Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2602.21388 · Physical Review Applied

Phonon decoherence produced by two-level tunneling states

Ryan O. Behunin, Taylor Ray, Dylan Chapman, Andrew J. Shepherd, Yizhi Luo, Peter T. Rakich

cond-mat.mes-hallquant-phSubmitted Feb 24, 2026• Announced Feb 26, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Phonon modes within pristine crystalline resonators now routinely reach the quantum ground state. Such systems are attractive for quantum information science applications, as advanced fabrication and processing can enable relatively long quantum coherence times, and precision control can be realized through optical, electrical, or qubit coupling. In many state-of-the-art systems, the phonon lifetime is limited by disorder. In particular, native oxides or damaged `dead layers' at surfaces can host two-level tunneling states that lead to a particularly problematic form of dissipation that increases at lower temperatures. As mechanical losses are driven down in systems such as micro-fabricated bulk acoustic wave resonators, tunneling states are expected to emerge as the dominant mechanism for phonon decoherence. A quantitative description of these mesoscopic systems therefore requires a framework that captures interactions between a selected phonon mode and a large ensemble of TLS. Here, we derive a quantum master equation for this coupled system, permitting the phonon decoherence produced by two-level tunneling states to be calculated. As an example, we estimate the lifetime of a variety of quantum states within quartz micro-resonators hosting a thin surface layer of tunneling states. We find that the phonon coherence time is maximized at low temperatures, in spite of increased mechanical dissipation, and that phonon-TLS coupling can be reduced for modes with strain nodes at the surfaces.

Comments
7 pages, 2 figures

Related papers

Millisecond coherence times in gigahertz-frequency mechanical oscillators

Yizhi Luo, Hilel Hagai Diamandi, Hanshi Li +9 more

High-frequency mechanical oscillators with long coherence times are essential for realizing a variety of high-fidelity quantum sensors, transducers and memories. However, the coherence times needed for quantum applications require advances in probing and mitigating the origins of phonon decoherence in the materials used for mechanical oscillators. Here we identify key sources of phonon decoherence in crystalline media by combining non-invasive laser spectroscopy with materials analysis. Using micro-fabricated high-overtone bulk acoustic-wave resonators as an experimental test bed, we find that phonon–surface interactions are the dominant source of phonon decoherence in crystalline quartz. The probable causes are lattice distortion, subsurface damage and a high concentration of elemental impurities. We use an optimized polishing process to remove the compromised surface layer and produce resonators with quality factors exceeding 240 million at 12 GHz, corresponding to phonon coherence times of over 6 ms. We verify that these mechanical oscillators have negligible dephasing. Building on these results, we propose a path that could reach coherence times beyond 100 ms as the basis for high-frequency quantum memories. These findings demonstrate that enhanced control over surfaces enables a substantial reduction in dissipation and noise. Phonon decoherence in quantum high-overtone bulk acoustic-wave resonators is dominated by imperfections under the material surface. Removing the damaged subsurface layer substantially increases the performance of these devices.

Nature Physics•Jul 9, 2026•1 citation

Decoherence of surface phonons in a quantum acoustic system

C. Undershute, J. M. Kitzman, Camille A. Mikolas +1 more

Phononic resonators are becoming increasingly important in quantum information science, both for applications in quantum computing, communication, and sensing as well as in experiments investigating fundamental physics. Here, we study the decoherence of phonons confined in a surface acoustic wave (SAW) resonator strongly coupled $(g/2\ensuremath{\pi}\ensuremath{\approx}9\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\mathrm{MHz})$ to a superconducting transmon qubit. By comparing experimental data with numerical solutions to the Markovian master equation, we report a surface phononic energy decay rate of ${\ensuremath{\kappa}}_{1}/2\ensuremath{\pi}=480\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\mathrm{kHz}$ and a pure dephasing rate of ${\ensuremath{\kappa}}_{\ensuremath{\phi}}/2\ensuremath{\pi}=180\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\mathrm{kHz}$. These rates are in good agreement with the level of decoherence we extract from qubit-assisted spectroscopic measurements of the SAW resonator. We additionally find that the timescales over which coherent driven dynamics and decoherence occur are comparable, highlighting the need to model the composite device as an open quantum system. We discuss possible sources of decoherence in SAW-based quantum acoustic devices and the application of these devices in future quantum acoustic dissipation engineering experiments. The decoherence characterization techniques we employ are broadly applicable for investigating and benchmarking the effects of loss and dephasing on mechanical resonators in the quantum regime.

