Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.02679

Entanglement inference from quantum erasure and path discrimination

Mohd Asad Siddiqui

quant-phSubmitted Nov 2, 2026• Announced Nov 3, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Fringes recovered by conditioning on quantum-eraser outcomes do not, by themselves, establish entanglement. We determine the minimum entanglement compatible with recorded eraser data when the preparation may be mixed, distinguishing these data from independently determined optimal which-path distinguishabilities and additional joint measurement outcomes. For noisy Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) preparations, explicit compatible states establish sharp entanglement-depth thresholds and show how parity information strengthens certification. A matching converse establishes the exact threshold for two complete Pauli-outcome distributions. For an ideal three-qubit eraser, we classify the additional marker measurement directions that certify genuine multipartite entanglement within a fixed eraser configuration and determine the separate minima of compatible concurrence and squared GHZ fidelity for specified tilted axes. For noisy three-qubit data, an exact semidefinite characterization and constructive converse determine biseparable compatibility at arbitrary fixed local measurement axes, with rational certificates bounding one example. These results establish what entanglement is required by the measurement record, rather than inferred from assumptions about the source.

AI Summary

The paper asks what entanglement is required by quantum-eraser measurement records when the source may be mixed. It distinguishes conditional path-state tomography, independently supplied optimal which-path distinguishabilities, and additional joint outcome distributions. A single product-projective eraser record always has a fully separable realization. For an $(m+1)$-qubit GHZ family with path-coherence parameter $\eta$ and white-noise fraction $p$, explicit GHZ and pair-entangled flagged preparations reproduce identical eraser records and all marker-subset distinguishabilities. The minimum compatible entanglement depth is exactly two for $p<1-1/\sqrt{1+\eta^2}$ and one otherwise. Retaining path–marker parity raises this threshold to $p<\eta/(1+\eta)$. Two specified complete Pauli distributions certify genuine multipartite entanglement exactly when $p<\eta/(2+\eta-2^{1-m})$, using an established stabilizer witness and matching biseparable constructions. For the ideal three-qubit target with fixed $Z_BX_C$ eraser tomography, one additional product measurement can certify genuine multipartite entanglement precisely when its $C$ direction satisfies $n_xn_z\ne0$, with suitable other axes. Logical-qubit support and positivity establish this classification and exact compatible concurrence and fidelity minima. For noisy three-qubit data at arbitrary fixed axes, real/partial-transpose symmetrization gives an exact biseparable-compatibility SDP with a constructive converse. Rational certificates bracket one example’s critical noise at $0.14919347\le p_c\le0.14919348$. The analysis assumes trusted measurements. Exact-axis results provide no uniform robustness near excluded directions; finite-trial guarantees additionally assume independent, setting-independent preparations and calibrated errors. No experimental resource advantage over conventional Pauli tests is established.

Little sign of AI-generated text

Error found: The claimed rigorous numerical bracket for the rational-axis example is not accompanied by the rational primal/dual certificates or boundary preparation needed to verify its endpoints.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
30 pages, 6 figures, 1 table; includes Supplemental Material

Related papers

Joint Relational Certification of Articulation and Entanglement from Two Global Observables

Oliver Tuma

Which properties of a quantum state are determined by two global observables and the outcomes of specified measurement sequences? On a calibrated four-level system, the marked observables determine two complementary qubit factor algebras without prior local qubit labels. For each measurement protocol, the paper asks how much entanglement every state compatible with its data must possess. For a single sequential measurement, retaining the complete outcome record gives sharp lower bounds on concurrence and negativity. A second measurement can be recorded either as a parity or as four resolved outcomes. The parity record gives a rank-five measurement space with explicit attainable bounds. Retaining individual population differences within a parity class can strengthen those bounds without further measurement runs. In an explicit example, the guaranteed concurrence rises from zero to one half. The paper identifies which population difference produces that gain and when the resulting certificate is exact. Further results include an exact rank formula for pulse sampling, a four-duration minimum within the specified pulse family, and explicit states for which rank-ten and rank-fourteen protocols certify entanglement in opposite directions. The manuscript gives finite-sample and calibration bounds and distinguishes reconstruction on the assumed system from identification of a physical realisation solely from probabilities. The accompanying archive contains fifteen Python verification scripts, run logs and a SHA-256 manifest. All numerical data are synthetic.

