Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2601.08076

Comment on arXiv:2601.04248v1: Superposition of states in quantum theory (J.-M. Vigoureux)

Mikołaj Sienicki, Krzysztof Sienicki

Published Jan 12, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Vigoureux suggests replacing the usual linear superposition rule of quantum mechanics with a M"obius-type "composition law" $\oplus$, motivated by (i) bounded-domain composition laws in special relativity, (ii) familiar transfer-matrix formulas in multilayer optics, and (iii) an analogy with the inclusion-exclusion rule for classical probabilities. In this note we explain why the proposal does not work as a modification of quantum theory. For two components, the new rule differs from the ordinary sum only by an overall scalar factor, so after normalization it represents the same ray and cannot change any physical prediction. For three or more components, if one extends the two-term prescription in the natural recursive way, the result becomes bracket/order dependent and can even change the ray, so a "state" is no longer uniquely determined by a given preparation. We also clarify why the inclusion-exclusion argument and the optics analogy do not support a foundational change to Hilbert-space linearity.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2601.08076

Related papers

No extension of the Quantum Tensor Product admits a Superposition principle

Vincenzo Fiorentino, Kuntal Sengupta

Textbook quantum superposition refers to the feature that certain linear combinations of Hilbert space rays, each representing a valid quantum state, are themselves valid states. This notion is not operational, and it relies on the underlying Hilbert space formalism. Recent proposals for experimental tests of indefinite causal order, as well as tests probing the non-classicality of gravity, pivot on superposition, thereby calling for a theory-independent, operational formalisation of the concept. Here, we define superposition within the framework of Generalised Probabilistic Theories, based on observed statistics in prepare-and-measure experiments. Using this, we formulate three superposition principles to investigate which structural features of quantum theory carry over to other theories. We study conditions under which these principles carry over from subsystems to their compositions; to this end, we show that the quantum tensor product emerges as the largest composition rule for quantum systems respecting all three principles. Furthermore, we show how non-classical features such as entanglement and preparational uncertainty can be viewed as special forms of superposition.

quant-pharXiv:2608.17572•Aug 19, 2026•0 citations

Superposition of states in quantum theory

J. M. Vigoureux

The most general mathematical law for summing bounded quantities is not the arithmetic law, but a composition law of which the summation law for velocities in special relativity is only one particular example. We believe that this composition law, should also be used in quantum theory. We present it with a few examples, we discuss its physical meaning and we show how it can be useful in quantum theory. We show in particular that its use may open the way for a new interpretation of the use of probabilities in quantum theory.

arXiv:2601.04248•Jan 6, 2026•1 citation

✨ On the Significance and Implications of the Obidi Probability Law Derived from the Principles of the Theory of Entropicity (ToE)