arXiv:2410.03005•Physical Review A•Jan 13, 2025•4 citations

Lifetime-limited Gigahertz-frequency Mechanical Oscillators with Millisecond Coherence Times

Yizhi Luo, Hilel Hagai Diamandi, Li, Hanshi +9 more

High-frequency mechanical oscillators with long coherence times are essential to realizing a variety of high-fidelity quantum sensors, transducers, and memories. However, the unprecedented coherence times needed for quantum applications require exquisitely sensitive new techniques to probe the material origins of phonon decoherence and new strategies to mitigate decoherence in mechanical oscillators. Here, we combine non-invasive laser spectroscopy techniques with materials analysis to identify key sources of phonon decoherence in crystalline media. Using micro-fabricated high-overtone bulk acoustic-wave resonators ($μ$HBARs) as an experimental testbed, we identify phonon-surface interactions as the dominant source of phonon decoherence in crystalline quartz; lattice distortion, subsurface damage, and high concentration of elemental impurities near the crystal surface are identified as the likely causes. Removal of this compromised surface layer using an optimized polishing process is seen to greatly enhance coherence times, enabling $μ$HBARs with Q-factors of > 240 million at 12 GHz frequencies, corresponding to > 6 ms phonon coherence times and record-level f-Q products. Complementary phonon linewidth and time-domain ringdown measurements, performed using a new Brillouin-based pump-probe spectroscopy technique, reveal negligible dephasing within these oscillators. Building on these results, we identify a path to > 100 ms coherence times as the basis for high-frequency quantum memories. These findings clearly demonstrate that, with enhanced control over surfaces, dissipation and noise can be significantly reduced in a wide range of quantum systems.

arXiv:2504.07523•Apr 10, 2025•1 citation

Loss Mechanisms in High-coherence Multimode Mechanical Resonators Coupled to Superconducting Circuits

Raquel Garcia Belles, Alexander Anferov, Lukas F. Deeg +14 more

Circuit quantum acoustodynamics (cQAD) devices have a wide range of applications in quantum science, all of which depend crucially on the quantum coherence of the mechanical subsystem. In this context, high-overtone bulk acoustic-wave resonators (HBARs) are particularly promising, since they have shown very high quality factors with negligible dephasing. However, the introduction of piezoelectric films, which are necessary for coupling to a superconducting circuit, can lead to additional loss channels, such as surface scattering and two-level systems (TLS). Here, we study the acoustic dissipation of HBAR resonators in cQAD systems and find that the defect density of the piezoelectric material and its interface with the bulk are limiting factors for the coherence. We measure acoustic modes with phonon lifetimes up to 400 $μ$s and lifetime-limited coherence times approaching one millisecond in the quantum regime. When coupled to a superconducting qubit, this leads to a hybrid system with a large quantum coherence cooperativity of $C_{T_2}=1.1\times10^5$. These results represent a new milestone for the performance of cQAD devices and offer concrete paths forward for further improvements.

quant-pharXiv:2602.22117•PRX Quantum•Feb 26, 2026•3 citations

Quantum sensors for microscopic tunneling systems

Alexander Bilmes, Serhii Volosheniuk, Jan David Brehm +2 more

Abstract The anomalous low-temperature properties of glasses arise from intrinsic excitable entities, so-called tunneling Two-Level-Systems (TLS), whose microscopic nature has been baffling solid-state physicists for decades. TLS have become particularly important for micro-fabricated quantum devices such as superconducting qubits, where they are a major source of decoherence. Here, we present a method to characterize individual TLS in virtually arbitrary materials deposited as thin films. The material is used as the dielectric in a capacitor that shunts the Josephson junction of a superconducting qubit. In such a hybrid quantum system the qubit serves as an interface to detect and control individual TLS. We demonstrate spectroscopic measurements of TLS resonances, evaluate their coupling to applied strain and DC-electric fields, and find evidence of strong interaction between coherent TLS in the sample material. Our approach opens avenues for quantum material spectroscopy to investigate the structure of tunneling defects and to develop low-loss dielectrics that are urgently required for the advancement of superconducting quantum computers.

