Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2601.19469 · Quantum Studies Mathematics and Foundations

Quantum Zeno-like Paradox for Position Measurements: A Particle Precisely Found in Space is Nowhere to be Found in Hilbert Space

Xabier Oianguren-Asua, Roderich Tumulka

quant-phmath-phSubmitted Jan 27, 2026• Announced Jan 28, 2026• 0 citations• Revised Jul 8, 2026 (v3)
v1 · Jan 27, 2026v2 · Feb 25, 2026v3 · Jul 8, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

On a quantum particle in the unit interval $[0,1]$, perform a position measurement with inaccuracy $1/n$ and then a quantum measurement of the projection $|φ\rangle\langleφ|$ with some arbitrary but fixed normalized $φ$. Call the outcomes $X \in[0,1]$ and $Y \in\{0,1\}$. We show that in the limit $n\to\infty$ corresponding to perfect precision for $X$, the probability of $Y=1$ tends to 0 for every $φ$. Since there is no density matrix, pure or mixed, which upon measurement of any $|φ\rangle\langleφ|$ yields outcome 1 with probability 0, our result suggests that a novel type of quantum state beyond Hilbert space is necessary to describe a quantum particle after a perfect position measurement.

Journal reference
Quantum Studies: Mathematics and Foundations 13: 32 (2026)
DOI
10.1007/s40509-026-00406-w
Comments
12 pages LaTeX, no figures; v3 minor additions

Related papers

The classical limit of the quantum Zeno effect

Paolo Facchi, S. Graffi, Marilena Ligabò

The evolution of a quantum system subjected to infinitely many measurements in a finite time interval is confined in a proper subspace of the Hilbert space. This phenomenon is called 'quantum Zeno effect': a particle under intensive observation which does not evolve. This effect is at variance with the classical evolution, which obviously is not affected by any observations. By a semiclassical analysis, we will show that the quantum Zeno effect vanishes at all orders, when the Planck constant tends to zero, and thus it is a purely quantum phenomenon without classical analog, at the same level of tunneling.

arXiv:0911.5675•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Dec 17, 2009•7 citations

How to determine a quantum state by measurements: The Pauli problem for a particle with arbitrary potential

Stefan Weigert

The problem of reconstructing a pure quantum state \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\psi}〉 from measurable quantities is considered for a particle moving in a one-dimensional potential V(x). Suppose that the position probability distribution \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\psi}(x,t)${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Vert}}}^{2}$ has been measured at time t, and let it have M nodes. It is shown that after measuring the time evolved distribution at a short-time interval \ensuremath{\Delta}t later, \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\psi}(x,t+\ensuremath{\Delta}t)${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Vert}}}^{2}$, the set of wave functions compatible with these distributions is given by a smooth manifold M in Hilbert space. The manifold M is isomorphic to an M-dimensional torus, ${\mathcal{T}}^{\mathit{M}}$. Finally, M additional expectation values of appropriately chosen nonlocal operators fix the quantum state uniquely. The method used here is the analog of an approach that has been applied successfully to the corresponding problem for a spin system. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

Physical Review A•Apr 1, 1996•48 citations

Quantum interference of position and momentum: A particle propagation paradox

Holger Friedrich Hofmann

Optimal simultaneous control of position and momentum can be achieved by maximizing the probabilities of finding their experimentally observed values within two well-defined intervals. The assumption that particles move along straight lines in free space can then be tested by deriving a lower limit for the probability of finding the particle in a corresponding spatial interval at any intermediate time $t$. Here, it is shown that this lower limit can be violated by quantum superpositions of states confined within the respective position and momentum intervals. These violations of the particle propagation inequality show that quantum mechanics changes the laws of motion at a fundamental level, providing a different perspective on causality relations and time evolution in quantum mechanics.

