Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.11094

Attainable Boundaries versus Operational Equivalence: Dual Benchmarks for the Hierarchical Assessment of Quantum Resources

Sunho Kim, Chunhe Xiong, Junde Wu

quant-phSubmitted Oct 8, 2026• Announced Oct 9, 2026• 0 citations
v1 · Oct 8, 2026v2 · Oct 27, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

While conventional quantum resource theories quantify utility relative to an idealized set of free states, practical implementations are confined to a specific supply environment---a framework encompassing all states realizable or preparable via current experimental apparatus and design choices, not limited to free states. This work proposes a novel framework for evaluating the relative utility of arbitrary quantum states against the resource set made accessible by these current selections. We specifically focus our investigation on two canonical representations: the set of states reachable via free operations as the attainable boundary imposed by current experimental constraints, and the set defined through numerical optimization as the criterion for operational equivalence. Our framework establishes two core evaluation methodologies. First, we provide a strategy-dependent benchmark by assessing a state's performance relative to the reference set under its individually optimized strategy, thereby quantifying achievable performance. Second, we derive a computable lower bound on this superiority by considering optimal strategies for each state individually, enabling the quantification of strategy-independent relative performance independent of specific experimental setups. Beyond relative efficiency metrics, we demonstrate the practical utility of this approach for resource management scenarios, including the selective extraction of states advantageous for storage and distribution, and the concentration of residual resources. Using quantum entanglement as a paradigmatic example, we prove that distillable entanglement can be fully recovered via extraction and concentration when the reference set is restricted to pure states, thereby demonstrating the practical relevance of our framework.

Comments
13 pages, 2 figures

Related papers

Quantification of Quantum Resources

Gilad Gour

Chapter 10 delves into the quantification of quantum resources, an essential aspect of quantum resource theories that determines the value of quantum states for specific applications. It begins by defining resource measures and investigating their fundamental properties such as monotonicity under free operations and convexity. The chapter discusses distance-based resource measures, which quantify how far a given quantum state is from the set of free states. Such measures often utilize divergences and metrics explored in earlier chapters. Techniques to compute the relative entropy of a resource are also covered. To refine resource measures, the chapter introduces the concept of smoothing, which considers small deviations from the ideal state to make the measures more robust against perturbations. This approach is crucial in single-shot scenarios where finite resources are available. Furthermore, the chapter examines resource monotones and support functions, offering a comprehensive framework for the theoretical and practical assessment of quantum resources.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 10, 2025•0 citations

Distance-based resource quantification for sets of quantum measurements

Lucas Tendick, Martin Kliesch, Hermann Kampermann +1 more

The advantage that quantum systems provide for certain quantum information processing tasks over their classical counterparts can be quantified within the general framework of resource theories. Certain distance functions between quantum states have successfully been used to quantify resources like entanglement and coherence. Perhaps surprisingly, such a distance-based approach has not been adopted to study resources of quantum measurements, where other geometric quantifiers are used instead. Here, we define distance functions between sets of quantum measurements and show that they naturally induce resource monotones for convex resource theories of measurements. By focusing on a distance based on the diamond norm, we establish a hierarchy of measurement resources and derive analytical bounds on the incompatibility of any set of measurements. We show that these bounds are tight for certain projective measurements based on mutually unbiased bases and identify scenarios where different measurement resources attain the same value when quantified by our resource monotone. Our results provide a general framework to compare distance-based resources for sets of measurements and allow us to obtain limitations on Bell-type experiments.

arXiv:2205.08546•Quantum•May 15, 2023•14 citations

Quantification of the Resource Theory of Imaginarity Revisited

Yue Han, Naihong Hu

This work studies the decay of three imaginarity measures, namely the $l_1$-norm-based imaginarity, the robustness of imaginarity, and the relative-entropy-based imaginarity, under typical noise channels. For arbitrary single-qubit pure states subject to real quantum channels, we prove an exact attenuation theorem: the $l_1$-norm-based imaginarity and the robustness exhibit identical attenuation governed by a common channel-dependent factor, whereas the relative-entropy-based imaginarity additionally depends on the input-state orientation relative to the reference basis. We extend the investigation to two-qubit entangled and dual-rail states, establishing a quantitative link between photon-loss probability and residual imaginarity for photonic dual-rail encodings. For separable two-qubit states, we define a real-operation resource preorder and show that $Ω_{++}=|+\rangle\langle+|\otimes|+\rangle\langle+|$ is operationally maximal. We further distinguish operational de-imaginary power from reference-state imaginarity loss. For several real two-qubit channels we derive exact operational de-imaginary powers, while for other channels we provide analytic reference-state losses serving as benchmarks and rigorous lower bounds.

