Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.09594

Magic Can Superactivate Quantum Capacity

Chunhe Xiong, Sunho Kim, Shunlong Luo, Lin Zhang, Shao‐Ming Fei, Junde Wu

Published Nov 6, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Environmental magic can enable two channels with zero quantum capacity to transmit quantum information jointly. We establish this superactivation within a family of discrete quantum convolution channels with fixed Clifford interactions. For the couplings considered, stabilizer-mixture environments induce entanglement-breaking channels. We construct a mixed magic environment whose induced channel has positive private capacity and a Choi state with positive partial transpose, hence zero quantum capacity. A half-erasure auxiliary activates this channel through the Smith--Yard mechanism. Finite-block encoding and decoding over a self-complementary convolution auxiliary then realize a higher-dimensional erasure channel that still permits activation. We also bound the activated capacity by the modified relative entropy of magic of the main environment. Replacing either environment of the convolution pair by any stabilizer mixture makes the joint quantum capacity vanish, identifying environmental magic as a necessary resource on both sides for this realization.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2611.09594

Related papers

Transport and Channel Normal Forms for Clifford Interactions

Xiong Chunhe, Kim Sunho, Zhang Qing-Hua +2 more

We study how Clifford interactions with a fixed environment determine quantum transmission, in a setting that extends positive discrete quantum convolution . We characterize when Clifford operations on the environment can be replaced by operations on the signal input and the two outputs, and classify the interactions under local Clifford transformations . For pure stabilizer environments, we determine the noiseless, dephasing, and completely depolarizing parts of the channel directly from the interaction and environmental stabilizers, obtaining its quantum and private capacities . This reveals a distinction between interactions: those locally equivalent to positive convolution produce entanglement-breaking channels for every pure stabilizer environment, whereas every other interaction in the class admits noiseless quantum transmission with a suitable pure stabilizer environment . For positive convolution, environmental Clifford transport also allows us to separate the stabilized coordinates of an arbitrary mixed environment . These coordinates carry only a classical label shared by the receiver and environment, so removing them preserves quantum and private capacities . The resulting channel reduction yields a private-capacity bound by the modified relative entropy of magic of the environmental state .

quant-pharXiv:2609.30125•Sep 25, 2026•1 citation

Private Capacity of Quantum Channels Induced by Non-stabilizer Environmental States

Chunhe Xiong, Sunho Kim, Long Long +1 more

We investigate the private capacity of quantum channels using the recently proposed quantum convolution theory for discrete-variable quantum systems. We focus on the role of the magic resource played in this framework. Firstly, for a large class of convolutional channels, we find that the private capacity is zero if the fixed environmental state is a stabilizer state. Moreover, we show that the private capacity can be nonzero for some magic environmental states. Furthermore, we show that the private capacity of a discrete beam splitter unitary is upper-bounded by the amount of magic of the environmental state. In addition, if the environmental state exhibits a certain symmetric structure, even if it is magic, the corresponding private capacity will also vanish for a class of convolution. These results emphasize the role of magic resources in quantum communication

quant-pharXiv:2607.11793•Physical Review A•Jul 14, 2026•2 citations

Computational Refutation of Quantum Superactivation via Bound Entanglement in Low Dimensions

Yaroslav Murai

Smith and Yard (2008) famously demonstrated that two quantum channels with zero quantum capacity can possess a strictly positive joint capacity, a phenomenon known as superactivation. Their proof relies on the existence of Positive Partial Transpose (PPT) states possessing a strictly positive Devetak-Winter private key rate ($K_{DW} > 0$), explicitly citing a 4x4 construction by Horodecki et al. We present a two-tiered computational refutation of this phenomenon. First, using a high-precision global optimization framework with exact Stinespring purifications, we compute $K_{DW}$ across the full 512-dimensional PPT manifold for d=4x4 and find a strict upper bound of $K_{DW} \le -0.68$ bits, physically breaking the foundational protocol. Second, to address recent theoretical defenses concerning macro-scale finite-blocklength scaling ($N \ge 17$), we deploy a 30-qubit hybrid machine learning simulator (equivalent to $N=15$ joint channels). By evaluating the joint topology under strict causal limits and with omniscient encoder prescience, we demonstrate a complete failure to achieve positive capacity, establishing that superactivation is physically impossible in practical quantum systems.

