Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2608.29353

Spinor Structure from Relativistic Mass-Shell Factorisation in Phase Space

Mark Everitt

quant-phphysics.class-phSubmitted Aug 29, 2026• Announced Sep 1, 2026• 0 citations
v1 · Aug 29, 2026v2 · Sep 1, 2026v3 · Sep 19, 2026v4 · Oct 10, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Spin is usually regarded as one of the most intrinsically quantum phenomena, while its lack of a natural analogue in classical physics presents an obstacle to phase-space deformation-quantisation accounts of its origin. We show that this difficulty may arise from imposing an overly restrictive scalar Hamiltonian structure on relativistic phase space. Requiring the complete massive mass-shell constraint to be represented by a single finite-dimensional expression that is linear in all four components of momentum forces its coefficient matrices to satisfy a Clifford algebra. The minimal complex representation of this algebra is four-dimensional. Requiring statistical completeness within the rank-two subspace selected by the mass-shell factor then leads to a four-by-four matrix-valued ensemble distribution. At each on-shell momentum, the linear mass-shell operator selects a two-dimensional subspace, so a general classical ensemble is described by a $2 \times 2$ matrix before quantisation. Projecting the Weyl-ordered Liouville equation into this subspace gives relativistic transport while preserving arbitrary populations and coherences and the remaining projector components determine the first deformation correction. Expansion of the matrix Moyal star commutator yields the symmetrised classical matrix Liouvillian at leading order. If the stronger two-sided star constraints are imposed, they reproduce the left and right Dirac-Wigner equations and introduce $\hbar$ as the scale converting the dimensionless internal algebra into physical angular momentum. These results suggest a non-quantum origin for spinor structure and a route to reconciling relativistic covariance, classical phase-space transport, and quantum spin.

Comments
6 pages. A improved distinct, self-contained treatment of the free-particle result embedded in the broader framework of arXiv:2505.03551. It substantially revises and isolates the minimal argument for the Clifford algebra and rank-two spinor structure, responding to feedback that the result required a more focused presentation. The earlier preprint has broader scope and is not superseded

Related papers

From Mass-Shell Factorisation to Spin: An Attempt at a Matrix-Valued Liouville Framework for Relativistic Classical and Quantum Phase-Spacetime

M. J. Everitt

Here we argue that spinor structure arises naturally if relativistic statistical mechanics is formulated directly on phase spacetime. Requiring a first-order phase-spacetime description that retains both mass-shell branches leads to a Clifford factorisation of the relativistic constraint and hence to a $4\times4$ spinor-matrix distribution function. We show that deformation quantisation leads to a phase-space formulation of spin quantum mechanics. We argue that projection onto positive- and negative-energy sectors recovers the standard relativistic classical transport equations in the appropriate scalar limits, while the corresponding left- and right- stargenvalue equations reproduce the constraint structure of the Dirac-Wigner formulation. The result is a phase-space route from relativistic statistical mechanics to spinor quantum mechanics, in which spin algebra emerges as the internal structure required by any relativistic statistical theory containing both mass-shell branches and the dimensions of angular momentum from quantum non-locality.

arXiv:2505.03551•May 6, 2025•0 citations

From Relation to Quantum Dynamics, A Three-Level Construction of Spinorial States, Lorentzian Dynamics, and the Dirac Equation

Andrzej Tyminski

We present a three-level organization of a bilocal relational theory inwhich structures usually associated with quantum mechanics arise atlogically distinct stages. The first level is purely geometric. Starting from the bilocalconfiguration space \(M\times M\) and its canonical cotangent bundle,the relative sector admits a radial--angular decomposition. For \(N=3\),the angular phase space is \(T^*S^2\). Its non-singular sector isnaturally organized as\(\mathbb R_+\times SO(3)\) and therefore possesses the canonical doublecover\[\mathbb R_+\times SU(2)\simeq\mathbb C^2\setminus\{0\}.\] A classical two-component \(SU(2)\)-spinorial carrier thus appearsbefore any Lorentzian dynamics or quantum postulate; its identificationwith a Lorentz-covariant Weyl spinor is not assumed at this stage.Reduction at fixed internalCasimir yields the Hopf fibration with \(|c_1|=1\). For \(N=3\), defining\(p_\mu=(p_t,\mathbf P)\) and\(\mu_{\rm int}=\kappa_1+i\kappa_2\)rewrites the full constraint as\[p_\mu p^\mu+|\mu_{\rm int}|^2=0.\]Its Clifford factorization then admits an exact chiral first-order formwith a two-dimensional complex kernel. At this stage the constructionremains classical: the momenta are phase-space variables and the kernelspinor is not yet a quantum wave function.The third level promotes this geometric and dynamical structure toquantum spinor dynamics. Geometry supplies an integer topological classbut not a universal scale of action; the identification\(I=n\hbar/2\) therefore requires the quantum scale \(\hbar\).Together with the operator rule\(p_\mu\mapsto-i\hbar D_\mu\), the classical chiral factorization becomesa quantum Dirac-type equation. If the internal complex contributionadmits a sector or limit in which it reduces to a real constant\(m\), the standard massive Dirac equation\[(i\hbar\gamma^\mu D_\mu-m)\Psi_D=0\]is recovered. The construction therefore separates three ingredients that arenormally introduced together: spinorial and topological statestructure, Lorentzian dynamics, and quantum operator dynamics. We donot derive quantum mechanics from classical geometry. Rather, we showthat the spinorial carrier and the algebraic architecture of the Diracequation can arise before quantization, while the quantum scale andoperator realization remain independent inputs. This identifiesprecisely which elements of quantum spinor dynamics are geometric,which depend on the Lorentzian dynamical postulate, and which remaingenuinely quantum assumptions.