•Nov 4, 2026•0 citations

Observables suitable for restricting the fidelity to multipartite maximally entangled states

Koji Nagata, Masato Koashi, Nobuyuki Imoto

We present a class of observables which are suitable for determining the fidelity of a state to the multipartite Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) state. Given an expectation value of an observable belonging to the class, we give a simple formula that gives a lower bound and an upper bound for the fidelity. Applying the formula to the GHZ-state preparation experiment by Pan et al. [Nature (London) 403, 515 (2000)], we show that the observed state lies outside of the class of biseparable mixed three-qubit states. We also show that for this class of operators, adopting the principle of minimum variance [Phys. Rev. A 60, 4338 (1999)] in the state estimation always results in the state with the minimum fidelity.

arXiv:quant-ph/0510237•Physical Review A•Apr 1, 2002•15 citations

Neural quantum states for entanglement depth certification from randomized Pauli measurements

Marcin Płodzień

Entanglement depth quantifies how many qubits share genuine multipartite entanglement, but certification typically relies on tailored witnesses or full tomography, both of which scale poorly with system size. We recast entanglement-depth and non-$k$-separability certification as likelihood-based model selection among neural quantum states whose architecture enforces a chosen entanglement constraint. A hierarchy of separable neural quantum states is trained on finite-shot local Pauli outcomes and compared against an unconstrained reference model trained on the same data. When all constrained models are statistically disfavored, the data certify entanglement beyond the imposed limit directly from measurement statistics, without reconstructing the density matrix. We validate the method on simulated six- and ten-qubit datasets targeting GHZ, Dicke, and Bell-pair states, and demonstrate robustness for mixed states under local noise. Finally, we discuss lightweight interpretability diagnostics derived from trained parameters that expose coarse entanglement patterns and qubit groupings directly from bitstring statistics.

quant-pharXiv:2512.13121•Physical Review Research•Dec 16, 2025•1 citation

Entanglement classification and non- k -separability certification via Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger-class fidelity

Marcin Płodzień, Jan Chwedeńczuk, Maciej Lewenstein +1 more

Many-body quantum systems can be characterized using the notions of $k$-separability and entanglement depth. A quantum state is $k$-separable if it can be expressed as a mixture of $k$ entangled subsystems, and its entanglement depth is given by the size of the largest entangled subsystem. In this paper we propose a multipartite entanglement measure that satisfies the following criteria: (i) It can be used with both pure and mixed states; (ii) it is encoded in a single element of the density matrix, so it does not require knowledge of the full spectrum of the density matrix; (iii) it can be applied to large systems; and (iv) it can be experimentally verified. The proposed method allows the certification of non-$k$-separability of a given quantum state. We show that the proposed method successfully classifies three-qubit systems into known stochastic local operations and classical communication (SLOCC) classes, namely, bipartite, $W$-, and Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger-type entanglement. Furthermore, we characterize the non-$k$-separability in nine known SLOCC classes of four-qubit states and absolutely maximally entangled states for five and six qubits and for arbitrary-size-qubit Dicke states.

arXiv:2406.10662•Physical Review A•Sep 23, 2024•12 citations

Entanglement and genuine entanglement of three qubit GHZ diagonal states

Xiaoyu Chen, Li-zhen Jiang, Yu, Ping +1 more

We analytically prove the necessary and sufficient criterion for the full separability of three-qubit Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) diagonal states. The corresponding entanglement is exactly calculable for some GHZ diagonal states and is tractable for the others using the relative entropy of entanglement. We show that the biseparable criterion and the genuine entanglement are determined only by the biggest GHZ diagonal element regardless of all the other smaller diagonal elements. We have completely solved the entanglement problems of three-qubit GHZ diagonal states.

