Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2605.15059

Quantum criticality in the two-dimensional Hubbard model

Mathias Pelz, Gabriel Kotliar, Jan von Delft, Andreas Gleis

Published May 14, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study the normal-state, doping-driven phase diagram of the square-lattice Hubbard model using the dynamical cluster approximation combined with the numerical renormalization group as a cluster solver, which gives direct access to real-frequency dynamics at essentially zero temperature. In a parameter regime relevant for cuprates, $U=7t$ and $t'=-0.3t$, we find a critical doping $p^{\ast}$ that marks a continuous quantum phase transition between a pseudogap metal and a normal Fermi liquid. The transition is identified by a continuous collapse, from both sides, of the Fermi-liquid scale extracted from charge, spin, and $d_{x^2-y^2}$-wave pairing susceptibilities. This collapse produces a non-Fermi-liquid regime at intermediate energy scales, which appears to extend to arbitrarily low scales at $p^{\ast}$. As $p^{\ast}$ is crossed from the normal Fermi liquid at $p>p^{\ast}$ into the pseudogap metal at $p

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2605.15059

Related papers

Scaling theory for Mott–Hubbard transitions-II: quantum criticality of the doped Mott insulator

Anirban Mukherjee, Siddhartha Lal

Abstract We present a T = 0 K renormalization group (RG) phase diagram for the hole-doped 2D Hubbard model on the square lattice. The RG method employed is nonperturbative in treating quantum fluctuations of the single-particle occupation number via the unitarily decoupling of one electronic state at every RG step. As a result, the RG phase diagram possesses the quantum fluctuation energy scale (ω) as one of its axes. Using effective Hamiltonians and wavefunctions for the low-energy many-body eigenstates for the doped Mott liquid obtained from the stable fixed point of the RG flows, we demonstrate the collapse of the pseudogap for charge excitations (Mottness) at a quantum critical point (QCP) possessing a nodal non-Fermi liquid with superconducting fluctuations, and spin-pseudogapping near the antinodes. The QCP is characterised using both thermodynamic and quantum information-theoretic measures. d-wave superconducting order is shown to arise from this quantum critical state of matter. The pseudogap phase possesses a variety of fluctuations that lead to several symmetry-broken phases at low-energies. Benchmarking of the ground state energy per particle and the double-occupancy fraction obtained from a finite-size scaling analysis against existing numerical results yields excellent agreement. We present detailed insight into the T = 0 origin of several experimentally observed findings in the cuprates, including Homes law and Planckian dissipation. We also establish that the heirarchy of temperature scales for the pseudogap (T PG), onset temperature for pairing (T ons), formation of the Mott liquid (T ML) and superconductivity (T C) obtained from our analysis is quantitatively consistent with that observed experimentally for some members of the cuprates. Our results offer insight on the ubiquitous origin of superconductivity in doped Mott insulating states, and pave the way towards a systematic search for higher superconducting transition temperatures in such systems.

arXiv:1802.06528•New Journal of Physics•Apr 14, 2020•16 citations

Dynamical scaling near the pseudogap quantum critical point of the two-dimensional Hubbard model

Mathias Pelz, Gabriel Kotliar, Jan von Delft +1 more

We study dynamical scaling in the quantum-critical fan of the pseudogap-metal to Fermi-liquid transition of the two-dimensional Hubbard model. Using a four-patch dynamical cluster approximation with the numerical renormalization group as a cluster impurity solver, we access real-frequency dynamics over several decades at arbitrary temperatures. Close to the critical doping, the local spin and cluster-current susceptibility spectra exhibit $x=ω/T$ scaling of the form $χ''(ω,T)\sim \tanh(x/2)$, and the cluster contribution to the optical conductivity obeys $Tσ'_{\mathrm{cl}}(ω,T) \sim \tanh(x/2)/x$, implying a $1/T$ cluster dc conductivity. In the scaling regime, the vertex contribution to the cluster optical response is much larger than the bubble contribution. We further find evidence for a marginal-Fermi-liquid nodal self-energy. This, together with the $1/T$ vertex contribution to the conductivity, implies strange-metal optical transport in the quantum critical region. Our results describe several qualitative aspects of several experimental observations.

