but the theoretical models employed are intricate, and numerical methods are needed both to generate the dynamic equations and to solve them. We propose a model where the complexity is strongly reduced, allowing analytical solutions [7]. We consider a collection of identical two-level emitters interacting with a single cavity mode. We start from Maxwell-Bloch equations, but instead of making the typical adiabatic elimination of the polarization, we allow the polarization decay rate to be of the same magnitude or smaller than other decay rates. Hence, the traditional laser rate equations for the photon number and the population inversion must be supplemented by equations for the emitter-field correlation and the emitter-emitter correlation. This gives us four generalized laser rate equations, which we solve analytically in steady state. Comparing with the steady state results obtained from the traditional laser rate equations we see that inclusion of collective effects leads to a reduction of the photon number for small pump rates, similarly to what is found in [4]. From the generalized laser rate equations, we derive a measure of the strength of collective effects in terms of laser parameters: This describes the difference between results with and without inter-emitter correlations, and it goes smoothly to zero as we approach parameter values where the traditional laser rate equations become valid. To gain insight into the photon statistics of the laser, we construct dynamic equations for higher order correlations of operators. We derive an analytical expression for the zero-delay photon auto-correlation function, and for low pump rates we find that the interaction of emitters results in super-thermal values of the auto-correlation. This feature is observed in experiments and numerical models [4-5], and with our analytical expressions, we are able to pinpoint the parameter combinations for which the collective effects have the largest impact. Considering the same model in terms of the Fourier components of the operators, we find results for the photon number that agree well with the previous approach, while allowing computation of the linewidth. Thus, we can examine how emitter-emitter correlation affects the line broadening of the laser.

Semiconductor Lasers and Laser Dynamics•May 23, 2018•0 citations

Superradiant Peak Emission Rate and Time in Quantum Emitter Arrays

Raphael Holzinger, Susanne F. Yelin

Determining the peak photon emission time and rate for an ensemble of $N$ quantum systems undergoing collective superradiant decay typically requires tracking the time evolution of the density operator. Generally, the dimension of the density operator grows exponentially ($\sim \! 2^N$) with the number of emitters, in the absence of any symmetries such as in Dicke superradiance with full or partial permutational symmetry. We present a detailed study of the superradiant peak emission rate and time for initially fully excited quantum emitter ensembles, for one-, two- and three-dimensional arrays in free-space and emitter chains coupled to waveguide reservoirs. For few emitters ($N\lesssim 14$) we utilize the full quantum master equation, and for mesoscopic emitter numbers ($N\lesssim 400$) we use a second- and third-order cumulant expansion of the operator averages to track the time evolution of the system.

arXiv:2504.09985•Apr 14, 2025•9 citations

Collective Effects in Nanolasers Explained by Generalized Rate Equations

Игорь Евгеньевич Проценко, Emil C. André, Alexander V. Uskov +2 more

We study the stationary photon output and statistics of small lasers. Our closed-form expressions clarify the contribution of collective effects due to the interaction between quantum emitters. We generalize laser rate equations and explain photon trapping: a decrease of the photon number output below the lasing threshold, derive an expression for the stationary cavity mode autocorrelation function $g_2$, which implies that collective effects may strongly influence the photon statistics. We identify conditions for coherent, thermal and superthermal radiation, the latter being a unique fingerprint for collective emission in lasers. These generic analytical results agree with recent experiments, complement numerical results, and provide insight into and design rules for nanolasers.

arXiv:1709.08200•Sep 24, 2017•10 citations

Observation of Superradiant Bursts in a Cascaded Quantum System

Christian Liedl, Felix Tebbenjohanns, Constanze Bach +3 more

We experimentally investigate the collective radiative decay of a fully inverted ensemble of two-level atoms for a chiral, i.e., propagation direction-dependent light-matter coupling. Despite a fundamentally different interaction Hamiltonian which has a reduced symmetry compared to the standard Dicke case of superradiance, we do observe a superradiant burst of light. The burst occurs above a threshold number of atoms, and its peak power scales faster with the number of atoms than in the case of free-space Dicke superradiance. We measure the first-order coherence of the burst and experimentally distinguish two regimes, one dominated by the coherence induced during the excitation process and the other governed by vacuum fluctuations. Our results shed light on the collective radiative dynamics of cascaded quantum many-body systems, i.e., systems in which each quantum emitter is only driven by light radiated by emitters that are upstream in the cascade. Our findings may turn out useful for generating multiphoton Fock states as a resource for quantum technologies. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2211.08940•Physical Review X•Feb 16, 2024•68 citations

