Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2603.24789

Absence of Far-Detuned Attractive Optical Traps for Alkali Rydberg Atoms

Gabriel E. Patenotte, Youngshin Kim, Samuel Gebretsadkan, Kang-Kuen Ni

physics.atom-phquant-phSubmitted Mar 25, 2026• Announced Mar 27, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Neutral-atom quantum simulation is susceptible to entanglement between the atom's internal electronic state and its center-of-mass position. In many alkali Rydberg platforms, the 'spin-motion coupling' is exacerbated by the free expansion required to avoid ponderomotive anti-trapping from optical fields. A recent proposal (arXiv:2505.01071) claims sufficiently excited Rydberg states could be trapped in a monochromatic, far-detuned, circularly polarized optical field by harnessing a large vector polarizability. We disprove the proposal through analytic calculation and measurement of the vector polarizability of the $54S$, $54P$, and $53D$ orbitals of Cesium. Regarding the optical angular frequency $ω$, we analytically derive that the scalar, vector, and tensor polarizabilities scale as $ω^{-2}$, $ω^{-3}$, and $ω^{-4}$, as opposed to the proposed scaling of $ω^{-2}$, $ω^{-1}$, and $ω^{-2}$. We refine the sum-over-states expression for vector and tensor polarizability to be numerically stable and predict negligible vector and tensor polarizabilities far detuned from resonances, in agreement with our measurements. However, we find vector polarizability can enhance a recent proposal for near-detuned attractive trapping. Furthermore, we evaluate the breakdown of the electric-dipole approximation and derive no effect stronger than ponderomotive repulsion. We conclude that an attractive, monochromatic, far-detuned optical trap for alkali Rydberg states is not possible, regardless of the beam geometry.

Related papers

Forces on alkali Rydberg atoms due to nonlinearly polarized light

Anal Bhowmik, D. Blume

Trapped Rydberg atoms are highly promising candidates for quantum science experiments. While several approaches have been put forward to exert (trapping) forces on isolated Rydberg atoms, a widely applicable lossless technique is lacking. This paper proposes a robust versatile alternative technique that avoids lifetime compromising losses. Our proposal leverages the vector polarizability, which is induced by nonlinearly polarized light and is shown to be several orders of magnitude larger than the usual scalar and tensor polarizabilities for commonly used alkali Rydberg series such as the $nS$, $nP$, and $nD$ series with principal quantum number $n$ as low as 30. The resulting force can be used to trap isolated Rydberg atoms over long times, which constitutes a key advance that is expected to impact quantum simulation applications, as well as to generate large light--Rydberg-atom hybrid states, which possess nontrivial position-dependent forces.

arXiv:2505.01071•Physical Review A•May 28, 2025•2 citations

Scalar, tensor, and vector polarizability of Tm atoms in a 532-nm dipole trap

V. V. Tsyganok, D. A. Pershin, E. T. Davletov +2 more

Dipolar atoms have unique properties, making them interesting for laser cooling and quantum simulations. But, due to relatively large orbital momentum in the ground state these atoms may have large dynamic tensor and vector polarizabilities in the ground state. This enables the formation of spin-dependent optical traps. In this paper the real part of tensor and vector dynamic polarizability was experimentally measured and compared to a theoretical simulation. For an optical dipole trap operating around 532.07 nm, tensor polarizability was found to be $\ensuremath{-}145\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}53\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\mathrm{a}.\mathrm{u}.$ and vector polarizability was $680\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}240\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\mathrm{a}.\mathrm{u}.$ The measurements were compared with simulations, which were done based on the known set of levels from a thulium atom. The simulations are in good agreement with experimental results. In addition, losses of atoms from the dipole trap were measured for different trap configurations and compared to the calculated imaginary part of vector and tensor polarizabilities.

arXiv:1905.03842•Physical Review A•Oct 4, 2019•17 citations

Towards implementation of a magic optical-dipole trap for confining ground-state and Rydberg-state cesium cold atoms

