Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.03460

Surface charges and quantum reflection of hydrogen-isotope beams at grazing incidence

A. Yu. Voronin, V. V. Nesvizhevsky

quant-phSubmitted Nov 2, 2026• Announced Nov 3, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Experiments with cryogenic beams of hydrogen isotopes (hydrogen (H), deuterium (D), and tritium (T)) can be used to study quantum reflection from solid dielectric mirrors. Most dielectric surfaces carry trapped electric charges whose field polarizes the incident atom. We study theoretically how such charges, distributed randomly, in clusters, with compensation over a finite length, or in order, change specular reflection and diffuse scattering of H, D, and T at grazing incidence on typical dielectric mirrors (SiO$_2$/Si and MgF$_2$), for longitudinal velocities of 100--300~m/s and normal velocities of 3--100~cm/s which might become available soon in grazing incidence experiments. Starting from the exact coupled-channel equations, we show that the specular wave feels only the laterally averaged polarization potential, which is fixed by the structure factor of the charges and, for uncorrelated charges, is an inverse-square tail $-C_2/z^2$. The exact solution replaces the linear threshold law $1-\Rr\propto\vperp$ by the fractional power $\vperp^{2ν}$, $ν=(1/4-ζ)^{1/2}$, with the coupling $ζ\propto C_2$; for weak coupling, this appears as a logarithmic velocity dependence, and for $ζ>1/4$, the reflection coefficient oscillates log-periodically. At the surface charge density of $10^{12}$ cm$^{-2}$, absorption increases by up to 26\% for SiO$_2$/Si and by a factor of two to three for MgF$_2$; the effect increases with atomic mass, saturates for compensated charges, and is accompanied by diffuse scattering below $10^{-3}$ of charge-induced loss. We also formulate the condition of complete absorption at the solid surface.

AI Summary

This theoretical study asks how trapped surface charges alter quantum reflection of cryogenic H, D and T beams from dielectric mirrors at grazing incidence. It considers SiO$_2$(2 nm)/Si and MgF$_2$, longitudinal velocities of 100–300 m/s, normal velocities of 3–100 cm/s, and charge densities of $10^{10}$–$10^{12}\,\mathrm{cm}^{-2}$. Starting from coupled-channel equations, it argues that rapid longitudinal motion suppresses coupling out of the specular channel, allowing reflection to be calculated using the laterally averaged polarization potential. This potential is expressed through the charge structure factor; uncorrelated charges produce $-C_2/z^2$. Bessel-function matching gives the threshold law $1-R\propto v_\perp^{\sqrt{1-4\zeta}}$, where $\zeta=2mC_2/\hbar^2$, replacing the neutral mirror’s linear law. Weak coupling yields a logarithmic enhancement. Numerical integration with Lifshitz atom–surface potentials predicts that $10^{12}\,\mathrm{cm}^{-2}$ charges at 3 cm/s increase absorption by 17–26% on silicon and roughly two- to threefold on MgF$_2$. Finite-length charge compensation cuts off the inverse-square tail and restores linear threshold behavior at sufficiently low velocity. Estimated diffuse scattering is approximately $10^{-3}$ or less of charge-induced specular loss. The reduction requires weak individual-charge scattering and sufficient spatial averaging; locally screened charges on conducting substrates do not produce the stated tail. Complete surface absorption is justified using a microscopic-disorder model, but can fail on atomically ordered surfaces. The predicted log-periodic reflection for $\zeta>1/4$ lies outside the stated beam regime. The experiments are prospective, and quantitative predictions depend on the unknown charge distribution.

No sign of AI-generated textIncrementalStrong assumptions

Error found: The abstract presents the laterally averaged potential as the sole influence on specular reflection, although the derivation neglects a nonzero channel-coupling self-energy under explicit conditions that restrict its applicability, particularly for clustered charges. The claimed strict diffuse-loss bound below 10^-3 of charge-induced absorption is contradicted by the table's value of 1.1×10^-3 for deuterium at 10 cm/s.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Related papers

Quantum reflection of He * on silicon

H. Oberst, Yoshihisa Tashiro, Kazuko Shimizu +1 more

A cold beam of ${\mathrm{He}}^{*}\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}(2\phantom{\rule{0.2em}{0ex}}^{3}S_{1})$ atoms is used at grazing incidence to study the quantum reflection on a flat polished silicon surface. We measure the reflectivity as a function of the normal incident velocity component between 3 and $30\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{cm}∕\mathrm{s}$. Our result is in reasonable agreement with a calculation of the attractive van der Waals surface potential using the dielectric function of Si and the dipole polarizability of ${\mathrm{He}}^{*}$. We discuss the influence of the conductivity and of a thin oxide layer on the potential. By comparing our data to those previously measured with ${\mathrm{Ne}}^{*}$ atoms, we are also able to confirm the scaling of the reflectivity with atomic mass.

