Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.00826

Thermal entanglement transitions from strong $\textrm{SU}(2)$ symmetry

Siqi Mo, Ehud Altman, Samuel J. Garratt

cond-mat.stat-mechcond-mat.str-elquant-phSubmitted Sep 30, 2026• Announced Oct 2, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study mixed-state entanglement in Gibbs states with strong $\mathrm{SU}(2)$ symmetry, focusing on locally interacting spin systems with ferromagnetic interactions. Our main result is to show that finite-temperature ordering transitions are associated with entanglement transitions, and therefore the steady state of strongly symmetric Lindbladians can exhibit entanglement transitions. While in the paramagnetic phase it is known that the distillable entanglement and logarithmic entanglement negativity between two halves of a large system grow logarithmically with the square root of the number of spins, we show that in ferromagnetic phases these quantities grow parametrically faster with system size. To arrive at this result we first establish relations between these mixed-state entanglement measures and spin correlations in states that are singlets under global $\rm{SU}(2)$ symmetry transformations. We then introduce a semiclassical theory for $\rm{SU}(2)$ singlet thermal states. While the global singlet constraint generally enters this theory as a complicated function of the full semiclassical spin configuration, we show that in large $S$ limit it simplifies drastically to a Gaussian suppression of total magnetization in disordered phases as well as in ordered phases in the vicinity of continuous thermal phase transitions. This leads us to a field theory describing spin correlations in the singlet sector. Using this we determine the behavior of various probes of mixed-state entanglement at low and at high temperatures, supporting our analytical results using numerical Monte Carlo simulations of a three-dimensional lattice realization of our semiclassical theory. We also use exact numerics in one-dimensional spin-$1/2$ systems to confirm our predictions for the scaling of mixed-state entanglement with correlation length and system size in the paramagnetic phase.

Comments
24 pages, 8 figures

Related papers

Universal logarithmic corrections to entanglement entropies in two dimensions with spontaneously broken continuous symmetries

David J. Luitz, Xavier Plat, Fabien Alet +1 more

We explore the R\'enyi entanglement entropies of a one-dimensional (line) subsystem of length $L$ embedded in a two-dimensional $L\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}L$ square lattice for quantum spin models whose ground state breaks a continuous symmetry in the thermodynamic limit. We first study the ${J}_{1}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{J}_{2}$ Heisenberg model (with antiferromagnetic nearest-neighbor ${J}_{1}>0$ and ferromagnetic second-neighbor couplings ${J}_{2}\ensuremath{\le}0)$, breaking SU(2) symmetry in the ground state, using quantum Monte Carlo simulations. The signature of SU(2)-symmetry breaking on finite-size systems, ranging from $L=4$ up to $L=40$, clearly appears as a universal additive logarithmic correction to the R\'enyi entanglement entropies: ${l}_{q}lnL$ with ${l}_{q}\ensuremath{\simeq}1$, independent of the R\'enyi index and values of ${J}_{2}$. We then confirm this result using a spin-wave analysis (with restored spin rotational symmetry) on the same ${J}_{1}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{J}_{2}$ model, as well as on the XY model, with a $U(1)$ broken symmetry in the ground state. The high-precision spin-wave calculations are performed on finite lattices up to ${10}^{5}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{5}$ sites, allowing us to explore further nonuniversal finite-size corrections. Our results fully agree with the prediction ${l}_{q}={n}_{G}/2$, where ${n}_{G}$ is the number of Goldstone modes, by Metlitski and Grover (arXiv:1112.5166).