•Aug 29, 2026•0 citations

The Logical Origin of the Dirac Equation

H.-K. Chan

This paper derives the Dirac equation as the logically forced relativistic completion of the de Broglie wave dynamics established in prior work of this series. Starting from the logical foundation that yields Lorentz/Poincaré invariance, we promote the non-relativistic framework (continuous spacetime, Fourier duality, local plane-wave structures, and probability conservation via statistical energy flux) to the relativistic regime. We show that the requirements of exact local relativistic plane-wave structures (with phase gradients satisfying the mass-shell condition $p^\mu p_\mu = m^2 c^2$), first-order time evolution (needed for clean probability conservation), and full Lorentz covariance together force the introduction of a specific non-commuting algebraic structure and a multi-component wave function. The Dirac equation emerges as the unique linear differential operator of order at most one in the spacetime derivatives that consistently glues these local structures across smooth backgrounds while preserving a conserved four-current with positive-definite time component. This multi-component structure arises naturally as the minimal algebraic consequence of the constraints, without any separate postulate for intrinsic angular momentum. In exact analogy with the emergence of the finite invariant causal speed in special relativity, the Dirac dynamics is revealed not as an ad-hoc linearization of the Klein--Gordon equation, but as the mathematically inevitable description of indivisible particles in continuous relativistic spacetime. The derivation thereby completes the single-particle sector of the series, demonstrating that core structures of relativistic quantum mechanics flow deductively from a small number of deep, nearly tautological commitments.

•Apr 13, 2026•0 citations

Spin–1/2 Particle Fields in Maxwell–Schwartz Theory: Dirac–Schwartz Dynamics, Probability Currents and Entanglement

David Carfì

We develop a Maxwell–Schwartz field-theoretic formulation of spin-1/2 quantum systems within the framework of tempered distribution spaces and Schwartz linear algebra. In this approach, the fundamental objects of the theory are Maxwellian fields, namely elements of S′(M4,C3), while scalar quantum states arise as derived projections carrying the spectral structure of the theory. Relativistic dynamics is formulated through square-root Hamiltonian operators defined via spectral calculus. On a distinguished subspace of Maxwellian fields, the curl operator realizes the momentum magnitude operator, allowing a direct correspondence between scalar and vectorial relativistic dynamics. This leads to a Schrödinger-type formulation of relativistic evolution without requiring Dirac’s matrix factorization as a primitive assumption. Spin-1/2 structures emerge naturally from two-component Cartesian configurations of Maxwellian fields. The Pauli algebra is realized as an internal symmetry acting on such pairs, and spin observables correspond to explicit transformations of field components. A first-order Dirac-type dynamics is obtained through operator factorization, yielding a Maxwellian realization of relativistic two-component equations, including the massless Weyl regime. The tensorial structure of the theory provides a natural setting for entanglement. Bell-type correlations are derived intrinsically from Maxwellian field configurations, reproducing the standard quantum predictions and their violation of Bell inequalities. A central result of the present work is the energetic interpretation of quantum probability. The spectral coefficients of a state determine the amplitudes of its Maxwellian realization, whose energy density is quadratic in these amplitudes. The Born rule is thus recovered as a normalized energy distribution law. Moreover, the electromagnetic continuity equation induces a probability continuity equation, with the probability current identified as the normalized Poynting flux. This transport interpretation extends to entangled states, where Bell correlations are interpreted as correlations in the transport of energy across field channels. Finally, the framework is extended to massive Maxwellian fields, where probability currents are expressed through nonlocal spectral kernels associated with square-root Hamiltonians, yielding a unified continuity structure for both massless and massive regimes. These results suggest that spinorial quantum structures, probabilistic interpretation, and quantum correlations may be understood as emerging from the internal organization, spectral structure, and energy transport of Maxwellian fields in the Schwartz distributional setting.