quant-pharXiv:2603.13980•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Mar 17, 2026•0 citations

Resource-Induced Non-Representability of Exact Quantum Limits

Claudio Menéndez

This work studies the operational limitations on the physical realization of exact mathematical limits in quantum theory. Focusing on the zero-temperature limit, we analyze the extent to which ground-state preparation can be achieved using quantum operations constrained by finite physical resources. We introduce a general class of physically realizable quantum channels characterized by bounded interaction strength, finite implementation time, and finite control resolution. Within this resource-theoretic setting, we derive bounds on spectral localization using quantum speed limits and variance propagation arguments. These bounds imply that arbitrarily sharp spectral concentration cannot be achieved by finite-resource operations in finite time. As a consequence, the preparation of states arbitrarily close to the exact ground state is subject to resource-dependent limitations. In particular, the achievable trace distance to the ground state is bounded from below by a quantity determined by the available energy, control precision, and operational time. The result is independent of specific coarse-graining models or measurement schemes. Instead, the limitation follows from general dynamical and informational constraints associated with finite resources in quantum operations. This perspective provides a resource-theoretic interpretation of the third law of thermodynamics. Within this framework, the unattainability of absolute zero can be understood not only as a dynamical constraint but also as a consequence of operational bounds on spectral localization. These considerations also imply practical limits for ground-state preparation, quantum annealing protocols, and low-temperature quantum metrology, where finite resources impose irreducible accuracy floors. The analysis is interpreted within the broader program of Finite-Closure Geometry (FCG), which distinguishes between mathematical closure operations (such as exact limits) and the physically realizable projections produced by finite-resource dynamics. In this view, exact limits function as ideal mathematical constructs that guide theoretical descriptions but cannot be implemented exactly by finite physical processes. Related work This work complements and extends the results of Operational Non-Representability of the Zero-Temperature Limit under Finite Energy Resolution (Menéndez, 2025). The earlier paper demonstrates non-representability through explicit finite-resolution coarse-graining channels. The present work instead analyzes the problem from a more general resource-theoretic perspective, where the obstruction arises from dynamical bounds on quantum operations implemented with finite resources. In this sense, finite-resolution models appear as particular realizations within a broader class of resource-constrained dynamics. Together, the two works provide both an explicit operational example and a general dynamical perspective on the limitations associated with exact quantum limits. Conceptual index of the Finite-Closure Geometry (FCG) research program Finite-Closure Geometry (FCG): A Structural Program for Global Non-ClosureDOI: 10.5281/zenodo.18001440 Keywords quantum channels, finite resources, zero-temperature limit, third law of thermodynamics, quantum speed limits, spectral localization, ground-state preparation, quantum thermodynamics, operational limits, trace distance, resource theory, finite-closure geometry, quantum foundations, mathematical limits

•Dec 30, 2025•0 citations

Distillation and simulation in quantum information

Kun Fang

We use the techniques of convex optimization, especially semidefinite programming, to study two kinds of fundamental tasks, i.e., distillation and simulation in quantum information theory. We investigate these tasks in a unified framework of resource theory and focus on their computation and characterization with finite resources. Particularly we study the tradeoff among relevant parameters such as the number of resource copies, resource transformation rate, error tolerance and success probability. In the first part, we study the task of distillation for two different resources, maximally entangled state and maximally coherent state, representing nonlocal and local “quantumness” respectively. For entanglement distillation, we derive an efficiently computable second-order estimation of the distillation rate for general quantum states, which are tight for quantum states of practical interest. Our study overcomes the limitation of conventional research either focusing on the asymptotic rate or ignoring the computability. For the coherence distillation, we perform finite analysis for both deterministic and probabilistic scenarios. Our results unveil several new features of coherence from a resource theoretic viewpoint and contribute to an increased understanding of the fundamental properties of different sets of free operations. In the second part, we investigate the resource cost of simulating a quantum channel via quantum coherence or another quantum channel. We introduce the channel’s analogs of max-relative entropy, logarithmic robustness and max-information of quantum states, providing their operational interpretation with the channel simulation cost via different resources. Particularly, we establish the asymptotic equipartition property of the channel’s max-information, that is, it converges to the quantum mutual information of the channel in the independent and identically distributed asymptotic limit. As applications, this asymptotic equipartition property implies the quantum reverse Shannon theorem in the presence of non-signalling correlations. From the perspective of resource theory, the worth of a resource can usually be characterized by the minimum distance to a set of useless resources under a proper distance measure. We give such characterization for all the tasks studied in this thesis, and find that the distance measure for the distillation and simulation process naturally corresponds to the quantum hypothesis testing relative entropy and the max-relative entropy, respectively.

