Analogue gravity explores how collective excitations in condensed matter systems can reproduce the behavior of fields in curved spacetimes. An important example is the acoustic black holes that can occur for sound in a moving fluid. In these lecture notes, we focus on atomic Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs), quantum fluids that provide an interesting platform for analogue gravity studies thanks to their accurate theoretical description, remarkable experimental control, and ultralow temperatures that allow the quantum nature of sound to emerge. We give a pedagogical introduction to analogue black holes and the theoretical description of BECs and their elementary excitations, which behave as quantum fields in curved spacetimes. We then apply these tools to survey the current understanding of black-hole superradiance and analogue Hawking radiation, including explicit examples and numerical methods.
Comments
Lecture notes based on the course given by Luca Giacomelli at "Analogue Gravity 2023, Benasque". 71 pages, 13 figures
Analogue gravity explores how collective excitations in condensed matter systems can reproduce the behavior of fields in curved spacetimes. An important example is the acoustic black holes that can occur for sound in a moving fluid. In these lecture notes, we focus on atomic Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs), quantum fluids that provide an interesting platform for analogue gravity studies thanks to their accurate theoretical description, remarkable experimental control, and ultralow temperatures that allow the quantum nature of sound to emerge. We give a pedagogical introduction to analogue black holes and the theoretical description of BECs and their elementary excitations, which behave as quantum fields in curved spacetimes. We then apply these tools to survey the current understanding of black-hole superradiance and analogue Hawking radiation, including explicit examples and numerical methods.
The propagation of fluctuations in the velocity potential of an inviscid, irrotational fluid is governed by a wave equation very similar to that governing the propagation of massless scalar fields in curved spacetime. This similarity allows certain fluid systems to be used as experimentally realisable models for objects that cannot be studied under controlled conditions, such as black holes and ultrarelativitsic rotating stars. The analogy applies only to the propagation of fields in a fixed background, not to the behaviour of the background itself. However, even this limited similarity has excited a great deal of interest from researchers, since it suggests that phenomena such as superradiance and Hawking radiation may have analogues in superfluids. In recent years, experimental advances in the creation and manipulation of Bose-Einstein condensates have provided researchers with very low temperature systems possessing a uniquely simple microscopic theory. Furthermore, under certain long-length-scale approximations, Bose-Einstein condensates can be described as classical irrotational inviscid fluids, and therefore can be treated as analogues of appropriate gravitational systems. We present a comprehensive and detailed critical review of the mean-field theory of Bose-Einstein condensates, the conditions under which Bose-Einstein condensates can be treated as an analogue gravity system, the construction of analogue black holes, and several derivations of Hawking radiation and analogue Hawking radiation. The interdisciplinary nature of analogue gravity means that the relevant results are widely scattered in the literature, and we consider this critical review and discussion of the relevant literature to be a central and noteworthy element of the project. We then analyse in detail a recent derivation of analogue Hawking radiation in Bose-Einstein condensates as a consequence of quantum depletion. We elucidate the methodology and the physical meaning of the results by comparison with the derivations of Hawking radiation considered previously, and discuss possible extensions and improvements. We also present an original investigation of analogue superradiance in simple vortices, with the vortex density profile chosen to mimic a realistic vortex in a Bose-Einstein condensate. We find that superradiant amplification occurs and is likely to be significant, but our long-length-scale approximation is of dubious validity near the scattering point.
This Thesis develops in the field of analogue gravity, a branch of physics which relies on a specific correspondence that exists between fluid dynamics and curved spacetimes; thanks to that, effects which are hard to study in the gravitational context are investigated in the realm of hydrodynamics with the hope that the consequent results could be transferred back to the cosmological domain and give us better insights in the gravitational context. In this Thesis, I try to introduce the reader to the realm of analogue gravity and to the concepts of Bose-Einstein condensation, Hawking radiation and its analogue counterpart (Chapter 1 and 2); then in Chapter 3 and 4 I describe the details of our work. In the past years, we have developed two directions of research, both aimed at the characterization of the analogue Hawking radiation in Bose-Einstein condensates. One side of our work had the purpose of investigating the results obtained in recent experiments apt to the detection of the analogue Hawking radiation in a quantum gas. Our results are very important in the description of the phenomena and give insights on how to develop future experiments (Chapter 3). The other side of our work aimed at the characterization of this effect from a theoretical point of view by means of an innovative approach, which allows for a much deeper and more detailed description of the radiation and helps shine new light on this effect (Chapter 4). In Chapter 5 we briefly discuss the possible developments of our studying, highlighting the missing pieces of this field and suggesting possible ways to approach the existing problems.
