Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2603.05594 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Fingerprinting fractons with pump-probe spectroscopy

Anonymous, Oliver Hart, Rahul Nandkishore

Published Jul 28, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We demonstrate how pump-probe techniques enable specific spectroscopic diagnostics of fracton phases of matter by studying lineon-planon braiding in the paradigmatic X-cube model. Our discussion builds on previous works probing anyonic exchange statistics in conventional spin liquids, but the extension to fracton phases reveals qualitatively new phenomena due to the restricted mobility of fractionalized excitations. A key feature is that nearby planons can form an emergent bound state by accessing different planes via alternative pairing configurations. We show that this bound state qualitatively modifies the long-time linear and nonlinear responses, leading to an asymptotic linear-in-$t$ behavior for the pump-probe signal $χ_\mathit{ZZX}$. By contrast, swapping the pump and probe polarizations produces a nonlinear response $χ_\mathit{XXZ}$ that is asymptotically $t$-independent. This asymmetry reflects the fact that the two species of fractionalized excitations live in different spatial dimensions. Thus, the pump-probe signals studied here are sensitive to (i) nontrivial braiding statistics in three dimensions, (ii) the existence of bound states among fractionalized excitations, and (iii) the one-dimensional mobility of lineons. Our results therefore provide spectroscopic signatures that distinguish fracton phases from conventional topologically ordered spin liquids.

DOI
10.1103/jvwy-mfxg

Related papers

Anomalous thermal relaxation and pump-probe spectroscopy of two-dimensional topologically ordered systems

Max McGinley, Michele Fava, S. A. Parameswaran

We study the behavior of linear and nonlinear spectroscopic quantities in two-dimensional topologically ordered systems, which host anyonic excitations exhibiting fractional statistics. We highlight the role that braiding phases between anyons have on the dynamics of such quasiparticles, which as we show dictates the behavior of both linear response coefficients at finite temperatures, as well as nonlinear pump-probe response coefficients. These quantities, which act as probes of temporal correlations in the system, are shown to obey distinctive universal forms at sufficiently long timescales. As well as providing an experimentally measurable fingerprint of anyonic statistics, the universal behavior that we find also demonstrates anomalously fast thermal relaxation: correlation functions decay as a “squished exponential” C ( t ) ∼ exp ( − [ t / τ ] 3 / 2 ) at long times. We attribute this unusual asymptotic form to the nonlocal nature of interactions between anyons, which allows relaxation to occur much faster than in systems with quasiparticles interacting via local, nonstatistical interactions. While our results apply to any Abelian or non-Abelian topological phase in two-dimensions, we discuss in particular the implications for candidate quantum spin liquid materials, wherein the relevant quantities can be measured using pre-existing time-resolved terahertz-domain spectroscopic techniques. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2402.06484•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 6, 2024•6 citations

Detection of anyon braiding through pump–probe spectroscopy

Xu Yang, Ryan Buechele, Nandini Trivedi

We show that the braiding of anyons in a quantum spin liquid leaves a distinct dynamical signature in the nonlinear pump–probe response. Using a combination of exact diagonalization and matrix product state techniques, we study the nonlinear pump–probe response of the toric code in a magnetic field, a model with mobile electric e and magnetic m anyonic excitations. While the linear response signal oscillates and decays with time like ∼ t − 1.3 , the amplitude of the nonlinear signal for χ XZZ ( 3 ) features a linear-in-time enhancement at early times and a stronger enhancement t α with α > 1 at later times. The comparison between χ XZZ ( 3 ) , which involves nontrivial braiding of e and m anyons, and χ XXX ( 3 ) that involves trivial braiding of the same types of anyons, distinguishes the braiding statistics of anyons. We support our analysis with a hard-core anyon model with statistical gauge fields to develop further insights into the time dependence of the pump–probe response. Pump–probe spectroscopy provides a distinctive new probe of quantum spin liquid states, beyond the inconclusive broad features observed in single spin-flip inelastic neutron scattering.

