Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2512.10703 · PRX Quantum

Sub-Bath Cooling in Bosonic Systems: Gaussian Constraints and Non-Gaussian Enhancements

Wen-Han Png, Xueyuan Hu, Valerio Scarani

quant-phSubmitted Dec 11, 2025• Announced Dec 12, 2025• 0 citations
v1 · Dec 11, 2025v2 · May 4, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Cooling quantum systems with finite resources is a central task in quantum technologies and has been extensively explored in discrete-variable settings. As continuous-variable (CV) platforms play an increasingly important role in quantum information processing, it becomes crucial to understand the fundamental limitations of cooling bosonic systems. In this work, we develop a general framework for cooling CV systems, identifying both the constraints imposed by Gaussianity and the advantages enabled by non-Gaussian interactions. We derive a reachable bound on the cooling performance of Gaussian operations that applies to arbitrary cooling architectures. By optimizing over all protocols saturating this bound, we further identify the most efficient scheme, which minimizes dissipated energy for a given number of ancilla modes. Beyond Gaussian operations, we show that $p$-excitation exchange exploits non-Gaussian resources to achieve a $p$-fold enhancement of the cooling limit. Our results establish the fundamental limits of CV heat-bath algorithmic cooling and reveal the crucial role of non-Gaussianity in surpassing Gaussian cooling barriers.

Journal reference
PRX Quantum, 7(2), 020316 (2026)
DOI
10.1103/3qnz-6bcz
Comments
18 pages, 6 figures

Related papers

Gaussian Thermal Operations and The Limits of Algorithmic Cooling

Alessio Serafini, Matteo Lostaglio, S Longden +3 more

The study of thermal operations allows one to investigate the ultimate possibilities of quantum states and of nanoscale thermal machines. Whilst fairly general, these results typically do not apply to continuous variable systems and do not take into account that, in many practically relevant settings, system-environment interactions are effectively bilinear. Here we tackle these issues by focusing on Gaussian quantum states and channels. We provide a complete characterization of the most general Gaussian thermal operation acting on an arbitrary number of bosonic modes, which turn out to be all embeddable in a Markovian dynamics, and derive necessary and sufficient conditions for state transformations under such operations in the single-mode case, encompassing states with nonzero coherence in the energy eigenbasis (i.e., squeezed states). Our analysis leads to a no-go result for the technologically relevant task of algorithmic cooling: We show that it is impossible to reduce the entropy of a system coupled to a Gaussian environment below its own or the environmental temperature, by means of a sequence of Gaussian thermal operations interspersed by arbitrary (even non-Gaussian) unitaries. These findings establish fundamental constraints on the usefulness of Gaussian resources for quantum thermodynamic processes.

arXiv:1909.06123•Physical Review Letters•Jan 2, 2020•32 citations

Heating-cooling asymmetry in quantum systems

Camila Raupp da Luz

Understanding how quantum systems equilibrate is a fundamental question with implications for quantum technologies, such as state preparation for quantum computing. However, linear response theory fails to explain the thermal relaxation of far-from-equilibrium classical and quantum systems. In this context, recent studies have reported a relaxation asymmetry, where heating is faster than cooling for initial states that are thermodynamically equidistant from equilibrium, but understanding how quantum resources affect this asymmetry is still an open question. In this work, we investigate the heating and cooling asymmetry in discrete and continuous-variable quantum systems. For the discrete case, we study two interacting qubits coupled to a global bosonic bath, focusing on the effects of initial coherences, steady state correlations generated by the dynamics and local non-Markovianity. For the continuous case, we consider Gaussian states and compare the thermal relaxation asymmetry of displaced and squeezed states. Our results for the discrete case indicate that non-Markovianity may accelerate thermal relaxation, while the initial coherences do not change the equilibration time. In Gaussian systems, applying the displacement operator in the initial states does not affect the asymmetry, but applying the squeezing operator reduces the asymmetry. Additionally, we show an invertion of the asymmetry, making cooling faster than heating, by squeezing the hotter state and displacing the cooler state.