arXiv:2011.14327•npj Quantum Information•Feb 5, 2021•32 citations

Quartz phononic crystal resonators for hybrid acoustic quantum memories

Yang Hu, Angad Gupta, Jacob Repicky +2 more

Circuit quantum acoustodynamics systems have emerged as a promising platform for quantum information by coupling superconducting qubits to mechanical resonators, with their long-lived mechanical modes serving as quantum memories. We demonstrate suspended quartz phononic crystal resonators at 100 MHz with millisecond lifetimes at 8 K. With a contactless electrode geometry suppressing both two-level system losses and other electrode-induced energy dissipation, we evaluate the piezoelectric coupling rate between the mechanical modes and fluxonium qubits (resonant coupling) and transmon qubits (parametric coupling mediated by a Josephon-junction-based three-wave mixer). We further discuss multi-period defect geometries for enhancing these coupling rates.

arXiv:2509.07900•Sep 9, 2025•0 citations
Phonon modes within pristine crystalline resonators now routinely reach the quantum ground state. Such systems are attractive for quantum information science applications, as advanced fabrication and processing can enable relatively long quantum coherence times, and precision control can be realized through optical, electrical, or qubit coupling. In many state-of-the-art systems, the phonon lifetime is limited by disorder. In particular, native oxides or damaged `dead layers' at surfaces can host two-level tunneling states that lead to a particularly problematic form of dissipation that increases at lower temperatures. As mechanical losses are driven down in systems such as micro-fabricated bulk acoustic wave resonators, tunneling states are expected to emerge as the dominant mechanism for phonon decoherence. A quantitative description of these mesoscopic systems therefore requires a framework that captures interactions between a selected phonon mode and a large ensemble of TLS. Here, we derive a quantum master equation for this coupled system, permitting the phonon decoherence produced by two-level tunneling states to be calculated. As an example, we estimate the lifetime of a variety of quantum states within quartz micro-resonators hosting a thin surface layer of tunneling states. We find that the phonon coherence time is maximized at low temperatures, in spite of increased mechanical dissipation, and that phonon-TLS coupling can be reduced for modes with strain nodes at the surfaces.
High-frequency mechanical oscillators with long coherence times are essential for realizing a variety of high-fidelity quantum sensors, transducers and memories. However, the coherence times needed for quantum applications require advances in probing and mitigating the origins of phonon decoherence in the materials used for mechanical oscillators. Here we identify key sources of phonon decoherence in crystalline media by combining non-invasive laser spectroscopy with materials analysis. Using micro-fabricated high-overtone bulk acoustic-wave resonators as an experimental test bed, we find that phonon–surface interactions are the dominant source of phonon decoherence in crystalline quartz. The probable causes are lattice distortion, subsurface damage and a high concentration of elemental impurities. We use an optimized polishing process to remove the compromised surface layer and produce resonators with quality factors exceeding 240 million at 12 GHz, corresponding to phonon coherence times of over 6 ms. We verify that these mechanical oscillators have negligible dephasing. Building on these results, we propose a path that could reach coherence times beyond 100 ms as the basis for high-frequency quantum memories. These findings demonstrate that enhanced control over surfaces enables a substantial reduction in dissipation and noise. Phonon decoherence in quantum high-overtone bulk acoustic-wave resonators is dominated by imperfections under the material surface. Removing the damaged subsurface layer substantially increases the performance of these devices.
Phononic resonators are becoming increasingly important in quantum information science, both for applications in quantum computing, communication, and sensing as well as in experiments investigating fundamental physics. Here, we study the decoherence of phonons confined in a surface acoustic wave (SAW) resonator strongly coupled $(g/2\ensuremath{\pi}\ensuremath{\approx}9\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\mathrm{MHz})$ to a superconducting transmon qubit. By comparing experimental data with numerical solutions to the Markovian master equation, we report a surface phononic energy decay rate of ${\ensuremath{\kappa}}_{1}/2\ensuremath{\pi}=480\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\mathrm{kHz}$ and a pure dephasing rate of ${\ensuremath{\kappa}}_{\ensuremath{\phi}}/2\ensuremath{\pi}=180\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\mathrm{kHz}$. These rates are in good agreement with the level of decoherence we extract from qubit-assisted spectroscopic measurements of the SAW resonator. We additionally find that the timescales over which coherent driven dynamics and decoherence occur are comparable, highlighting the need to model the composite device as an open quantum system. We discuss possible sources of decoherence in SAW-based quantum acoustic devices and the application of these devices in future quantum acoustic dissipation engineering experiments. The decoherence characterization techniques we employ are broadly applicable for investigating and benchmarking the effects of loss and dephasing on mechanical resonators in the quantum regime.