Jiandong Bai, Shuo Liu, Jun He +1 more

Abstract Long ground-Rydberg coherence lifetime is interesting for implementing high-fidelity quantum logic gates, many-body physics, and other quantum information protocols. However, the potential formed by a conventional far-off-resonance red-detuned optical-dipole trap (ODT) is usually repulsive for Rydberg atoms, which will result in fast atom loss and low repetition rate of the experimental sequence. These issues can be addressed by a magic ODT. We performed the calculation of ODT’s magic detuning for confinement of ground-state and Rydberg-state cesium atoms with the same potential well. We used a sum-over-states method to calculate the dynamic polarizabilities of 6S 1/2 ground state and highly-excited ( n S 1/2 and n P 3/2 ) Rydberg state of cesium atoms, and identify corresponding magic detuning for optical wavelengths in the range of 850–1950 nm. We estimated the trapping lifetime of cesium Rydberg atoms confined in the magic ODT by including different dissipative mechanisms. Furthermore, we have experimentally realized an 1879.43 nm single-frequency laser system with a watt-level output power for setting up the magic ODT for 6S 1/2 ground-state and 84P 3/2 Rydberg-state cesium cold atoms.

arXiv:2001.05698•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•May 11, 2020•10 citations

Angle-Dependent Magic Optical Trap for the 6S1/2↔nP3/2 Rydberg Transition of Cesium Atoms

Jiandong Bai, Xin Wang, Xiaokai Hou +2 more

The existence of an anisotropic tensor part of atomic states with an angular momentum greater than 1/2 causes their dynamic polarizabilities to be very sensitive to the polarization direction of the laser field. Therefore, the magic wavelength of the transition between two atomic states also depends on the polarization angle between the quantized axis and the polarization vector. We perform a calculation of the magic conditions of the 6S1/2↔nP3/2 (n = 50–90) Rydberg transition of cesium atoms by introducing an auxiliary electric diople transition connected to the target Rydberg state and a low-excited state. The magic condition is determined by the intersection of dynamic polarizabilities of the 6S1/2 ground state and the nP3/2 Rydberg state. The dynamic polarizability is calculated by using the sum-over-states method. Furthermore, we analyze the dependence of magic detuning on the polarization angle for a linearly polarized trapping laser and establish the relationship between magic detuning and a principal quantum number of the Rydberg state at the magic angle. The magic optical dipole trap can confine the ground-state and Rydberg-state atoms simultaneously, and the differential light shift in the 6S1/2↔nP3/2 transition can be canceled under the magic condition. It is of great significance for the application of long-lifetime high-repetition-rate accurate manipulation of Rydberg atoms on high-fidelity entanglement and quantum logic gate operation.

Photonics•Apr 28, 2022•6 citations

Electric dipole polarizabilities of Rydberg states of alkali-metal atoms

Vladimir A. Yerokhin, Stefan Yoshi Buhmann, S. Fritzsche +1 more

Calculations of the static electric-dipole scalar and tensor polarizabilities are presented for two alkali-metal atoms, Rb and Cs, for the $nS, n{P}_{\textonehalf{},\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}3/2}$, and $n{D}_{3/2,\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}5/2}$ states with large principal quantum numbers up to $n=50$. The calculations are performed within an effective one-electron approximation, based on the Dirac-Fock Hamiltonian with a semiempirical core-polarization potential. The obtained results are compared with those from a simpler semiempirical approach and with available experimental data.

