Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2608.10118

Bounds for Apparent Second-Law Violations in Quantum Trajectories

Domingos S. P. Salazar

quant-phcond-mat.stat-mechSubmitted Aug 10, 2026• Announced Aug 12, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Negative stochastic entropy production is commonly called an apparent violation of the second law. In general quantum-trajectory dynamics, however, the physical entropy production $σ$ need not obey a forward detailed fluctuation theorem. A general arbitrary-coupling formulation identifies a dynamical-asymmetry term $σ^\ast$ that completes it into $Ω=σ+σ^\ast$, whose mean is $\langleΩ\rangle=Σ+Σ^\ast$. We prove that the likelihood-ratio sign is optimal among reversal-odd trajectory observables and use this fact to transfer an established sharp fluctuation-theorem floor to the tie-corrected physical sign statistic $Π_σ=\Pr(σ<0)+\Pr(σ=0)/2$. When $\Pr(σ=0)=0$, the result reads $\Pr(σ<0)\ge[1-\langleΩ\rangle/g(\langleΩ\rangle)]/2$, where $g$ is the inverse of $a\mapsto a\tanh(a/2)$. The physical integral fluctuation theorem simultaneously suppresses large negative events, producing a quantitative ``frequent but mild'' law, while the sign imbalance lower-bounds the hidden mean $Σ^\ast$. We formulate the measured-record protocol explicitly and illustrate and numerically audit the tie-corrected theorem in random finite-coupling collision models and a coherently driven qubit interacting with thermal ancillas.

Comments
8 pages, 2 figures. Supplemental Material: 10 pages, 1 figure

Related papers

Dissipation production in a closed two-level quantum system as a test of the irreversibility of the dynamics

Claudia L. Clarke, Ian J. Ford

Irreversible behavior in open stochastic dynamical systems is quantified by stochastic entropy production, a property that measures the difference in likelihoods of forward and subsequent backward system evolution. But for a closed system, governed by deterministic dynamics, such an approach is not appropriate. Instead, we can consider the difference in likelihoods of forward and "obverse" behavior: the latter being a backward trajectory initiated at the same time as the forward trajectory. Such a comparison allows us to define "dissipation production," an analog of stochastic entropy production. It quantifies the breakage of a property of the evolution termed "obversibility" just as stochastic entropy production quantifies a breakage of reversibility. Both are manifestations of irreversibility. In this study we discuss dissipation production in a quantum system. We consider a simple, deterministic, two-level quantum system characterized by a statistical ensemble of state vectors, and we provide numerical results to illustrate the ideas. We consider cases that both do and do not satisfy an Evans-Searles Fluctuation Theorem for the dissipation production, and hence identify conditions under which the system displays time-asymmetric average behavior: an arrow of time.

arXiv:1806.11055•Physical review. E•Jul 26, 2023•1 citation

Joint statistics of work and entropy production along quantum trajectories

Harry J. D. Miller, Majid Mohammady, Martí Perarnau-Llobet +1 more

In thermodynamics, entropy production and work quantify irreversibility and the consumption of useful energy, respectively, when a system is driven out of equilibrium. For quantum systems, these quantities can be identified at the stochastic level by unravelling the system's evolution in terms of quantum jump trajectories. We here derive a general formula for computing the joint statistics of work and entropy production in Markovian driven quantum systems, whose instantaneous steady states are of Gibbs form. If the driven system remains close to the instantaneous Gibbs state at all times, then we show that the corresponding two-variable cumulant generating function implies a joint detailed fluctuation theorem so long as detailed balance is satisfied. As a corollary, we derive a modified fluctuation-dissipation relation (FDR) for the entropy production alone, applicable to transitions between arbitrary steady states, and for systems that violate detailed balance. This FDR contains a term arising from genuinely quantum fluctuations, and extends an analogous relation from classical thermodynamics to the quantum regime.

arXiv:2011.11589•Physical review. E•May 27, 2021•25 citations

Quantum Martingale Theory and Entropy Production

Gonzalo Manzano, Rosario Fazio, Édgar Roldán

We employ martingale theory to describe fluctuations of entropy production for open quantum systems in nonequilbrium steady states. Using the formalism of quantum jump trajectories, we identify a decomposition of entropy production into an exponential martingale and a purely quantum term, both obeying integral fluctuation theorems. An important consequence of this approach is the derivation of a set of genuine universal results for stopping-time and infimum statistics of stochastic entropy production. Finally, we complement the general formalism with numerical simulations of a qubit system.

arXiv:1903.02925•Physical Review Letters•Jun 7, 2019•31 citations

Quantum Fluctuation Theorem for Arbitrary Measurement and Feedback Schemes

Kacper Prech, Patrick P. Potts

Fluctuation theorems and the second law of thermodynamics are powerful relations constraining the behavior of out-of-equilibrium systems. While there exist generalizations of these relations to feedback controlled quantum systems, their applicability is limited, in particular when considering strong and continuous measurements. In this Letter, we overcome this shortcoming by deriving a novel fluctuation theorem, and the associated second law of information thermodynamics, which remain applicable in arbitrary feedback control scenarios. In our second law, the entropy production is bounded by the coarse-grained entropy production that is inferrable from the measurement outcomes, an experimentally accessible quantity that does not diverge even under strong continuous measurements. We illustrate our results by a qubit undergoing discrete and continuous measurement, where our approach provides a useful bound on the entropy production for all measurement strengths.

