Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.31127

The often overlooked role of sound in liquid thermal transport

Kamran Behnia

cond-mat.mtrl-scicond-mat.othercond-mat.quant-gasquant-phSubmitted Oct 22, 2026• Announced Oct 23, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Formulated a hundred years ago, the Bridgman formula for thermal conductivity of liquids postulates a proportionality between sound velocity and thermal conductivity. This designates phonons as heat carriers in a liquid. Its empirical success has been under-appreciated and its conceptual implications overlooked. It is not mentioned in well-known condensed-matter textbook. Here, we review its origin, its links to hydrodynamic Euler equations and to the fundamental paradox surrounding the parabolic heat equation and its fate across the quantum-classical crossover.

AI Summary

This short review examines whether sound-mediated collective excitations provide a useful description of heat transport in liquids, focusing on the century-old Bridgman relation $\kappa=rk_Bv_sn^{2/3}$. It connects this empirical scaling to liquid correlations, hydrodynamics, finite-speed heat propagation, and the quantum–classical crossover. Using published transport and thermodynamic data, it compares thermal diffusivity across ice, liquid water, and vapor. For liquid water, the estimate $D=v_sd/3$, with intermolecular spacing $d\simeq0.31$ nm and sound speed $v_s\simeq1500$ m/s, gives $D\simeq0.155$ mm$^2$/s, compared with measured values of $0.14$–$0.17$ mm$^2$/s. In supercritical water at 40 MPa, the same estimate gives $0.072$ mm$^2$/s near 700 K, versus a measured minimum of approximately $0.063$ mm$^2$/s. A phenomenological construction starts from acoustic propagation in Euler hydrodynamics, then assumes local equilibration after one intermolecular transit. This yields Bridgman scaling with a heat-capacity-dependent, nonuniversal prefactor. Its finite relaxation time is related conceptually to Cattaneo–Vernotte heat transport. For normal liquid $^3$He, the paper revisits an earlier two-channel model combining quasiparticle conductivity proportional to $T^{-1}$ with a proposed collective contribution proportional to $T^{1/2}$. Reported agreement with data over roughly 0.02–3 K is within 20%. The discussion is not an exhaustive review; the equilibration length is assumed rather than microscopically derived, and agreement with helium data is explicitly not proof that sound carries most heat. Extension to metallic Fermi liquids remains open.

No sign of AI-generated textStrong assumptionsUnclear novelty

Central claim may not hold: The abstract identifies phonons as liquid heat carriers more definitively than the evidence warrants, because the conductivity construction assumes acoustic transport and molecular-scale relaxation rather than independently establishing that mechanism. Figure 4's caption omits the factor 1/3: the quoted inputs make v_s d approximately 233% larger than the measured minimum diffusivity, whereas v_s d/3 agrees within approximately 11%. The quantum-crossover discussion reports an extracted helium-4 prefactor r ≈ 1.8, although both Table 1 and its underlying numbers give r ≈ 1.54.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
10 pages, five figures

Related papers

Thermal conductivity of an ultracold Fermi gas in the BCS-BEC crossover

Hang Zhou, Yong-li Ma

Recent experiments on sound waves in a unitary Fermi gas reveal many transport properties about strongly interacting fermions. Sound propagates through the coupling of momentum and heat transport, and attenuates strongly with the presence of a phase transition. In this work, focusing on the temperature regimes near and below the superfluid critical temperature [Formula: see text] in the BCS-BEC crossover, we present a Kubo-based microscopic calculation of thermal conductivity [Formula: see text], which has not attracted much attention compared to the shear viscosity. Our approach primarily addresses the contributions of the fermionic quasiparticles to thermal transport and our results return to the kinetic descriptions at high temperatures. [Formula: see text] drops upon crossing the pseudogap temperature [Formula: see text], and its temperature dependence changes below [Formula: see text]. The drops become more pronounced on the weakly coupled BCS side, where the Pauli blocking causes the upturn of [Formula: see text] above [Formula: see text]. Our calculations fit well with the sound measurement on the damping rate.