John Onimisi Obidi

✨On the Significance and Implications of the Obidi Probability Law Derived from the Principles of the Theory of Entropicity (ToE) The Obidi probability law is a central result in John Onimisi Obidi's Theory of Entropicity (ToE), and it marks a radical departure from classical probability theory. In standard Kolmogorov or quantum mechanics, the rule that the sum of all probabilities equals one is taken as an axiom with no dynamical origin. In ToE, Obidi derives this rule from the geometry and dynamics of the universe's Hilbert space, elevating probability from an epistemic bookkeeping rule to an ontological conservation law. The Connection Between Usual Probability and the Obidi Probability Law The simplest and perhaps clearest way to express the relationship between the usual [traditional] probability law and Obidi's entropic probability law is this: usual probability tells you what you might see, while the Obidi probability tells you why you see what you see. Usual probability is a predictive rule; Obidi probability is a structural law. They share a mathematical surface, but they arise from entirely different conceptual foundations. Understanding this distinction is essential for appreciating the depth of the Obidi Probability Law and its implications for physics. Mathematically, the two frameworks look deceptively similar. Usual probability is built on the normalization condition ∑iPi=1, while the Obidi Probability Law expresses a unique conservation law through the relation Po(t)+Pe(t)=1. Both involve quantities between 0 and 1 that sum to unity. This superficial resemblance is precisely why the Obidi formulation feels familiar at first glance: it preserves the algebraic structure of probability. Yet the meaning of these quantities is entirely different. In usual probability, the numbers represent degrees of belief or frequencies of outcomes. In the Obidi probability, they represent the partitioning of physical reality between coherent and entropic sectors of the universe's informational geometry. Usual probability is fundamentally epistemic. It answers the question, "Given what I know, what outcome should I expect?" It depends on the observer's knowledge, uncertainty, and measurement context. It is a rule of inference, not a physical law. The Born Rule, Bayesian updating, and the Kolmogorov axioms all fall into this category: they describe how observers assign probabilities, not how the universe itself behaves. In this sense, usual probability is a tool for reasoning about outcomes, not a description of the underlying structure of reality. Obidi probability is ontological. It answers a different question entirely: "How is reality partitioned between coherence and entropy?" It is observer‑independent, conserved, and rooted in the entropic geometry of the universe. It does not describe ignorance or uncertainty; it describes the physical distribution of amplitude between the coherent sector Po and the entropic sector Pe. It is not optional, not interpretive, and not dependent on measurement. It is a law of nature, not a rule of reasoning. In this sense, Obidi probability is a structural invariant of the universe's informational architecture. The connection between the two emerges when the entropic sector becomes negligible. When Pe(t)≈0, the coherent sector satisfies Po(t)≈1, and the usual Born‑rule probability appears as the projection of the coherent sector onto the observer's measurement basis. In this limit, usual probability is recovered as a special case of the Obidi Probability Law. This relationship mirrors other major correspondences in physics: Newtonian mechanics as a limit of relativity, classical thermodynamics as a limit of statistical mechanics, and classical geometry as a limit of quantum geometry. In each case, the familiar theory is not wrong - it is simply the low‑entropy, low‑curvature, or low‑energy approximation of a deeper structure. Usual probability plays the same role relative to Obidi probability. Measurement provides the final bridge between the two frameworks. In standard quantum mechanics, measurement is modeled as a discontinuous collapse of the wavefunction, with probabilities jumping abruptly according to the Born Rule. In Obidi's Theory of Entropicity (ToE), measurement is reinterpreted as an irreversible flow of amplitude from the coherent sector Po into the entropic sector Pe. This entropic transfer supplies a physical mechanism for what usual probability merely describes. The Born Rule becomes the visible cast or projection of a deeper entropic process unfolding beneath the surface of quantum mechanics. In summary, usual probability is what the observer computes, while the Obidi probability is what the universe is doing underneath. How the Obidi Probability Law Is Formulated In the Theory of Entropicity (ToE), the total quantum state of the universe is written as: Ψ(t) = ψ_o(t) + ψ_e(t) where: ψ_o(t) = the component of the state in the observer (coherent) sector ψ_e(t) = the component of the state in the entropic (irreversible) sector ψ_o(t) is orthogonal to ψ_e(t) This orthogonality is written as: ψ_o ⟂ ψ_e The total state always has unit norm: ‖Ψ(t)‖² = 1 If you decompose a vector into orthogonal components: Ψ = A + B then automatically: ‖Ψ‖² = ‖A‖² + ‖B‖² This is not the Born rule. This is Pythagoras in Hilbert space. Here, we are not assuming probability. We are deriving a conservation identity. From this, the Obidi Probability Law follows immediately: P_o(t) + P_e(t) = 1 where: P_o(t) = ‖ψ_o(t)‖² P_e(t) = ‖ψ_e(t)‖² This means that: P_o(t) is the probability associated with the coherent observer sector P_e(t) is the probability associated with the entropic sector Their sum is always 1, because they partition the entire Hilbert space of reality This is the entropic probability conservation law in ToE. In other words: The Theory of Entropicity (ToE) begins by decomposing the universe's total Hilbert space into two orthogonal sectors: Hₒ - The Coherent Observer Sector This is where quantum amplitudes evolve unitarily. It contains all accessible information. It is the sector in which observers, measurements, and coherent quantum states live. 2. Hₒ - The Entropic Sector This is the domain into which amplitude flows irreversibly. It represents informationally inaccessible states. It is responsible for decoherence, irreversibility, and the arrow of time. The total state of the universe is written as: Ψ(t) = ψₒ(t) + ψₑ(t) with the orthogonality condition: ψₒ ⟂ ψₑ We then write the probabilities as: Pₒ(t) = |ψₒ(t)|² Pₑ(t) = |ψₑ(t)|² In the Theory of Entropicity (ToE), the above [Pₒ(t) = |ψₒ(t)|² and Pₑ(t) = |ψₑ(t)|²] is NOT the Born rule - it is a sector‑weight derived from Hilbert‑space geometry. With the norm conservation of the full state which demands that: |Ψ(t)|² = 1, this immediately yields the Obidi Probability Law: Pₒ(t) + Pₑ(t) = 1 This is the entropic probability conservation law in ToE. Explore: Entropic Field Significance of the Obidi Entropic Probability Law From axiom to conservation principle Unlike classical probability, which partitions events, the Obidi law partitions sectors of physical reality. The sum is not imposed but follows from the Hilbert‑space structure and the combined unitary–entropic evolution . Ontological status of probability Probability becomes a structural invariant of the universe's geometry and dynamics, not just a measure of ignorance. This reframes probability as a fundamental physical law rather than a statistical convention. Mechanism for irreversibility and decoherence The entropic operator transfers amplitude from the observer sector to the entropic sector, generating irreversibility, decoherence, and the arrow of time while keeping total probability constant. Unified explanation of physical phenomena In ToE, this law underpins explanations of wavefunction collapse, classical irreversibility, and even the black hole information paradox: measurement outcomes correspond to irreversible amplitude transfer into the entropic sector. Conceptual shift in physics By embedding probability conservation in the geometry of reality rather than in human observation, the Obidi law challenges the Copenhagen interpretation and suggests a deeper, sector‑based ontology of quantum processes. In short: The Obidi probability law is significant because it redefines probability as a derived, conserved quantity rooted in the universe's Hilbert‑space structure, linking quantum coherence, entropy, and the arrow of time in a single, unified framework. The Obidi Probability Law is precisely a theory of the visible and invisible sectors of reality. This is one of its deepest conceptual achievements, and it's why it feels so different from anything in standard physics. In the following sections, we lay it out clearly and technically for the reader, so as not to lose sight of the elegance of the idea. The Obidi Probability Law teaches us about the visible and invisible sectors of reality The Obidi Probability Law divides the universe into two complementary informational sectors: the coherent sector Po - the visible, reversible, interference‑preserving part of reality the entropic sector Pe - the invisible, irreversible, information‑absorbing part of reality And the law states: Po(t)+Pe(t)=1 This is not a bookkeeping identity. It is a conservation law describing how reality is partitioned between what can be observed and what cannot [what we can reasonably access and what we cannot; and this has nothing to do with the limits of our laboratory or experimental apparatus or devices, but the inherent constraints of nature itself, independent of how accurate or efficient our tools are]. 1. The "visible sector": the coherent part of reality The coherent sector Po corresponds to: superposition interference unitary evolution reversible dynamics the part of the wavefunction that can produce observable outcomes This is the sector that standard quantum mechanics foc