arXiv:1204.5511•Apr 24, 2012•3 citations

Multipartite Entanglement

Reinhold A. Bertlmann, Nicolai Friis

Abstract This chapter takes a closer look at entanglement in multipartite systems. An examination of pure tripartite systems serves a starting point from which we discover the equivalence classes of Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) states and W states. We then continue with the mixed-state case and discuss the notions of full separability, partition-separability and biseparability versus genuine tripartite entanglement, before stating the GHZ theorem in the formulation following Mermin. For systems of three or more parties we then formulate the definitions for k-separability and genuine multipartite entanglement (GME), as well as for k-producibility and entanglement depth, followed by prominent examples for GME states such as the generalized GHZ states and Dicke states. We give an overview of the problem of detecting GME using various linear and non-linear GME witnesses, lifted witnesses, PPT mixers, before discussing challenges for the characterization and quantification of multipartite entanglement. We close by analysing the phenomenon of entangled entanglement.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Sep 7, 2023•1 citation
Fringes recovered by conditioning on quantum-eraser outcomes do not, by themselves, establish entanglement. We determine the minimum entanglement compatible with recorded eraser data when the preparation may be mixed, distinguishing these data from independently determined optimal which-path distinguishabilities and additional joint measurement outcomes. For noisy Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) preparations, explicit compatible states establish sharp entanglement-depth thresholds and show how parity information strengthens certification. A matching converse establishes the exact threshold for two complete Pauli-outcome distributions. For an ideal three-qubit eraser, we classify the additional marker measurement directions that certify genuine multipartite entanglement within a fixed eraser configuration and determine the separate minima of compatible concurrence and squared GHZ fidelity for specified tilted axes. For noisy three-qubit data, an exact semidefinite characterization and constructive converse determine biseparable compatibility at arbitrary fixed local measurement axes, with rational certificates bounding one example. These results establish what entanglement is required by the measurement record, rather than inferred from assumptions about the source.
The paper asks what entanglement is required by quantum-eraser measurement records when the source may be mixed. It distinguishes conditional path-state tomography, independently supplied optimal which-path distinguishabilities, and additional joint outcome distributions. A single product-projective eraser record always has a fully separable realization.
For an (m+1)(m+1)(m+1)-qubit GHZ family with path-coherence parameter η\etaη and white-noise fraction ppp, explicit GHZ and pair-entangled flagged preparations reproduce identical eraser records and all marker-subset distinguishabilities. The minimum compatible entanglement depth is exactly two for p<1−1/1+η2p<1-1/\sqrt{1+\eta^2}p<1−1/1+η2​ and one otherwise. Retaining path–marker parity raises this threshold to p<η/(1+η)p<\eta/(1+\eta)p<η/(1+η). Two specified complete Pauli distributions certify genuine multipartite entanglement exactly when p<η/(2+η−21−m)p<\eta/(2+\eta-2^{1-m})p<η/(2+η−21−m), using an established stabilizer witness and matching biseparable constructions.
For the ideal three-qubit target with fixed ZBXCZ_BX_CZB​XC​ eraser tomography, one additional product measurement can certify genuine multipartite entanglement precisely when its CCC direction satisfies nxnz≠0n_xn_z\ne0nx​nz​=0, with suitable other axes. Logical-qubit support and positivity establish this classification and exact compatible concurrence and fidelity minima. For noisy three-qubit data at arbitrary fixed axes, real/partial-transpose symmetrization gives an exact biseparable-compatibility SDP with a constructive converse. Rational certificates bracket one example’s critical noise at 0.14919347≤pc≤0.149193480.14919347\le p_c\le0.149193480.14919347≤pc​≤0.14919348.
The analysis assumes trusted measurements. Exact-axis results provide no uniform robustness near excluded directions; finite-trial guarantees additionally assume independent, setting-independent preparations and calibrated errors. No experimental resource advantage over conventional Pauli tests is established.
Which properties of a quantum state are determined by two global observables and the outcomes of specified measurement sequences? On a calibrated four-level system, the marked observables determine two complementary qubit factor algebras without prior local qubit labels. For each measurement protocol, the paper asks how much entanglement every state compatible with its data must possess. For a single sequential measurement, retaining the complete outcome record gives sharp lower bounds on concurrence and negativity. A second measurement can be recorded either as a parity or as four resolved outcomes. The parity record gives a rank-five measurement space with explicit attainable bounds. Retaining individual population differences within a parity class can strengthen those bounds without further measurement runs. In an explicit example, the guaranteed concurrence rises from zero to one half. The paper identifies which population difference produces that gain and when the resulting certificate is exact. Further results include an exact rank formula for pulse sampling, a four-duration minimum within the specified pulse family, and explicit states for which rank-ten and rank-fourteen protocols certify entanglement in opposite directions. The manuscript gives finite-sample and calibration bounds and distinguishes reconstruction on the assumed system from identification of a physical realisation solely from probabilities. The accompanying archive contains fifteen Python verification scripts, run logs and a SHA-256 manifest. All numerical data are synthetic.