Scientific Reports•Jan 13, 2021•8 citations

First, Second, and Quasi-Particle Sound

Philippe Nozières, David Pines

The wave propagation might be appropriately called quasi-particle sound, since in the long wave-length limit the only density fluctuations of importance are those produced by exciting a single quasi-particle from the condensate. Quasi-particle sound has essentially the same physical origin as zero sound in a Fermi liquid. The quasi-particle sound velocity will be temperature dependent, since the energy of a given quasi-particle depends on the thermal excitation of other quasi-particles. Superfluid hydrodynamics is richer than its Fermi liquid counterpart because one can have relative motion of the thermal quasi-particles and the condensate. This chapter describes the propagation of first and second sound in the hydrodynamic limit and then go on to a consideration of quasi-particle sound in the collisionless regime. A wide variety of irreversible phenomena which have as their physical origin collisions between the thermally-excited quasi-particles.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 5, 2018•0 citations

Propagation and attenuation of sound in one-dimensional quantum liquids

К. А. Матвеев, Anton V. Andreev

At low temperatures, elementary excitations of a one-dimensional quantum liquid form a gas that can move as a whole with respect to the center of mass of the system. This internal motion attenuates at exponentially long time scales. As a result, in a broad range of frequencies, the liquid is described by two-fluid hydrodynamics, and the system supports two sound modes. The physical nature of the two sounds depends on whether the particles forming the quantum liquid have a spin degree of freedom. For particles with spin, the modes are analogous to the first and second sound modes in superfluid $^{4}\mathrm{He}$, which are the waves of density and entropy, respectively. When dissipative processes are taken into account, we find that at low frequencies, the second sound is transformed into heat diffusion, while the first sound mode remains weakly damped and becomes the ordinary sound. In a spinless liquid, the entropy and density oscillations are strongly coupled and the resulting sound modes are hybrids of the first and second sound. As the frequency is lowered and dissipation processes become important, the crossover to a single-fluid regime occurs in two steps. First the hybrid modes transform into predominantly density and entropy waves, similar to the first and second sound, and then the density wave transforms to the ordinary sound and the entropy wave becomes a heat-diffusion mode. Finally, we account for the dissipation due to viscosity and intrinsic thermal conductivity of the gas of excitations, which controls attenuation of the sound modes at high frequencies.

arXiv:1809.01099•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Oct 29, 2018•8 citations

Transport Theory in Low Dimensional Systems from Thermoelectric Effects in Luttinger Liquids to Hydrodynamic Expansion of Cold Atoms

David Rasch

The impact of lattice vibrations on the electric conductivity has been considered a settled issue since the proof of the Migdal theorem. The precondition for its validity is a higher velocity of electronic than phononic excitation modes. In some new materials, e. g. weakly coupled spin chains and heavy fermion systems, this precondition is not fulfilled. The heat conductivity of such systems is calculated by means of perturbation theory in this work. Another subject is the interplay of Umklapp scattering and weak disorder in spin chains and one-dimensional correlated metals. Hidden conservation laws lead to a strong coupling between heat current and charge or spin current, respectively. The transport properties are calculated perturbatively within the hydrodynamic memory matrix formalism, which gives a lower bound to the conductivies. To calculate the Lorenz number of one-dimensional metals, we model within this formalism also the influence of phonons, which in physical systems contribute substantially to the heat current. The introduction of ultracold quantum gases in optical lattices in the recent years provides a powerful tool for the modeling of many systems to solid state physics, in particular systems out of equilibrium. The relatively slow dynamics of the cold atoms allows for time resolved imaging of the atoms and thus opens up new perspectives. In the last part of this thesis, a recent experiment, which measures the expansion of a correlated atom cloud in an optical lattice, is compared to a lattice Boltzmann simulation. Depending on the local density, the problem is shown to be described by the crossover from diffusive to ballistic transport.

