arXiv:2604.14229

Magnitude Is All You Need? Rethinking Phase in Quantum Encoding of Complex SAR Data

Sakthi Prabhu Gunasekar, Prasanna Kumar Rangarajan

quant-phcs.AIcs.LGeess.IVSubmitted Apr 14, 2026• Announced Apr 16, 2026• 0 citations• Revised May 4, 2026 (v2)

Abstract

Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) data is inherently complex-valued, while quantum machine learning (QML) models operate in complex Hilbert spaces. This similarity suggests that using both the magnitude and phase of SAR data in quantum encoding should help automatic target recognition in SAR images. In this study, we test this assumption by comparing five encoding strategies for quantum models: magnitude-only encoding, joint magnitude-phase encoding, in-phase and quadrature encoding, preprocessed phase encoding, and a purely quantum architecture. All approaches are evaluated under a unified experimental setup on the MSTAR benchmark dataset. Surprisingly, we find that magnitude-only encoding performs better than phase-inclusive encodings in hybrid quantum-classical models. It achieves 99.57 percent accuracy on the 3-class task and 71.19 percent accuracy on the 8-class task, outperforming complex-valued alternatives under the same framework. Adding phase information provides little or no improvement and can sometimes degrade performance. However, in purely quantum models with only 184 to 224 trainable parameters and no classical neural-network layers, phase information becomes much more important, improving accuracy by up to 21.65 percentage points. These findings show that the usefulness of phase information depends not only on the data, but also on the architecture used to process it. Hybrid models can compensate for missing phase information through their classical components, while pure quantum models rely more strongly on phase information for class discrimination. The results provide practical guidance for encoding complex-valued data in quantum machine learning and highlight the importance of jointly designing encoding strategies and model architectures for current quantum systems.

Comments: 10 pages, 4 figures, 6 tables. Submitted to IEEE Quantum Week / QCE 2026

Related papers

Quantum classification for synthetic aperture radar

Salil Naik, Nolan Vaughn, Glen S. Uehara +2 more

The field of quantum computing, especially quantum machine learning (QML), has been the subject of much research in recent years. Leveraging the quantum properties of superposition and entanglement promises exponential decrease in computation costs. With the promises of increased speed and accuracy in the quantum paradigm, many classical machine learning algorithms have been adapted to run on quantum computers, typically using a quantum-classical hybrid model. While some work has been done to compare classical and quantum classification algorithms in the Electro-Optical (EO) image domain, this paper will compare the performance of classical and quantum-hybrid classification algorithms in their applications on Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) data using the MSTAR dataset. We find that there is no significant difference in classification performance when training with quantum algorithms in ideal simulators as compared to their classical counterparts. However, the true performance benefits will become more apparent as the hardware matures.

Automatic target recognition. ConferenceJun 7, 20242 citations

On the potentials of Tensor-based Quantum Machine Learning for SAR land-cover classification

Sreejit Dutta, Sigurd Huber, Gerhard Krieger

Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) data, characterised by its high-dimensionality and complex spatial correlations, poses significant challenges in terms of efficient processing and meaningful interpretation. Classical algorithms, while effective, often struggle with the sheer volume and intricacy of the data. This paper introduces a novel approach employing tensor quantum machine learning (QML) to tackle the intricacies of SAR data. By harnessing the computational advantages of quantum mechanics and the representational efficiency of tensor networks, we try to achieve enhanced feature extraction and pattern recognition. We look at various Tensor decomposition schemes to reduce data dimensionality as well as Tensor based quantum circuits to perform land-cover classification. Preliminary results, based on simulations, demonstrate the potential of our tensor QML framework. For the scope of this research so far, we worked with simulated amplitude and phase data, but we will be applying the same for real world data in the future. This interdisciplinary study not only opens avenues for improved SAR data analysis but also enriches the burgeoning field of quantum machine learning by highlighting its applicability in remote sensing domains.

Apr 1, 20240 citations

Integrating Quantum-Classical Algorithms with Tensor Networks for Noise Reduction in Synthetic Aperture Radar

Dutta, Sreejit, Huber, Sigurd, Krieger, Gerhard

Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) imaging is crucial in remote sensing due to its ability to produce high-resolution images regardless of weather conditions or daylight. However, SAR images often suffer from various types of noise, especially speckle noise, which degrades image quality and complicates data analysis. Traditional noise reduction techniques face challenges in balancing noise suppression with the preservation of image details. Recent deep learning approaches, such as U-Net architectures, have made strides in addressing these issues. Simultaneously, quantum computing has emerged as a promising field that can potentially enhance computational methods in image processing. We propose a hybrid classical-quantum U-Net framework that integrates quantum-classical algorithms with tensor networks for improved noise reduction in SAR images. Leveraging the representational capacity of tensor networks and the computational strengths of quantum algorithms, our method aims to surpass the limitations of classical techniques in managing complex noise patterns. In our architecture, certain layers of the U-Net are implemented using quantum circuits specifically optimized for noise suppression. The inclusion of tensor networks enables efficient handling of high-dimensional data within the hybrid model. The idea is to perform extensive experiments on standard SAR datasets to demonstrate that our hybrid U-Net outperforms traditional denoising methods and purely classical deep learning models in both noise reduction and detail preservation. Quantitative assessments using metrics like Peak Signal-to-Noise Ratio (PSNR) and Structural Similarity Index (SSIM) would be used for comparison. Moreover, we will evaluate the computational efficiency of our approach, underscoring the potential of quantum computing to expedite complex image processing tasks. This work aims to highlight the feasibility and benefits of integrating quantum computing into practical remote sensing applications. Our hybrid quantum-classical U-Net architecture with tensor networks paves the way for advanced noise reduction techniques in SAR imaging and potentially other domains. Future research will focus on optimizing quantum circuit designs for specific noise types and exploring the scalability of our approach alongside advancements in quantum hardware.

