Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2605.01103

On Quantum Indeterminacy

Maurice de Gosson

quant-phmath-phmath.GTmath.SGSubmitted May 1, 2026• Announced May 5, 2026• 0 citations• Revised May 28, 2026 (v2)
v1 · May 1, 2026v2 · May 28, 2026v3 · Jul 4, 2026v4 · Sep 12, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We introduce a geometric formulation of quantum indeterminacy from which the standard uncertainty inequalities emerge as necessary consequences. Our approach is based on convex geometry in phase space and on methods from symplectic topology, and does not rely on statistical descriptors such as variances or covariances. Instead, we associate to empirical position and momentum data with convex bodies whose mutual relations encode the fundamental constraints of quantum mechanics. The central tools are h-polar duality and symplectic capacities, which provide intrinsic, coordinate-free bounds on admissible phase-space configurations. Within this framework, the Robertson-Schrodinger inequalities arise naturally as manifestations of deeper geometric and topological principles. This perspective suggests that quantum indeterminacy is not primarily a statistical phenomenon, but rather a structural property of phase space governed by symplectic covariance. The results thus provide a unified and conceptually transparent foundation for the uncertainty principle.

Comments
First version

Related papers

Quantum Polar Duality and the Symplectic Camel: a Geometric Approach to Quantization

Maurice A. de Gosson

We define and study the notion of quantum polarity, which is a kind of geometric Fourier transform between sets of positions and sets of momenta. Extending previous work of ours, we show that the orthogonal projections of the covariance ellipsoid of a quantum state on the configuration and momentum spaces form what we call a dual quantum pair. We thereafter show that quantum polarity allows solving the Pauli reconstruction problem for Gaussian wavefunctions. The notion of quantum polarity exhibits a strong interplay between the uncertainty principle and symplectic and convex geometry and our approach could therefore pave the way for a geometric and topological version of quantum indeterminacy. We relate our results to the Blaschke-Santaló inequality and to the Mahler conjecture. We also discuss the Hardy uncertainty principle and the less-known Donoho--Stark principle from the point of view of quantum polarity.

arXiv:2009.10678•Sep 22, 2020•0 citations

Quantum Indeterminacy, Polar Duality, and Symplectic Capacities

Maurice A. de Gosson

The notion of polarity between sets, well-known from convex geometry, is a geometric version of the Fourier transform. We exploit this analogy to propose a new simple definition of quantum indeterminacy, using what we call "hbar-polar quantum pairs", which can be viewed as pairs of position-momentum indeterminacy with minimum spread. The existence of such pairs is guaranteed by the usual uncertainty principle, but is at the same time more general. We use recent advances in symplectic topology to show that this quantum indeterminacy can be measured using a particular symplectic capacity related to action and which reduces to area in the case of one degree of freedom. We show in addition that polar quantum pairs are closely related to Hardy's uncertainty principle about the localization of a function and its Fourier transform.

arXiv:1310.7885•Oct 29, 2013•1 citation

Quantum Polar Duality and the Symplectic Camel: A New Geometric Approach to Quantization

Maurice A. de Gosson

We define and study the notion of quantum polarity, which is a kind of geometric Fourier transform between sets of positions and sets of momenta. Extending previous work of ours, we show that the orthogonal projections of the covariance ellipsoid of a quantum state on the configuration and momentum spaces form what we call a dual quantum pair. We thereafter show that quantum polarity allows solving the Pauli reconstruction problem for Gaussian wavefunctions. The notion of quantum polarity exhibits a strong interplay between the uncertainty principle and symplectic and convex geometry and our approach could therefore pave the way for a geometric and topological version of quantum indeterminacy. We relate our results to the Blaschke-Santaló inequality and to the Mahler conjecture. We also discuss the Hardy uncertainty principle and the less-known Donoho-Stark principle from the point of view of quantum polarity.

Foundations of Physics•May 21, 2021•9 citations

Quantum Indeterminacy and Polar Duality: a Probabilistic Approach

Maurice A. de Gosson

We present a probabilistic argument supporting the application of polar duality, as discussed in our previous work, to express the indeterminacy principle of quantum mechanics. Our approach combines the properties of the Mahler volume of a convex body with the Donoho--Stark uncertainty principle from harmonic analysis, which characterizes the concentration of a function and its Fourier transform. The central result demonstrates that the sum of the probabilities of position concentration near a convex body and momentum concentration near its polar dual is equal to one, with an error term that diminishes rapidly as the number of degrees of freedom increases. This result motivates the interpretation of polar duality as a kind of geometric Fourier transform.

arXiv:2412.10314•Dec 13, 2024•0 citations

Symplectic Polar Duality, Quantum Blobs, and Generalized Gaussians

Maurice A. de Gosson, Charlyne de Gosson

We apply the notion of polar duality from convex geometry to the study of quantum covariance ellipsoids in symplectic phase space. We consider in particular the case of “quantum blobs” introduced in previous work; quantum blobs are the smallest symplectic invariant regions of the phase space compatible with the uncertainty principle in its strong Robertson–Schrödinger form. We show that these phase space units can be characterized by a simple condition of reflexivity using polar duality, thus improving previous results. We apply these geometric constructions to the characterization of pure Gaussian states in terms of partial information on the covariance ellipsoid, which allows us to formulate statements related to symplectic tomography.

arXiv:2206.06334•Symmetry•Sep 9, 2022•3 citations

Pointillisme à la Signac and Construction of a Quantum Fiber Bundle Over Convex Bodies