arXiv:2503.22792•Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Nov 12, 2025•4 citations

Spectroscopic fingerprints of gapped quantum spin liquids, both conventional and fractonic

Rahul Nandkishore, Wonjune Choi, Yong Baek Kim

We explain how gapped quantum spin liquids, both conventional and "fractonic," may be unambiguously diagnosed experimentally using the technique of multidimensional coherent spectroscopy."Conventional" nonchiral gapped quantum spin liquids (e.g., Z 2 spin liquid) do not have sharp signatures in linear response, but they do have clear fingerprints in nonlinear response, accessible through the already existing experimental technique of two-dimensional coherent spectroscopy.Type I fracton phases (e.g., X-cube) are (surprisingly) even easier to distinguish, with strongly suggestive features even in linear response, and unambiguous signatures in nonlinear response.Type II fracton systems, like Haah's code, are most subtle, and they may require consideration of high-order nonlinear response for unambiguous diagnosis.

arXiv:2010.07947•Physical Review Research•Mar 19, 2021•52 citations

Signatures of Fractional Statistics in Nonlinear Pump-Probe Spectroscopy

Max McGinley, Michele Fava, S. A. Parameswaran

We show that the presence of anyons in the excitation spectrum of a two-dimensional system can be inferred from nonlinear spectroscopic quantities. In particular, we consider pump-probe spectroscopy, where a sample is irradiated by two light pulses with an adjustable time delay between them. The relevant response coefficient exhibits a universal form that originates from the statistical phase acquired when anyons created by the first pulse braid around those created by the second. This behavior is shown to be qualitatively unchanged by nonuniversal physics including nonstatistical interactions and small nonzero temperatures. In magnetic systems, the signal of interest can be measured using currently available terahertz-domain probes, highlighting the potential usefulness of nonlinear spectroscopic techniques in the search for quantum spin liquids.

arXiv:2210.16249•Physical Review Letters•Feb 6, 2024•20 citations

Measuring Anyonic Exchange Phases Using Two-Dimensional Coherent Spectroscopy

Nico Kirchner, Wonjune Choi, Frank Pollmann

Identifying experimental signatures of anyons, which exhibit fractional exchange statistics, remains a central challenge in the study of two-dimensional topologically ordered systems. Previous theoretical work has shown that the threshold behavior in linear response spectroscopy can reveal the fractional exchange statistics between an anyon and its antiparticle. In this work, we extend this framework to nonlinear, two-dimensional coherent spectroscopy. We demonstrate by analyzing time-ordered four-point correlation functions that the threshold behavior of nonlinear response functions encodes the fractional statistics between general pairs of anyons that can combine to any composite topological charge. This feature in particular provides a powerful probe for unambiguously distinguishing non-Abelian anyons, which can form multiple composite charges with distinct nontrivial braid statistics. Our approach is validated using numerical simulations that are consistent with the correct fractional exchange statistics for both the Abelian anyons in the toric code and non-Abelian Ising anyons.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2511.17420•Nov 24, 2025•1 citation