•Jan 1, 2010•1 citation

Thermal conductivity in one-dimensional electronic fluids

Dmitri B. Gutman, Ivan V. Protopopov, Rickmoy Samanta +1 more

We study thermal conductivity in one-dimensional electronic fluids combining kinetic [R. Samanta, I. V. Protopopov, A. D. Mirlin, and D. B. Gutman, Thermal transport in one-dimensional electronic fluid, Phys. Rev. Lett. 122, 206801 (2019)] and hydrodynamic [I. V. Protopopov, R. Samanta, A. D. Mirlin, and D. B. Gutman, Anomalous hydrodynamics in one-dimensional electronic fluid, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 256801 (2021)] theories. The kinetic approach is developed by partitioning the Hilbert space into bosonic and fermionic sectors. We focus on the regime where the long-living thermal excitations are fermions and compute thermal conductivity. From the kinetic theory standpoint, the fermionic part of thermal conductivity is normal, while the bosonic one is anomalous, that scales as ω–1/3 and thus dominates in the infrared limit. The multi-mode hydrodynamic theory is obtained by projecting the fermionic kinetic equation on the zero modes of its collision integral. On a bare level, both theories agree and the thermal conductivity computed in hydrodynamic theory matches the result of the kinetic equation. The interaction between hydrodynamic modes leads to renormalization and consequently to anomalous scaling of the transport coefficients. In a four-mode regime, all modes are ballistic and the anomaly manifests itself in Kardar-Parisi-Zhang-like broadening with asymmetric power-law tails. “Heads” and “tails” of the pulses contribute equally to thermal conductivity, leading to ω–1/3 scaling of heat conductivity. In the three-mode regime, the system is in the universality class of a classical viscous fluid [Herbert Spohn, Nonlinear fluctuating hydrodynamics for anharmonic chains, J. Stat. Phys. 154, 1191 (2014); O. Narayan and S. Ramaswamy, Anomalous heat conduction in one-dimensional momentum-conserving systems, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 200601 (2002)].