Maurice A. de Gosson, Charlyne de Gosson

We use the notion of polar duality from convex geometry and the theory of Lagrangian planes from symplectic geometry to construct a fiber bundle over ellipsoids that can be viewed as a quantum-mechanical substitute for the classical symplectic phase space. The total space of this fiber bundle consists of geometric quantum states, products of convex bodies carried by Lagrangian planes by their polar duals with respect to a second transversal Lagrangian plane. Using the theory of the John ellipsoid we relate these geometric quantum states to the notion of "quantum blobs" introduced in previous work; quantum blobs are the smallest symplectic invariant regions of the phase space compatible with the uncertainty principle. We show that the set of equivalence classes of unitarily related geometric quantum states is in a one-to-one correspondence with the set of all Gaussian wavepackets. We emphasize that the uncertainty principle appears in this paper as geometric property of the states we define, and is not expressed in terms of variances and covariances, the use of which was criticized by Hilgevoord and Uffink.

arXiv:2208.00470•Foundations of Physics•Mar 29, 2023•4 citations
We introduce a geometric formulation of quantum indeterminacy from which the standard uncertainty inequalities emerge as necessary consequences. Our approach is based on convex geometry in phase space and on methods from symplectic topology, and does not rely on statistical descriptors such as variances or covariances. Instead, we associate to empirical position and momentum data with convex bodies whose mutual relations encode the fundamental constraints of quantum mechanics. The central tools are h-polar duality and symplectic capacities, which provide intrinsic, coordinate-free bounds on admissible phase-space configurations. Within this framework, the Robertson-Schrodinger inequalities arise naturally as manifestations of deeper geometric and topological principles. This perspective suggests that quantum indeterminacy is not primarily a statistical phenomenon, but rather a structural property of phase space governed by symplectic covariance. The results thus provide a unified and conceptually transparent foundation for the uncertainty principle.
We define and study the notion of quantum polarity, which is a kind of geometric Fourier transform between sets of positions and sets of momenta. Extending previous work of ours, we show that the orthogonal projections of the covariance ellipsoid of a quantum state on the configuration and momentum spaces form what we call a dual quantum pair. We thereafter show that quantum polarity allows solving the Pauli reconstruction problem for Gaussian wavefunctions. The notion of quantum polarity exhibits a strong interplay between the uncertainty principle and symplectic and convex geometry and our approach could therefore pave the way for a geometric and topological version of quantum indeterminacy. We relate our results to the Blaschke-Santaló inequality and to the Mahler conjecture. We also discuss the Hardy uncertainty principle and the less-known Donoho--Stark principle from the point of view of quantum polarity.
The notion of polarity between sets, well-known from convex geometry, is a geometric version of the Fourier transform. We exploit this analogy to propose a new simple definition of quantum indeterminacy, using what we call "hbar-polar quantum pairs", which can be viewed as pairs of position-momentum indeterminacy with minimum spread. The existence of such pairs is guaranteed by the usual uncertainty principle, but is at the same time more general. We use recent advances in symplectic topology to show that this quantum indeterminacy can be measured using a particular symplectic capacity related to action and which reduces to area in the case of one degree of freedom. We show in addition that polar quantum pairs are closely related to Hardy's uncertainty principle about the localization of a function and its Fourier transform.
We define and study the notion of quantum polarity, which is a kind of geometric Fourier transform between sets of positions and sets of momenta. Extending previous work of ours, we show that the orthogonal projections of the covariance ellipsoid of a quantum state on the configuration and momentum spaces form what we call a dual quantum pair. We thereafter show that quantum polarity allows solving the Pauli reconstruction problem for Gaussian wavefunctions. The notion of quantum polarity exhibits a strong interplay between the uncertainty principle and symplectic and convex geometry and our approach could therefore pave the way for a geometric and topological version of quantum indeterminacy. We relate our results to the Blaschke-Santaló inequality and to the Mahler conjecture. We also discuss the Hardy uncertainty principle and the less-known Donoho-Stark principle from the point of view of quantum polarity.
We present a probabilistic argument supporting the application of polar duality, as discussed in our previous work, to express the indeterminacy principle of quantum mechanics. Our approach combines the properties of the Mahler volume of a convex body with the Donoho--Stark uncertainty principle from harmonic analysis, which characterizes the concentration of a function and its Fourier transform. The central result demonstrates that the sum of the probabilities of position concentration near a convex body and momentum concentration near its polar dual is equal to one, with an error term that diminishes rapidly as the number of degrees of freedom increases. This result motivates the interpretation of polar duality as a kind of geometric Fourier transform.
We apply the notion of polar duality from convex geometry to the study of quantum covariance ellipsoids in symplectic phase space. We consider in particular the case of “quantum blobs” introduced in previous work; quantum blobs are the smallest symplectic invariant regions of the phase space compatible with the uncertainty principle in its strong Robertson–Schrödinger form. We show that these phase space units can be characterized by a simple condition of reflexivity using polar duality, thus improving previous results. We apply these geometric constructions to the characterization of pure Gaussian states in terms of partial information on the covariance ellipsoid, which allows us to formulate statements related to symplectic tomography.
We use the notion of polar duality from convex geometry and the theory of Lagrangian planes from symplectic geometry to construct a fiber bundle over ellipsoids that can be viewed as a quantum-mechanical substitute for the classical symplectic phase space. The total space of this fiber bundle consists of geometric quantum states, products of convex bodies carried by Lagrangian planes by their polar duals with respect to a second transversal Lagrangian plane. Using the theory of the John ellipsoid we relate these geometric quantum states to the notion of "quantum blobs" introduced in previous work; quantum blobs are the smallest symplectic invariant regions of the phase space compatible with the uncertainty principle. We show that the set of equivalence classes of unitarily related geometric quantum states is in a one-to-one correspondence with the set of all Gaussian wavepackets. We emphasize that the uncertainty principle appears in this paper as geometric property of the states we define, and is not expressed in terms of variances and covariances, the use of which was criticized by Hilgevoord and Uffink.