•Apr 9, 2026•0 citations

Architectural Reconstruction of Physical Laws Primitive Architecture, Quantum Evolution, Relativistic Propagation, and Dirac Structure

Borros Arneth

Modern physics is formulated through several mathematical frameworks that are individually successful but structurally distinct. Quantum mechanics is expressed through Hilbert spaces and self-adjoint operators, relativistic quantum theory through representations of spacetime symmetries and Clifford algebras, gauge theories through connections and curvature, quantum field theory through propagators and Green functions, statistical mechanics through state multiplicities and probability measures, and general relativity through Lorentzian geometry. The present work asks whether some of these structures can be reconstructed as representations of a more primitive mathematical architecture rather than independently postulated. An architecture is introduced in terms of four structural sectors: composable transport, interaction, holonomy, and recursive closure. Physical theories are then interpreted as representation classes of this architecture subject to explicitly stated additional conditions. Continuous norm-preserving transport in a complex Hilbert representation yields Schrödinger evolution. Lorentz-covariant spacetime transport gives the relativistic mass-shell relation, while scalar and first-order representations lead respectively to Klein–Gordon and Dirac structures. The central methodological requirement is that established equations must arise from primitive rules plus explicit representation conditions rather than being inserted retrospectively.

•Aug 11, 2026•0 citations

The Dirac Information Carrier for Relativistic Quantum Computation

Barry C Sanders

Quantum computation has traditionally been formulated by postulating abstract information carriers and subsequently identifying physical systems that realize them. We adopt the opposite viewpoint and ask what computational structure is supplied by a fundamental relativistic quantum system itself. Focusing on the simplest nontrivial massive spin carrier, spin-1/2, we show that its relativistic description supplies a native four-dimensional information carrier through the Dirac equation. The resulting Dirac information carrier possesses an intrinsic positive- and negative-energy decomposition that induces a physics-constrained computational structure comprising sector-preserving and sector-coupling quantum logic. Restricting the relativistic computational structure to the positive-energy sector and taking the nonrelativistic regime recovers the familiar Pauli qubit description. We distinguish mathematical unitary transformations from physically admissible gates and show how charge-conjugation structure, charge superselection, and associated reference-frame resources can constrain quantum logic beyond the sector-preserving structure. Finally, under appropriate physical assumptions, we establish the conditions under which this structure supports full single-carrier controllability. Our work establishes the Dirac information carrier as the massive spin-1/2 instance of a broader programme in which computational structures are derived from the relativistic representation carried by the underlying physical system.

