arXiv:2611.00443
Validation of the five-electron pO qubit in Si using full configuration interaction
David W. Kanaar, John H. Caporaletti, J. P. Kestner, Christopher R. Anderson, Mark F. Gyure
Abstract
The $pO$ qubit is a recently proposed charge qubit consisting of five electrons confined in a gate-defined Si quantum dot. Because its two qubit states have no dipole moment, it couples to electric fields only through the quadrupole moment, suppressing the dominant decoherence channel of conventional charge qubits while retaining all-electrical control. The original proposal was formulated in a shell-filling picture without Coulomb interactions. In this work we perform full configuration interaction (FCI) calculations to assess the impact of the Coulomb interaction on the viability of the $pO$ qubit. We find that the interacting eigenstates occupy orbital shells beyond the shell-filling picture, with the degree of excitation governed by the competition between valley splitting, orbital energy, and Coulomb energy scales. Additionally, we find that the ground states form degenerate doublets, but of two distinct kinds. Above a crossover near a valley splitting of $E_{\rm{VS}}\approx50~μ$eV the doublet is a pair of orbital angular momentum excitations with $|\langle L_z\rangle|=1$ in the lower valley, while below the crossover the doublet is a pair of single valley excitations with $\langle L_z\rangle=0$. Despite this substantial departure from the shell-filling picture, for $E_{\rm{VS}} > 50~μ$eV the essential features, vanishing dipole moments and nonzero quadrupole tensor between qubit states are preserved. We show that the vanishing dipole is in fact guaranteed by the symmetry properties of the five-electron Hamiltonian. The same energy scales that govern the orbital occupation also set the quadrupole tensor elements and the first excited state energy gap, both of which are in principle tunable through device engineering.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether Coulomb interactions preserve the operating principle of the proposed five-electron silicon $pO$ charge qubit: dipole-free logical states with nonzero quadrupole coupling for electrical control. It uses full configuration interaction in the $S_z=-1/2$ sector for an idealized, laterally harmonic Si/SiGe dot with $\hbar\omega=1$ meV, retaining 42 spatial orbitals through the $h$ shell and varying valley splitting from 2 to 240 $\mu$eV. Interactions substantially invalidate the noninteracting shell-filling picture: the ground states have mean orbital excitation near 10 rather than 1. A crossover occurs near $E_{\mathrm{VS}}\approx50\,\mu$eV. Below it, the ground doublet has zero orbital angular momentum and negligible quadrupole coupling; above it, the doublet has $L_z=\pm\hbar$, essentially no upper-valley occupation, and nonzero quadrupole coupling. The quadrupole-difference norm is approximately $361\,e\,\mathrm{nm}^2$, versus $1702\,e\,\mathrm{nm}^2$ without interactions. At $E_{\mathrm{VS}}=240\,\mu$eV, the excitation gap is approximately $63\,\mu$eV. Symmetry arguments establish the degeneracy of opposite-angular-momentum states and vanishing permanent and transition dipoles within same-parity doublets, independently of interaction strength. The model omits alloy disorder and spin–orbit coupling; parity-breaking disorder can restore dipole coupling. Direct convergence testing with both valleys is computationally inaccessible. A larger, lower-valley-only basis preserves the operating doublet but changes quadrupole norms by roughly 20% and reduces the gap to $51\,\mu$eV; it cannot test convergence of the valley crossover.
Error found: The approximately 50 μeV ground-state crossover lacks a larger-basis convergence test retaining both valleys, so its quantitative location is less firmly established than the qualitative existence of two regimes. The paper does not distinguish the angular-momentum eigenbasis used to report |⟨Lz⟩| = 1 from the superposition basis needed for its px/py-like densities and nonzero diagonal quadrupole difference. The control perturbation and frequency formula are algebraically inconsistent: at equal confinement frequencies the written perturbation remains quadrupolar but the formula predicts zero splitting. The simulated-input table lists a 55 μeV case, while the corresponding moment tables label it 50 μeV without explanation.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 15 pages, 13 figures