arXiv:1706.04286•Physical Review A•Aug 28, 2017•17 citations

A particle in space

Benjamin W. Schumacher, Michael D. Westmoreland

The quantum systems we have discussed so far have been described by finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces. Basic measurements on such systems have a finite number of possible outcomes, and a quantum state predicts a discrete probability distribution over these. Now we wish to extend our theory to handle systems with one or more continuous degrees of freedom, such as the position of a particle that can move in one dimension. This will require an extension of our theory to Hilbert spaces of infinite dimension, and to systems with continuous observables.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Mar 25, 2010•0 citations

Quantum Zeno region in quantum walk dynamics

C. M. Chandrashekar

We investigate the discrete-time quantum walk evolution under the influence of the periodic measurements in position subspace. The undisturbed survival probability of the particle at the position subspace, $P(0, t)$ is compared with the survival probability after frequent ($n$) measurements at interval $\tau = t/n$, $P(0, \tau)^n$. We show that $P(0, \tau)^n > P(0, t)$ leading to the quantum Zeno effect in the position subspace when a parameter $\theta$ in the quantum coin operations and frequency of measurements is greater than the critical value, $\theta > \theta_{c}$ and $n>n_{c}$. This Zeno effect in the subspace preserves the dynamics in coin Hilbert space of the walk dynamics and has a potential to play a significant role in quantum tasks such as, preserving the quantum state of the particle at any particular position and to understand the Zeno dynamics in a multidimensional system which is highly transient in nature.

•Jul 8, 2010•0 citations

Zeno subspace in quantum-walk dynamics

C. M. Chandrashekar

We investigate discrete-time quantum-walk evolution under the influence of periodic measurements in position subspace. The undisturbed survival probability of the particle at the position subspace $P(0,t)$ is compared with the survival probability after frequent ($n$) measurements at interval $\ensuremath{\tau}=t/n$, $P(0,\ensuremath{\tau}){}^{n}$. We show that $P(0,\ensuremath{\tau}){}^{n}>P(0,t)$ leads to the quantum Zeno effect in position subspace when a parameter $\ensuremath{\theta}$ in the quantum coin operations and frequency of measurements is greater than the critical value, $\ensuremath{\theta}>{\ensuremath{\theta}}_{c}$ and $n>{n}_{c}$. This Zeno effect in the subspace preserves the dynamics in coin Hilbert space of the walk dynamics and has the potential to play a significant role in quantum tasks such as preserving the quantum state of the particle at any particular position, and to understand the Zeno dynamics in a multidimensional system that is highly transient in nature.