•Jan 1, 2018•1 citation

Complexity-Constrained Quantum Thermodynamics

Anthony Munson, Naga Bhavya Teja Kothakonda, Jonas Haferkamp +3 more

Quantum complexity measures the difficulty of realizing a quantum process, such as preparing a state or implementing a unitary. We present an approach to quantifying the thermodynamic resources required to implement a process if the process’s complexity is restricted. We focus on the prototypical task of information erasure, or Landauer erasure, wherein an n -qubit memory is reset to the all-zero state. We show that the minimum thermodynamic work required to reset an arbitrary state in our model, via a complexity-constrained process, is quantified by the state’s . The complexity entropy therefore quantifies a trade-off between the work cost and complexity cost of resetting a state. If the qubits have a nontrivial (but product) Hamiltonian, the optimal work cost is determined by the . The complexity entropy quantifies the amount of randomness a system appears to have to a computationally limited observer. Similarly, the complexity relative entropy quantifies such an observer’s ability to distinguish two states. We prove elementary properties of the complexity (relative) entropy. In a random circuit—a simple model for quantum chaotic dynamics—the complexity entropy transitions from zero to its maximal value around the time corresponding to the observer’s computational-power limit. Also, we identify information-theoretic applications of the complexity entropy. The complexity entropy quantifies the resources required for data compression if the compression algorithm must use a restricted number of gates. We further introduce a , which arises naturally in a complexity-constrained variant of information-theoretic decoupling. Assuming that this entropy obeys a conjectured chain rule, we show that the entropy bounds the number of qubits that one can decouple from a reference system, as judged by a computationally bounded referee. Overall, our framework extends the resource-theoretic approach to thermodynamics to integrate a notion of , as quantified by .