•Aug 26, 2026•0 citations

Unified framework for bosonic quantum information encoding, resources, and universality from superselection rules

Éloi Descamps, Astghik Saharyan, Adrien Chivet +2 more

Since the early days of quantum information science, diverse strategies have been proposed to encode qubits and implement quantum gates across various physical platforms. Modes and bosonic states offer a flexible framework for quantum information processing, from single-photon optics to superconducting circuits, combining massless and massive particles. Universal gate sets have been established for specific encodings—such as those based on Fock states or the field’s quadratures. However, a general framework clarifying how different bosonic resources—such as mode structure, particle-number statistics, Gaussian and non-Gaussian states and operations—combine to enable universality and potential quantum advantage irrespectively of the encoding remains lacking. A main difficulty lies in the coexistence of distinct paradigms that appear to combine loosely in bosonic quantum information: discrete-variable schemes—where information is encoded in qubits or effective finite-dimensional systems—and continuous-variable schemes—which rely on infinite-dimensional Hilbert spaces associated with the field’s quadratures. Despite the success of each approach, they remain seemingly incompatible in many aspects—in particular in terms of physical resource analysis for universality—due to their underlying mathematical differences. In this work, we apply a superselection-rule-compliant framework for bosonic quantum information that unifies these paradigms. This representation explicitly incorporates the phase reference and enforces total particle number conservation, allowing for a consistent treatment of bosonic quantum information protocols and resources across both discrete and continuous regimes. We derive necessary and sufficient conditions expressed in terms of Gaussian and non-Gaussian resources for universality that apply to any encoding, without resorting to specific mappings. Our results show that continuous variable encodings are not fundamentally distinct from discrete ones, but rather emerge as subspaces within a general bosonic structure. Importantly, in such a widely studied framework, non-Gaussian properties of bosonic states and operations can be washed out, providing evidence that the continuous variables regime is not the most suitable to fully assess the quantum properties of bosons.

arXiv:2501.03943•Optica Quantum•Feb 6, 2026•2 citations

Advances in quantum learning theory with bosonic systems

Francesco Anna Mele

This paper reviews recent advances in quantum learning theory for continuous-variable (CV) systems. Quantum learning theory investigates how to extract classical information from quantum systems as efficiently as possible. CV systems are ubiquitous in nature and in quantum technologies, as they describe bosonic and quantum-optical systems. While quantum learning theory for finite-dimensional systems has been extensively studied, the corresponding theory for CV systems has only recently begun to develop; here we provide a concise review. We focus on the following questions: what is the minimum number of copies (the sample complexity) required to learn a non-Gaussian state, possibly under energy constraints? What is the sample complexity for learning Gaussian states? How does the performance of CV state learning depend on non-Gaussianity? How can one test whether a state is Gaussian or far from the set of Gaussian states? And how can Gaussian processes be learned efficiently? Central to these topics, we also review several bounds on the trace distance between CV states in terms of their covariance matrices, which may be of independent interest. Overall, this work summarises selected developments in tomography of CV systems and highlights a selection of open problems.

quant-pharXiv:2605.08082•May 11, 2026•0 citations

Thermodynamic approach to quantum cooling limit of continuous Gaussian feedback

Kousuke Kumasaki, Toshihiro Yada, Ken Funo +1 more

Feedback cooling plays a critical role in stabilizing quantum systems and achieving low temperatures, where a key question is to determine the fundamental thermodynamic limits on cooling performance. We establish a fundamental bound on quantum feedback cooling in Gaussian systems, by deriving a generalized second law of thermodynamics involving the kinetic temperatures of the system and a measure of quantum information flow obtained by continuous measurement. In contrast to previously known bounds, the obtained bound can be saturated by experimentally feasible situations using the quantum Kalman filter with a large feedback gain, where the cooling efficiency approaches its maximum. Our theoretical result is numerically demonstrated using parameters from an experiment of levitated nanoparticles. Our theory provides a general framework for understanding the thermodynamic constraints on quantum feedback cooling.