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Superposition of states and the structure of quantum logics

Platon C. Deliyannis

A derivation of the classical Hilbert space model of quantum theory is given (including superselection rules) based (i) on various axioms on the behavior of events and (ii) an explicit formula for the superposition of two pure states in terms of transition probabilities.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Feb 1, 1976•7 citations

Local Uniqueness of the Born Rule on Categories with Complex-Weighted Morphisms

Tayfun Ustun

I prove a local uniqueness theorem for the Born rule in the setting of quiver-generated categories equipped with complex morphism weights and path-amplitude probability functionals. Given (i) non-negativity, (ii) invariance of bounded total degree, (iii) global U(1) invariance, (iv) classical-limit additivity over mutually exclusive paths, and (v) normalization, I show that the probability assignment P: C -> R>=0 is uniquely determined to be P(z) = |z|^2. The notion of mutually exclusive paths is given a precise categorical formulation as the absence of a shared factorization through any common morphism. I relate the result to reconstructions of quantum probability due to Gleason, Hardy, Chiribella-D'Ariano-Perinotti, and several further, more recent reconstructions, and identify the extension to global coherence under morphism composition as an open problem connected to synthetic probability theory in Markov categories. The Born rule emerges as the unique locally consistent probability law on complex amplitudes, fixed by phase invariance and classical-limit behavior together with polynomiality and normalization, independent of any Hilbert-space framework.