arXiv:1608.04515•Physical Review A•Sep 6, 2016•31 citations

Circularizing Rydberg atoms with time-dependent optical traps

Ryan Cardman, Georg A. Raithel

We discuss three proposed schemes of initializing circular-state Rydberg atoms via optical couplings provided by the ponderomotive effect in contrast to the current circularization methods that utilize electric-dipole interactions. In our first proposed method, a radial optical trap consisting of two Laguerre-Gaussian beams of opposite winding numbers transfers orbital angular momentum to the Rydberg atom, providing a first-order coherent coupling between an F state and a circular state. Additionally, we propose a one-dimensional ponderomotive optical lattice modulated at rf frequencies, providing quadrupolelike couplings in the hydrogenic manifold for rapid adiabatic passage through a series of intermediate Rydberg states into the circular state. For the third proposed scheme, a two-dimensional ponderomotive optical lattice with a time-orbiting trap center induces effectively the same coupling as a ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}^{+}$- or ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}^{\ensuremath{-}}$-polarized rf field of tunable purity for all-optical rapid adiabatic passage into the circular state.

arXiv:1909.06612•Physical Review A•Jan 30, 2020•24 citations
Neutral-atom quantum simulation is susceptible to entanglement between the atom's internal electronic state and its center-of-mass position. In many alkali Rydberg platforms, the 'spin-motion coupling' is exacerbated by the free expansion required to avoid ponderomotive anti-trapping from optical fields. A recent proposal (arXiv:2505.01071) claims sufficiently excited Rydberg states could be trapped in a monochromatic, far-detuned, circularly polarized optical field by harnessing a large vector polarizability. We disprove the proposal through analytic calculation and measurement of the vector polarizability of the 54S54S54S, 54P54P54P, and 53D53D53D orbitals of Cesium. Regarding the optical angular frequency ωωω, we analytically derive that the scalar, vector, and tensor polarizabilities scale as ω−2ω^{-2}ω−2, ω−3ω^{-3}ω−3, and ω−4ω^{-4}ω−4, as opposed to the proposed scaling of ω−2ω^{-2}ω−2, ω−1ω^{-1}ω−1, and ω−2ω^{-2}ω−2. We refine the sum-over-states expression for vector and tensor polarizability to be numerically stable and predict negligible vector and tensor polarizabilities far detuned from resonances, in agreement with our measurements. However, we find vector polarizability can enhance a recent proposal for near-detuned attractive trapping. Furthermore, we evaluate the breakdown of the electric-dipole approximation and derive no effect stronger than ponderomotive repulsion. We conclude that an attractive, monochromatic, far-detuned optical trap for alkali Rydberg states is not possible, regardless of the beam geometry.
Trapped Rydberg atoms are highly promising candidates for quantum science experiments. While several approaches have been put forward to exert (trapping) forces on isolated Rydberg atoms, a widely applicable lossless technique is lacking. This paper proposes a robust versatile alternative technique that avoids lifetime compromising losses. Our proposal leverages the vector polarizability, which is induced by nonlinearly polarized light and is shown to be several orders of magnitude larger than the usual scalar and tensor polarizabilities for commonly used alkali Rydberg series such as the nSnSnS, nPnPnP, and nDnDnD series with principal quantum number nnn as low as 30. The resulting force can be used to trap isolated Rydberg atoms over long times, which constitutes a key advance that is expected to impact quantum simulation applications, as well as to generate large light--Rydberg-atom hybrid states, which possess nontrivial position-dependent forces.
Dipolar atoms have unique properties, making them interesting for laser cooling and quantum simulations. But, due to relatively large orbital momentum in the ground state these atoms may have large dynamic tensor and vector polarizabilities in the ground state. This enables the formation of spin-dependent optical traps. In this paper the real part of tensor and vector dynamic polarizability was experimentally measured and compared to a theoretical simulation. For an optical dipole trap operating around 532.07 nm, tensor polarizability was found to be $\ensuremath{-}145\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}53\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\mathrm{a}.\mathrm{u}.$ and vector polarizability was $680\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}240\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\mathrm{a}.\mathrm{u}.$ The measurements were compared with simulations, which were done based on the known set of levels from a thulium atom. The simulations are in good agreement with experimental results. In addition, losses of atoms from the dipole trap were measured for different trap configurations and compared to the calculated imaginary part of vector and tensor polarizabilities.