arXiv:1503.01094•Physical Review B•Apr 27, 2015•27 citations

Quantum entanglement in the one-dimensional spin-orbital SU(2)⊗XXZ model

Wen‐Long You, Peter Horsch, Andrzej M. Oleś

We investigate the phase diagram and the spin-orbital entanglement of a one-dimensional $\mathrm{SU}(2)\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\ensuremath{\bigotimes}\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\text{XXZ}$ model with SU(2) spin exchange and anisotropic $\text{XXZ}$ orbital exchange interactions and negative exchange coupling constant. As a unique feature, the spin-orbital entanglement entropy in the entangled ground states increases here linearly with system size. In the case of Ising orbital interactions, we identify an emergent phase with long-range spin-singlet dimer correlations triggered by a quadrupling of correlations in the orbital sector. The peculiar translational-invariant spin-singlet dimer phase has finite von Neumann entanglement entropy and survives when orbital quantum fluctuations are included. It even persists in the isotropic $\mathrm{SU}(2)\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\ensuremath{\bigotimes}\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\text{SU}$(2) limit. Surprisingly, for finite transverse orbital coupling, the long-range spin-singlet correlations also coexist in the antiferromagnetic spin and alternating orbital phase making this phase also unconventional. Moreover, we also find a complementary orbital singlet phase that exists in the isotropic case but does not extend to the Ising limit. The nature of entanglement appears essentially different from that found in the frequently discussed model with positive coupling. Furthermore, we investigate the collective spin and orbital wave excitations of the disentangled ferromagnetic-spin/ferro-orbital ground state and explore the continuum of spin-orbital excitations. Interestingly, one finds among the latter excitations two modes of exciton bound states. Their spin-orbital correlations differ from the remaining continuum states and exhibit logarithmic scaling of the von Neumann entropy with increasing system size. We demonstrate that spin-orbital excitons can be experimentally explored using resonant inelastic x-ray scattering, where the strongly entangled exciton states can be easily distinguished from the spin-orbital continuum.

arXiv:1507.07103•Physical Review B•Aug 12, 2015•15 citations

Strongly Correlated Systems, Transport, Entanglement, and Dynamics

Younes Javanmard

Strongly correlated systems, i.e., quantum materials for which the interactions between its constituents are strong, are good candidates for the development of applications based on quantum-mechanical principles, such as quantum computers. Two paradigmatic models of strongly correlated systems are heavy-fermionic systems and one-dimensional spin-12 systems, with and without quenched disorder. In the past decade, improvement in computational methods and a vast enhancement in computational power has made it possible to study these systems in a a non-perturbative manner. In this thesis we present state-of-the-art numerical methods to investigate the properties of strongly correlated systems, and we apply these methods to solve a couple of selected problems in quantum condensed matter theory. We start by revisiting the phase diagram of the Falicov-Kimball model on the square lattice which can be considered as a heavy-fermionic systems. This model describes an interplay between conduction electrons and heavy electrons and reveals several distinct metal-insulator phase transitions. Using a lattice Monte-Carlo method, we study the transport properties of the model. Our analysis describes the role of temperature and interaction strength on the metal-insulator phase transitions in the Falicov-Kimball model. The second part of the thesis investigate the spatial structure of the entanglement in ground and thermal statesof the transverse-field Ising chain. We use the logarithmic negativity as a measure for the entanglement between two disjoint blocks. We investigate how logarithmic negativity depends on the spatial separation between two blocks, which can be viewed as the entanglement analog of a spatial correlation function. We find sharp entanglement thresholds at a critical distance beyond which the logarithmic negativity vanishes exactly and thus the two blocks become unentangled. Our results hold even in the presence of long-ranged quantum correlations, i.e., at the system’s quantum critical point. Using Time-Evolving Block Decimation (TEBD), we explore this feature as a function of temperature and size of the two blocks. We present a simple model to describe our numerical observations. In the last part of this thesis, we introduce an order parameter for a many-body localized spin-glass (MBL-SG) phase. We show that many-body localized spin-glass order can also be detected from two-site reduced density matrices, which we use to construct an eigenstate spin-glass order parameter. We find that this eigenstate spin-glass order parameter captures spin-glass phases in random Ising chains, both in many-body eigenstates as well as in the nonequilibrium dynamics, from a local in time measurement. We discuss how our results can be used to observe MBL-SG order within current experiments in Rydberg atoms and trapped ion systems.