arXiv:1007.1303•Physical Review A•Nov 9, 2010•10 citations
On a quantum particle in the unit interval [0,1][0,1][0,1], perform a position measurement with inaccuracy 1/n1/n1/n and then a quantum measurement of the projection ∣φ⟩⟨φ∣|φ\rangle\langleφ|∣φ⟩⟨φ∣ with some arbitrary but fixed normalized φφφ. Call the outcomes X∈[0,1]X \in[0,1]X∈[0,1] and Y∈{0,1}Y \in\{0,1\}Y∈{0,1}. We show that in the limit n→∞n\to\inftyn→∞ corresponding to perfect precision for XXX, the probability of Y=1Y=1Y=1 tends to 0 for every φφφ. Since there is no density matrix, pure or mixed, which upon measurement of any ∣φ⟩⟨φ∣|φ\rangle\langleφ|∣φ⟩⟨φ∣ yields outcome 1 with probability 0, our result suggests that a novel type of quantum state beyond Hilbert space is necessary to describe a quantum particle after a perfect position measurement.
The evolution of a quantum system subjected to infinitely many measurements in a finite time interval is confined in a proper subspace of the Hilbert space. This phenomenon is called 'quantum Zeno effect': a particle under intensive observation which does not evolve. This effect is at variance with the classical evolution, which obviously is not affected by any observations. By a semiclassical analysis, we will show that the quantum Zeno effect vanishes at all orders, when the Planck constant tends to zero, and thus it is a purely quantum phenomenon without classical analog, at the same level of tunneling.
The problem of reconstructing a pure quantum state \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\psi}〉 from measurable quantities is considered for a particle moving in a one-dimensional potential V(x). Suppose that the position probability distribution \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\psi}(x,t)${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Vert}}}^{2}$ has been measured at time t, and let it have M nodes. It is shown that after measuring the time evolved distribution at a short-time interval \ensuremath{\Delta}t later, \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\psi}(x,t+\ensuremath{\Delta}t)${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Vert}}}^{2}$, the set of wave functions compatible with these distributions is given by a smooth manifold M in Hilbert space. The manifold M is isomorphic to an M-dimensional torus, TM{\mathcal{T}}^{\mathit{M}}TM. Finally, M additional expectation values of appropriately chosen nonlocal operators fix the quantum state uniquely. The method used here is the analog of an approach that has been applied successfully to the corresponding problem for a spin system. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
Optimal simultaneous control of position and momentum can be achieved by maximizing the probabilities of finding their experimentally observed values within two well-defined intervals. The assumption that particles move along straight lines in free space can then be tested by deriving a lower limit for the probability of finding the particle in a corresponding spatial interval at any intermediate time ttt. Here, it is shown that this lower limit can be violated by quantum superpositions of states confined within the respective position and momentum intervals. These violations of the particle propagation inequality show that quantum mechanics changes the laws of motion at a fundamental level, providing a different perspective on causality relations and time evolution in quantum mechanics.
The quantum systems we have discussed so far have been described by finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces. Basic measurements on such systems have a finite number of possible outcomes, and a quantum state predicts a discrete probability distribution over these. Now we wish to extend our theory to handle systems with one or more continuous degrees of freedom, such as the position of a particle that can move in one dimension. This will require an extension of our theory to Hilbert spaces of infinite dimension, and to systems with continuous observables.
We investigate the discrete-time quantum walk evolution under the influence of the periodic measurements in position subspace. The undisturbed survival probability of the particle at the position subspace, P(0,t)P(0, t)P(0,t) is compared with the survival probability after frequent (nnn) measurements at interval τ=t/n\tau = t/nτ=t/n, P(0,τ)nP(0, \tau)^nP(0,τ)n. We show that P(0,τ)n>P(0,t)P(0, \tau)^n > P(0, t)P(0,τ)n>P(0,t) leading to the quantum Zeno effect in the position subspace when a parameter θ\thetaθ in the quantum coin operations and frequency of measurements is greater than the critical value, θ>θc\theta > \theta_{c}θ>θc​ and n>ncn>n_{c}n>nc​. This Zeno effect in the subspace preserves the dynamics in coin Hilbert space of the walk dynamics and has a potential to play a significant role in quantum tasks such as, preserving the quantum state of the particle at any particular position and to understand the Zeno dynamics in a multidimensional system which is highly transient in nature.
We investigate discrete-time quantum-walk evolution under the influence of periodic measurements in position subspace. The undisturbed survival probability of the particle at the position subspace P(0,t)P(0,t)P(0,t) is compared with the survival probability after frequent (nnn) measurements at interval $\ensuremath{\tau}=t/n$, $P(0,\ensuremath{\tau}){}^{n}$. We show that $P(0,\ensuremath{\tau}){}^{n}>P(0,t)$ leads to the quantum Zeno effect in position subspace when a parameter $\ensuremath{\theta}$ in the quantum coin operations and frequency of measurements is greater than the critical value, $\ensuremath{\theta}>{\ensuremath{\theta}}_{c}$ and n>ncn>{n}_{c}n>nc​. This Zeno effect in the subspace preserves the dynamics in coin Hilbert space of the walk dynamics and has the potential to play a significant role in quantum tasks such as preserving the quantum state of the particle at any particular position, and to understand the Zeno dynamics in a multidimensional system that is highly transient in nature.