Low Temperature Physics•Dec 1, 2023•1 citation

Landau's theory of superfluidity

Allan Griffin, Tetsuro Nikuni, E. Zaremba

In this chapter, we review the famous Landau theory of superfluidity at finite temperatures. This theory is based on coupled hydrodynamic equations for the superfluid and normal fluid components. Landau's two-fluid description is only valid when collisions among the thermal excitations making up the normal fluid are strong enough to produce local hydrodynamic equilibrium. These two-fluid equations were originally developed for liquid. He but are thought to be generic in form, describing the collision-dominated hydrodynamic region of all Bose superfluids. In this chapter, we will consider the solutions of the two-fluid equations mainly for a uniform superfluid. We discuss the existence of second sound (involving the out-of-phase motion of the superfluid and normal fluid components) as a characteristic feature of a Bose superfluid at finite temperatures. This chapter gives background material needed for Chapters 15–19. In Chapter 15, we will show that, in the appropriate limit, the Landau two-fluid equations can be derived from the ZNG coupled equations given in Chapter 3 for a trapped dilute Bose-condensed gas. In Chapters 17–19, we extend this discussion and derive the Landau–Khalatnikov two-fluid equations, which include hydrodynamic damping associated with various transport coefficients. Useful reviews of the two-fluid equations in the context of dilute spatially uniform Bose-condensed gases are given by Pethick and Smith (2008, Chapter 10) and Pitaevskii and Stringari (2003, Chapter 6). History of two-fluid equations The original discovery of superfluidity in liquid He was dramatically announced with the publication of the famous back-to-back papers of Kapitza (1938) in Moscow and Allen and Misener (1938) in Cambridge. These and subsequent experiments in the next few years showed that superfluid He could exhibit very bizarre hydrodynamic behaviour compared to classical liquids.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 19, 2009•1 citation
Formulated a hundred years ago, the Bridgman formula for thermal conductivity of liquids postulates a proportionality between sound velocity and thermal conductivity. This designates phonons as heat carriers in a liquid. Its empirical success has been under-appreciated and its conceptual implications overlooked. It is not mentioned in well-known condensed-matter textbook. Here, we review its origin, its links to hydrodynamic Euler equations and to the fundamental paradox surrounding the parabolic heat equation and its fate across the quantum-classical crossover.
This short review examines whether sound-mediated collective excitations provide a useful description of heat transport in liquids, focusing on the century-old Bridgman relation κ=rkBvsn2/3\kappa=rk_Bv_sn^{2/3}κ=rkB​vs​n2/3. It connects this empirical scaling to liquid correlations, hydrodynamics, finite-speed heat propagation, and the quantum–classical crossover.
Using published transport and thermodynamic data, it compares thermal diffusivity across ice, liquid water, and vapor. For liquid water, the estimate D=vsd/3D=v_sd/3D=vs​d/3, with intermolecular spacing d≃0.31d\simeq0.31d≃0.31 nm and sound speed vs≃1500v_s\simeq1500vs​≃1500 m/s, gives D≃0.155D\simeq0.155D≃0.155 mm2^22/s, compared with measured values of 0.140.140.14–0.170.170.17 mm2^22/s. In supercritical water at 40 MPa, the same estimate gives 0.0720.0720.072 mm2^22/s near 700 K, versus a measured minimum of approximately 0.0630.0630.063 mm2^22/s.
A phenomenological construction starts from acoustic propagation in Euler hydrodynamics, then assumes local equilibration after one intermolecular transit. This yields Bridgman scaling with a heat-capacity-dependent, nonuniversal prefactor. Its finite relaxation time is related conceptually to Cattaneo–Vernotte heat transport.
For normal liquid 3^33He, the paper revisits an earlier two-channel model combining quasiparticle conductivity proportional to T−1T^{-1}T−1 with a proposed collective contribution proportional to T1/2T^{1/2}T1/2. Reported agreement with data over roughly 0.02–3 K is within 20%. The discussion is not an exhaustive review; the equilibration length is assumed rather than microscopically derived, and agreement with helium data is explicitly not proof that sound carries most heat. Extension to metallic Fermi liquids remains open.
Recent experiments on sound waves in a unitary Fermi gas reveal many transport properties about strongly interacting fermions. Sound propagates through the coupling of momentum and heat transport, and attenuates strongly with the presence of a phase transition. In this work, focusing on the temperature regimes near and below the superfluid critical temperature [Formula: see text] in the BCS-BEC crossover, we present a Kubo-based microscopic calculation of thermal conductivity [Formula: see text], which has not attracted much attention compared to the shear viscosity. Our approach primarily addresses the contributions of the fermionic quasiparticles to thermal transport and our results return to the kinetic descriptions at high temperatures. [Formula: see text] drops upon crossing the pseudogap temperature [Formula: see text], and its temperature dependence changes below [Formula: see text]. The drops become more pronounced on the weakly coupled BCS side, where the Pauli blocking causes the upturn of [Formula: see text] above [Formula: see text]. Our calculations fit well with the sound measurement on the damping rate.
The wave propagation might be appropriately called quasi-particle sound, since in the long wave-length limit the only density fluctuations of importance are those produced by exciting a single quasi-particle from the condensate. Quasi-particle sound has essentially the same physical origin as zero sound in a Fermi liquid. The quasi-particle sound velocity will be temperature dependent, since the energy of a given quasi-particle depends on the thermal excitation of other quasi-particles. Superfluid hydrodynamics is richer than its Fermi liquid counterpart because one can have relative motion of the thermal quasi-particles and the condensate. This chapter describes the propagation of first and second sound in the hydrodynamic limit and then go on to a consideration of quasi-particle sound in the collisionless regime. A wide variety of irreversible phenomena which have as their physical origin collisions between the thermally-excited quasi-particles.