•Aug 30, 2018•0 citations

Entanglement and quantum phase transitions in quantum mixed spin chains

Shangbin Li, Zhaoxin Xu, Jianhui Dai +1 more

The ground entanglement and thermal entanglement in quantum mixed spin chains consisting of two integer spins 1 and two half-integer spins $\frac{1}{2}$ arrayed as $\frac{1}{2}\text{\ensuremath{-}}\frac{1}{2}\text{\ensuremath{-}}1\text{\ensuremath{-}}1$ in a unit cell with antiferromagnetic nearest-neighbor couplings ${J}_{1}$ $({J}_{2})$ between the spins of equal (different) magnitudes are investigated by employing the logarithmic negativity as entanglement measure. The ground entanglement transition found here is closely related to the valence-bond-solid phase transition, and the thermal entanglement near the critical point is calculated and it is shown that two distinct behaviors exist in the nearest-neighbor same kind of spins and different kind of spins, respectively.

arXiv:quant-ph/0508115•Physical Review B•May 10, 2006•16 citations

Magnetization-resolved density of states and mixed-order transition in the two-dimensional random bond Ising model: an entropic sampling study

Yi Liu, Ding Wang, Xin Wang +2 more

Abstract Systems with quenched disorder possess complex energy landscapes that are challenging to explore under conventional Monte Carlo methods. In this work, we implement an efficient entropy sampling scheme for accurate computation of the entropy function in low-energy regions. The method is applied to the two-dimensional ± J random-bond Ising model, where frustration is controlled by the fraction p of ferromagnetic bonds. We investigate the low-temperature paramagnetic–ferromagnetic phase boundary below the multicritical point at T N = 0.9530(4), P N = 0.89078(8), as well as the zero-temperature ferromagnetic–spin-glass transition. Finite-size scaling analysis reveals that the phase boundary for T < T N exhibits reentrant behavior. By analyzing the evolution of the magnetization-resolved density of states g ( E , M ) and ground-state spin configurations against increasing frustration, we provide strong evidence that the zero-temperature transition is a mixed-order. Finite-size scaling conducted on the spin-glass side supports the validity of β = 0, where β is the magnetization exponent, with a correlation length exponent ν = 1.50(8). Our results provide new insights into the nature of the ferromagnetic-to-spin-glass phase transition in an extensively degenerate ground state.

Communications in Theoretical Physics•Jun 14, 2025•1 citation

Low Temperature Phase of the m-component Spin Glass

A. Braun

We investigate the low temperature phase of a vector spin glass in the limit of large component numbers $m$ of the spins, where this model is expected to be replica symmetric. On a Bethe lattice, a random graph with fixed and finite connectivity, we employ a self-consistent effective-field approach to the cavity method to describe equilibrium states of the system in terms of the configuration of cavity fields, which are reduced mean fields onto each spin. We make use of an iterative algorithm to find such equilibrium states for finite system sizes $N$ and observe a phase transition, which is indicated by an order parameter describing the preferred direction each spin points into in terms of the configuration of cavity, resp. mean local fields. On single realizations of Bethe lattices the transition is sharp and accompanied by the Generalized-Bose-Einstein condensation, in which the cavity, resp. local fields of the spins condense into a subspace of the available $m$-dimensional space for large $m$. The dimension of this subspace, $m_{\rm eff}(T)$ depends on the temperature. Is either one or two right at the critical temperature and increases below. Furthermore, for fixed temperature it is expected to scale with the system size $N$ with an exponent $\mu_m$ which depends on the connectivity. Averaging over many realizations of disorder we find $\overline{m_{\rm eff}}(T_c)=2$ and $\overline{m_{\rm eff}}(T)\sim N^{\mu_m}$. Even more, the cavity fields are subject to rotations in the low temperature phase, i.e. there is no freezing in time as generally expected. In case of $m_{\rm eff}(T_c)=2$ the whole configuration rotates at the critical temperature about the same angle and the same axis of rotation corresponding to a single droplet. In addition, we find replica symmetry breaking below the large-$m$ limit, i.e. for $m_{\rm eff}(T) > m$. These results are supported by results of parallel tempering Monte Carlo simulations. Replica symmetry breaking is further investigated by an analytical method in the large connectivity limit, where we compare the free energy in terms of spin-spin-correlations of different replicas calculated with a replica symmetric and a one-step broken replica symmetry ansatz. In the large-$m$ limit, we find that both solutions coexist for finite connectivities and that replica symmetry holds for full connectivity up to corrections in second order around the saddle point for $m\to\infty$. In the last chapter we calculate the sample-to-sample fluctuations of the free energy of the SK model of the large-$m$ limit. We derive an exact connection between these fluctuations and bond chaos. Making use of a replica calculation for the {\it large deviations} and a scaling ansatz for the {\it small deviations}, we quantify bond chaos, i.e. calculate the probability of finding a given link overlap for two systems with possibly different sets of bonds. With this, we find the sample-to-sample fluctuations to scale with the number of spins, $N$, with an exponent $\mu$ in between $1/5$ and $3/10$.

