We characterize four groups of Clifford circuits for Calderbank--Shor--Steane (CSS) codes that are relevant to fault-tolerant logical operations. First, we show that every code-preserving Clifford circuit is a product of Z-diagonal circuits, composed of S and CZ gates, and their X-basis analogues. Second, we define the two-fold transversal group, generated by depth-one two-local code-preserving circuits, and show that each of its elements can be expressed as a product of layers consisting of either Z-diagonal, X-diagonal, or CNOT gates. As a corollary, every transversal gate is a product of three transversal diagonal circuits; for connected non-self-dual codes, two such circuits suffice.
We further show that every code-preserving automorphism circuit, consisting of single-qubit Clifford gates and permutations, has a normal form comprising a Hadamard layer, a permutation, and two diagonal circuits. We also define a two-fold automorphism group, in which a depth-one two-local circuit may be code-preserving up to a permutation, and show that its logical image can be larger than that of the two-fold transversal group.
For 231 CSS codes, we provide explicit generators and determine the logical image of the two-fold transversal group. We tabulate 173 codes whose full logical Clifford group is generated by two-fold-transversal circuits, including codes of distances 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 10, 12, and 13, with respective best rates 2/5, 3/4, 34/77, 17/28, 14/25, 1/27, 3/56, and 1/33. We construct families of CSS codes from bipartite grids, cut-complements, and quadrics, and census the self-dual codes invariant under rank-3 permutation groups. Many of these codes realize the full logical Clifford group in this way.
Calderbank-Shor-Steane (CSS) codes, constructed from nested classical codes
C2⊆C1, are typically optimized for good code parameters. However, practical quantum computing equally demands fault-tolerant logical gates. In this work, we characterize nested pairs
(C1,C2) whose resulting CSS codes realize a target logical diagonal gate via transversal physical
Z-rotations. In doing so, we recover a result of Camps-Moreno et al. that CSS codes can realize only logical single-qubit
Z-rotations and multi-qubit controlled
Z-rotations via transversal physical
Z-rotations. Building on our characterization, we develop the ''appending construction'', that takes as input an
[[n′,k′]] CSS code
Q′ and a target logical
Z-rotation (single-qubit or multi-controlled)
UL, and extends
Q′ by systematically appending
n′′ physical qubits to obtain an
[[n,k]] CSS code
Q with
n=n′+n′′ and
k=k′. The target logical gate
UL is realized in
Q by applying a well-chosen physical transversal
Z-rotation to the
n′′ appended physical qubits. Moreover, any logical gate realized via transversal physical
Z-rotations in the input code
Q′ remains transversally realizable in the extended code
Q. The CSS code
Q may incur a loss in minimum distance, but the loss can be controlled through the parameter choices made in the construction. By repeatedly applying the appending construction, we can extend any CSS code
Q′ to obtain a CSS code
Q that supports fault-tolerant implementations of multiple desired logical
Z-rotations. The cost to be paid for this is the increased physical qubit overhead as the number of target logical gates grows. To illustrate our methodology, we construct CSS code families that transversally realize addressable logical single-qubit and multi-controlled
Z-rotations.
Storing quantum information in a quantum error correction code can protect it from errors, but the ability to transform the stored quantum information in a fault tolerant way is equally important. Logical Pauli group operators can be implemented on Calderbank-Shor-Steane (CSS) codes, a commonly-studied category of codes, by applying a series of physical Pauli X and Z gates. Logical operators of this form are fault-tolerant because each qubit is acted upon by at most one gate, limiting the spread of errors, and are referred to as transversal logical operators. Identifying transversal logical operators outside the Pauli group is less well understood. Pauli operators are the first level of the Clifford hierarchy which is deeply connected to fault-tolerance and universality. In this work, we study transversal logical operators composed of single- and multi-qubit diagonal Clifford hierarchy gates. We demonstrate algorithms for identifying all transversal diagonal logical operators on a CSS code that are more general or have lower computational complexity than previous methods. We also show a method for constructing CSS codes that have a desired diagonal logical Clifford hierarchy operator implemented using single qubit phase gates. Our methods rely on representing operators composed of diagonal Clifford hierarchy gates as diagonal XP operators and this technique may have broader applications.