•May 14, 2026•0 citations

Onset of superactivation of quantum capacity

Marco Parentin, Bjarne Bergh, Nilanjana Datta +1 more

Superactivation of quantum capacity is the phenomenon whereby two quantum channels, each with zero quantum capacity, can exhibit a strictly positive capacity when used in tandem. In this work, we explore superactivation in the previously unexplored non-asymptotic regime of finitely many channel uses. We give a definition of finite-blocklength superactivation and propose numerical methods that can certify it. Then, focusing on the 50% erasure and positive-partial-transpose channels considered in the original work on superactivation, we show that as few as 17 uses of the joint channel already enable qubit transmission with a fidelity unattainable by any number of uses of either channel alone, demonstrating a strong finite-blocklength form of superactivation and opening the door to experimental demonstration.

quant-pharXiv:2604.27042•Apr 30, 2026•2 citations

Standard super-activation for Gaussian channels requires squeezing

Daniel Lercher, G. Giedke, Michael M. Wolf

The quantum capacity of bosonic Gaussian quantum channels can be non-additive in a particularly striking way: a pair of such optical fiber type channels can individually have zero quantum capacity but super-activate each other such that the combined channel has strictly positive capacity. This has been shown in Smith et al (2011 Nature Photon. 5 624) where it was conjectured that squeezing is a necessary resource for this phenomenon. We provide a proof of this conjecture by showing that for gauge covariant channels a Choi matrix with positive partial transpose implies that the channel is entanglement-breaking. In addition, we construct an example which shows that this implication fails to hold for Gaussian channels which arise from passive interactions with a squeezed environment.

arXiv:1209.5574•New Journal of Physics•Dec 4, 2013•10 citations

Parrondo's paradox and superactivation of classical and quantum capacity of communication channels with memory

Sergii Strelchuk

There exist memoryless zero-capacity quantum channels that when used jointly result in a channel with positive capacity. This phenomenon is called superactivation. Making use of Parrondo's paradox, we exhibit examples of the superactivation-like effect for the capacity of classical communication channels as well as quantum and private capacity of quantum channels with memory. There are several ingredients necessary for superactivation of quantum capacity to occur in the memoryless case. The first one is the requirement for the quantum channels which are suitable for superactivation to come from two distinct families: binding entanglement channels and erasure channels. The second one is the ability to utilize inputs which are entangled across the uses of the channels. Our construction uses a single family of erasure channels with classical memory to achieve the same superactivation-like effect for quantum capacity without any of the ingredients above.