quant-pharXiv:2608.11647•Aug 13, 2026•0 citations
Spin is usually regarded as one of the most intrinsically quantum phenomena, while its lack of a natural analogue in classical physics presents an obstacle to phase-space deformation-quantisation accounts of its origin. We show that this difficulty may arise from imposing an overly restrictive scalar Hamiltonian structure on relativistic phase space. Requiring the complete massive mass-shell constraint to be represented by a single finite-dimensional expression that is linear in all four components of momentum forces its coefficient matrices to satisfy a Clifford algebra. The minimal complex representation of this algebra is four-dimensional. Requiring statistical completeness within the rank-two subspace selected by the mass-shell factor then leads to a four-by-four matrix-valued ensemble distribution. At each on-shell momentum, the linear mass-shell operator selects a two-dimensional subspace, so a general classical ensemble is described by a 2×22 \times 22×2 matrix before quantisation. Projecting the Weyl-ordered Liouville equation into this subspace gives relativistic transport while preserving arbitrary populations and coherences and the remaining projector components determine the first deformation correction. Expansion of the matrix Moyal star commutator yields the symmetrised classical matrix Liouvillian at leading order. If the stronger two-sided star constraints are imposed, they reproduce the left and right Dirac-Wigner equations and introduce ℏ\hbarℏ as the scale converting the dimensionless internal algebra into physical angular momentum. These results suggest a non-quantum origin for spinor structure and a route to reconciling relativistic covariance, classical phase-space transport, and quantum spin.
Here we argue that spinor structure arises naturally if relativistic statistical mechanics is formulated directly on phase spacetime. Requiring a first-order phase-spacetime description that retains both mass-shell branches leads to a Clifford factorisation of the relativistic constraint and hence to a 4×44\times44×4 spinor-matrix distribution function. We show that deformation quantisation leads to a phase-space formulation of spin quantum mechanics. We argue that projection onto positive- and negative-energy sectors recovers the standard relativistic classical transport equations in the appropriate scalar limits, while the corresponding left- and right- stargenvalue equations reproduce the constraint structure of the Dirac-Wigner formulation. The result is a phase-space route from relativistic statistical mechanics to spinor quantum mechanics, in which spin algebra emerges as the internal structure required by any relativistic statistical theory containing both mass-shell branches and the dimensions of angular momentum from quantum non-locality.
We present a three-level organization of a bilocal relational theory inwhich structures usually associated with quantum mechanics arise atlogically distinct stages. The first level is purely geometric. Starting from the bilocalconfiguration space M×MM\times MM×M and its canonical cotangent bundle,the relative sector admits a radial--angular decomposition. For N=3N=3N=3,the angular phase space is T∗S2T^*S^2T∗S2. Its non-singular sector isnaturally organized asR+×SO(3)\mathbb R_+\times SO(3)R+​×SO(3) and therefore possesses the canonical doublecoverR+×SU(2)≃C2∖{0}.\mathbb R_+\times SU(2)\simeq\mathbb C^2\setminus\{0\}.R+​×SU(2)≃C2∖{0}. A classical two-component SU(2)SU(2)SU(2)-spinorial carrier thus appearsbefore any Lorentzian dynamics or quantum postulate; its identificationwith a Lorentz-covariant Weyl spinor is not assumed at this stage.Reduction at fixed internalCasimir yields the Hopf fibration with ∣c1∣=1|c_1|=1∣c1​∣=1. For N=3N=3N=3, definingpμ=(pt,P)p_\mu=(p_t,\mathbf P)pμ​=(pt​,P) andμint=κ1+iκ2\mu_{\rm int}=\kappa_1+i\kappa_2μint​=κ1​+iκ2​rewrites the full constraint aspμpμ+∣μint∣2=0.p_\mu p^\mu+|\mu_{\rm int}|^2=0.pμ​pμ+∣μint​∣2=0.Its Clifford factorization then admits an exact chiral first-order formwith a two-dimensional complex kernel. At this stage the constructionremains classical: the momenta are phase-space variables and the kernelspinor is not yet a quantum wave function.The third level promotes this geometric and dynamical structure toquantum spinor dynamics. Geometry supplies an integer topological classbut not a universal scale of action; the identificationI=nℏ/2I=n\hbar/2I=nℏ/2 therefore requires the quantum scale ℏ\hbarℏ.Together with the operator rulepμ↦−iℏDμp_\mu\mapsto-i\hbar D_\mupμ​↦−iℏDμ​, the classical chiral factorization becomesa quantum Dirac-type equation. If the internal complex contributionadmits a sector or limit in which it reduces to a real constantmmm, the standard massive Dirac equation(iℏγμDμ−m)ΨD=0(i\hbar\gamma^\mu D_\mu-m)\Psi_D=0(iℏγμDμ​−m)ΨD​=0is recovered. The construction therefore separates three ingredients that arenormally introduced together: spinorial and topological statestructure, Lorentzian dynamics, and quantum operator dynamics. We donot derive quantum mechanics from classical geometry. Rather, we showthat the spinorial carrier and the algebraic architecture of the Diracequation can arise before quantization, while the quantum scale andoperator realization remain independent inputs. This identifiesprecisely which elements of quantum spinor dynamics are geometric,which depend on the Lorentzian dynamical postulate, and which remaingenuinely quantum assumptions.
This paper derives the Dirac equation as the logically forced relativistic completion of the de Broglie wave dynamics established in prior work of this series. Starting from the logical foundation that yields Lorentz/Poincaré invariance, we promote the non-relativistic framework (continuous spacetime, Fourier duality, local plane-wave structures, and probability conservation via statistical energy flux) to the relativistic regime. We show that the requirements of exact local relativistic plane-wave structures (with phase gradients satisfying the mass-shell condition pμpμ=m2c2p^\mu p_\mu = m^2 c^2pμpμ​=m2c2), first-order time evolution (needed for clean probability conservation), and full Lorentz covariance together force the introduction of a specific non-commuting algebraic structure and a multi-component wave function. The Dirac equation emerges as the unique linear differential operator of order at most one in the spacetime derivatives that consistently glues these local structures across smooth backgrounds while preserving a conserved four-current with positive-definite time component. This multi-component structure arises naturally as the minimal algebraic consequence of the constraints, without any separate postulate for intrinsic angular momentum. In exact analogy with the emergence of the finite invariant causal speed in special relativity, the Dirac dynamics is revealed not as an ad-hoc linearization of the Klein--Gordon equation, but as the mathematically inevitable description of indivisible particles in continuous relativistic spacetime. The derivation thereby completes the single-particle sector of the series, demonstrating that core structures of relativistic quantum mechanics flow deductively from a small number of deep, nearly tautological commitments.
