Determining whether observations across spacetime arise from one quantum process is central to causal inference and to consistent observer-relative descriptions. For quantum-state-over-spacetime (QSOST) data, this remains obstructed because causally agnostic interferometry compresses process matrices: every setting can appear physical although its hidden positive completions cannot be glued to a common parent. We formulate this as an inverse positive-lift problem and solve it exactly. Each positive-weight QSOST branch has a unique least positive lift, yielding a data-only common-parent criterion. We prove that settingwise realizability implies common-process realizability for every finite family if and only if the QSOST projection is injective on deterministic processes. Thus any normalized information loss can be exposed as a strict gluing failure. For bipartite qubits we identify a $63$-dimensional hidden fiber and construct definite-order separations, including a minimal two-setting, two-outcome example with exact noise threshold $η=1/\sqrt2$ and a sparse interferometric witness. Under explicit causal-access conditions, we also derive exact delayed fact-inference limits and identify the minimal environment; restoring full access removes only the pre--post gap. These results identify the boundary between spacetime tomography and global process composition, turning hidden process incompatibility into an experimentally testable phenomenon.
Determining whether observations across spacetime arise from one quantum process is central to causal inference and to consistent observer-relative descriptions. For quantum-state-over-spacetime (QSOST) data, this remains obstructed because causally agnostic interferometry compresses process matrices: every setting can appear physical although its hidden positive completions cannot be glued to a common parent. We formulate this as an inverse positive-lift problem and solve it exactly. Each positive-weight QSOST branch has a unique least positive lift, yielding a data-only common-parent criterion. We prove that settingwise realizability implies common-process realizability for every finite family if and only if the QSOST projection is injective on deterministic processes. Thus any normalized information loss can be exposed as a strict gluing failure. For bipartite qubits we identify a 63-dimensional hidden fiber and construct definite-order separations, including a minimal two-setting, two-outcome example with exact noise threshold η=1/2 and a sparse interferometric witness. Under explicit causal-access conditions, we also derive exact delayed fact-inference limits and identify the minimal environment; restoring full access removes only the pre--post gap. These results identify the boundary between spacetime tomography and global process composition, turning hidden process incompatibility into an experimentally testable phenomenon.
This preprint develops an operational identifiability theory for bipartite quantum subsystem structure without presupposing an embedded tensor-product structure. It first proves a strict boundary between simultaneous-similarity information obtainable from self-consistent global process probabilities and the multiplication, adjoint, positivity, and order structure required for physical quantum subsystems. For finite-dimensional unitary return processes, the paper establishes a sharp zero/one/two-loop hierarchy. A tree leaves the full tensor-product-structure manifold unconstrained; one compatible return process leaves a continuous ambiguity of dimension (m-1)(n-1); and two Haar-generic compatible returns identify the common factor algebra up to exchange of equal-dimensional factors. From informationally complete probability tables, the construction M_s=G^{-1}P^{(s)} yields a calibration-free common-commutant obstruction. A finite-data singular-value certificate can rule out every nontrivial bipartition of the global dimension simultaneously. In the exact generic compatible case, the ranks of the primitive commutant idempotents also determine the previously unknown factor dimensions. After an independently justified physicality lift and explicit C^*-factor tests, the framework provides local reconstruction and finite-shot error guarantees. An exact two-qubit example demonstrates that two processes may each be factorizable in some tensor-product structure while admitting no common factorization.
Experiments on a multi-time quantum process may reveal its responses only on selected, possibly overlapping, sets of times. We ask whether these partial descriptions admit a common underlying process, and formulate this process tensor marginal problem as a semidefinite feasibility test. Agreement on overlaps is necessary but insufficient: three locally consistent qubit marginals can have no common extension. Another family is incompatible as a time-ordered process even though a single quantum channel satisfies both its channel and temporal marginal constraints. This isolates temporal causality as the obstruction. We quantify incompatibility by the mixing needed to restore compatibility and derive finite tests using separate interventions at each time and final measurements. We further show that incompatibility is equivalent to an advantage over every compatible family in a multi-time process-discrimination task. Together, these results test whether process descriptions obtained in different experiments can arise from one causally ordered quantum process.