Calderbank--Shor--Steane (CSS) codes support decoding and fault-tolerant logical operations through separate pure
X and pure
Z stabilizer checks. Generator choices and single-qubit Clifford transformations can obscure this structure. We give a deterministic polynomial-time algorithm that decides whether an arbitrary stabilizer code is locally Clifford-equivalent to a CSS code and constructs the required transformation and CSS checks whenever such a form exists. For
m possibly redundant generator rows on
n qubits, the algorithm uses
O(mn2+n4) binary field operations. We reduce the problem to affine linear systems by characterizing local projectors that preserve the span of the binary stabilizer labels. The conversion preserves code parameters and check sparsity for quantum low-density parity-check (qLDPC) codes. We demonstrate CSS recovery and decoder reuse and resolve previously open LC-to-CSS classification questions for published code constructions. For graph states, LC-to-CSS equivalence corresponds to the existence of a bipartite graph in the local-complementation orbit. We derive a necessary-and-sufficient adjacency-matrix criterion for this property and construct such a graph whenever one exists. Our algorithm makes CSS decoding and fault-tolerant constructions accessible throughout the local Clifford equivalence classes of CSS codes.
Abstract Storing quantum information in a quantum error correction code can protect it from errors, but the ability to transform the stored quantum information in a fault tolerant way is equally important. Logical Pauli group operators can be implemented on Calderbank-Shor-Steane (CSS) codes, a commonly-studied category of codes, by applying a series of physical Pauli X and Z gates. Logical operators of this form are fault-tolerant because each qubit is acted upon by at most one gate, limiting the spread of errors, and are referred to as transversal logical operators. Identifying transversal logical operators outside the Pauli group is less well understood. Pauli operators are the first level of the Clifford hierarchy which is deeply connected to fault-tolerance and universality. In this work, we study transversal logical operators composed of single- and multi-qubit diagonal Clifford hierarchy gates. We demonstrate algorithms for identifying all transversal diagonal logical operators on a CSS code that are more general or have lower computational complexity than previous methods. We also show a method for constructing CSS codes that have a desired diagonal logical Clifford hierarchy operator implemented using single qubit phase gates. Our methods rely on representing operators composed of diagonal Clifford hierarchy gates as diagonal XP operators and this technique may have broader applications.
Fault tolerant quantum computation is a critical step in the development of practical quantum computers. Unfortunately, not every quantum error correcting code can be used for fault tolerant computation. Rengaswamy et. al. define CSS-T codes, which are CSS codes that admit the transversal application of the T gate, which is a key step in achieving fault tolerant computation. They then present a family of quantum Reed-Muller fault tolerant codes. Their family of codes admits a transversal T gate, but the asymptotic rate of the family is zero. We build on their work by reframing their CSS-T conditions using the concept of self-orthogonality. Using this framework, we define an alternative family of quantum Reed-Muller fault tolerant codes. Like the quantum Reed-Muller family found by Rengaswamy et. al., our family admits a transversal T gate, but also has a nonvanishing asymptotic rate.\nWe prove three key results in our search for a Reed-Muller CSS-T family with a nonvanishing rate. First, we show an equivalence between a code containing a self-dual subcode and the dual of that code being self-orthogonal. This allows us to more easily determine if a pair of codes define a CSS-T code. Next, we show that if C1 and C2 are both Reed-Muller codes that form a CSS-T code, C1 must be self-orthogonal. This limits the rate of any family that is constructed solely from Reed-Muller codes. Lastly, we define a family of CSS-T codes by choosing C1 = RM(r, 2r + 1) and C2 = RM(0, 2r + 1) for some nonnegative integer r. We show that this family has an asymptotic rate of 1/2, and show that it is the only possible CSS-T family constructed only from Reed-Muller codes where C1 is self dual.