arXiv:2503.04270•Physical Review Research•Nov 10, 2025•4 citations

Heat-Bath Algorithmic Cooling with optimal thermalization strategies

Alvaro Martin Alhambra, Matteo Lostaglio, Christopher Perry

Heat-Bath Algorithmic Cooling is a set of techniques for producing highly pure quantum systems by utilizing a surrounding heat-bath and unitary interactions. These techniques originally used the thermal environment only to fully thermalize ancillas at the environment temperature. Here we extend HBAC protocols by optimizing over the thermalization strategy. We find, for any d -dimensional system in an arbitrary initial state, provably optimal cooling protocols with surprisingly simple structure and exponential convergence to the ground state. Compared to the standard ones, these schemes can use fewer or no ancillas and exploit memory effects to enhance cooling. We verify that the optimal protocols are robusts to various deviations from the ideal scenario. For a single target qubit, the optimal protocol can be well approximated with a Jaynes-Cummings interaction between the system and a single thermal bosonic mode for a wide range of environmental temperatures. This admits an experimental implementation close to the setup of a micromaser, with a performance competitive with leading proposals in the literature. The proposed protocol provides an experimental setup that illustrates how non-Markovianity can be harnessed to improve cooling. On the technical side we 1. introduce a new class of states called maximally active states and discuss their thermodynamic significance in terms of optimal unitary control, 2. introduce a new set of thermodynamic processes, called β-permutations , whose access is sufficient to simulate a generic thermalization process, 3. show how to use abstract toolbox developed within the resource theory approach to thermodynamics to perform challenging optimizations, while combining it with open quantum system dynamics tools to approximate optimal solutions within physically realistic setups.

