Symmetry-breaking order at low temperatures is often accompanied by slow relaxation dynamics, due to diverging free-energy barriers arising from interfaces between different ordered states. Here, we extend this correspondence to classical topological order, where the ordered states are locally indistinguishable, so there is no notion of interfaces between them. We study the relaxation dynamics of the three-dimensional (3D) classical $\mathbb{Z}_2$ lattice gauge theory (LGT) as a canonical example. We prove a lower bound on the mixing time in the deconfined phase, $t_{\text{mix}} = \exp [Ω(L)]$, where L is the linear system size. This bound applies even in the presence of perturbations that explicitly break the one-form symmetry between different long-lived states. This perturbation destroys the energy barriers between ordered states, but we show that entropic effects nevertheless lead to diverging free-energy barriers at nonzero temperature. Our proof establishes the LGT as a robust finite-temperature classical memory. We further prove that entropic effects lead to an emergent one-form symmetry, via a notion that we make precise. We argue that the exponential mixing time follows from universal properties of the deconfined phase, and numerically corroborate this expectation by exploring mixing time scales at the Higgs and confinement transitions out of the deconfined phase. These transitions are found to exhibit markedly different dynamic scaling, even though both have the static critical exponents of the 3D Ising model. We expect this novel entropic mechanism for memory and emergent symmetry to also bring insight into self-correcting quantum memories.
Slow mixing and emergent one-form symmetries in three-dimensional Z2 gauge theory
Symmetry-breaking order at low temperatures is often accompanied by slow relaxation dynamics, due to diverging free-energy barriers arising from interfaces between different ordered states. Here, we extend this correspondence to classical topological order, where the ordered states are locally indistinguishable, so there is no notion of interfaces between them. We study the relaxation dynamics of the three-dimensional (3D) classical Z2 lattice gauge theory (LGT) as a canonical example. We prove a lower bound on the mixing time in the deconfined phase, tmix=exp[Ω(L)], where L is the linear system size. This bound applies even in the presence of perturbations that explicitly break the one-form symmetry between different long-lived states. This perturbation destroys the energy barriers between ordered states, but we show that entropic effects nevertheless lead to diverging free-energy barriers at nonzero temperature. Our proof establishes the LGT as a robust finite-temperature classical memory. We further prove that entropic effects lead to an emergent one-form symmetry, via a notion that we make precise. We argue that the exponential mixing time follows from universal properties of the deconfined phase, and numerically corroborate this expectation by exploring mixing time scales at the Higgs and confinement transitions out of the deconfined phase. These transitions are found to exhibit markedly different dynamic scaling, even though both have the static critical exponents of the 3D Ising model. We expect this novel entropic mechanism for memory and emergent symmetry to also bring insight into self-correcting quantum memories.
Self-dual criticality in three-dimensional Z2 gauge theory with matter
The simplest topologically ordered phase in 2+1D is the deconfined phase of Z2 gauge theory, realized for example in the toric code. This phase permits a duality that exchanges electric and magnetic excitations (``e'' and ``m'' particles). Condensing either particle while the other remains gapped yields a phase transition with 3D Ising exponents. More mysterious, however, is the transition out of the deconfined phase when self-duality symmetry is preserved. If this transition is continuous, which has so far been unclear, then it may be the simplest critical point for which we still lack any useful continuum Lagrangian description. This transition also has a soft matter interpretation, as a multicritical point for classical membranes in 3D. We study the self-dual transition with Monte Carlo simulations of the Z2 gauge-Higgs model on cubic lattices of linear size L≤96. Our results indicate a continuous transition: for example, cumulants show a striking parameter-free scaling collapse. We estimate scaling dimensions by using duality symmetry to distinguish the leading duality-odd/duality-even scaling operators A and S. All local operators have large scaling dimensions, making standard techniques for locating the critical point ineffective. We develop an alternative using ``renormalization group trajectories'' of cumulants. We check that two- and three-point functions, and temporal correlators in the Monte-Carlo dynamics, are scale-invariant, with scaling dimensions xA and xS and dynamical exponent z. We also give a picture for emergence of 1-form symmetries, in some parts of the phase diagram, in terms of ``patching'' of membranes/worldsurfaces. We relate this to the percolation of anyon worldlines in spacetime. Analyzing percolation yields a fourth exponent for the self-dual transition. We propose variations of the model for further investigation.
We characterize the dynamic universality classes of a relaxational dynamics under equilibrium conditions at the continuous transitions of three-dimensional (3D) spin systems with Z2 gauge symmetry. In particular, we consider the pure lattice Z2 gauge model and the lattice Z2 gauge XY model, which present various types of transitions: topological transitions without a local order parameter and transitions characterized by both gauge-invariant and non-gauge-invariant XY order parameters. We consider a standard relaxational (locally reversible) Metropolis dynamics and determine the dynamic critical exponent z that characterizes the critical slowing down of the dynamics as the continuous transition is approached. At the topological Z2 gauge transitions we find z=2.55(6). Therefore, the dynamics is significantly slower than in Ising systems---$z\ensuremath{\approx}2.02$ for the 3D Ising universality class---although 3D Z2 gauge systems and Ising systems have the same static critical behavior because of duality. As for the nontopological transitions in the 3D Z2 gauge XY model, we find that their critical dynamics belong to the same dynamic universality class as the relaxational dynamics in ungauged XY systems independently of the gauge-invariant or non-gauge-invariant nature of the order parameter at the transition.