quant-pharXiv:2608.05197•Aug 5, 2026•0 citations

Postulates for General Quantum Mechanics

Irving E. Segal

We present in this paper a set of postulates for a physical system and deduce from these the main general features of the quantum theory of stationary states. Our theory is strictly operational in the sense that only the observables of the physical system are involved in the postulates. The collection of all bounded self-adj oint operators on a Hilbert space, which has previously been used as a mathematical model for the observables in quantum mechanics, satisfy the postulates, as do a variety of considerably more general mathematical structures. We show that for any two observables there exists a pure state of the system (this term being defined essentially as done by von Neumann and Weyl) in which they have different (expectation) values. Each observable has a spectral resolution, and a state of the system induces, in a natural way, a probability distribution on the range of spectral values of each observable. A number of observables are simultaneously observable if and only if they commute (although the product of two observables is not defined in general, a reasonable notion of commutativity can be introduced). Inasmuch as Hilbert space plays no role in our theory, our proofs are necessarily of a different character from the proofs of these results for the case of the system of all bounded selfadjoint operators. Actually, Hilbert space appears to be somewhat inadequate as a state space even for the latter system, in that there exist pure states of the system which cannot be represented in the usual way by rays of the Hilbert space. The postulates are partly algebraic and partly metric. The algebraic postulates require essentially that an observable can be multiplied by real numbers and raised to integral powers, and that any two observables can be added. It is assumed that the usual algebraic laws are satisfied so that (1) the observables can be treated like the elements of a linear space, and (2) the usual rules for dealing with polynomials in one variable with real coefficients remain valid when the variable is replaced by an observable. It is not assumed that two observables have a product. The metric postulates require that for each observable there be defined a kind of maximum numerical value, which plays the part of a norm, and has various properties in accord with its physical significance. While this norm is quite essential to the development of the theory, an interesting consequence of the theory is that the norm can be (uniquely) defined in a purely algebraic fashion. This shows that the objective features of a physical system,-the spectral values and probability distributions of the observables, and the pure states,-are completely determined by the algebra of observables, i.e., by the rules for addition, scalar multiplication, and powers, of observables.

