arXiv:2610.31127
The often overlooked role of sound in liquid thermal transport
Kamran Behnia
Abstract
Formulated a hundred years ago, the Bridgman formula for thermal conductivity of liquids postulates a proportionality between sound velocity and thermal conductivity. This designates phonons as heat carriers in a liquid. Its empirical success has been under-appreciated and its conceptual implications overlooked. It is not mentioned in well-known condensed-matter textbook. Here, we review its origin, its links to hydrodynamic Euler equations and to the fundamental paradox surrounding the parabolic heat equation and its fate across the quantum-classical crossover.
AI Summary
This short review examines whether sound-mediated collective excitations provide a useful description of heat transport in liquids, focusing on the century-old Bridgman relation $\kappa=rk_Bv_sn^{2/3}$. It connects this empirical scaling to liquid correlations, hydrodynamics, finite-speed heat propagation, and the quantum–classical crossover. Using published transport and thermodynamic data, it compares thermal diffusivity across ice, liquid water, and vapor. For liquid water, the estimate $D=v_sd/3$, with intermolecular spacing $d\simeq0.31$ nm and sound speed $v_s\simeq1500$ m/s, gives $D\simeq0.155$ mm$^2$/s, compared with measured values of $0.14$–$0.17$ mm$^2$/s. In supercritical water at 40 MPa, the same estimate gives $0.072$ mm$^2$/s near 700 K, versus a measured minimum of approximately $0.063$ mm$^2$/s. A phenomenological construction starts from acoustic propagation in Euler hydrodynamics, then assumes local equilibration after one intermolecular transit. This yields Bridgman scaling with a heat-capacity-dependent, nonuniversal prefactor. Its finite relaxation time is related conceptually to Cattaneo–Vernotte heat transport. For normal liquid $^3$He, the paper revisits an earlier two-channel model combining quasiparticle conductivity proportional to $T^{-1}$ with a proposed collective contribution proportional to $T^{1/2}$. Reported agreement with data over roughly 0.02–3 K is within 20%. The discussion is not an exhaustive review; the equilibration length is assumed rather than microscopically derived, and agreement with helium data is explicitly not proof that sound carries most heat. Extension to metallic Fermi liquids remains open.
Central claim may not hold: The abstract identifies phonons as liquid heat carriers more definitively than the evidence warrants, because the conductivity construction assumes acoustic transport and molecular-scale relaxation rather than independently establishing that mechanism. Figure 4's caption omits the factor 1/3: the quoted inputs make v_s d approximately 233% larger than the measured minimum diffusivity, whereas v_s d/3 agrees within approximately 11%. The quantum-crossover discussion reports an extracted helium-4 prefactor r ≈ 1.8, although both Table 1 and its underlying numbers give r ≈ 1.54.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 10 pages, five figures