Benchmarking the Cumulant Expansion Method Using Dicke Superradiance

Martin Fasser, Claudiu Genes, Helmut Ritsch +1 more

Collective superradiant decay of a tightly packed inverted quantum emitter ensemble is among the most intensely studied phenomena in quantum optics. Since the seminal work of Dicke more than half a century ago, a plethora of theoretical calculations in quantum many-body physics have followed. Widespread experimental efforts range from the microwave to the X-ray regime. Nevertheless, accurate calculations of the time dynamics of the superradiant emission pulse still remain a challenging task requiring approximate methods for large ensembles. Here, we benchmark the cumulant expansion method for describing collective superradiant decay against a newly found exact solution. The application of two variants of the cumulant expansion exhibits reliable convergence of time and magnitude of the maximum emission power with increasing truncation order. The long-term population evolution is only correctly captured for low emitter numbers, where an individual spin-based cumulant expansion proves more reliable than the collective spin-based variant. Surprisingly, odd orders show unphysical behavior. At sufficiently high spin numbers, both chosen cumulant methods agree, but still fail to reliably converge to the numerically exact result. Generally, on longer time scales the expansions substantially overestimate the remaining population. While numerically fast and efficient, cumulant expansion methods need to be treated with sufficient caution when used for long-time evolution or reliably finding steady states.