These notes are adapted from six lectures that I delivered at Analogue Gravity in Benasque 2023. They present the unified Gaussian (phase-space) framework to describe linear bosonic quantum systems, the standard tool in quantum optics and continuous-variable quantum information, emphasizing its simplicity and platform independence, with applications to semi-classical black holes and analogue gravity. Parts (I-III) develop the formalism: from harmonic dynamics and Gaussian transformations to state characterization via moments, Wigner functions, and entanglement measures. Part (IV) applies these tools to semi-classical black holes, discussing Hawking radiation and quantum superradiance in rotating black holes, and laboratory analogues in light-matter systems via toy models.
There are a number of interesting phenomena that are predicted to be a result of the behaviour of general relativity close to a black hole. The most well known of these is Hawking radiation. Although well established, the theory of Hawking radiation is unsupported by experiment, since black holes cannot be investigated in the lab. However, there is a strong similarity between the equations governing the behaviour of a sound wave in inviscid irrotational fluid systems and a massless scalar field in a gravitational system. This similarity provides hope that effects like Hawking radiation can be investigated in analogous fluid systems. The requirement that potential fluid analogues be barotropic, inviscid and irrotational indicates that superfluids would be the logical object of experiments designed to analyse such systems. The most easily controlled superfluid to which experimentalists have access is a Bose Einstein Condensate in an appropriately designed trap, and there is interest in designing an experiment to look for Hawking radiation in a BEC. A BEC is also ideal for that purpose because of the extremely low temperatures at which the condensation occurs, given the very low temperature of Hawking radiation. However, Hawking radiation itself is a very subtle effect, and it would be very hard to detect. This means that a related but more conspicuous effect is interesting as a stepping stone to a test for the more well known Hawking radiation. This related effect is Superradiance, a result of the reflection of an incoming scalar field with appropriate angular characteristics from the ergoregion of a massive rotating body such as a black hole. An ergoregion is a region around a rotating black hole or supermassive rotating star within which it is impossible to remain stationary with respect to an observer at infinity without exceeding the speed of light. Before an experiment can be designed to test for superradiance in a BEC it is necessary to establish whether the theory describing Bose-Einstein Condensates predicts that it will actually occur. Work on this problem thus far has either failed to consider whether the effect occurs, and instead focused on the consequences it would have, or has involved approximations that are not strictly valid. Here therefore, after an overview of both the analogy between fluid and gravitational systems and the specific theory related to Bose Einstein Condensates is an analysis using the full quantum theory of BECs. The initial consideration is analytic in character, but the equations do not allow for an exact solution within the approximations attempted that predict superradiance, so a change is made to a numerical simulation using the XMDS numerical simulation package. Unfortunately, this attempt also fails, since ongoing problems encountered in running the simulation consumed all the time available. A discussion of these problems is included.
The analogy between the propagation of a massless scalar field in curved spacetime and the propagation of sound waves in a Bose-Einstein Condensate (BEC) gives rise to the possibility of observing the analogues of black hole radiance effects, such as Hawking Radiation and superradiance, in the laboratory. In order to provide a solid foundation for realising such analogue gravity models in an experimental setting, we have conducted a numerical investigation of phonon scattering from a BEC vortex by solving the time-dependent Gross-Pitaevskii (GP) equation, describing the dynamics of dilute gas BECs. The consideration of phonon superradiance in BECs in advance of Hawking Radiation is motivated by the fact superradiance may be easier to detect. ¶ We first present the results of one-dimensional simulations of sound waves propagating in a BEC and reflecting from a vortex-like density profile. Using these results as a guide, two-dimensional simulations of sound propagation in a BEC, and reflection from a BEC vortex, are performed. The technique of propagating the wavefunction in imaginary time was employed to find the vortex ground state. The accuracy of the simulations and the convergence of the solution to the vortex ground state was verified using a range of numerical diagnostics. Finally, preliminary simulations were performed within the superradiant frequency regime for the purposes of determining whether the amplification of incoming waves occurs given an appropriate choice of parameters. Overall, the two-dimensional modelling of reflection of cylindrical waves from a BEC vortex provides a basis for a systematic study of phonon superradiance in BECs.
Analogue physics became very popular in recent decades. It allows simulating inaccessible physical phenomena, such as black holes, in the laboratory. The first success of analogue physics is in fact much older being due to Maxwell, who derived his equations for the electromagnetic field by analogy with fluid dynamics in presence of vortices. Here we propose to use vortices for analogue gravity. We implement an acoustic Kerr black hole with quantized angular momentum in a Bose-Einstein condensate. We show that the condensate's metric is equivalent to the Kerr's one, exhibiting a horizon and an ergosphere. We confirm that this metric is obeyed not only by weak density waves, but also by quantum vortices which behave as massive test particles. We use these topological defects to demonstrate a quantum Penrose effect, extracting the rotation energy of the black hole by quanta of angular momentum. The particle trajectories are well described by the timelike geodesics of the Kerr metric, confirming the potential of analogue quantum gravity.