Although condensed matter systems usually do not have higher-form symmetries, we show that, unlike 0-form symmetry, higher-form symmetries can emerge as exact symmetries at low energies and long distances. In particular, emergent higher-form symmetries at zero temperature are robust to arbitrary local UV perturbations in the thermodynamic limit. This result is true for both invertible and noninvertible higher-form symmetries. Therefore emergent higher-form symmetries are exact emergent symmetries: they are not UV symmetries but constrain low-energy dynamics as if they were. Since phases of matter are defined in the thermodynamic limit, this implies that a UV theory without higher-form symmetries can have phases characterized by exact emergent higher-form symmetries. We demonstrate this in three lattice models, the quantum clock model and emergent ZN and U(1)p-gauge theory, finding regions of parameter space with exact emergent (anomalous) higher-form symmetries. Furthermore, we perform a generalized Landau analysis of a 2+1D lattice model that gives rise to Z2 gauge theory. Using exact emergent 1-form symmetries accompanied by their own energy/length scales, we show that the transition between the deconfined and Higgs/confined phases is continuous and equivalent to the spontaneous symmetry-breaking transition of a Z2 symmetry, even though the lattice model has no symmetry. Also, we show that this transition line must always contain two parts separated by multi-critical points or other phase transitions. We discuss the physical consequences of exact emergent higher-form symmetries and contrast them to emergent 0-form symmetries. Lastly, we show that emergent 1-form symmetries are no longer exact at finite temperatures, but emergent p-form symmetries with $p\ensuremath{\ge}2$ are.
Motivated by the growing interest in self-correcting quantum memories, we study the feasibility of self-correction in classical lattice systems composed of bounded degrees of freedom with local interactions. We argue that self-correction, including a requirement of stability against external perturbation, cannot be realized in system with broken global symmetries such as the two-dimensional Ising model, but that systems with local, i.e., gauge symmetries, have the required properties. Previous work identified a three-dimensional (3D) quantum system which realizes a self-correcting classical memory [E. Dennis et al., J. Math. Phys. 43, 4452 (2002)]. Here, we show that a purely classical 3D system, Wegner's Ising lattice gauge model [F. J. Wegner, J. Math. Phys. 12, 2259 (1971)], can also realize this self-correction despite having an extensive ground-state degeneracy. We give a detailed numerical study to support the existence of a self-correcting phase in this system, even when the gauge symmetry is explicitly broken. More generally, our results obtained by studying the memory lifetime of the system are in quantitative agreement with the phase diagram obtained from conventional analysis of the system's specific heat [I. S. Tupitsyn et al., Phys. Rev. B 82, 085114 (2010)], except that self-correction extends beyond the topological phase, past the lower critical temperature.
After fifty years of lattice gauge theories (LGTs), the nature of the transition between their topological phases (confinement or deconfinement) remains challenging due to the absence of a local order parameter. In this work, we conduct a percolation analysis of Wegner's three-dimensional Z_{2} lattice gauge model using intensive Monte Carlo simulations and finite-size scaling, offering fresh insights into the topological phase transitions of gauge-invariant systems. We demonstrate that, regardless of the connection rules, geometrical loops, constructed by piercing excited plaquettes percolate precisely at the thermal critical point T_{c}, with critical exponents coinciding with those of the loop representation of the dual 3D Ising model. Further, we construct Fortuin-Kasteleyn (FK) clusters in a random-cluster representation, showing that they also percolate at T_{c}, enabling access to all thermal critical exponents. Strikingly, the Binder cumulants of the percolation order parameters for both loops and FK clusters reveal a pseudo-first-order transition. This work sheds new light on the critical behavior of pure LGTs, with potential implications for condensed matter systems and quantum error correction.
Higher-form symmetries act on subdimensional spatial manifolds of a quantum system. They can emerge as an exact symmetry at low energies even when they are explicitly broken at the microscopic level, making them difficult to characterize. In this work, we propose that the emergence of 1-form symmetries is information-theoretic in nature, characterized by the preservation of information about a specific bare (microscopic) 1-form symmetry. As a consequence, the loss of the emergent 1-form symmetry is an information-theoretic transition which we argue to be revealed from the long-range entanglement in the ensemble of post-measurement states. We analytically determine the regimes in which a 1-form symmetry emerges in product states on one- and two-dimensional lattices. In analytically intractable regimes, we demonstrate how to efficiently detect 1-form symmetries with a global quantum error correction (QEC) decoder and numerically examine the information-theoretic transition of the 1-form symmetry, including systems with Z 2 topological order. As a practical application of our framework, we show that once the 1-form symmetry is detected to exist, a topological quantum phase transition characterized by the spontaneous breaking of the 1-form symmetry can be accurately determined by a disorder parameter. We further argue that our proposed theory for emergent 1-form symmetries offers new perspectives on particle condensation and suggests sharp information-theoretic phase boundaries between Higgs and confining regimes in the Z 2 lattice gauge theory.