arXiv:2601.21930 · Physical Review A

Entropy production versus memory effects in two-level open quantum systems

Guillaume Théret, Dominique Sugny, Camille L. Latune

quant-phSubmitted Jan 29, 2026• Announced Jan 30, 2026• 0 citations• Revised Jul 27, 2026 (v2)

Abstract

We compare several definitions of entropy production rate introduced in the literature from a large variety of situations and motivations, and then analyze their relations with memory effects. Considering a relevant experimental example of a qubit interacting with a single bosonic mode playing the role of a finite bath, we show that all definitions of entropy production coincide at weak coupling. In a stronger coupling regime, significant discrepancies emerge between the different entropy production rates, although some similarities in the overall behaviour remain. However, surprisingly, two of these definitions --one based on local quantities of the system and the other on non-local quantities-- coincide exactly, even in the case of strong coupling. Finally, a high degree of correspondence is observed when memory effects characterized by P-divisibility are compared with the sign of all entropy production rates in the case of weak coupling. Such correspondence degrades at stronger coupling, leading us to extend the concept of entropy production to the dynamical map. We show a perfect equivalence between the sign of this enlarged concept of entropy production and P-divisibility, both numerically and analytically, in the case of phase-covariant master equations.

Journal reference: Phys. Rev. A 114, 012456 (2026)
DOI: 10.1103/s999-8w59
Comments: 8+10 pages, 5+7 figures. Published in Phys. Rev. A 114, 012456 (2026)

Related papers

Local approach to entropy production in the nonequilibrium dynamics of open quantum systems

Irene Ada Picatoste, Alessandra Colla, Heinz-Peter Breuer

We discuss fundamental features of the local expression for the entropy production rate of the nonequilibrium quantum dynamics of open systems and its relations to memory effects and the spectrum of the generator of the dynamics. Defining the entropy production rate as negative rate of change of the relative entropy with respect to an instantaneous fixed point, it is shown that positivity of the entropy production rate for all possible initial states implies that the real parts of the eigenvalues of the time-local generator for the quantum master equation are always negative. It is further demonstrated that Markovian dynamics, identified as P-divisibility of the quantum dynamical map, implies positivity of entropy production rate, thus providing a kind of generalized second law in the nonequilibrium regime. We also prove by means of the counterexample of a phase covariant quantum master equation that the converse of this statement is not true, i.e., there are non-Markovian dynamics for which the entropy production rate is always positive. Thus, we conclude that the emergence of negative entropy production rates is a sufficient but not necessary condition for non-Markovianity of the quantum dynamics. Finally, we also consider a recently introduced map-based notion of entropy production and show the equivalence between its positivity and Markovianity for general finite-dimensional systems.

quant-pharXiv:2603.01861Mar 3, 20260 citations

Heat current and entropy production rate in local non-Markovian quantum dynamics of global Markovian evolution

Ahana Ghoshal, Ujjwal Sen

We examine the elements of the balance equation of entropy in open quantum evolutions and their response as we go from a Markovian to a non-Markovian situation. In particular, we look at the heat current and entropy production rate in the non-Markovian reduced evolution, as well as a Markovian limit of the same, experienced by one of two interacting systems immersed in a Markovian bath. The analysis naturally leads us to define a heat current deficit and an entropy production rate deficit, which are differences between the global and local versions of the corresponding quantities. The investigation leads, in certain cases, to a complementarity of the time-integrated heat current deficit and the relative entropy of entanglement between the two systems.