•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations
Thermal entanglement transitions from strong SU(2)\textrm{SU}(2)SU(2) symmetry
We study mixed-state entanglement in Gibbs states with strong SU(2)\mathrm{SU}(2)SU(2) symmetry, focusing on locally interacting spin systems with ferromagnetic interactions. Our main result is to show that finite-temperature ordering transitions are associated with entanglement transitions, and therefore the steady state of strongly symmetric Lindbladians can exhibit entanglement transitions. While in the paramagnetic phase it is known that the distillable entanglement and logarithmic entanglement negativity between two halves of a large system grow logarithmically with the square root of the number of spins, we show that in ferromagnetic phases these quantities grow parametrically faster with system size. To arrive at this result we first establish relations between these mixed-state entanglement measures and spin correlations in states that are singlets under global SU(2)\rm{SU}(2)SU(2) symmetry transformations. We then introduce a semiclassical theory for SU(2)\rm{SU}(2)SU(2) singlet thermal states. While the global singlet constraint generally enters this theory as a complicated function of the full semiclassical spin configuration, we show that in large SSS limit it simplifies drastically to a Gaussian suppression of total magnetization in disordered phases as well as in ordered phases in the vicinity of continuous thermal phase transitions. This leads us to a field theory describing spin correlations in the singlet sector. Using this we determine the behavior of various probes of mixed-state entanglement at low and at high temperatures, supporting our analytical results using numerical Monte Carlo simulations of a three-dimensional lattice realization of our semiclassical theory. We also use exact numerics in one-dimensional spin-1/21/21/2 systems to confirm our predictions for the scaling of mixed-state entanglement with correlation length and system size in the paramagnetic phase.
We explore the R\'enyi entanglement entropies of a one-dimensional (line) subsystem of length LLL embedded in a two-dimensional $L\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}L$ square lattice for quantum spin models whose ground state breaks a continuous symmetry in the thermodynamic limit. We first study the ${J}_{1}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{J}_{2}$ Heisenberg model (with antiferromagnetic nearest-neighbor J1>0{J}_{1}>0J1​>0 and ferromagnetic second-neighbor couplings ${J}_{2}\ensuremath{\le}0)$, breaking SU(2) symmetry in the ground state, using quantum Monte Carlo simulations. The signature of SU(2)-symmetry breaking on finite-size systems, ranging from L=4L=4L=4 up to L=40L=40L=40, clearly appears as a universal additive logarithmic correction to the R\'enyi entanglement entropies: lqlnL{l}_{q}lnLlq​lnL with ${l}_{q}\ensuremath{\simeq}1$, independent of the R\'enyi index and values of J2{J}_{2}J2​. We then confirm this result using a spin-wave analysis (with restored spin rotational symmetry) on the same ${J}_{1}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{J}_{2}$ model, as well as on the XY model, with a U(1)U(1)U(1) broken symmetry in the ground state. The high-precision spin-wave calculations are performed on finite lattices up to ${10}^{5}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{5}$ sites, allowing us to explore further nonuniversal finite-size corrections. Our results fully agree with the prediction lq=nG/2{l}_{q}={n}_{G}/2lq​=nG​/2, where nG{n}_{G}nG​ is the number of Goldstone modes, by Metlitski and Grover (arXiv:1112.5166).
We investigate the phase diagram and the spin-orbital entanglement of a one-dimensional $\mathrm{SU}(2)\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\ensuremath{\bigotimes}\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\text{XXZ}$ model with SU(2) spin exchange and anisotropic XXZ\text{XXZ}XXZ orbital exchange interactions and negative exchange coupling constant. As a unique feature, the spin-orbital entanglement entropy in the entangled ground states increases here linearly with system size. In the case of Ising orbital interactions, we identify an emergent phase with long-range spin-singlet dimer correlations triggered by a quadrupling of correlations in the orbital sector. The peculiar translational-invariant spin-singlet dimer phase has finite von Neumann entanglement entropy and survives when orbital quantum fluctuations are included. It even persists in the isotropic $\mathrm{SU}(2)\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\ensuremath{\bigotimes}\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\text{SU}$(2) limit. Surprisingly, for finite transverse orbital coupling, the long-range spin-singlet correlations also coexist in the antiferromagnetic spin and alternating orbital phase making this phase also unconventional. Moreover, we also find a complementary orbital singlet phase that exists in the isotropic case but does not extend to the Ising limit. The nature of entanglement appears essentially different from that found in the frequently discussed model with positive coupling. Furthermore, we investigate the collective spin and orbital wave excitations of the disentangled ferromagnetic-spin/ferro-orbital ground state and explore the continuum of spin-orbital excitations. Interestingly, one finds among the latter excitations two modes of exciton bound states. Their spin-orbital correlations differ from the remaining continuum states and exhibit logarithmic scaling of the von Neumann entropy with increasing system size. We demonstrate that spin-orbital excitons can be experimentally explored using resonant inelastic x-ray scattering, where the strongly entangled exciton states can be easily distinguished from the spin-orbital continuum.
Strongly correlated systems, i.e., quantum materials for which the interactions between its constituents are strong, are good candidates for the development of applications based on quantum-mechanical principles, such as quantum computers. Two paradigmatic models of strongly correlated systems are heavy-fermionic systems and one-dimensional spin-12 systems, with and without quenched disorder. In the past decade, improvement in computational methods and a vast enhancement in computational power has made it possible to study these systems in a a non-perturbative manner. In this thesis we present state-of-the-art numerical methods to investigate the properties of strongly correlated systems, and we apply these methods to solve a couple of selected problems in quantum condensed matter theory. We start by revisiting the phase diagram of the Falicov-Kimball model on the square lattice which can be considered as a heavy-fermionic systems. This model describes an interplay between conduction electrons and heavy electrons and reveals several distinct metal-insulator phase transitions. Using a lattice Monte-Carlo method, we study the transport properties of the model. Our analysis describes the role of temperature and interaction strength on the metal-insulator phase transitions in the Falicov-Kimball model. The second part of the thesis investigate the spatial structure of the entanglement in ground and thermal statesof the transverse-field Ising chain. We use the logarithmic negativity as a measure for the entanglement between two disjoint blocks. We investigate how logarithmic negativity depends on the spatial separation between two blocks, which can be viewed as the entanglement analog of a spatial correlation function. We find sharp entanglement thresholds at a critical distance beyond which the logarithmic negativity vanishes exactly and thus the two blocks become unentangled. Our results hold even in the presence of long-ranged quantum correlations, i.e., at the system’s quantum critical point. Using Time-Evolving Block Decimation (TEBD), we explore this feature as a function of temperature and size of the two blocks. We present a simple model to describe our numerical observations. In the last part of this thesis, we introduce an order parameter for a many-body localized spin-glass (MBL-SG) phase. We show that many-body localized spin-glass order can also be detected from two-site reduced density matrices, which we use to construct an eigenstate spin-glass order parameter. We find that this eigenstate spin-glass order parameter captures spin-glass phases in random Ising chains, both in many-body eigenstates as well as in the nonequilibrium dynamics, from a local in time measurement. We discuss how our results can be used to observe MBL-SG order within current experiments in Rydberg atoms and trapped ion systems.
The ground entanglement and thermal entanglement in quantum mixed spin chains consisting of two integer spins 1 and two half-integer spins 12\frac{1}{2}21​ arrayed as $\frac{1}{2}\text{\ensuremath{-}}\frac{1}{2}\text{\ensuremath{-}}1\text{\ensuremath{-}}1$ in a unit cell with antiferromagnetic nearest-neighbor couplings J1{J}_{1}J1​ (J2)({J}_{2})(J2​) between the spins of equal (different) magnitudes are investigated by employing the logarithmic negativity as entanglement measure. The ground entanglement transition found here is closely related to the valence-bond-solid phase transition, and the thermal entanglement near the critical point is calculated and it is shown that two distinct behaviors exist in the nearest-neighbor same kind of spins and different kind of spins, respectively.