Abstract Long ground-Rydberg coherence lifetime is interesting for implementing high-fidelity quantum logic gates, many-body physics, and other quantum information protocols. However, the potential formed by a conventional far-off-resonance red-detuned optical-dipole trap (ODT) is usually repulsive for Rydberg atoms, which will result in fast atom loss and low repetition rate of the experimental sequence. These issues can be addressed by a magic ODT. We performed the calculation of ODT’s magic detuning for confinement of ground-state and Rydberg-state cesium atoms with the same potential well. We used a sum-over-states method to calculate the dynamic polarizabilities of 6S 1/2 ground state and highly-excited ( n S 1/2 and n P 3/2 ) Rydberg state of cesium atoms, and identify corresponding magic detuning for optical wavelengths in the range of 850–1950 nm. We estimated the trapping lifetime of cesium Rydberg atoms confined in the magic ODT by including different dissipative mechanisms. Furthermore, we have experimentally realized an 1879.43 nm single-frequency laser system with a watt-level output power for setting up the magic ODT for 6S 1/2 ground-state and 84P 3/2 Rydberg-state cesium cold atoms.
The existence of an anisotropic tensor part of atomic states with an angular momentum greater than 1/2 causes their dynamic polarizabilities to be very sensitive to the polarization direction of the laser field. Therefore, the magic wavelength of the transition between two atomic states also depends on the polarization angle between the quantized axis and the polarization vector. We perform a calculation of the magic conditions of the 6S1/2↔nP3/2 (n = 50–90) Rydberg transition of cesium atoms by introducing an auxiliary electric diople transition connected to the target Rydberg state and a low-excited state. The magic condition is determined by the intersection of dynamic polarizabilities of the 6S1/2 ground state and the nP3/2 Rydberg state. The dynamic polarizability is calculated by using the sum-over-states method. Furthermore, we analyze the dependence of magic detuning on the polarization angle for a linearly polarized trapping laser and establish the relationship between magic detuning and a principal quantum number of the Rydberg state at the magic angle. The magic optical dipole trap can confine the ground-state and Rydberg-state atoms simultaneously, and the differential light shift in the 6S1/2↔nP3/2 transition can be canceled under the magic condition. It is of great significance for the application of long-lifetime high-repetition-rate accurate manipulation of Rydberg atoms on high-fidelity entanglement and quantum logic gate operation.
Calculations of the static electric-dipole scalar and tensor polarizabilities are presented for two alkali-metal atoms, Rb and Cs, for the $nS, n{P}_{\textonehalf{},\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}3/2}$, and nD3/2,5/2n{D}_{3/2,\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}5/2}nD3/2,5/2​ states with large principal quantum numbers up to n=50n=50n=50. The calculations are performed within an effective one-electron approximation, based on the Dirac-Fock Hamiltonian with a semiempirical core-polarization potential. The obtained results are compared with those from a simpler semiempirical approach and with available experimental data.
We discuss three proposed schemes of initializing circular-state Rydberg atoms via optical couplings provided by the ponderomotive effect in contrast to the current circularization methods that utilize electric-dipole interactions. In our first proposed method, a radial optical trap consisting of two Laguerre-Gaussian beams of opposite winding numbers transfers orbital angular momentum to the Rydberg atom, providing a first-order coherent coupling between an F state and a circular state. Additionally, we propose a one-dimensional ponderomotive optical lattice modulated at rf frequencies, providing quadrupolelike couplings in the hydrogenic manifold for rapid adiabatic passage through a series of intermediate Rydberg states into the circular state. For the third proposed scheme, a two-dimensional ponderomotive optical lattice with a time-orbiting trap center induces effectively the same coupling as a ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}^{+}$- or ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}^{\ensuremath{-}}$-polarized rf field of tunable purity for all-optical rapid adiabatic passage into the circular state.