Physical Review A•May 11, 2005•102 citations

Coherent Reflection of He Atom Beams from Rough Surfaces at Grazing Incidence

Bum Suk Zhao, H. Christian Schewe, Gerard Meijer +1 more

We report coherent reflection of thermal He atom beams from various microscopically rough surfaces at grazing incidence. For a sufficiently small normal component k(z) of the incident wave vector of the atom the reflection probability is found to be a function of k(z) only. This behavior is explained by quantum reflection at the attractive branch of the Casimir-van der Waals interaction potential. For larger values of k(z) the overall reflection probability decreases rapidly and is found to also depend on the parallel component k(x) of the wave vector. The material specific k(x) dependence for this classic reflection at the repulsive branch of the potential is discussed in terms of an averaging out of the surface roughness under grazing incidence conditions.

arXiv:1005.3711•Physical Review Letters•Sep 24, 2010•34 citations

Specular Reflection of Very Slow Metastable Neon Atoms from a Solid Surface

Fujio Shimizu

An ultracold narrow atomic beam of metastable neon in the 1s3[(2s)(5)3p:1P0] state is used to study specular reflection of atoms from a solid surface at extremely slow incident velocity. The reflectivity on a silicon (1,0,0) surface and a BK7 glass surface is measured at the normal incident velocity between 1 mm/s and 3 cm/s. The reflectivity above 30% is observed at about 1 mm/s. The observed velocity dependence is explained semiquantitatively by the quantum reflection that is caused by the attractive Casimir-van der Waals potential of the atom-surface interaction.

Physical Review Letters•Feb 5, 2001•302 citations

Quantum reflection: focusing of hyrodgen atoms with a hemispheric mirror

Jook T. M. Walraven

We studied the low-energy limit of atomsurface scattering and the phenomenon of quantum reflection by using hydrogen atoms and the surface of liquid helium. Measuring the specular reflectivity of a liquid-helium-covered hemispheric mirror for a beam of hydrogen atoms we obtained information on elastic and inelastic scattering phenomena. At 100 mK, reflectivities larger than 90% were achieved; this can be used to demonstrate atomic beam focusing. Approximately three-fourths of the atoms escaping from a small orifice in a cell were reflected back into the cell. The dominant inelastic processes at work here are surface absorption and direct inelastic scattering over small angles under excitation of surface ripplons (quantized capillary waves). Helium-covered surfaces maybe useful for atomic-beam manipulation of atomic hydrogen.

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America•Jan 1, 1990•0 citations

Quantum threshold reflection of He-atom beams from rough surfaces

Germán A. Rojas-Lorenzo, Jesús Rubayo‐Soneira, Salvador Miret-Artés +1 more

Quantum reflection of thermal He atoms from various surfaces (glass slide, GaAs wafer, flat, and structured Cr) at grazing conditions is studied within the elastic close-coupling formalism. Comparison with the experimental results of Zhao et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 133203 (2010)] is quite reasonable but the conclusions of the present theoretical analysis are different from those discussed in the experimental work. The universal linear behavior observed in the dependence of the reflection probability on the incident wave-vector component perpendicular to the surface is only valid at small values of the component whereas, at larger values, deviation from the linearity is evident, approaching a quadratic dependence at higher values. The surface roughness seems to play no important role in this scattering. Moreover, the claim that one observes a transition from quantum to classical reflection seems to be imprecise.

arXiv:1909.04034•Physical Review A•Feb 24, 2020•8 citations

Ridged atomic mirrors and atomic nanoscope

Dmitrii Kouznetsov, H. Oberst, Alexander Neumann +5 more

Recent results on the reflection of waves from ridged mirrors are discussed. Numerical calculations, analytical estimates and the direct measurements of coefficient of specular reflection of atomic waves from solid-state mirrors are combined. The reflectivity is approximated as an elementary function of period L of ridges, their width ℓ, wavenumber K, grazing angle θ and effective depth w of the van der Waals potential. In a special case L = ℓ, the fit reproduces the reflectivity of flat surfaces. Our approximation allows us to optimize the L at given ℓ and estimate the maximum performance of a ridged mirror. Such a mirror is suggested as a focusing element for the nano-scale imaging system. 1.

Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Mar 13, 2006•16 citations
Experiments with cryogenic beams of hydrogen isotopes (hydrogen (H), deuterium (D), and tritium (T)) can be used to study quantum reflection from solid dielectric mirrors. Most dielectric surfaces carry trapped electric charges whose field polarizes the incident atom. We study theoretically how such charges, distributed randomly, in clusters, with compensation over a finite length, or in order, change specular reflection and diffuse scattering of H, D, and T at grazing incidence on typical dielectric mirrors (SiO2_22​/Si and MgF2_22​), for longitudinal velocities of 100--300m/s and normal velocities of 3--100cm/s which might become available soon in grazing incidence experiments. Starting from the exact coupled-channel equations, we show that the specular wave feels only the laterally averaged polarization potential, which is fixed by the structure factor of the charges and, for uncorrelated charges, is an inverse-square tail −C2/z2-C_2/z^2−C2​/z2. The exact solution replaces the linear threshold law 1−\Rr∝\vperp1-\Rr\propto\vperp1−\Rr∝\vperp by the fractional power \vperp2ν\vperp^{2ν}\vperp2ν, ν=(1/4−ζ)1/2ν=(1/4-ζ)^{1/2}ν=(1/4−ζ)1/2, with the coupling ζ∝C2ζ\propto C_2ζ∝C2​; for weak coupling, this appears as a logarithmic velocity dependence, and for ζ>1/4ζ>1/4ζ>1/4, the reflection coefficient oscillates log-periodically. At the surface charge density of 101210^{12}1012 cm−2^{-2}−2, absorption increases by up to 26% for SiO2_22​/Si and by a factor of two to three for MgF2_22​; the effect increases with atomic mass, saturates for compensated charges, and is accompanied by diffuse scattering below 10−310^{-3}10−3 of charge-induced loss. We also formulate the condition of complete absorption at the solid surface.
This theoretical study asks how trapped surface charges alter quantum reflection of cryogenic H, D and T beams from dielectric mirrors at grazing incidence. It considers SiO2_22​(2 nm)/Si and MgF2_22​, longitudinal velocities of 100–300 m/s, normal velocities of 3–100 cm/s, and charge densities of 101010^{10}1010–1012 cm−210^{12}\,\mathrm{cm}^{-2}1012cm−2.
Starting from coupled-channel equations, it argues that rapid longitudinal motion suppresses coupling out of the specular channel, allowing reflection to be calculated using the laterally averaged polarization potential. This potential is expressed through the charge structure factor; uncorrelated charges produce −C2/z2-C_2/z^2−C2​/z2. Bessel-function matching gives the threshold law 1−R∝v⊥1−4ζ1-R\propto v_\perp^{\sqrt{1-4\zeta}}1−R∝v⊥1−4ζ​​, where ζ=2mC2/ℏ2\zeta=2mC_2/\hbar^2ζ=2mC2​/ℏ2, replacing the neutral mirror’s linear law. Weak coupling yields a logarithmic enhancement. Numerical integration with Lifshitz atom–surface potentials predicts that 1012 cm−210^{12}\,\mathrm{cm}^{-2}1012cm−2 charges at 3 cm/s increase absorption by 17–26% on silicon and roughly two- to threefold on MgF2_22​. Finite-length charge compensation cuts off the inverse-square tail and restores linear threshold behavior at sufficiently low velocity. Estimated diffuse scattering is approximately 10−310^{-3}10−3 or less of charge-induced specular loss.
The reduction requires weak individual-charge scattering and sufficient spatial averaging; locally screened charges on conducting substrates do not produce the stated tail. Complete surface absorption is justified using a microscopic-disorder model, but can fail on atomically ordered surfaces. The predicted log-periodic reflection for ζ>1/4\zeta>1/4ζ>1/4 lies outside the stated beam regime. The experiments are prospective, and quantitative predictions depend on the unknown charge distribution.
A cold beam of He∗(23S1){\mathrm{He}}^{*}\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}(2\phantom{\rule{0.2em}{0ex}}^{3}S_{1})He∗(23S1​) atoms is used at grazing incidence to study the quantum reflection on a flat polished silicon surface. We measure the reflectivity as a function of the normal incident velocity component between 3 and 30cm∕s30\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{cm}∕\mathrm{s}30cm∕s. Our result is in reasonable agreement with a calculation of the attractive van der Waals surface potential using the dielectric function of Si and the dipole polarizability of He∗{\mathrm{He}}^{*}He∗. We discuss the influence of the conductivity and of a thin oxide layer on the potential. By comparing our data to those previously measured with Ne∗{\mathrm{Ne}}^{*}Ne∗ atoms, we are also able to confirm the scaling of the reflectivity with atomic mass.