arXiv:2102.06694Physical Review AFeb 17, 20228 citations

Entropy production in the mesoscopic-leads formulation of quantum thermodynamics

Artur M. Lacerda, Michael J. Kewming, Marlon Brenes +4 more

Understanding the entropy production of systems strongly coupled to thermal baths is a core problem of both quantum thermodynamics and mesoscopic physics. While many techniques exist to accurately study entropy production in such systems, they typically require a microscopic description of the baths, which can become numerically intractable to study for large systems. Alternatively an open-systems approach can be employed with all the nuances associated with various levels of approximation. Recently, the mesoscopic leads approach has emerged as a powerful method for studying such quantum systems strongly coupled to multiple thermal baths. In this method, a set of discretized lead modes, each locally damped, provide a Markovian embedding. Here we show that this method proves extremely useful to describe entropy production of a strongly coupled open quantum system. We show numerically, for both noninteracting and interacting setups, that a system coupled to a single bath exhibits a thermal fixed point at the level of the embedding. This allows us to use various results from the thermodynamics of quantum dynamical semigroups to infer the nonequilibrium thermodynamics of the strongly coupled, non-Markovian central systems. In particular, we show that the entropy production in the transient regime recovers the well-established microscopic definitions of entropy production with a correction that can be computed explicitly for both the single- and multiple-lead cases.

arXiv:2312.12513Physical review. EJul 17, 202410 citations

Non-Markovianity and negative entropy production rates

Philipp Strasberg, Massimiliano Esposito

Entropy production plays a fundamental role in nonequilibrium thermodynamics to quantify the irreversibility of open systems. Its positivity can be ensured for a wide class of setups, but the entropy production rate can become negative sometimes. This is often taken as an indicator of non-Markovianity. We make this link precise by showing under which conditions a negative entropy production rate implies non-Markovianity and when it does not. For a system coupled to a single heat bath, this can be established within a unified language for two setups: (i) the dynamics resulting from a coarse-grained description of a Markovian master equation and (ii) the classical Hamiltonian dynamics of a system coupled to a bath. The quantum version of the latter result is shown not to hold despite the fact that the integrated thermodynamic description is formally equivalent to the classical case. The instantaneous fixed point of a non-Markovian dynamics plays an important role in our study. Our key contribution is to provide a consistent theoretical framework to study the finite-time thermodynamics of a large class of dynamics with a precise link to its non-Markovianity.

arXiv:1806.09101Physical review. EJan 14, 2019116 citations

Quantum fluctuation theorem for dissipative processes

Gabriele De Chiara, Alberto Imparato

We present a general quantum fluctuation theorem for the entropy production of an open quantum system coupled to multiple environments, not necessarily at equilibrium. Such a general theorem, when restricted to the weak-coupling and Markovian regime, holds for both local and global master equations, corroborating the thermodynamic consistency of local quantum master equations. The theorem is genuinely quantum, as it can be expressed in terms of conservation of a Hermitian operator, describing the dynamics of the system state operator and of the entropy change in the baths. The integral fluctuation theorem follows from the properties of such an operator. Furthermore, it is also valid when the system is described by a time-dependent Hamiltonian. As such, the quantum Jarzynski equality is a particular case of the general result presented here. Moreover, our result can be extended to nonthermal baths, as long as microreversibility is preserved. We present some numerical examples to showcase the exact results previously obtained. We finally generalize the fluctuation theorem to the case where the interaction between the system and the bath is explicitly taken into account. We show that the fluctuation theorem amounts to a relation between time-reversed dynamics of the global density matrix and a two-time correlation function along the forward dynamics involving the baths' entropy alone.

arXiv:2108.05937Physical Review ResearchJun 21, 202211 citations

Entropy production in a controlled non-Markovian setting

Maria Popovic, Bassano Vacchini, Steve Campbell

We study the relationship between a (non-)Markovian evolution and the entropy production rate. We consider a system qubit in contact with a thermal bath and in addition the system is strongly coupled to an ancillary qubit. We examine the steady state properties finding that the coupling leads to effective temperatures emerging in the composite system, and show that this is related to the creation of correlations between the qubits. By establishing the conditions under which the system reaches thermal equilibrium with the bath despite undergoing a non-Markovian evolution, we examine the entropy production rate, showing that its transient negativity is a sufficient sign of non-Markovianity.

Apr 11, 20181 citation