arXiv:2403.04828•PRX Quantum•Mar 10, 2025•24 citations
While conventional quantum resource theories quantify utility relative to an idealized set of free states, practical implementations are confined to a specific supply environment---a framework encompassing all states realizable or preparable via current experimental apparatus and design choices, not limited to free states. This work proposes a novel framework for evaluating the relative utility of arbitrary quantum states against the resource set made accessible by these current selections. We specifically focus our investigation on two canonical representations: the set of states reachable via free operations as the attainable boundary imposed by current experimental constraints, and the set defined through numerical optimization as the criterion for operational equivalence. Our framework establishes two core evaluation methodologies. First, we provide a strategy-dependent benchmark by assessing a state's performance relative to the reference set under its individually optimized strategy, thereby quantifying achievable performance. Second, we derive a computable lower bound on this superiority by considering optimal strategies for each state individually, enabling the quantification of strategy-independent relative performance independent of specific experimental setups. Beyond relative efficiency metrics, we demonstrate the practical utility of this approach for resource management scenarios, including the selective extraction of states advantageous for storage and distribution, and the concentration of residual resources. Using quantum entanglement as a paradigmatic example, we prove that distillable entanglement can be fully recovered via extraction and concentration when the reference set is restricted to pure states, thereby demonstrating the practical relevance of our framework.
Chapter 10 delves into the quantification of quantum resources, an essential aspect of quantum resource theories that determines the value of quantum states for specific applications. It begins by defining resource measures and investigating their fundamental properties such as monotonicity under free operations and convexity. The chapter discusses distance-based resource measures, which quantify how far a given quantum state is from the set of free states. Such measures often utilize divergences and metrics explored in earlier chapters. Techniques to compute the relative entropy of a resource are also covered. To refine resource measures, the chapter introduces the concept of smoothing, which considers small deviations from the ideal state to make the measures more robust against perturbations. This approach is crucial in single-shot scenarios where finite resources are available. Furthermore, the chapter examines resource monotones and support functions, offering a comprehensive framework for the theoretical and practical assessment of quantum resources.
The advantage that quantum systems provide for certain quantum information processing tasks over their classical counterparts can be quantified within the general framework of resource theories. Certain distance functions between quantum states have successfully been used to quantify resources like entanglement and coherence. Perhaps surprisingly, such a distance-based approach has not been adopted to study resources of quantum measurements, where other geometric quantifiers are used instead. Here, we define distance functions between sets of quantum measurements and show that they naturally induce resource monotones for convex resource theories of measurements. By focusing on a distance based on the diamond norm, we establish a hierarchy of measurement resources and derive analytical bounds on the incompatibility of any set of measurements. We show that these bounds are tight for certain projective measurements based on mutually unbiased bases and identify scenarios where different measurement resources attain the same value when quantified by our resource monotone. Our results provide a general framework to compare distance-based resources for sets of measurements and allow us to obtain limitations on Bell-type experiments.
This work studies the decay of three imaginarity measures, namely the l1l_1l1​-norm-based imaginarity, the robustness of imaginarity, and the relative-entropy-based imaginarity, under typical noise channels. For arbitrary single-qubit pure states subject to real quantum channels, we prove an exact attenuation theorem: the l1l_1l1​-norm-based imaginarity and the robustness exhibit identical attenuation governed by a common channel-dependent factor, whereas the relative-entropy-based imaginarity additionally depends on the input-state orientation relative to the reference basis. We extend the investigation to two-qubit entangled and dual-rail states, establishing a quantitative link between photon-loss probability and residual imaginarity for photonic dual-rail encodings. For separable two-qubit states, we define a real-operation resource preorder and show that Ω++=∣+⟩⟨+∣⊗∣+⟩⟨+∣Ω_{++}=|+\rangle\langle+|\otimes|+\rangle\langle+|Ω++​=∣+⟩⟨+∣⊗∣+⟩⟨+∣ is operationally maximal. We further distinguish operational de-imaginary power from reference-state imaginarity loss. For several real two-qubit channels we derive exact operational de-imaginary powers, while for other channels we provide analytic reference-state losses serving as benchmarks and rigorous lower bounds.
This work studies the operational limitations on the physical realization of exact mathematical limits in quantum theory. Focusing on the zero-temperature limit, we analyze the extent to which ground-state preparation can be achieved using quantum operations constrained by finite physical resources. We introduce a general class of physically realizable quantum channels characterized by bounded interaction strength, finite implementation time, and finite control resolution. Within this resource-theoretic setting, we derive bounds on spectral localization using quantum speed limits and variance propagation arguments. These bounds imply that arbitrarily sharp spectral concentration cannot be achieved by finite-resource operations in finite time. As a consequence, the preparation of states arbitrarily close to the exact ground state is subject to resource-dependent limitations. In particular, the achievable trace distance to the ground state is bounded from below by a quantity determined by the available energy, control precision, and operational time. The result is independent of specific coarse-graining models or measurement schemes. Instead, the limitation follows from general dynamical and informational constraints associated with finite