Evolution of dynamical signature in the X-cube fracton topological order

Chengkang Zhou, Meng-Yuan Li, Zheng Yan +2 more

As an unconventional realization of topological orders with an exotic interplay of topology and geometry, fracton (topological) orders feature subextensive topological ground-state degeneracy and subdimensional excitations that are movable only within a certain subspace. It has been known, in the exactly solvable three-dimensional X-cube model that universally represents the type-I fracton orders, that mobility constraints on subdimensional excitations originate from the absence of spatially deformable stringlike operators. To unveil the interplay of topology and geometry, in this paper, we study the dynamical signature in the X-cube model in the presence of external Zeeman fields via large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulation and stochastic analytic continuation. We compute both real-space correlation functions and dynamic structure factors of subdimensional excitations (i.e., fractons, lineons, and planons) in the fracton phase and their evolution into the trivial paramagnetic phase by increasing external fields. We find, in the fracton phase, that the correlation functions and the spectral functions show clear anisotropy exactly caused by the underlying mobility constraints. On the other hand, the external fields successfully induce quantum fluctuations and offer mobility to excitations along the subspace allowed by mobility constraints. These numerical results provide the evolution of a dynamical signature of subdimensional particles in fracton orders, indicating that the mobility constraints on local dynamical properties of subdimensional excitations are deeply related to the existence of fracton topological order. The results will also be helpful in potential experimental identifications in spectroscopy measurements such as neutron scattering and nuclear magnetic resonance.