We present a class of observables which are suitable for determining the fidelity of a state to the multipartite Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) state. Given an expectation value of an observable belonging to the class, we give a simple formula that gives a lower bound and an upper bound for the fidelity. Applying the formula to the GHZ-state preparation experiment by Pan et al. [Nature (London) 403, 515 (2000)], we show that the observed state lies outside of the class of biseparable mixed three-qubit states. We also show that for this class of operators, adopting the principle of minimum variance [Phys. Rev. A 60, 4338 (1999)] in the state estimation always results in the state with the minimum fidelity.
Entanglement depth quantifies how many qubits share genuine multipartite entanglement, but certification typically relies on tailored witnesses or full tomography, both of which scale poorly with system size. We recast entanglement-depth and non-kkk-separability certification as likelihood-based model selection among neural quantum states whose architecture enforces a chosen entanglement constraint. A hierarchy of separable neural quantum states is trained on finite-shot local Pauli outcomes and compared against an unconstrained reference model trained on the same data. When all constrained models are statistically disfavored, the data certify entanglement beyond the imposed limit directly from measurement statistics, without reconstructing the density matrix. We validate the method on simulated six- and ten-qubit datasets targeting GHZ, Dicke, and Bell-pair states, and demonstrate robustness for mixed states under local noise. Finally, we discuss lightweight interpretability diagnostics derived from trained parameters that expose coarse entanglement patterns and qubit groupings directly from bitstring statistics.
Many-body quantum systems can be characterized using the notions of kkk-separability and entanglement depth. A quantum state is kkk-separable if it can be expressed as a mixture of kkk entangled subsystems, and its entanglement depth is given by the size of the largest entangled subsystem. In this paper we propose a multipartite entanglement measure that satisfies the following criteria: (i) It can be used with both pure and mixed states; (ii) it is encoded in a single element of the density matrix, so it does not require knowledge of the full spectrum of the density matrix; (iii) it can be applied to large systems; and (iv) it can be experimentally verified. The proposed method allows the certification of non-kkk-separability of a given quantum state. We show that the proposed method successfully classifies three-qubit systems into known stochastic local operations and classical communication (SLOCC) classes, namely, bipartite, WWW-, and Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger-type entanglement. Furthermore, we characterize the non-kkk-separability in nine known SLOCC classes of four-qubit states and absolutely maximally entangled states for five and six qubits and for arbitrary-size-qubit Dicke states.
We analytically prove the necessary and sufficient criterion for the full separability of three-qubit Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) diagonal states. The corresponding entanglement is exactly calculable for some GHZ diagonal states and is tractable for the others using the relative entropy of entanglement. We show that the biseparable criterion and the genuine entanglement are determined only by the biggest GHZ diagonal element regardless of all the other smaller diagonal elements. We have completely solved the entanglement problems of three-qubit GHZ diagonal states.
Abstract This chapter takes a closer look at entanglement in multipartite systems. An examination of pure tripartite systems serves a starting point from which we discover the equivalence classes of Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) states and W states. We then continue with the mixed-state case and discuss the notions of full separability, partition-separability and biseparability versus genuine tripartite entanglement, before stating the GHZ theorem in the formulation following Mermin. For systems of three or more parties we then formulate the definitions for k-separability and genuine multipartite entanglement (GME), as well as for k-producibility and entanglement depth, followed by prominent examples for GME states such as the generalized GHZ states and Dicke states. We give an overview of the problem of detecting GME using various linear and non-linear GME witnesses, lifted witnesses, PPT mixers, before discussing challenges for the characterization and quantification of multipartite entanglement. We close by analysing the phenomenon of entangled entanglement.