Annals of Mathematics•Oct 1, 1947•418 citations
Vigoureux suggests replacing the usual linear superposition rule of quantum mechanics with a M"obius-type "composition law" ⊕\oplus⊕, motivated by (i) bounded-domain composition laws in special relativity, (ii) familiar transfer-matrix formulas in multilayer optics, and (iii) an analogy with the inclusion-exclusion rule for classical probabilities. In this note we explain why the proposal does not work as a modification of quantum theory. For two components, the new rule differs from the ordinary sum only by an overall scalar factor, so after normalization it represents the same ray and cannot change any physical prediction. For three or more components, if one extends the two-term prescription in the natural recursive way, the result becomes bracket/order dependent and can even change the ray, so a "state" is no longer uniquely determined by a given preparation. We also clarify why the inclusion-exclusion argument and the optics analogy do not support a foundational change to Hilbert-space linearity.
Textbook quantum superposition refers to the feature that certain linear combinations of Hilbert space rays, each representing a valid quantum state, are themselves valid states. This notion is not operational, and it relies on the underlying Hilbert space formalism. Recent proposals for experimental tests of indefinite causal order, as well as tests probing the non-classicality of gravity, pivot on superposition, thereby calling for a theory-independent, operational formalisation of the concept. Here, we define superposition within the framework of Generalised Probabilistic Theories, based on observed statistics in prepare-and-measure experiments. Using this, we formulate three superposition principles to investigate which structural features of quantum theory carry over to other theories. We study conditions under which these principles carry over from subsystems to their compositions; to this end, we show that the quantum tensor product emerges as the largest composition rule for quantum systems respecting all three principles. Furthermore, we show how non-classical features such as entanglement and preparational uncertainty can be viewed as special forms of superposition.
The most general mathematical law for summing bounded quantities is not the arithmetic law, but a composition law of which the summation law for velocities in special relativity is only one particular example. We believe that this composition law, should also be used in quantum theory. We present it with a few examples, we discuss its physical meaning and we show how it can be useful in quantum theory. We show in particular that its use may open the way for a new interpretation of the use of probabilities in quantum theory.
✨On the Significance and Implications of the Obidi Probability Law Derived from the Principles of the Theory of Entropicity (ToE) The Obidi probability law is a central result in John Onimisi Obidi's Theory of Entropicity (ToE), and it marks a radical departure from classical probability theory. In standard Kolmogorov or quantum mechanics, the rule that the sum of all probabilities equals one is taken as an axiom with no dynamical origin. In ToE, Obidi derives this rule from the geometry and dynamics of the universe's Hilbert space, elevating probability from an epistemic bookkeeping rule to an ontological conservation law. The Connection Between Usual Probability and the Obidi Probability Law The simplest and perhaps clearest way to express the relationship between the usual [traditional] probability law and Obidi's entropic probability law is this: usual probability tells you what you might see, while the Obidi probability tells you why you see what you see. Usual probability is a predictive rule; Obidi probability is a structural law. They share a mathematical surface, but they arise from entirely different conceptual foundations. Understanding this distinction is essential for appreciating the depth of the Obidi Probability Law and its implications for physics. Mathematically, the two frameworks look deceptively similar. Usual probability is built on the normalization condition ∑iPi=1, while the Obidi Probability Law expresses a unique conservation law through the relation Po(t)+Pe(t)=1. Both involve quantities between 0 and 1 that sum to unity. This superficial resemblance is precisely why the Obidi formulation feels familiar at first glance: it preserves the algebraic structure of probability. Yet the meaning of these quantities is entirely different. In usual probability, the numbers represent degrees of belief or frequencies of outcomes. In the Obidi probability, they represent the partitioning of physical reality between coherent and entropic sectors of the universe's informational geometry. Usual probability is fundamentally epistemic. It answers the question, "Given what I know, what outcome should I expect?" It depends on the observer's knowledge, uncertainty, and measurement context. It is a rule of inference, not a physical law. The Born Rule, Bayesian updating, and the Kolmogorov axioms all fall into this category: they describe how observers assign probabilities, not how the universe itself behaves. In this sense, usual probability is a tool for reasoning about outcomes, not a description of the underlying structure of reality. Obidi probability is ontological. It answers a different question entirely: "How is reality partitioned between coherence and entropy?" It is observer‑independent, conserved, and rooted in the entropic geometry