arXiv:1807.07974•Quantum•Sep 23, 2019•59 citations
Cooling quantum systems with finite resources is a central task in quantum technologies and has been extensively explored in discrete-variable settings. As continuous-variable (CV) platforms play an increasingly important role in quantum information processing, it becomes crucial to understand the fundamental limitations of cooling bosonic systems. In this work, we develop a general framework for cooling CV systems, identifying both the constraints imposed by Gaussianity and the advantages enabled by non-Gaussian interactions. We derive a reachable bound on the cooling performance of Gaussian operations that applies to arbitrary cooling architectures. By optimizing over all protocols saturating this bound, we further identify the most efficient scheme, which minimizes dissipated energy for a given number of ancilla modes. Beyond Gaussian operations, we show that ppp-excitation exchange exploits non-Gaussian resources to achieve a ppp-fold enhancement of the cooling limit. Our results establish the fundamental limits of CV heat-bath algorithmic cooling and reveal the crucial role of non-Gaussianity in surpassing Gaussian cooling barriers.
The study of thermal operations allows one to investigate the ultimate possibilities of quantum states and of nanoscale thermal machines. Whilst fairly general, these results typically do not apply to continuous variable systems and do not take into account that, in many practically relevant settings, system-environment interactions are effectively bilinear. Here we tackle these issues by focusing on Gaussian quantum states and channels. We provide a complete characterization of the most general Gaussian thermal operation acting on an arbitrary number of bosonic modes, which turn out to be all embeddable in a Markovian dynamics, and derive necessary and sufficient conditions for state transformations under such operations in the single-mode case, encompassing states with nonzero coherence in the energy eigenbasis (i.e., squeezed states). Our analysis leads to a no-go result for the technologically relevant task of algorithmic cooling: We show that it is impossible to reduce the entropy of a system coupled to a Gaussian environment below its own or the environmental temperature, by means of a sequence of Gaussian thermal operations interspersed by arbitrary (even non-Gaussian) unitaries. These findings establish fundamental constraints on the usefulness of Gaussian resources for quantum thermodynamic processes.
Understanding how quantum systems equilibrate is a fundamental question with implications for quantum technologies, such as state preparation for quantum computing. However, linear response theory fails to explain the thermal relaxation of far-from-equilibrium classical and quantum systems. In this context, recent studies have reported a relaxation asymmetry, where heating is faster than cooling for initial states that are thermodynamically equidistant from equilibrium, but understanding how quantum resources affect this asymmetry is still an open question. In this work, we investigate the heating and cooling asymmetry in discrete and continuous-variable quantum systems. For the discrete case, we study two interacting qubits coupled to a global bosonic bath, focusing on the effects of initial coherences, steady state correlations generated by the dynamics and local non-Markovianity. For the continuous case, we consider Gaussian states and compare the thermal relaxation asymmetry of displaced and squeezed states. Our results for the discrete case indicate that non-Markovianity may accelerate thermal relaxation, while the initial coherences do not change the equilibration time. In Gaussian systems, applying the displacement operator in the initial states does not affect the asymmetry, but applying the squeezing operator reduces the asymmetry. Additionally, we show an invertion of the asymmetry, making cooling faster than heating, by squeezing the hotter state and displacing the cooler state.
Since the early days of quantum information science, diverse strategies have been proposed to encode qubits and implement quantum gates across various physical platforms. Modes and bosonic states offer a flexible framework for quantum information processing, from single-photon optics to superconducting circuits, combining massless and massive particles. Universal gate sets have been established for specific encodings—such as those based on Fock states or the field’s quadratures. However, a general framework clarifying how different bosonic resources—such as mode structure, particle-number statistics, Gaussian and non-Gaussian states and operations—combine to enable universality and potential quantum advantage irrespectively of the encoding remains lacking. A main difficulty lies in the coexistence of distinct paradigms that appear to combine loosely in bosonic quantum information: discrete-variable schemes—where information is encoded in qubits or effective finite-dimensional systems—and continuous-variable schemes—which rely on infinite-dimensional Hilbert spaces associated with the field’s quadratures. Despite the success of each approach, they remain seemingly incompatible in many aspects—in particular in terms of physical resource analysis for universality—due to their underlying mathematical differences. In this work, we apply a superselection-rule-compliant framework for bosonic quantum information that unifies these paradigms. This representation explicitly incorporates the phase reference and enforces total particle number conservation, allowing for a consistent treatment of bosonic quantum information protocols and resources across both discrete and continuous regimes. We derive necessary and sufficient conditions expressed in terms of Gaussian and non-Gaussian resources for universality that apply to any encoding, without resorting to specific mappings. Our results show that continuous variable encodings are not fundamentally distinct from discrete ones, but rather emerge as subspaces within a general bosonic structure. Importantly, in such a widely studied framework, non-Gaussian properties of bosonic states and operations can be washed out, providing evidence that the continuous variables regime is not the most suitable to fully assess the quantum properties of bosons.
This paper reviews recent advances in quantum learning theory for continuous-variable (CV) systems. Quantum learning theory investigates how to extract classical information from quantum systems as efficiently as possible. CV systems are ubiquitous in nature and in quantum technologies, as they describe bosonic and quantum-optical systems. While quantum learning theory for finite-dimensional systems has been extensively studied, the corresponding theory for CV systems has only recently begun to develop; here we provide a concise review. We focus on the following questions: what is the minimum number of copies (the sample complexity) required to learn a non-Gaussian state, possibly under energy constraints? What is the sample complexity for learning Gaussian states? How does the performance of CV state learning depend on non-Gaussianity? How can one test whether a state is Gaussian or far from the set of Gaussian states? And how can Gaussian processes be learned efficiently? Central to these topics, we also review several bounds on the trace distance between CV states in terms of their covariance matrices, which may be of independent interest. Overall, this work summarises selected developments in tomography of CV systems and highlights a selection of open problems.
Feedback cooling plays a critical role in stabilizing quantum systems and achieving low temperatures, where a key question is to determine the fundamental thermodynamic limits on cooling performance. We establish a fundamental bound on quantum feedback cooling in Gaussian systems, by deriving a generalized second law of thermodynamics involving the kinetic temperatures of the system and a measure of quantum information flow obtained by continuous measurement. In contrast to previously known bounds, the obtained bound can be saturated by experimentally feasible situations using the quantum Kalman filter with a large feedback gain, where the cooling efficiency approaches its maximum. Our theoretical result is numerically demonstrated using parameters from an experiment of levitated nanoparticles. Our theory provides a general framework for understanding the thermodynamic constraints on quantum feedback cooling.
Heat-Bath Algorithmic Cooling is a set of techniques for producing highly pure quantum systems by utilizing a surrounding heat-bath and unitary interactions. These techniques originally used the thermal environment only to fully thermalize ancillas at the environment temperature. Here we extend HBAC protocols by optimizing over the thermalization strategy. We find, for any d -dimensional system in an arbitrary initial state, provably optimal cooling protocols with surprisingly simple structure and exponential convergence to the ground state. Compared to the standard ones, these schemes can use fewer or no ancillas and exploit memory effects to enhance cooling. We verify that the optimal protocols are robusts to various deviations from the ideal scenario. For a single target qubit, the optimal protocol can be well approximated with a Jaynes-Cummings interaction between the system and a single thermal bosonic mode for a wide range of environmental temperatures. This admits an experimental implementation close to the setup of a micromaser, with a performance competitive with leading proposals in the literature. The proposed protocol provides an experimental setup that illustrates how non-Markovianity can be harnessed to improve cooling. On the technical side we 1. introduce a new class of states called maximally active states and discuss their thermodynamic significance in terms of optimal unitary control, 2. introduce a new set of thermodynamic processes, called β-permutations , whose access is sufficient to simulate a generic thermalization process, 3. show how to use abstract toolbox developed within the resource theory approach to thermodynamics to perform challenging optimizations, while combining it with open quantum system dynamics tools to approximate optimal solutions within physically realistic setups.