We develop a Maxwell–Schwartz field-theoretic formulation of spin-1/2 quantum systems within the framework of tempered distribution spaces and Schwartz linear algebra. In this approach, the fundamental objects of the theory are Maxwellian fields, namely elements of S′(M4,C3), while scalar quantum states arise as derived projections carrying the spectral structure of the theory. Relativistic dynamics is formulated through square-root Hamiltonian operators defined via spectral calculus. On a distinguished subspace of Maxwellian fields, the curl operator realizes the momentum magnitude operator, allowing a direct correspondence between scalar and vectorial relativistic dynamics. This leads to a Schrödinger-type formulation of relativistic evolution without requiring Dirac’s matrix factorization as a primitive assumption. Spin-1/2 structures emerge naturally from two-component Cartesian configurations of Maxwellian fields. The Pauli algebra is realized as an internal symmetry acting on such pairs, and spin observables correspond to explicit transformations of field components. A first-order Dirac-type dynamics is obtained through operator factorization, yielding a Maxwellian realization of relativistic two-component equations, including the massless Weyl regime. The tensorial structure of the theory provides a natural setting for entanglement. Bell-type correlations are derived intrinsically from Maxwellian field configurations, reproducing the standard quantum predictions and their violation of Bell inequalities. A central result of the present work is the energetic interpretation of quantum probability. The spectral coefficients of a state determine the amplitudes of its Maxwellian realization, whose energy density is quadratic in these amplitudes. The Born rule is thus recovered as a normalized energy distribution law. Moreover, the electromagnetic continuity equation induces a probability continuity equation, with the probability current identified as the normalized Poynting flux. This transport interpretation extends to entangled states, where Bell correlations are interpreted as correlations in the transport of energy across field channels. Finally, the framework is extended to massive Maxwellian fields, where probability currents are expressed through nonlocal spectral kernels associated with square-root Hamiltonians, yielding a unified continuity structure for both massless and massive regimes. These results suggest that spinorial quantum structures, probabilistic interpretation, and quantum correlations may be understood as emerging from the internal organization, spectral structure, and energy transport of Maxwellian fields in the Schwartz distributional setting.
Modern physics is formulated through several mathematical frameworks that are individually successful but structurally distinct. Quantum mechanics is expressed through Hilbert spaces and self-adjoint operators, relativistic quantum theory through representations of spacetime symmetries and Clifford algebras, gauge theories through connections and curvature, quantum field theory through propagators and Green functions, statistical mechanics through state multiplicities and probability measures, and general relativity through Lorentzian geometry. The present work asks whether some of these structures can be reconstructed as representations of a more primitive mathematical architecture rather than independently postulated. An architecture is introduced in terms of four structural sectors: composable transport, interaction, holonomy, and recursive closure. Physical theories are then interpreted as representation classes of this architecture subject to explicitly stated additional conditions. Continuous norm-preserving transport in a complex Hilbert representation yields Schrödinger evolution. Lorentz-covariant spacetime transport gives the relativistic mass-shell relation, while scalar and first-order representations lead respectively to Klein–Gordon and Dirac structures. The central methodological requirement is that established equations must arise from primitive rules plus explicit representation conditions rather than being inserted retrospectively.
Quantum computation has traditionally been formulated by postulating abstract information carriers and subsequently identifying physical systems that realize them. We adopt the opposite viewpoint and ask what computational structure is supplied by a fundamental relativistic quantum system itself. Focusing on the simplest nontrivial massive spin carrier, spin-1/2, we show that its relativistic description supplies a native four-dimensional information carrier through the Dirac equation. The resulting Dirac information carrier possesses an intrinsic positive- and negative-energy decomposition that induces a physics-constrained computational structure comprising sector-preserving and sector-coupling quantum logic. Restricting the relativistic computational structure to the positive-energy sector and taking the nonrelativistic regime recovers the familiar Pauli qubit description. We distinguish mathematical unitary transformations from physically admissible gates and show how charge-conjugation structure, charge superselection, and associated reference-frame resources can constrain quantum logic beyond the sector-preserving structure. Finally, under appropriate physical assumptions, we establish the conditions under which this structure supports full single-carrier controllability. Our work establishes the Dirac information carrier as the massive spin-1/2 instance of a broader programme in which computational structures are derived from the relativistic representation carried by the underlying physical system.