arXiv:2306.12281•Physical Review Letters•Oct 1, 2024•10 citations

Irreversible work and Maxwell demon in terms of quantum thermodynamic force

B. Ahmadi, S. Salimi, A. S. Khorashad

The second law of classical equilibrium thermodynamics, based on the positivity of entropy production, asserts that any process occurs only in a direction that some information may be lost (flow out of the system) due to the irreversibility inside the system. However, any thermodynamic system can exhibit fluctuations in which negative entropy production may be observed. In particular, in stochastic quantum processes due to quantum correlations and also memory effects we may see the reversal energy flow (heat flow from the cold system to the hot system) and the backflow of information into the system that leads to the negativity of the entropy production which is an apparent violation of the Second Law. In order to resolve this apparent violation, we will try to properly extend the Second Law to quantum processes by incorporating information explicitly into the Second Law. We will also provide a thermodynamic operational meaning for the flow and backflow of information. Finally, it is shown that negative and positive entropy production can be described by a quantum thermodynamic force.

arXiv:1809.00611•Scientific Reports•Jan 27, 2021•20 citations

Finite Measured Entropy Production Does Not Imply Finite Microscopic Irreversibility

Hieu Nguyen

Coarse-grained measurements provide a lower bound on entropy production, but how much microscopic irreversibility can they conceal? We construct a driven quantum system in which an imperfect counter registers a finite, strictly positive arrow of time while the microscopic entropy production is infinite. The system is a degenerate parametric oscillator below threshold, coupled to a thermal reservoir through repeated interactions with bosonic ancillas. The oscillator sustains a finite, positive heat current into the vacuum bath, where absorption is forbidden and forward and reverse trajectory laws have different supports. A photon counter with finite collection efficiency, gated time bins, and independent dark counts defines a common coarse-graining of the aligned trajectory laws. For fixed observation duration $\mathcal T$ and detector parameters, we prove that the observed relative entropy remains uniformly bounded as the bath temperature $T_b$ vanishes and is strictly positive at vacuum. The hidden contribution obeys $Σ_{\mathrm{hid}}(\mathcal T,T_b)=\mathcal T\dot Q_0/(k_BT_b)+O(1)$, where $\dot Q_0>0$ is the stationary vacuum heat current. False positives conceal the support mismatch while preserving measurable time asymmetry. Thus, finite and informative measurements of entropy production can coexist with infinite microscopic irreversibility.