High-frequency mechanical oscillators with long coherence times are essential to realizing a variety of high-fidelity quantum sensors, transducers, and memories. However, the unprecedented coherence times needed for quantum applications require exquisitely sensitive new techniques to probe the material origins of phonon decoherence and new strategies to mitigate decoherence in mechanical oscillators. Here, we combine non-invasive laser spectroscopy techniques with materials analysis to identify key sources of phonon decoherence in crystalline media. Using micro-fabricated high-overtone bulk acoustic-wave resonators (μμμHBARs) as an experimental testbed, we identify phonon-surface interactions as the dominant source of phonon decoherence in crystalline quartz; lattice distortion, subsurface damage, and high concentration of elemental impurities near the crystal surface are identified as the likely causes. Removal of this compromised surface layer using an optimized polishing process is seen to greatly enhance coherence times, enabling μμμHBARs with Q-factors of > 240 million at 12 GHz frequencies, corresponding to > 6 ms phonon coherence times and record-level f-Q products. Complementary phonon linewidth and time-domain ringdown measurements, performed using a new Brillouin-based pump-probe spectroscopy technique, reveal negligible dephasing within these oscillators. Building on these results, we identify a path to > 100 ms coherence times as the basis for high-frequency quantum memories. These findings clearly demonstrate that, with enhanced control over surfaces, dissipation and noise can be significantly reduced in a wide range of quantum systems.
Circuit quantum acoustodynamics (cQAD) devices have a wide range of applications in quantum science, all of which depend crucially on the quantum coherence of the mechanical subsystem. In this context, high-overtone bulk acoustic-wave resonators (HBARs) are particularly promising, since they have shown very high quality factors with negligible dephasing. However, the introduction of piezoelectric films, which are necessary for coupling to a superconducting circuit, can lead to additional loss channels, such as surface scattering and two-level systems (TLS). Here, we study the acoustic dissipation of HBAR resonators in cQAD systems and find that the defect density of the piezoelectric material and its interface with the bulk are limiting factors for the coherence. We measure acoustic modes with phonon lifetimes up to 400 μμμs and lifetime-limited coherence times approaching one millisecond in the quantum regime. When coupled to a superconducting qubit, this leads to a hybrid system with a large quantum coherence cooperativity of CT2=1.1×105C_{T_2}=1.1\times10^5CT2​​=1.1×105. These results represent a new milestone for the performance of cQAD devices and offer concrete paths forward for further improvements.
Abstract The anomalous low-temperature properties of glasses arise from intrinsic excitable entities, so-called tunneling Two-Level-Systems (TLS), whose microscopic nature has been baffling solid-state physicists for decades. TLS have become particularly important for micro-fabricated quantum devices such as superconducting qubits, where they are a major source of decoherence. Here, we present a method to characterize individual TLS in virtually arbitrary materials deposited as thin films. The material is used as the dielectric in a capacitor that shunts the Josephson junction of a superconducting qubit. In such a hybrid quantum system the qubit serves as an interface to detect and control individual TLS. We demonstrate spectroscopic measurements of TLS resonances, evaluate their coupling to applied strain and DC-electric fields, and find evidence of strong interaction between coherent TLS in the sample material. Our approach opens avenues for quantum material spectroscopy to investigate the structure of tunneling defects and to develop low-loss dielectrics that are urgently required for the advancement of superconducting quantum computers.
Circuit quantum acoustodynamics systems have emerged as a promising platform for quantum information by coupling superconducting qubits to mechanical resonators, with their long-lived mechanical modes serving as quantum memories. We demonstrate suspended quartz phononic crystal resonators at 100 MHz with millisecond lifetimes at 8 K. With a contactless electrode geometry suppressing both two-level system losses and other electrode-induced energy dissipation, we evaluate the piezoelectric coupling rate between the mechanical modes and fluxonium qubits (resonant coupling) and transmon qubits (parametric coupling mediated by a Josephon-junction-based three-wave mixer). We further discuss multi-period defect geometries for enhancing these coupling rates.