Abstract Systems with quenched disorder possess complex energy landscapes that are challenging to explore under conventional Monte Carlo methods. In this work, we implement an efficient entropy sampling scheme for accurate computation of the entropy function in low-energy regions. The method is applied to the two-dimensional ± J random-bond Ising model, where frustration is controlled by the fraction p of ferromagnetic bonds. We investigate the low-temperature paramagnetic–ferromagnetic phase boundary below the multicritical point at T N = 0.9530(4), P N = 0.89078(8), as well as the zero-temperature ferromagnetic–spin-glass transition. Finite-size scaling analysis reveals that the phase boundary for T < T N exhibits reentrant behavior. By analyzing the evolution of the magnetization-resolved density of states g ( E , M ) and ground-state spin configurations against increasing frustration, we provide strong evidence that the zero-temperature transition is a mixed-order. Finite-size scaling conducted on the spin-glass side supports the validity of β = 0, where β is the magnetization exponent, with a correlation length exponent ν = 1.50(8). Our results provide new insights into the nature of the ferromagnetic-to-spin-glass phase transition in an extensively degenerate ground state.
We investigate the low temperature phase of a vector spin glass in the limit of large component numbers mmm of the spins, where this model is expected to be replica symmetric. On a Bethe lattice, a random graph with fixed and finite connectivity, we employ a self-consistent effective-field approach to the cavity method to describe equilibrium states of the system in terms of the configuration of cavity fields, which are reduced mean fields onto each spin. We make use of an iterative algorithm to find such equilibrium states for finite system sizes NNN and observe a phase transition, which is indicated by an order parameter describing the preferred direction each spin points into in terms of the configuration of cavity, resp. mean local fields. On single realizations of Bethe lattices the transition is sharp and accompanied by the Generalized-Bose-Einstein condensation, in which the cavity, resp. local fields of the spins condense into a subspace of the available mmm-dimensional space for large mmm. The dimension of this subspace, meff(T)m_{\rm eff}(T)meff​(T) depends on the temperature. Is either one or two right at the critical temperature and increases below. Furthermore, for fixed temperature it is expected to scale with the system size NNN with an exponent μm\mu_mμm​ which depends on the connectivity. Averaging over many realizations of disorder we find meff‾(Tc)=2\overline{m_{\rm eff}}(T_c)=2meff​​(Tc​)=2 and meff‾(T)∼Nμm\overline{m_{\rm eff}}(T)\sim N^{\mu_m}meff​​(T)∼Nμm​. Even more, the cavity fields are subject to rotations in the low temperature phase, i.e. there is no freezing in time as generally expected. In case of meff(Tc)=2m_{\rm eff}(T_c)=2meff​(Tc​)=2 the whole configuration rotates at the critical temperature about the same angle and the same axis of rotation corresponding to a single droplet. In addition, we find replica symmetry breaking below the large-mmm limit, i.e. for meff(T)>mm_{\rm eff}(T) > mmeff​(T)>m. These results are supported by results of parallel tempering Monte Carlo simulations. Replica symmetry breaking is further investigated by an analytical method in the large connectivity limit, where we compare the free energy in terms of spin-spin-correlations of different replicas calculated with a replica symmetric and a one-step broken replica symmetry ansatz. In the large-mmm limit, we find that both solutions coexist for finite connectivities and that replica symmetry holds for full connectivity up to corrections in second order around the saddle point for m→∞m\to\inftym→∞. In the last chapter we calculate the sample-to-sample fluctuations of the free energy of the SK model of the large-mmm limit. We derive an exact connection between these fluctuations and bond chaos. Making use of a replica calculation for the {\it large deviations} and a scaling ansatz for the {\it small deviations}, we quantify bond chaos, i.e. calculate the probability of finding a given link overlap for two systems with possibly different sets of bonds. With this, we find the sample-to-sample fluctuations to scale with the number of spins, NNN, with an exponent μ\muμ in between 1/51/51/5 and 3/103/103/10.