arXiv:2611.13110•Nov 9, 2026•0 citations
Negative stochastic entropy production is commonly called an apparent violation of the second law. In general quantum-trajectory dynamics, however, the physical entropy production σσσ need not obey a forward detailed fluctuation theorem. A general arbitrary-coupling formulation identifies a dynamical-asymmetry term σ∗σ^\astσ∗ that completes it into Ω=σ+σ∗Ω=σ+σ^\astΩ=σ+σ∗, whose mean is ⟨Ω⟩=Σ+Σ∗\langleΩ\rangle=Σ+Σ^\ast⟨Ω⟩=Σ+Σ∗. We prove that the likelihood-ratio sign is optimal among reversal-odd trajectory observables and use this fact to transfer an established sharp fluctuation-theorem floor to the tie-corrected physical sign statistic Πσ=Pr⁡(σ<0)+Pr⁡(σ=0)/2Π_σ=\Pr(σ<0)+\Pr(σ=0)/2Πσ​=Pr(σ<0)+Pr(σ=0)/2. When Pr⁡(σ=0)=0\Pr(σ=0)=0Pr(σ=0)=0, the result reads Pr⁡(σ<0)≥[1−⟨Ω⟩/g(⟨Ω⟩)]/2\Pr(σ<0)\ge[1-\langleΩ\rangle/g(\langleΩ\rangle)]/2Pr(σ<0)≥[1−⟨Ω⟩/g(⟨Ω⟩)]/2, where ggg is the inverse of a↦atanh⁡(a/2)a\mapsto a\tanh(a/2)a↦atanh(a/2). The physical integral fluctuation theorem simultaneously suppresses large negative events, producing a quantitative ``frequent but mild'' law, while the sign imbalance lower-bounds the hidden mean Σ∗Σ^\astΣ∗. We formulate the measured-record protocol explicitly and illustrate and numerically audit the tie-corrected theorem in random finite-coupling collision models and a coherently driven qubit interacting with thermal ancillas.
Irreversible behavior in open stochastic dynamical systems is quantified by stochastic entropy production, a property that measures the difference in likelihoods of forward and subsequent backward system evolution. But for a closed system, governed by deterministic dynamics, such an approach is not appropriate. Instead, we can consider the difference in likelihoods of forward and "obverse" behavior: the latter being a backward trajectory initiated at the same time as the forward trajectory. Such a comparison allows us to define "dissipation production," an analog of stochastic entropy production. It quantifies the breakage of a property of the evolution termed "obversibility" just as stochastic entropy production quantifies a breakage of reversibility. Both are manifestations of irreversibility. In this study we discuss dissipation production in a quantum system. We consider a simple, deterministic, two-level quantum system characterized by a statistical ensemble of state vectors, and we provide numerical results to illustrate the ideas. We consider cases that both do and do not satisfy an Evans-Searles Fluctuation Theorem for the dissipation production, and hence identify conditions under which the system displays time-asymmetric average behavior: an arrow of time.
In thermodynamics, entropy production and work quantify irreversibility and the consumption of useful energy, respectively, when a system is driven out of equilibrium. For quantum systems, these quantities can be identified at the stochastic level by unravelling the system's evolution in terms of quantum jump trajectories. We here derive a general formula for computing the joint statistics of work and entropy production in Markovian driven quantum systems, whose instantaneous steady states are of Gibbs form. If the driven system remains close to the instantaneous Gibbs state at all times, then we show that the corresponding two-variable cumulant generating function implies a joint detailed fluctuation theorem so long as detailed balance is satisfied. As a corollary, we derive a modified fluctuation-dissipation relation (FDR) for the entropy production alone, applicable to transitions between arbitrary steady states, and for systems that violate detailed balance. This FDR contains a term arising from genuinely quantum fluctuations, and extends an analogous relation from classical thermodynamics to the quantum regime.
We employ martingale theory to describe fluctuations of entropy production for open quantum systems in nonequilbrium steady states. Using the formalism of quantum jump trajectories, we identify a decomposition of entropy production into an exponential martingale and a purely quantum term, both obeying integral fluctuation theorems. An important consequence of this approach is the derivation of a set of genuine universal results for stopping-time and infimum statistics of stochastic entropy production. Finally, we complement the general formalism with numerical simulations of a qubit system.
Fluctuation theorems and the second law of thermodynamics are powerful relations constraining the behavior of out-of-equilibrium systems. While there exist generalizations of these relations to feedback controlled quantum systems, their applicability is limited, in particular when considering strong and continuous measurements. In this Letter, we overcome this shortcoming by deriving a novel fluctuation theorem, and the associated second law of information thermodynamics, which remain applicable in arbitrary feedback control scenarios. In our second law, the entropy production is bounded by the coarse-grained entropy production that is inferrable from the measurement outcomes, an experimentally accessible quantity that does not diverge even under strong continuous measurements. We illustrate our results by a qubit undergoing discrete and continuous measurement, where our approach provides a useful bound on the entropy production for all measurement strengths.
The second law of classical equilibrium thermodynamics, based on the positivity of entropy production, asserts that any process occurs only in a direction that some information may be lost (flow out of the system) due to the irreversibility inside the system. However, any thermodynamic system can exhibit fluctuations in which negative entropy production may be observed. In particular, in stochastic quantum processes due to quantum correlations and also memory effects we may see the reversal energy flow (heat flow from the cold system to the hot system) and the backflow of information into the system that leads to the negativity of the entropy production which is an apparent violation of the Second Law. In order to resolve this apparent violation, we will try to properly extend the Second Law to quantum processes by incorporating information explicitly into the Second Law. We will also provide a thermodynamic operational meaning for the flow and backflow of information. Finally, it is shown that negative and positive entropy production can be described by a quantum thermodynamic force.
Coarse-grained measurements provide a lower bound on entropy production, but how much microscopic irreversibility can they conceal? We construct a driven quantum system in which an imperfect counter registers a finite, strictly positive arrow of time while the microscopic entropy production is infinite. The system is a degenerate parametric oscillator below threshold, coupled to a thermal reservoir through repeated interactions with bosonic ancillas. The oscillator sustains a finite, positive heat current into the vacuum bath, where absorption is forbidden and forward and reverse trajectory laws have different supports. A photon counter with finite collection efficiency, gated time bins, and independent dark counts defines a common coarse-graining of the aligned trajectory laws. For fixed observation duration T\mathcal TT and detector parameters, we prove that the observed relative entropy remains uniformly bounded as the bath temperature TbT_bTb​ vanishes and is strictly positive at vacuum. The hidden contribution obeys Σhid(T,Tb)=TQ˙0/(kBTb)+O(1)Σ_{\mathrm{hid}}(\mathcal T,T_b)=\mathcal T\dot Q_0/(k_BT_b)+O(1)Σhid​(T,Tb​)=TQ˙​0​/(kB​Tb​)+O(1), where Q˙0>0\dot Q_0>0Q˙​0​>0 is the stationary vacuum heat current. False positives conceal the support mismatch while preserving measurable time asymmetry. Thus, finite and informative measurements of entropy production can coexist with infinite microscopic irreversibility.