arXiv:2605.15060•May 14, 2026•0 citations

Finite-temperature exact diagonalization cluster dynamical mean-field study of the two-dimensional Hubbard model: Pseudogap, non-Fermi-liquid behavior, and particle-hole asymmetry

A. Liebsch, Ning-Hua Tong

The effect of doping in the two-dimensional Hubbard model is studied within finite-temperature exact diagonalization combined with cluster dynamical mean-field theory. By employing a mixed basis involving cluster sites and bath molecular orbitals for the projection of the lattice Green's function onto $2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}2$ clusters, a considerably more accurate description of the low-frequency properties of the self-energy is achieved than in a pure site picture. To evaluate the phase diagram, the transition from Fermi-liquid to non-Fermi-liquid behavior for decreasing hole doping is studied as a function of Coulomb energy, next-nearest-neighbor hopping, and temperature. The self-energy component ${\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{X}$ associated with $X=(\ensuremath{\pi},0)$ is shown to develop a collective mode above ${E}_{F}$, whose energy and strength exhibits a distinct dispersion with doping. This low-energy excitation gives rise to non-Fermi-liquid behavior as the hole doping decreases below a critical value ${\ensuremath{\delta}}_{c}$, and to an increasing particle-hole asymmetry, in agreement with recent photoemission data. This behavior is consistent with the removal of spectral weight from electron states above ${E}_{F}$ and the opening of a pseudogap, which increases with decreasing doping. The phase diagram reveals that ${\ensuremath{\delta}}_{c}\ensuremath{\approx}0.15\dots{}0.20$ for various system parameters. For electron doping, the collective mode of ${\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{X}(\ensuremath{\omega})$ and the concomitant pseudogap are located below the Fermi energy, which is consistent with the removal of spectral weight from the hole states just below ${E}_{F}$. The critical doping, which marks the onset of non-Fermi-liquid behavior, is systematically smaller than for hole doping.

Physical Review B•Oct 27, 2009•92 citations

Pseudogap-to-metal transition in the anisotropic two-dimensional Hubbard model

Jean Paul Latyr Faye, David Sénéchal

The transition between a metallic and a pseudogap phase in high-${T}_{c}$ cuprate superconductors, which is the subject of recent experimental investigations, is studied theoretically within the Hubbard model. We apply the cluster dynamical impurity approximation to the anisotropic Hubbard model on the square lattice at zero temperature and finite doping. This approach can detect a first-order transition between two metallic states: a pseudogap state at low doping with a depleted density of states at the Fermi level and a correlated metal at higher doping. This transition was seen first in the cluster dynamical mean-field theory at finite temperatures by Sordi et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 216401 (2012)] on the isotropic Hubbard model. Here we investigate this transition at zero temperature and as a function of on-site interaction $U$, anisotropy ${t}_{y}/{t}_{x}$, and doping. We find a first-order transition line which ends at a critical point, which occurs around ${t}_{y}/{t}_{x}\ensuremath{\sim}0.5$.

arXiv:1707.09446•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 7, 2017•11 citations

Breakdown of the Fermi-liquid regime in the two-dimensional Hubbard model from a two-loop field-theoretical renormalization group approach