We report coherent reflection of thermal He atom beams from various microscopically rough surfaces at grazing incidence. For a sufficiently small normal component k(z) of the incident wave vector of the atom the reflection probability is found to be a function of k(z) only. This behavior is explained by quantum reflection at the attractive branch of the Casimir-van der Waals interaction potential. For larger values of k(z) the overall reflection probability decreases rapidly and is found to also depend on the parallel component k(x) of the wave vector. The material specific k(x) dependence for this classic reflection at the repulsive branch of the potential is discussed in terms of an averaging out of the surface roughness under grazing incidence conditions.
An ultracold narrow atomic beam of metastable neon in the 1s3[(2s)(5)3p:1P0] state is used to study specular reflection of atoms from a solid surface at extremely slow incident velocity. The reflectivity on a silicon (1,0,0) surface and a BK7 glass surface is measured at the normal incident velocity between 1 mm/s and 3 cm/s. The reflectivity above 30% is observed at about 1 mm/s. The observed velocity dependence is explained semiquantitatively by the quantum reflection that is caused by the attractive Casimir-van der Waals potential of the atom-surface interaction.
We studied the low-energy limit of atomsurface scattering and the phenomenon of quantum reflection by using hydrogen atoms and the surface of liquid helium. Measuring the specular reflectivity of a liquid-helium-covered hemispheric mirror for a beam of hydrogen atoms we obtained information on elastic and inelastic scattering phenomena. At 100 mK, reflectivities larger than 90% were achieved; this can be used to demonstrate atomic beam focusing. Approximately three-fourths of the atoms escaping from a small orifice in a cell were reflected back into the cell. The dominant inelastic processes at work here are surface absorption and direct inelastic scattering over small angles under excitation of surface ripplons (quantized capillary waves). Helium-covered surfaces maybe useful for atomic-beam manipulation of atomic hydrogen.
Quantum reflection of thermal He atoms from various surfaces (glass slide, GaAs wafer, flat, and structured Cr) at grazing conditions is studied within the elastic close-coupling formalism. Comparison with the experimental results of Zhao et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 133203 (2010)] is quite reasonable but the conclusions of the present theoretical analysis are different from those discussed in the experimental work. The universal linear behavior observed in the dependence of the reflection probability on the incident wave-vector component perpendicular to the surface is only valid at small values of the component whereas, at larger values, deviation from the linearity is evident, approaching a quadratic dependence at higher values. The surface roughness seems to play no important role in this scattering. Moreover, the claim that one observes a transition from quantum to classical reflection seems to be imprecise.
Recent results on the reflection of waves from ridged mirrors are discussed. Numerical calculations, analytical estimates and the direct measurements of coefficient of specular reflection of atomic waves from solid-state mirrors are combined. The reflectivity is approximated as an elementary function of period L of ridges, their width ℓ, wavenumber K, grazing angle θ and effective depth w of the van der Waals potential. In a special case L = ℓ, the fit reproduces the reflectivity of flat surfaces. Our approximation allows us to optimize the L at given ℓ and estimate the maximum performance of a ridged mirror. Such a mirror is suggested as a focusing element for the nano-scale imaging system. 1.