arXiv:2203.13274•Physical Review Research•Aug 9, 2022•18 citations
We demonstrate how pump-probe techniques enable specific spectroscopic diagnostics of fracton phases of matter by studying lineon-planon braiding in the paradigmatic X-cube model. Our discussion builds on previous works probing anyonic exchange statistics in conventional spin liquids, but the extension to fracton phases reveals qualitatively new phenomena due to the restricted mobility of fractionalized excitations. A key feature is that nearby planons can form an emergent bound state by accessing different planes via alternative pairing configurations. We show that this bound state qualitatively modifies the long-time linear and nonlinear responses, leading to an asymptotic linear-in-ttt behavior for the pump-probe signal χZZXχ_\mathit{ZZX}χZZX​. By contrast, swapping the pump and probe polarizations produces a nonlinear response χXXZχ_\mathit{XXZ}χXXZ​ that is asymptotically ttt-independent. This asymmetry reflects the fact that the two species of fractionalized excitations live in different spatial dimensions. Thus, the pump-probe signals studied here are sensitive to (i) nontrivial braiding statistics in three dimensions, (ii) the existence of bound states among fractionalized excitations, and (iii) the one-dimensional mobility of lineons. Our results therefore provide spectroscopic signatures that distinguish fracton phases from conventional topologically ordered spin liquids.
We study the behavior of linear and nonlinear spectroscopic quantities in two-dimensional topologically ordered systems, which host anyonic excitations exhibiting fractional statistics. We highlight the role that braiding phases between anyons have on the dynamics of such quasiparticles, which as we show dictates the behavior of both linear response coefficients at finite temperatures, as well as nonlinear pump-probe response coefficients. These quantities, which act as probes of temporal correlations in the system, are shown to obey distinctive universal forms at sufficiently long timescales. As well as providing an experimentally measurable fingerprint of anyonic statistics, the universal behavior that we find also demonstrates anomalously fast thermal relaxation: correlation functions decay as a “squished exponential” C ( t ) ∼ exp ( − [ t / τ ] 3 / 2 ) at long times. We attribute this unusual asymptotic form to the nonlocal nature of interactions between anyons, which allows relaxation to occur much faster than in systems with quasiparticles interacting via local, nonstatistical interactions. While our results apply to any Abelian or non-Abelian topological phase in two-dimensions, we discuss in particular the implications for candidate quantum spin liquid materials, wherein the relevant quantities can be measured using pre-existing time-resolved terahertz-domain spectroscopic techniques. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
We show that the braiding of anyons in a quantum spin liquid leaves a distinct dynamical signature in the nonlinear pump–probe response. Using a combination of exact diagonalization and matrix product state techniques, we study the nonlinear pump–probe response of the toric code in a magnetic field, a model with mobile electric e and magnetic m anyonic excitations. While the linear response signal oscillates and decays with time like ∼ t − 1.3 , the amplitude of the nonlinear signal for χ XZZ ( 3 ) features a linear-in-time enhancement at early times and a stronger enhancement t α with α > 1 at later times. The comparison between χ XZZ ( 3 ) , which involves nontrivial braiding of e and m anyons, and χ XXX ( 3 ) that involves trivial braiding of the same types of anyons, distinguishes the braiding statistics of anyons. We support our analysis with a hard-core anyon model with statistical gauge fields to develop further insights into the time dependence of the pump–probe response. Pump–probe spectroscopy provides a distinctive new probe of quantum spin liquid states, beyond the inconclusive broad features observed in single spin-flip inelastic neutron scattering.
We explain how gapped quantum spin liquids, both conventional and "fractonic," may be unambiguously diagnosed experimentally using the technique of multidimensional coherent spectroscopy."Conventional" nonchiral gapped quantum spin liquids (e.g., Z 2 spin liquid) do not have sharp signatures in linear response, but they do have clear fingerprints in nonlinear response, accessible through the already existing experimental technique of two-dimensional coherent spectroscopy.Type I fracton phases (e.g., X-cube) are (surprisingly) even easier to distinguish, with strongly suggestive features even in linear response, and unambiguous signatures in nonlinear response.Type II fracton systems, like Haah's code, are most subtle, and they may require consideration of high-order nonlinear response for unambiguous diagnosis.
We show that the presence of anyons in the excitation spectrum of a two-dimensional system can be inferred from nonlinear spectroscopic quantities. In particular, we consider pump-probe spectroscopy, where a sample is irradiated by two light pulses with an adjustable time delay between them. The relevant response coefficient exhibits a universal form that originates from the statistical phase acquired when anyons created by the first pulse braid around those created by the second. This behavior is shown to be qualitatively unchanged by nonuniversal physics including nonstatistical interactions and small nonzero temperatures. In magnetic systems, the signal of interest can be measured using currently available terahertz-domain probes, highlighting the potential usefulness of nonlinear spectroscopic techniques in the search for quantum spin liquids.
Identifying experimental signatures of anyons, which exhibit fractional exchange statistics, remains a central challenge in the study of two-dimensional topologically ordered systems. Previous theoretical work has shown that the threshold behavior in linear response spectroscopy can reveal the fractional exchange statistics between an anyon and its antiparticle. In this work, we extend this framework to nonlinear, two-dimensional coherent spectroscopy. We demonstrate by analyzing time-ordered four-point correlation functions that the threshold behavior of nonlinear response functions encodes the fractional statistics between general pairs of anyons that can combine to any composite topological charge. This feature in particular provides a powerful probe for unambiguously distinguishing non-Abelian anyons, which can form multiple composite charges with distinct nontrivial braid statistics. Our approach is validated using numerical simulations that are consistent with the correct fractional exchange statistics for both the Abelian anyons in the toric code and non-Abelian Ising anyons.
As an unconventional realization of topological orders with an exotic interplay of topology and geometry, fracton (topological) orders feature subextensive topological ground-state degeneracy and subdimensional excitations that are movable only within a certain subspace. It has been known, in the exactly solvable three-dimensional X-cube model that universally represents the type-I fracton orders, that mobility constraints on subdimensional excitations originate from the absence of spatially deformable stringlike operators. To unveil the interplay of topology and geometry, in this paper, we study the dynamical signature in the X-cube model in the presence of external Zeeman fields via large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulation and stochastic analytic continuation. We compute both real-space correlation functions and dynamic structure factors of subdimensional excitations (i.e., fractons, lineons, and planons) in the fracton phase and their evolution into the trivial paramagnetic phase by increasing external fields. We find, in the fracton phase, that the correlation functions and the spectral functions show clear anisotropy exactly caused by the underlying mobility constraints. On the other hand, the external fields successfully induce quantum fluctuations and offer mobility to excitations along the subspace allowed by mobility constraints. These numerical results provide the evolution of a dynamical signature of subdimensional particles in fracton orders, indicating that the mobility constraints on local dynamical properties of subdimensional excitations are deeply related to the existence of fracton topological order. The results will also be helpful in potential experimental identifications in spectroscopy measurements such as neutron scattering and nuclear magnetic resonance.