arXiv:1305.1326•Physical Review A•Sep 11, 2013•3 citations
Environmental magic can enable two channels with zero quantum capacity to transmit quantum information jointly. We establish this superactivation within a family of discrete quantum convolution channels with fixed Clifford interactions. For the couplings considered, stabilizer-mixture environments induce entanglement-breaking channels. We construct a mixed magic environment whose induced channel has positive private capacity and a Choi state with positive partial transpose, hence zero quantum capacity. A half-erasure auxiliary activates this channel through the Smith--Yard mechanism. Finite-block encoding and decoding over a self-complementary convolution auxiliary then realize a higher-dimensional erasure channel that still permits activation. We also bound the activated capacity by the modified relative entropy of magic of the main environment. Replacing either environment of the convolution pair by any stabilizer mixture makes the joint quantum capacity vanish, identifying environmental magic as a necessary resource on both sides for this realization.
We study how Clifford interactions with a fixed environment determine quantum transmission, in a setting that extends positive discrete quantum convolution . We characterize when Clifford operations on the environment can be replaced by operations on the signal input and the two outputs, and classify the interactions under local Clifford transformations . For pure stabilizer environments, we determine the noiseless, dephasing, and completely depolarizing parts of the channel directly from the interaction and environmental stabilizers, obtaining its quantum and private capacities . This reveals a distinction between interactions: those locally equivalent to positive convolution produce entanglement-breaking channels for every pure stabilizer environment, whereas every other interaction in the class admits noiseless quantum transmission with a suitable pure stabilizer environment . For positive convolution, environmental Clifford transport also allows us to separate the stabilized coordinates of an arbitrary mixed environment . These coordinates carry only a classical label shared by the receiver and environment, so removing them preserves quantum and private capacities . The resulting channel reduction yields a private-capacity bound by the modified relative entropy of magic of the environmental state .
We investigate the private capacity of quantum channels using the recently proposed quantum convolution theory for discrete-variable quantum systems. We focus on the role of the magic resource played in this framework. Firstly, for a large class of convolutional channels, we find that the private capacity is zero if the fixed environmental state is a stabilizer state. Moreover, we show that the private capacity can be nonzero for some magic environmental states. Furthermore, we show that the private capacity of a discrete beam splitter unitary is upper-bounded by the amount of magic of the environmental state. In addition, if the environmental state exhibits a certain symmetric structure, even if it is magic, the corresponding private capacity will also vanish for a class of convolution. These results emphasize the role of magic resources in quantum communication
Smith and Yard (2008) famously demonstrated that two quantum channels with zero quantum capacity can possess a strictly positive joint capacity, a phenomenon known as superactivation. Their proof relies on the existence of Positive Partial Transpose (PPT) states possessing a strictly positive Devetak-Winter private key rate (KDW>0K_{DW} > 0KDW​>0), explicitly citing a 4x4 construction by Horodecki et al. We present a two-tiered computational refutation of this phenomenon. First, using a high-precision global optimization framework with exact Stinespring purifications, we compute KDWK_{DW}KDW​ across the full 512-dimensional PPT manifold for d=4x4 and find a strict upper bound of KDW≤−0.68K_{DW} \le -0.68KDW​≤−0.68 bits, physically breaking the foundational protocol. Second, to address recent theoretical defenses concerning macro-scale finite-blocklength scaling (N≥17N \ge 17N≥17), we deploy a 30-qubit hybrid machine learning simulator (equivalent to N=15N=15N=15 joint channels). By evaluating the joint topology under strict causal limits and with omniscient encoder prescience, we demonstrate a complete failure to achieve positive capacity, establishing that superactivation is physically impossible in practical quantum systems.
Superactivation of quantum capacity is the phenomenon whereby two quantum channels, each with zero quantum capacity, can exhibit a strictly positive capacity when used in tandem. In this work, we explore superactivation in the previously unexplored non-asymptotic regime of finitely many channel uses. We give a definition of finite-blocklength superactivation and propose numerical methods that can certify it. Then, focusing on the 50% erasure and positive-partial-transpose channels considered in the original work on superactivation, we show that as few as 17 uses of the joint channel already enable qubit transmission with a fidelity unattainable by any number of uses of either channel alone, demonstrating a strong finite-blocklength form of superactivation and opening the door to experimental demonstration.
The quantum capacity of bosonic Gaussian quantum channels can be non-additive in a particularly striking way: a pair of such optical fiber type channels can individually have zero quantum capacity but super-activate each other such that the combined channel has strictly positive capacity. This has been shown in Smith et al (2011 Nature Photon. 5 624) where it was conjectured that squeezing is a necessary resource for this phenomenon. We provide a proof of this conjecture by showing that for gauge covariant channels a Choi matrix with positive partial transpose implies that the channel is entanglement-breaking. In addition, we construct an example which shows that this implication fails to hold for Gaussian channels which arise from passive interactions with a squeezed environment.
There exist memoryless zero-capacity quantum channels that when used jointly result in a channel with positive capacity. This phenomenon is called superactivation. Making use of Parrondo's paradox, we exhibit examples of the superactivation-like effect for the capacity of classical communication channels as well as quantum and private capacity of quantum channels with memory. There are several ingredients necessary for superactivation of quantum capacity to occur in the memoryless case. The first one is the requirement for the quantum channels which are suitable for superactivation to come from two distinct families: binding entanglement channels and erasure channels. The second one is the ability to utilize inputs which are entangled across the uses of the channels. Our construction uses a single family of erasure channels with classical memory to achieve the same superactivation-like effect for quantum capacity without any of the ingredients above.