Hermann Freire, Eberth de Almeida Correa, Álvaro Antônio Bandeira Ferraz

We analyze the particle-hole symmetric two-dimensional Hubbard model on a square lattice starting from weak-to-moderate couplings by means of the field-theoretical renormalization group approach up to two-loop order. This method is essential in order to evaluate the effect of the momentum-resolved anomalous dimension $\ensuremath{\eta}(\mathbf{p})$ which arises in the normal phase of this model on the corresponding low-energy single-particle excitations. As a result, we find important indications pointing to the existence of a non-Fermi-liquid (NFL) regime at temperature $T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$ displaying a truncated Fermi surface (FS) for a doping range exactly in between the well-known antiferromagnetic insulating and the ${d}_{{x}^{2}\ensuremath{-}{y}^{2}}$-wave singlet superconducting phases. This NFL evolves as a function of doping into a correlated metal with a large FS before the ${d}_{{x}^{2}\ensuremath{-}{y}^{2}}$-wave pairing susceptibility finally produces the dominant instability in the low-energy limit.

arXiv:0710.4938•Physical Review B•Sep 29, 2008•17 citations

Scaling theory for Mott–Hubbard transitions: I. T = 0 phase diagram of the 1/2-filled Hubbard model

Anirban Mukherjee, Siddhartha Lal

Abstract We present a T = 0 K renormalization group (RG) phase diagram for the electronic Hubbard model in two dimensions on the square lattice at half filling. The RG procedure treats quantum fluctuations in the single particle occupation number nonperturbatively via the unitarily decoupling of one electronic state at every RG step. The resulting phase diagram thus possesses the quantum fluctuation energy scale (ω) as one of its axes. A relation is derived between ω and the effective temperature scale upto which gapless, as well as emergent gapped phases can be obtained. We find that the normal and insulating phases of the half-filled Hubbard model correspond, for any on-site repulsion, to a marginal Fermi liquid normal phase and a topologically-ordered gapped Mott insulating liquid respectively. The marginal Fermi liquid is found to arise from singular forward scattering in directions normal to the nested Fermi surface, while singular backscattering events lead to Mott liquid state. The transition between these two phases involves passage through a pseudogapped phase bookended by Fermi surface topology-changing Lifshitz transitions. The pseudogap phase is observed to arise from the electronic differentiation encoded within the nested Fermi surface, and involves the gradual gapping of the Fermi surface from antinodes to nodes via charge and spin excitations that are mutually entangled. We obtain effective Hamiltonians for various phases, as well as wavefunctions for the low-energy many-body eigenstates of the Mott liquid. Benchmarking of the ground-state energy per particle and the double-occupancy fraction for the Mott liquid against existing numerical results yields excellent agreement. Presence of a Néel ordering symmetry-breaking perturbation in the RG leads to an antiferromagnetic spin-ordered charge insulating Mott state. Our results thus offer novel insights on a variety of aspects of the Mott–Hubbard problem, and can be extended to the doped system.