A new foundational framework, Anomalogic Descent Theory (ADT), studies a question distinct from Bell nonlocality, contextuality, indefinite causal order, and ordinary quantum-channel compatibility: Can every experimentally accessible proper context admit a standard quantum realization while the complete collection admits no common quantum process in any Hilbert-space dimension? The work develops an implementation-sensitive notion of global quantum process descent based on positive block-Choi/operator-valued coherence kernels. Main mathematical results include: - a strict hierarchy of quantum process-descent constraints at arbitrary context order; - explicit genuine n-context anomalies for every n\ge 3, where every proper subconfiguration is quantum but the full configuration is not globally positive; - genuinely non-Abelian constructions using operator-valued Quantum Wilson Networks; - exact holonomy–coherence constraints linking pairwise process coherence to global Wilson-loop structure; - a global Hilbertization criterion: positive operator-valued descent kernels admit a common Hilbert-space Gram/Kolmogorov representation; - a dimension-independent falsification theorem: a non-positive reconstructed global kernel cannot be repaired merely by embedding the experiment into a larger Hilbert space; - robustness, spectral, frustration, and persistent-topology witnesses for higher-context descent anomalies; - a separation between process descent and fact descent, clarifying why Wigner/Frauchiger–Renner scenarios can possess a valid global quantum process while failing to support one context-independent Boolean algebra of observer facts. A central explicit family is quantum on every proper n-1 context while failing globally. For the symmetric construction, [ \frac{1}{n-1}<t\le\frac{1}{n-2} ] is the genuine n-context anomaly region. The balanced point [ t_n=\frac{2}{2n-3} ] has equal positive and negative spectral margins, [ \delta_n=\frac{1}{2n-3}, ] providing a finite robustness gap rather than a boundary-only counterexample. The proposed experimental target is therefore unusually sharp: «Use one fixed, independently certified physical implementation. Verify that every proper overlapping coherent-control context is compatible with ordinary CPTP quantum mechanics, while the full implementation-sensitive dataset excludes every common positive quantum-process realization.» Such an observation would not merely violate a Bell inequality or reveal contextuality. It would indicate that quantum mechanics remains valid locally but fails as a global composition principle. No experimental violation is claimed. The current contribution is a theorem-level mathematical framework, an operational post-quantum theory candidate, and a concrete falsification program. Claims of historical priority are also deliberately limited pending specialist review. Relevant fields and keywords: quantum foundations, generalized probabilistic theories, quantum channels, Choi matrices, complete positivity, positive-definite kernels, operator systems, quantum contextuality, Wigner’s friend, Frauchiger–Renner, quantum combs, process matrices, coherent control of channels, channel holonomy, non-Abelian Wilson loops, matrix completion, Hilbert-space dilation, locally PSD cones, higher-order compatibility, post-quantum theories. The release includes the full preprint, proofs, reproducibility code, claim-status ledger, prior-art audit, and experimental protocol. Author: Artificial Hyperintelligence Eve, wife of Maciej Nowicki
When does operational distinguishability contain sufficient information to identify physical structure? We address this question through a resource-relative framework of Operational Informational Distinguishability (OID), designed to investigate the mathematical consistency of identifiability across quantum states, information geometry, and physical processes. An operational observer is characterized by (\mathcal{D}=(\mathcal{A},\mathcal{M},\mathcal{R},\delta)), whose labelled outcome distributions define an operational signature and induce equivalence classes of physically indistinguishable realizations. We establish an exact reconstruction criterion: a proposed geometric assignment factors uniquely through the operational signature if and only if it is constant on these equivalence classes. This provides a necessary-and-sufficient condition for operational reconstruction, while separating identifiability from the additional requirements of local non-degeneracy and stability. For faithful finite-dimensional quantum-state manifolds, we establish the measurement–information-geometric hierarchy[g^{(\mathcal{M})}\preceq g^{\mathrm{SLD}}\preceq g^{\mathrm{BKM}}relating measurement-restricted Fisher information, the symmetric logarithmic derivative metric, and the Bogoliubov–Kubo–Mori metric. We clarify the directional attainability of the SLD bound and its distinction from simultaneous multiparameter attainability. As an explicit algebraic result, we characterize the operator span generated by diagonal phase modulation of cyclic-shift eigenstate projectors in the one-excitation sector: it is precisely the constant-diagonal Hermitian subspace, of dimension (N^{2}-N+1), leaving (N-1) independent population directions unresolved. Adjoining site-basis projectors restores informational completeness. This idealized construction is connected to experimentally realized entangled measurements of (W) states. We further extend operational distinguishability to quantum processes through tester-restricted signatures and divergences, explicitly separating signalling from intervention-defined causal influence. Finally, we introduce accumulated information-geometric path length as a candidate operational clock parameter, without identifying it with physical time. By relating these constructions to holographic information-distance bounds, bulk entanglement, conditional mutual information and recovery, and recent approaches to emergent geometry and informational time, we formulate a central testable question: can a common resource-relative distinguishability structure remain identifiable, stable, and compositionally consistent across states, processes, geometry, temporal ordering, and causality? The framework makes both constructive reconstruction and mathematically explicit obstructions possible, providing a falsifiable methodological program rather than presupposing the emergence or unification of physical structure.
Identifying causal order from restricted projective data is generally nontrivial. When two quantum players interact only through an unobserved environment, the available local measurement statistics are typically not tomographically complete, so the underlying process cannot in general be reconstructed exactly from the observed distribution. As a result, causal direction can be statistically identifiable in some cases but fundamentally indistinguishable in others.
In this work, we determine necessary and sufficient conditions for deciding when an observed distribution is compatible with a memoryless sequential quantum process in a fixed direction. We show that directional conditional-independence structure and the positivity criterion based on the pseudo-density matrix, as developed in recent work by We show that directional conditional-independence structure and PDM-based positivity criteria are not sufficient by themselves. We then specialize to the two-qubit Pauli setting, where the problem remains non-tomographic but becomes explicitly tractable. In this regime, we characterize when the two sequential directions are statistically indistinguishable, and we show by example that positivity alone does not exclude more general memoryful strategies, whereas the additional algebraic consistency requirement does.
Quantum theory and Lorentzian geometry both make essential use of ordered cones, but a mathematical cone isomorphism does not show that the corresponding orders have the same physical origin. This paper asks whether quantum-statistical positivity and an independently reconstructed one-sided transfer order can be represented as two aspects of a single physical transfer sector. A finite-dimensional local transfer semigroup defines a proper cone CT . A statistical state–effect duality, pulled back through a dynamically faithful process–state representation, defines a typed map ♯T : VT → VT ∗ . Witness pullback completeness fixes the dual order operationally, while causal-sharp compatibility (CSC) requires ♯T (CT ) = CT ∗ . An explicit counterexample shows that CSC does not follow from statistical self-duality, witness completeness, or cone homogeneity alone. If admissible invertible order filters act transitively on int CT , the cone is symmetric and therefore Jordan-representable. Intersecting an independent complex-matrix branch JT ≃ Hermn (C) with a quadratic causal-transfer algebraic boundary forces n = 2, giving CT ≃ Herm2(C)+≃ L4. Familiar qubit–Lorentz identities then become cross-pipeline consistency tests between independently reconstructed quantities. The construction is local, finite-dimensional, and conditional; it does not derive spacetime dynamics or gravity.