of the universe. It does not describe ignorance or uncertainty; it describes the physical distribution of amplitude between the coherent sector Po and the entropic sector Pe. It is not optional, not interpretive, and not dependent on measurement. It is a law of nature, not a rule of reasoning. In this sense, Obidi probability is a structural invariant of the universe's informational architecture. The connection between the two emerges when the entropic sector becomes negligible. When Pe(t)≈0, the coherent sector satisfies Po(t)≈1, and the usual Born‑rule probability appears as the projection of the coherent sector onto the observer's measurement basis. In this limit, usual probability is recovered as a special case of the Obidi Probability Law. This relationship mirrors other major correspondences in physics: Newtonian mechanics as a limit of relativity, classical thermodynamics as a limit of statistical mechanics, and classical geometry as a limit of quantum geometry. In each case, the familiar theory is not wrong - it is simply the low‑entropy, low‑curvature, or low‑energy approximation of a deeper structure. Usual probability plays the same role relative to Obidi probability. Measurement provides the final bridge between the two frameworks. In standard quantum mechanics, measurement is modeled as a discontinuous collapse of the wavefunction, with probabilities jumping abruptly according to the Born Rule. In Obidi's Theory of Entropicity (ToE), measurement is reinterpreted as an irreversible flow of amplitude from the coherent sector Po into the entropic sector Pe. This entropic transfer supplies a physical mechanism for what usual probability merely describes. The Born Rule becomes the visible cast or projection of a deeper entropic process unfolding beneath the surface of quantum mechanics. In summary, usual probability is what the observer computes, while the Obidi probability is what the universe is doing underneath. How the Obidi Probability Law Is Formulated In the Theory of Entropicity (ToE), the total quantum state of the universe is written as: Ψ(t) = ψ_o(t) + ψ_e(t) where: ψ_o(t) = the component of the state in the observer (coherent) sector ψ_e(t) = the component of the state in the entropic (irreversible) sector ψ_o(t) is orthogonal to ψ_e(t) This orthogonality is written as: ψ_o ⟂ ψ_e The total state always has unit norm: ‖Ψ(t)‖² = 1 If you decompose a vector into orthogonal components: Ψ = A + B then automatically: ‖Ψ‖² = ‖A‖² + ‖B‖² This is not the Born rule. This is Pythagoras in Hilbert space. Here, we are not assuming probability. We are deriving a conservation identity. From this, the Obidi Probability Law follows immediately: P_o(t) + P_e(t) = 1 where: P_o(t) = ‖ψ_o(t)‖² P_e(t) = ‖ψ_e(t)‖² This means that: P_o(t) is the probability associated with the coherent observer sector P_e(t) is the probability associated with the entropic sector Their sum is always 1, because they partition the entire Hilbert space of reality This is the entropic probability conservation law in ToE. In other words: The Theory of Entropicity (ToE) begins by decomposing the universe's total Hilbert space into two orthogonal sectors: Hₒ - The Coherent Observer Sector This is where quantum amplitudes evolve unitarily. It contains all accessible information. It is the sector in which observers, measurements, and coherent quantum states live. 2. Hₒ - The Entropic Sector This is the domain into which amplitude flows irreversibly. It represents informationally inaccessible states. It is responsible for decoherence, irreversibility, and the arrow of time. The total state of the universe is written as: Ψ(t) = ψₒ(t) + ψₑ(t) with the orthogonality condition: ψₒ ⟂ ψₑ We then write the probabilities as: Pₒ(t) = |ψₒ(t)|² Pₑ(t) = |ψₑ(t)|² In the Theory of Entropicity (ToE), the above [Pₒ(t) = |ψₒ(t)|² and Pₑ(t) = |ψₑ(t)|²] is NOT the Born rule - it is a sector‑weight derived from Hilbert‑space geometry. With the norm conservation of the full state which demands that: |Ψ(t)|² = 1, this immediately yields the Obidi Probability Law: Pₒ(t) + Pₑ(t) = 1 This is the entropic probability conservation law in ToE. Explore: Entropic Field Significance of the Obidi Entropic Probability Law From axiom to conservation principle Unlike classical probability, which partitions events, the Obidi law partitions sectors of physical reality. The sum is not imposed but follows from the Hilbert‑space structure and the combined unitary–entropic evolution . Ontological status of probability Probability becomes a structural invariant of the universe's geometry and dynamics, not just a measure of ignorance. This reframes probability as a fundamental physical law rather than a statistical convention. Mechanism for irreversibility and decoherence The entropic operator transfers amplitude from the observer sector to the entropic sector, generating irreversibility, decoherence, and the arrow of time while keeping total probability constant. Unified explanation of physical phenomena In ToE, this law underpins explanations of wavefunction collapse, classical irreversibility, and even the black hole information paradox: measurement outcomes correspond to irreversible amplitude transfer into the entropic sector. Conceptual shift in physics By embedding probability conservation in the geometry of reality rather than in human observation, the Obidi law challenges the Copenhagen interpretation and suggests a deeper, sector‑based ontology of quantum processes. In short: The Obidi probability law is significant because it redefines probability as