Photonics•Oct 10, 2025•2 citations
In nanolasers, a few to a few hundred quantum emitters share a single mode of light. Coupled identically to the mode, the emitters do not radiate independently but form collective bright and dark states, producing superradiant bursts and strongly bunched photon statistics below the laser threshold. We investigate to what extent this behavior can be understood as random jumps between collective Dicke states. From the laser master equation, we derive a hierarchy of models defined by the polarization order, i.e., the number of photons involved in the coherence between the emitters and the light, and include the coherence to various orders. With all of the coherences eliminated, we obtain a Dicke Markov chain, a stochastic jump process over the photon number and the Dicke states, in which collective effects enter only through enhanced or suppressed transition rates. It predicts superthermal bunching and a strong even--odd dependence on the emitter number. It recovers about 80% of the bunching in the most coherent regime, where conventional rate equations predict no superthermal bunching. Keeping the first polarization order, i.e., the optical polarization, and eliminating the second order, i.e., the two-photon coherences, yields a population-polarization model, which recovers the bunching of the full master equation almost perfectly. This hierarchy of polarization orders is an alternative to the cumulant expansion and, unlike it, recovers the master equation at the highest order. As a numerically exact reference, a symmetry-reduced master equation extends the simulation range all the way to 34 (24) emitters below (above) threshold. The Dicke Markov chain can be solved directly for hundreds of emitters and sampled for thousands of emitters, further extending the range of numerical methods. We compare the numerical performance of the methods in detail to guide the choice of technique.
The random nature of spontaneous emission leads to unavoidable fluctuations in a laser's output. This is often included through random Langevin forces in laser rate equations, but this approach falls short for nanolasers. In this paper, we show that the laser quantum noise can be quantitatively computed for a very broad class of lasers by starting from simple and intuitive rate equations and merely assuming that the number of photons and excited electrons only takes discrete values. While the approach has seen previous success, we here derive it rigorously from an open quantum system master equation, whereas it was previously introduced only on phenomenological grounds. We further show that in the many-photon limit, the model simplifies to Langevin equations. We perform an extensive comparison of different approaches for computing quantum noise in lasers, identifying the best approach for different system sizes, ranging from nanolasers to macroscopic lasers, and different levels of excitation, i.e., cavity photon number. In particular, we show that below the laser threshold, stochastic fluctuations in the numerical solution to the Langevin equations can drive populations to unphysical negative values, requiring the introduction of population bounds, which in turn skew the noise statistics, leading to inaccuracies. The Laser Markov Chain model, on the other hand, is accurate for all pump values and laser sizes when collective emitter effects are excluded.
Traditionally, the active material in a laser is modelled as independent emitters, but in recent years it has become increasingly clear that radiative coupling between emitters can significantly change the characteristics of small lasers. Collective effects in free space such as superradiance have been studied extensively [1,2], but the effects of inter-emitter correlation in micro- and nano-cavities need further examination to be put on firm theoretical ground. Several studies of collective effects in nano-cavities have been made [3-6], but the theoretical models employed are intricate, and numerical methods are needed both to generate the dynamic equations and to solve them. We propose a model where the complexity is strongly reduced, allowing analytical solutions [7]. We consider a collection of identical two-level emitters interacting with a single cavity mode. We start from Maxwell-Bloch equations, but instead of making the typical adiabatic elimination of the polarization, we allow the polarization decay rate to be of the same magnitude or smaller than other decay rates. Hence, the traditional laser rate equations for the photon number and the population inversion must be supplemented by equations for the emitter-field correlation and the emitter-emitter correlation. This gives us four generalized laser rate equations, which we solve analytically in steady state. Comparing with the steady state results obtained from the traditional laser rate equations we see that inclusion of collective effects leads to a reduction of the photon number for small pump rates, similarly to what is found in [4]. From the generalized laser rate equations, we derive a measure of the strength of collective effects in terms of laser parameters: This describes the difference between results with and without inter-emitter correlations, and it goes smoothly to zero as we approach parameter values where the traditional laser rate equations become valid. To gain insight into the photon statistics of the laser, we construct dynamic equations for higher order correlations of operators. We derive an analytical expression for the zero-delay photon auto-correlation function, and for low pump rates we find that the interaction of emitters results in super-thermal values of the auto-correlation. This feature is observed in experiments and numerical models [4-5], and with our analytical expressions, we are able to pinpoint the parameter combinations for which the collective effects have the largest impact. Considering the same model in terms of the Fourier components of the operators, we find results for the photon number that agree well with the previous approach, while allowing computation of the linewidth. Thus, we can examine how emitter-emitter correlation affects the line broadening of the laser.
Determining the peak photon emission time and rate for an ensemble of NNN quantum systems undergoing collective superradiant decay typically requires tracking the time evolution of the density operator. Generally, the dimension of the density operator grows exponentially (∼ ⁣2N\sim \! 2^N∼2N) with the number of emitters, in the absence of any symmetries such as in Dicke superradiance with full or partial permutational symmetry. We present a detailed study of the superradiant peak emission rate and time for initially fully excited quantum emitter ensembles, for one-, two- and three-dimensional arrays in free-space and emitter chains coupled to waveguide reservoirs. For few emitters (N≲14N\lesssim 14N≲14) we utilize the full quantum master equation, and for mesoscopic emitter numbers (N≲400N\lesssim 400N≲400) we use a second- and third-order cumulant expansion of the operator averages to track the time evolution of the system.
We study the stationary photon output and statistics of small lasers. Our closed-form expressions clarify the contribution of collective effects due to the interaction between quantum emitters. We generalize laser rate equations and explain photon trapping: a decrease of the photon number output below the lasing threshold, derive an expression for the stationary cavity mode autocorrelation function g2g_2g2​, which implies that collective effects may strongly influence the photon statistics. We identify conditions for coherent, thermal and superthermal radiation, the latter being a unique fingerprint for collective emission in lasers. These generic analytical results agree with recent experiments, complement numerical results, and provide insight into and design rules for nanolasers.
We experimentally investigate the collective radiative decay of a fully inverted ensemble of two-level atoms for a chiral, i.e., propagation direction-dependent light-matter coupling. Despite a fundamentally different interaction Hamiltonian which has a reduced symmetry compared to the standard Dicke case of superradiance, we do observe a superradiant burst of light. The burst occurs above a threshold number of atoms, and its peak power scales faster with the number of atoms than in the case of free-space Dicke superradiance. We measure the first-order coherence of the burst and experimentally distinguish two regimes, one dominated by the coherence induced during the excitation process and the other governed by vacuum fluctuations. Our results shed light on the collective radiative dynamics of cascaded quantum many-body systems, i.e., systems in which each quantum emitter is only driven by light radiated by emitters that are upstream in the cascade. Our findings may turn out useful for generating multiphoton Fock states as a resource for quantum technologies. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Collective superradiant decay of a tightly packed inverted quantum emitter ensemble is among the most intensely studied phenomena in quantum optics. Since the seminal work of Dicke more than half a century ago, a plethora of theoretical calculations in quantum many-body physics have followed. Widespread experimental efforts range from the microwave to the X-ray regime. Nevertheless, accurate calculations of the time dynamics of the superradiant emission pulse still remain a challenging task requiring approximate methods for large ensembles. Here, we benchmark the cumulant expansion method for describing collective superradiant decay against a newly found exact solution. The application of two variants of the cumulant expansion exhibits reliable convergence of time and magnitude of the maximum emission power with increasing truncation order. The long-term population evolution is only correctly captured for low emitter numbers, where an individual spin-based cumulant expansion proves more reliable than the collective spin-based variant. Surprisingly, odd orders show unphysical behavior. At sufficiently high spin numbers, both chosen cumulant methods agree, but still fail to reliably converge to the numerically exact result. Generally, on longer time scales the expansions substantially overestimate the remaining population. While numerically fast and efficient, cumulant expansion methods need to be treated with sufficient caution when used for long-time evolution or reliably finding steady states.