resources in quantum operations. This perspective provides a resource-theoretic interpretation of the third law of thermodynamics. Within this framework, the unattainability of absolute zero can be understood not only as a dynamical constraint but also as a consequence of operational bounds on spectral localization. These considerations also imply practical limits for ground-state preparation, quantum annealing protocols, and low-temperature quantum metrology, where finite resources impose irreducible accuracy floors. The analysis is interpreted within the broader program of Finite-Closure Geometry (FCG), which distinguishes between mathematical closure operations (such as exact limits) and the physically realizable projections produced by finite-resource dynamics. In this view, exact limits function as ideal mathematical constructs that guide theoretical descriptions but cannot be implemented exactly by finite physical processes. Related work This work complements and extends the results of Operational Non-Representability of the Zero-Temperature Limit under Finite Energy Resolution (Menéndez, 2025). The earlier paper demonstrates non-representability through explicit finite-resolution coarse-graining channels. The present work instead analyzes the problem from a more general resource-theoretic perspective, where the obstruction arises from dynamical bounds on quantum operations implemented with finite resources. In this sense, finite-resolution models appear as particular realizations within a broader class of resource-constrained dynamics. Together, the two works provide both an explicit operational example and a general dynamical perspective on the limitations associated with exact quantum limits. Conceptual index of the Finite-Closure Geometry (FCG) research program Finite-Closure Geometry (FCG): A Structural Program for Global Non-ClosureDOI: 10.5281/zenodo.18001440 Keywords quantum channels, finite resources, zero-temperature limit, third law of thermodynamics, quantum speed limits, spectral localization, ground-state preparation, quantum thermodynamics, operational limits, trace distance, resource theory, finite-closure geometry, quantum foundations, mathematical limits
We use the techniques of convex optimization, especially semidefinite programming, to study two kinds of fundamental tasks, i.e., distillation and simulation in quantum information theory. We investigate these tasks in a unified framework of resource theory and focus on their computation and characterization with finite resources. Particularly we study the tradeoff among relevant parameters such as the number of resource copies, resource transformation rate, error tolerance and success probability. In the first part, we study the task of distillation for two different resources, maximally entangled state and maximally coherent state, representing nonlocal and local “quantumness” respectively. For entanglement distillation, we derive an efficiently computable second-order estimation of the distillation rate for general quantum states, which are tight for quantum states of practical interest. Our study overcomes the limitation of conventional research either focusing on the asymptotic rate or ignoring the computability. For the coherence distillation, we perform finite analysis for both deterministic and probabilistic scenarios. Our results unveil several new features of coherence from a resource theoretic viewpoint and contribute to an increased understanding of the fundamental properties of different sets of free operations. In the second part, we investigate the resource cost of simulating a quantum channel via quantum coherence or another quantum channel. We introduce the channel’s analogs of max-relative entropy, logarithmic robustness and max-information of quantum states, providing their operational interpretation with the channel simulation cost via different resources. Particularly, we establish the asymptotic equipartition property of the channel’s max-information, that is, it converges to the quantum mutual information of the channel in the independent and identically distributed asymptotic limit. As applications, this asymptotic equipartition property implies the quantum reverse Shannon theorem in the presence of non-signalling correlations. From the perspective of resource theory, the worth of a resource can usually be characterized by the minimum distance to a set of useless resources under a proper distance measure. We give such characterization for all the tasks studied in this thesis, and find that the distance measure for the distillation and simulation process naturally corresponds to the quantum hypothesis testing relative entropy and the max-relative entropy, respectively.
Quantum complexity measures the difficulty of realizing a quantum process, such as preparing a state or implementing a unitary. We present an approach to quantifying the thermodynamic resources required to implement a process if the process’s complexity is restricted. We focus on the prototypical task of information erasure, or Landauer erasure, wherein an n -qubit memory is reset to the all-zero state. We show that the minimum thermodynamic work required to reset an arbitrary state in our model, via a complexity-constrained process, is quantified by the state’s . The complexity entropy therefore quantifies a trade-off between the work cost and complexity cost of resetting a state. If the qubits have a nontrivial (but product) Hamiltonian, the optimal work cost is determined by the . The complexity entropy quantifies the amount of randomness a system appears to have to a computationally limited observer. Similarly, the complexity relative entropy quantifies such an observer’s ability to distinguish two states. We prove elementary properties of the complexity (relative) entropy. In a random circuit—a simple model for quantum chaotic dynamics—the complexity entropy transitions from zero to its maximal value around the time corresponding to the observer’s computational-power limit. Also, we identify information-theoretic applications of the complexity entropy. The complexity entropy quantifies the resources required for data compression if the compression algorithm must use a restricted number of gates. We further introduce a , which arises naturally in a complexity-constrained variant of information-theoretic decoupling. Assuming that this entropy obeys a conjectured chain rule, we show that the entropy bounds the number of qubits that one can decouple from a reference system, as judged by a computationally bounded referee. Overall, our framework extends the resource-theoretic approach to thermodynamics to integrate a notion of , as quantified by .