arXiv:2610.31680
Local Thermodynamics and Rényi Bounds on Black Hole Mergers
Sudhanva Joshi, Sunil Kumar Mishra
Abstract
Rényi entropy inequalities have been proposed to strengthen the area-theorem bound on mergers of thermodynamically stable black holes in Anti de Sitter (AdS) space. The stronger bounds depend on the joint initial state, whereas masses and temperatures fix only its local thermal marginals. We quantify this distinction inside the canonical two-hole description. Correlations confined to rare energy fluctuations can leave both thermal states exactly intact and drive the trace distance and mutual information to zero, yet still change the joint Rényi entropy at leading semiclassical order. We determine the smallest entropy compatible with a controlled approach to statistical independence, uniformly over all positive Rényi orders up to one. For equal Schwarzschild--AdS$_4$ holes, the resulting optimized canonical mass constraint reduces to the area bound at leading semiclassical order. The reduction concerns only the information needed to infer a bound; it does not produce a lighter attainable remnant or a dynamical instability. Stronger merger constraints therefore require control of the initial correlations beyond single black hole thermodynamics.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether Rényi-entropy merger bounds stronger than Hawking’s area bound follow from individual black holes’ thermal states, or require additional information about their initial correlations. It studies equal, stable Schwarzschild–AdS$_4$ holes in an effective canonical two-hole model. A separable construction suppresses simultaneous rare high-energy fluctuations while preserving both thermal marginals exactly. If each tail has probability $\delta$, its trace distance from the product state is $2\delta^2$, mutual information is $\delta^2+O(\delta^3)$, and maximum relative entropy is $-\log(1-\delta)$. Nevertheless, joint Rényi entropies change at leading semiclassical order. For Gibbs families with extensive thermal fluctuations, $S_1(\tau)=\Theta(\Lambda)$, and states satisfying $\rho\le e^{\eta_\Lambda}\tau^{\otimes2}$ with fixed marginals, $\eta_\Lambda\to0$, and $\log(1/\eta_\Lambda)=o(\Lambda)$, the sharp minimum is $S_1(\tau)+S_n(\tau)+o(\Lambda)$, uniformly over $0<n\le1$. Operator antitonicity establishes the quantum lower bound; one energy-sector construction attains it simultaneously for all orders. Using the canonical entropy response and nondecreasing heat capacity, the optimized merger constraint reduces to the area bound at leading order. At $r_i/\ell=1.1$, the product-state prescription instead gives $M_P/M_A=1.43227$. This is a statement about necessary entropy-derived constraints, not attainable remnants or merger dynamics. No smooth bulk realization or correlated replica saddle is supplied. Exact microscopic extension requires control over arbitrarily high temperatures beyond local stability; geometric Rényi constraints remain outside the analysis. Output measurement probabilities remain close under a common channel, while mean-mass stability additionally requires variance control.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 11 pages. To be submitted to a Journal. Comments will be highly appreciated