New Journal of Physics•Apr 9, 2020•17 citations
We study the normal-state, doping-driven phase diagram of the square-lattice Hubbard model using the dynamical cluster approximation combined with the numerical renormalization group as a cluster solver, which gives direct access to real-frequency dynamics at essentially zero temperature. In a parameter regime relevant for cuprates, U=7tU=7tU=7t and t′=−0.3tt'=-0.3tt′=−0.3t, we find a critical doping p∗p^{\ast}p∗ that marks a continuous quantum phase transition between a pseudogap metal and a normal Fermi liquid. The transition is identified by a continuous collapse, from both sides, of the Fermi-liquid scale extracted from charge, spin, and dx2−y2d_{x^2-y^2}dx2−y2​-wave pairing susceptibilities. This collapse produces a non-Fermi-liquid regime at intermediate energy scales, which appears to extend to arbitrarily low scales at p∗p^{\ast}p∗. As p∗p^{\ast}p∗ is crossed from the normal Fermi liquid at p>p∗p>p^{\ast}p>p∗ into the pseudogap metal at $p
Abstract We present a T = 0 K renormalization group (RG) phase diagram for the hole-doped 2D Hubbard model on the square lattice. The RG method employed is nonperturbative in treating quantum fluctuations of the single-particle occupation number via the unitarily decoupling of one electronic state at every RG step. As a result, the RG phase diagram possesses the quantum fluctuation energy scale (ω) as one of its axes. Using effective Hamiltonians and wavefunctions for the low-energy many-body eigenstates for the doped Mott liquid obtained from the stable fixed point of the RG flows, we demonstrate the collapse of the pseudogap for charge excitations (Mottness) at a quantum critical point (QCP) possessing a nodal non-Fermi liquid with superconducting fluctuations, and spin-pseudogapping near the antinodes. The QCP is characterised using both thermodynamic and quantum information-theoretic measures. d-wave superconducting order is shown to arise from this quantum critical state of matter. The pseudogap phase possesses a variety of fluctuations that lead to several symmetry-broken phases at low-energies. Benchmarking of the ground state energy per particle and the double-occupancy fraction obtained from a finite-size scaling analysis against existing numerical results yields excellent agreement. We present detailed insight into the T = 0 origin of several experimentally observed findings in the cuprates, including Homes law and Planckian dissipation. We also establish that the heirarchy of temperature scales for the pseudogap (T PG), onset temperature for pairing (T ons), formation of the Mott liquid (T ML) and superconductivity (T C) obtained from our analysis is quantitatively consistent with that observed experimentally for some members of the cuprates. Our results offer insight on the ubiquitous origin of superconductivity in doped Mott insulating states, and pave the way towards a systematic search for higher superconducting transition temperatures in such systems.
We study dynamical scaling in the quantum-critical fan of the pseudogap-metal to Fermi-liquid transition of the two-dimensional Hubbard model. Using a four-patch dynamical cluster approximation with the numerical renormalization group as a cluster impurity solver, we access real-frequency dynamics over several decades at arbitrary temperatures. Close to the critical doping, the local spin and cluster-current susceptibility spectra exhibit x=ω/Tx=ω/Tx=ω/T scaling of the form χ′′(ω,T)∼tanh⁡(x/2)χ''(ω,T)\sim \tanh(x/2)χ′′(ω,T)∼tanh(x/2), and the cluster contribution to the optical conductivity obeys Tσcl′(ω,T)∼tanh⁡(x/2)/xTσ'_{\mathrm{cl}}(ω,T) \sim \tanh(x/2)/xTσcl′​(ω,T)∼tanh(x/2)/x, implying a 1/T1/T1/T cluster dc conductivity. In the scaling regime, the vertex contribution to the cluster optical response is much larger than the bubble contribution. We further find evidence for a marginal-Fermi-liquid nodal self-energy. This, together with the 1/T1/T1/T vertex contribution to the conductivity, implies strange-metal optical transport in the quantum critical region. Our results describe several qualitative aspects of several experimental observations.
The effect of doping in the two-dimensional Hubbard model is studied within finite-temperature exact diagonalization combined with cluster dynamical mean-field theory. By employing a mixed basis involving cluster sites and bath molecular orbitals for the projection of the lattice Green's function onto $2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}2$ clusters, a considerably more accurate description of the low-frequency properties of the self-energy is achieved than in a pure site picture. To evaluate the phase diagram, the transition from Fermi-liquid to non-Fermi-liquid behavior for decreasing hole doping is studied as a function of Coulomb energy, next-nearest-neighbor hopping, and temperature. The self-energy component ${\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{X}$ associated with $X=(\ensuremath{\pi},0)$ is shown to develop a collective mode above EF{E}_{F}EF​, whose energy and strength exhibits a distinct