Dec 1, 20250 citations

Quantum Machine Learning for Optical and SAR Classification

Leslie Miller, Glen S. Uehara, Aradhita Sharma +1 more

We present in this paper a method to compare scene classification accuracy of C-band Synthetic aperture radar (SAR) and optical images utilizing both classical and quantum computing algorithms. This REU study uses data from the Sentinel satellite. The dataset contains (i) synthetic aperture radar images collected from the Sentinel-1 satellite and (ii) optical images for the same area as the SAR images collected from the Sentinel-2 satellite. We examine classical neural networks to classify four classes of images. We then explore Quantum Convolutional Neural Networks and deep learning techniques in terms of their training and classification performance. A hybrid Quantum-classical model that is trained on the Sentinel1-2 dataset is proposed, and its performance is then compared against the classical model in terms of classification accuracy.

IEEE International Conference on Digital Signal Processing (DSP)Jun 11, 202310 citations

Image Fusion With Quantum Processing for Scene Classification Using the BigEarthNet Dataset

Leslie Miller, Glen S. Uehara, Niraj Anil Babar +1 more

This paper presents algorithms, simulations, and results on the use of optical and Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) quantum image fusion and machine learning algorithms for radar and remote sensing applications. We propose novel quantum image fusion techniques that extract meaningful features for identifying and classifying scenes obtained from the BigEarthNet dataset. Specifically, this work focuses on multi-label scene classification using quantum image fusion of C-band SAR and optical imagery from the BigEarthNet dataset. The proposed fusion techniques enhance and sharpen structural and textural details that are not readily observable in raw SAR imagery, thereby improving downstream classification performance. To enable quantum image fusion, we design new quantum circuits that employ unitary and Pauli gates for phase encoding of pixel intensity values. These circuits allow optical and SAR image information to be encoded and fused within a quantum processing framework. Three fusion strategies are investigated, resulting in three distinct quantum image fusion models. Comparative evaluation of these models demonstrates that pixel-averaging–based quantum fusion yields improved classification accuracy relative to alternative fusion approaches. The fused images are subsequently processed using deep classical neural networks to perform scene classification. Our neural network study begins by customizing the Visual Geometry Group 16 (VGG16) architecture for multi-label remote sensing classification tasks. In addition, we examine the use of a Residual Network 50 (ResNet-50) architecture and provide comparative performance analysis between the two models. The effects of quantum noise on the fusion and classification pipeline are also studied to assess robustness under realistic quantum processing conditions. To evaluate classification performance, we employ standard metrics such as F1 and F2 scores, and additionally introduce false discovery rate and false negative rate metrics to provide a more comprehensive assessment of classification accuracy, particularly in multi-label settings. Overall, the results demonstrate the effectiveness of optical and SAR quantum image fusion in enhancing scene classification performance and highlight the potential of integrating quantum image processing with deep learning for advanced remote sensing applications.

IEEE AccessJan 1, 20261 citation

Quantum Data Encoding and Variational Algorithms: A Framework for Hybrid Quantum Classical Machine Learning

Bhavna Bose, Saurav Verma

The development of quantum computers has been the stimulus that enables the realization of Quantum Machine Learning (QML), an area that integrates the calculational framework of quantum mechanics with the adaptive properties of classical machine learning. This article suggests a broad architecture that allows the connection between classical data pipelines and quantum algorithms, hybrid quantum-classical models emerge as a promising route to scalable and near-term quantum benefit. At the core of this paradigm lies the Classical-Quantum (CQ) paradigm, in which the qubit states of high-dimensional classical data are encoded using sophisticated classical encoding strategies which encode the data in terms of amplitude and angle of rotation, along with superposition mapping. These techniques allow compression of information exponentially into Hilbert space representations, which, together with reduced sample complexity, allows greater feature expressivity. We also examine variational quantum circuits, quantum gates expressed as trainable variables that run with classical optimizers to overcome decoherence, noise, and gate-depth constraints of the existing Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices. Experimental comparisons with a Quantum Naive Bayes classifier prove that even small quantum circuits can approximate probabilistic inference with competitive accuracy compared to classical benchmarks, and have much better robustness to noisy data distributionsThis model does not only explain the algorithmic and architectural design of QML, it also offers a roadmap to the implementation of quantum kernels, variational algorithms, and hybrid feedback loops into practice, including optimization, computer vision, and medical diagnostics. The results support the idea that hybrid architectures with strong data encoding and adaptive error protection are key to moving QML out of theory to practice.

arXiv:2502.11951Feb 17, 20250 citations