At low temperatures, elementary excitations of a one-dimensional quantum liquid form a gas that can move as a whole with respect to the center of mass of the system. This internal motion attenuates at exponentially long time scales. As a result, in a broad range of frequencies, the liquid is described by two-fluid hydrodynamics, and the system supports two sound modes. The physical nature of the two sounds depends on whether the particles forming the quantum liquid have a spin degree of freedom. For particles with spin, the modes are analogous to the first and second sound modes in superfluid 4He^{4}\mathrm{He}4He, which are the waves of density and entropy, respectively. When dissipative processes are taken into account, we find that at low frequencies, the second sound is transformed into heat diffusion, while the first sound mode remains weakly damped and becomes the ordinary sound. In a spinless liquid, the entropy and density oscillations are strongly coupled and the resulting sound modes are hybrids of the first and second sound. As the frequency is lowered and dissipation processes become important, the crossover to a single-fluid regime occurs in two steps. First the hybrid modes transform into predominantly density and entropy waves, similar to the first and second sound, and then the density wave transforms to the ordinary sound and the entropy wave becomes a heat-diffusion mode. Finally, we account for the dissipation due to viscosity and intrinsic thermal conductivity of the gas of excitations, which controls attenuation of the sound modes at high frequencies.
The impact of lattice vibrations on the electric conductivity has been considered a settled issue since the proof of the Migdal theorem. The precondition for its validity is a higher velocity of electronic than phononic excitation modes. In some new materials, e. g. weakly coupled spin chains and heavy fermion systems, this precondition is not fulfilled. The heat conductivity of such systems is calculated by means of perturbation theory in this work. Another subject is the interplay of Umklapp scattering and weak disorder in spin chains and one-dimensional correlated metals. Hidden conservation laws lead to a strong coupling between heat current and charge or spin current, respectively. The transport properties are calculated perturbatively within the hydrodynamic memory matrix formalism, which gives a lower bound to the conductivies. To calculate the Lorenz number of one-dimensional metals, we model within this formalism also the influence of phonons, which in physical systems contribute substantially to the heat current. The introduction of ultracold quantum gases in optical lattices in the recent years provides a powerful tool for the modeling of many systems to solid state physics, in particular systems out of equilibrium. The relatively slow dynamics of the cold atoms allows for time resolved imaging of the atoms and thus opens up new perspectives. In the last part of this thesis, a recent experiment, which measures the expansion of a correlated atom cloud in an optical lattice, is compared to a lattice Boltzmann simulation. Depending on the local density, the problem is shown to be described by the crossover from diffusive to ballistic transport.
We study thermal conductivity in one-dimensional electronic fluids combining kinetic [R. Samanta, I. V. Protopopov, A. D. Mirlin, and D. B. Gutman, Thermal transport in one-dimensional electronic fluid, Phys. Rev. Lett. 122, 206801 (2019)] and hydrodynamic [I. V. Protopopov, R. Samanta, A. D. Mirlin, and D. B. Gutman, Anomalous hydrodynamics in one-dimensional electronic fluid, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 256801 (2021)] theories. The kinetic approach is developed by partitioning the Hilbert space into bosonic and fermionic sectors. We focus on the regime where the long-living thermal excitations are fermions and compute thermal conductivity. From the kinetic theory standpoint, the fermionic part of thermal conductivity is normal, while the bosonic one is anomalous, that scales as ω–1/3 and thus dominates in the infrared limit. The multi-mode hydrodynamic theory is obtained by projecting the fermionic kinetic equation on the zero modes of its collision integral. On a bare level, both theories agree and the thermal conductivity computed in hydrodynamic theory matches the result of the kinetic equation. The interaction between hydrodynamic modes leads to renormalization and consequently to anomalous scaling of the transport coefficients. In a four-mode regime, all modes are ballistic and the anomaly manifests itself in Kardar-Parisi-Zhang-like broadening with asymmetric power-law tails. “Heads” and “tails” of the pulses contribute equally to thermal conductivity, leading to ω–1/3 scaling of heat conductivity. In the three-mode regime, the system is in the universality class of a classical viscous fluid [Herbert Spohn, Nonlinear fluctuating hydrodynamics for anharmonic chains, J. Stat. Phys. 154, 1191 (2014); O. Narayan and S. Ramaswamy, Anomalous heat conduction in one-dimensional momentum-conserving systems, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 200601 (2002)].
In this chapter, we review the famous Landau theory of superfluidity at finite temperatures. This theory is based on coupled hydrodynamic equations for the superfluid and normal fluid components. Landau's two-fluid description is only valid when collisions among the thermal excitations making up the normal fluid are strong enough to produce local hydrodynamic equilibrium. These two-fluid equations were originally developed for liquid. He but are thought to be generic in form, describing the collision-dominated hydrodynamic region of all Bose superfluids. In this chapter, we will consider the solutions of the two-fluid equations mainly for a uniform superfluid. We discuss the existence of second sound (involving the out-of-phase motion of the superfluid and normal fluid components) as a characteristic feature of a Bose superfluid at finite temperatures. This chapter gives background material needed for Chapters 15–19. In Chapter 15, we will show that, in the appropriate limit, the Landau two-fluid equations can be derived from the ZNG coupled equations given in Chapter 3 for a trapped dilute Bose-condensed gas. In Chapters 17–19, we extend this discussion and derive the Landau–Khalatnikov two-fluid equations, which include hydrodynamic damping associated with various transport coefficients. Useful reviews of the two-fluid equations in the context of dilute spatially uniform Bose-condensed gases are given by Pethick and Smith (2008, Chapter 10) and Pitaevskii and Stringari (2003, Chapter 6). History of two-fluid equations The original discovery of superfluidity in liquid He was dramatically announced with the publication of the famous back-to-back papers of Kapitza (1938) in Moscow and Allen and Misener (1938) in Cambridge. These and subsequent experiments in the next few years showed that superfluid He could exhibit very bizarre hydrodynamic behaviour compared to classical liquids.