dispersion with doping. This low-energy excitation gives rise to non-Fermi-liquid behavior as the hole doping decreases below a critical value ${\ensuremath{\delta}}_{c}$, and to an increasing particle-hole asymmetry, in agreement with recent photoemission data. This behavior is consistent with the removal of spectral weight from electron states above EF{E}_{F}EF​ and the opening of a pseudogap, which increases with decreasing doping. The phase diagram reveals that ${\ensuremath{\delta}}_{c}\ensuremath{\approx}0.15\dots{}0.20$ for various system parameters. For electron doping, the collective mode of ${\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{X}(\ensuremath{\omega})$ and the concomitant pseudogap are located below the Fermi energy, which is consistent with the removal of spectral weight from the hole states just below EF{E}_{F}EF​. The critical doping, which marks the onset of non-Fermi-liquid behavior, is systematically smaller than for hole doping.
The transition between a metallic and a pseudogap phase in high-Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ cuprate superconductors, which is the subject of recent experimental investigations, is studied theoretically within the Hubbard model. We apply the cluster dynamical impurity approximation to the anisotropic Hubbard model on the square lattice at zero temperature and finite doping. This approach can detect a first-order transition between two metallic states: a pseudogap state at low doping with a depleted density of states at the Fermi level and a correlated metal at higher doping. This transition was seen first in the cluster dynamical mean-field theory at finite temperatures by Sordi et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 216401 (2012)] on the isotropic Hubbard model. Here we investigate this transition at zero temperature and as a function of on-site interaction UUU, anisotropy ty/tx{t}_{y}/{t}_{x}ty​/tx​, and doping. We find a first-order transition line which ends at a critical point, which occurs around ${t}_{y}/{t}_{x}\ensuremath{\sim}0.5$.
We analyze the particle-hole symmetric two-dimensional Hubbard model on a square lattice starting from weak-to-moderate couplings by means of the field-theoretical renormalization group approach up to two-loop order. This method is essential in order to evaluate the effect of the momentum-resolved anomalous dimension $\ensuremath{\eta}(\mathbf{p})$ which arises in the normal phase of this model on the corresponding low-energy single-particle excitations. As a result, we find important indications pointing to the existence of a non-Fermi-liquid (NFL) regime at temperature $T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$ displaying a truncated Fermi surface (FS) for a doping range exactly in between the well-known antiferromagnetic insulating and the ${d}_{{x}^{2}\ensuremath{-}{y}^{2}}$-wave singlet superconducting phases. This NFL evolves as a function of doping into a correlated metal with a large FS before the ${d}_{{x}^{2}\ensuremath{-}{y}^{2}}$-wave pairing susceptibility finally produces the dominant instability in the low-energy limit.
Abstract We present a T = 0 K renormalization group (RG) phase diagram for the electronic Hubbard model in two dimensions on the square lattice at half filling. The RG procedure treats quantum fluctuations in the single particle occupation number nonperturbatively via the unitarily decoupling of one electronic state at every RG step. The resulting phase diagram thus possesses the quantum fluctuation energy scale (ω) as one of its axes. A relation is derived between ω and the effective temperature scale upto which gapless, as well as emergent gapped phases can be obtained. We find that the normal and insulating phases of the half-filled Hubbard model correspond, for any on-site repulsion, to a marginal Fermi liquid normal phase and a topologically-ordered gapped Mott insulating liquid respectively. The marginal Fermi liquid is found to arise from singular forward scattering in directions normal to the nested Fermi surface, while singular backscattering events lead to Mott liquid state. The transition between these two phases involves passage through a pseudogapped phase bookended by Fermi surface topology-changing Lifshitz transitions. The pseudogap phase is observed to arise from the electronic differentiation encoded within the nested Fermi surface, and involves the gradual gapping of the Fermi surface from antinodes to nodes via charge and spin excitations that are mutually entangled. We obtain effective Hamiltonians for various phases, as well as wavefunctions for the low-energy many-body eigenstates of the Mott liquid. Benchmarking of the ground-state energy per particle and the double-occupancy fraction for the Mott liquid against existing numerical results yields excellent agreement. Presence of a Néel ordering symmetry-breaking perturbation in the RG leads to an antiferromagnetic spin-ordered charge insulating Mott state. Our results thus offer novel insights on a variety of aspects of the Mott–Hubbard problem, and can be extended to the doped system.