a derived, conserved quantity rooted in the universe's Hilbert‑space structure, linking quantum coherence, entropy, and the arrow of time in a single, unified framework. The Obidi Probability Law is precisely a theory of the visible and invisible sectors of reality. This is one of its deepest conceptual achievements, and it's why it feels so different from anything in standard physics. In the following sections, we lay it out clearly and technically for the reader, so as not to lose sight of the elegance of the idea. The Obidi Probability Law teaches us about the visible and invisible sectors of reality The Obidi Probability Law divides the universe into two complementary informational sectors: the coherent sector Po - the visible, reversible, interference‑preserving part of reality the entropic sector Pe - the invisible, irreversible, information‑absorbing part of reality And the law states: Po(t)+Pe(t)=1 This is not a bookkeeping identity. It is a conservation law describing how reality is partitioned between what can be observed and what cannot [what we can reasonably access and what we cannot; and this has nothing to do with the limits of our laboratory or experimental apparatus or devices, but the inherent constraints of nature itself, independent of how accurate or efficient our tools are]. 1. The "visible sector": the coherent part of reality The coherent sector Po corresponds to: superposition interference unitary evolution reversible dynamics the part of the wavefunction that can produce observable outcomes This is the sector that standard quantum mechanics foc
I prove a local uniqueness theorem for the Born rule in the setting of quiver-generated categories equipped with complex morphism weights and path-amplitude probability functionals. Given (i) non-negativity, (ii) invariance of bounded total degree, (iii) global U(1) invariance, (iv) classical-limit additivity over mutually exclusive paths, and (v) normalization, I show that the probability assignment P: C -> R>=0 is uniquely determined to be P(z) = |z|^2. The notion of mutually exclusive paths is given a precise categorical formulation as the absence of a shared factorization through any common morphism. I relate the result to reconstructions of quantum probability due to Gleason, Hardy, Chiribella-D'Ariano-Perinotti, and several further, more recent reconstructions, and identify the extension to global coherence under morphism composition as an open problem connected to synthetic probability theory in Markov categories. The Born rule emerges as the unique locally consistent probability law on complex amplitudes, fixed by phase invariance and classical-limit behavior together with polynomiality and normalization, independent of any Hilbert-space framework.
We present in this paper a set of postulates for a physical system and deduce from these the main general features of the quantum theory of stationary states. Our theory is strictly operational in the sense that only the observables of the physical system are involved in the postulates. The collection of all bounded self-adj oint operators on a Hilbert space, which has previously been used as a mathematical model for the observables in quantum mechanics, satisfy the postulates, as do a variety of considerably more general mathematical structures. We show that for any two observables there exists a pure state of the system (this term being defined essentially as done by von Neumann and Weyl) in which they have different (expectation) values. Each observable has a spectral resolution, and a state of the system induces, in a natural way, a probability distribution on the range of spectral values of each observable. A number of observables are simultaneously observable if and only if they commute (although the product of two observables is not defined in general, a reasonable notion of commutativity can be introduced). Inasmuch as Hilbert space plays no role in our theory, our proofs are necessarily of a different character from the proofs of these results for the case of the system of all bounded selfadjoint operators. Actually, Hilbert space appears to be somewhat inadequate as a state space even for the latter system, in that there exist pure states of the system which cannot be represented in the usual way by rays of the Hilbert space. The postulates are partly algebraic and partly metric. The algebraic postulates require essentially that an observable can be multiplied by real numbers and raised to integral powers, and that any two observables can be added. It is assumed that the usual algebraic laws are satisfied so that (1) the observables can be treated like the elements of a linear space, and (2) the usual rules for dealing with polynomials in one variable with real coefficients remain valid when the variable is replaced by an observable. It is not assumed that two observables have a product. The metric postulates require that for each observable there be defined a kind of maximum numerical value, which plays the part of a norm, and has various properties in accord with its physical significance. While this norm is quite essential to the development of the theory, an interesting consequence of the theory is that the norm can be (uniquely) defined in a purely algebraic fashion. This shows that the objective features of a physical system,-the spectral values and probability distributions of the observables, and the pure states,-are completely determined by the algebra of observables, i.e., by the rules for addition, scalar multiplication, and powers, of observables.