Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2512.02838

Experimental Blueprint for Distinguishing Decoherence from Objective Collapse

Ridha Horchani

quant-phSubmitted Dec 2, 2025• Announced Dec 3, 2025• 0 citations
v1 · Dec 2, 2025v2 · Jan 6, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The transition from the quantum to the classical realm remains one of the most profound open questions in physics. While quantum theory predicts the existence of macroscopic superpositions, their apparent absence in the everyday world is attributed either to environmental decoherence or to an intrinsic mechanism for wave-function collapse. This work presents a quantitative and experimentally grounded framework for distinguishing these possibilities. We propose a levitated optomechanical platform capable of generating controllable Schrodinger-cat states in the center of mass motion of a dielectric nanosphere. A comprehensive master equation incorporates gas collisions, black-body radiation, and photon-recoil noise, establishing a calibrated environmental baseline. The Continuous Spontaneous Localization (CSL) model is embedded within the same framework, predicting a characteristic saturation of the decoherence rate with superposition size and a quadratic scaling with mass. A Bayesian inference protocol is outlined to discriminate collapse induced excess decoherence from environmental noise. Together these elements provide a concrete experimental blueprint for a decisive test of quantum linearity, either revealing new physics beyond standard quantum mechanics or setting the most stringent bounds to date on objective-collapse parameters.

Comments
9 pages, 9 figures

Related papers

Proposing new experiments to test the quantum-to-classical transition

M Bahrami, Angelo Bassi

An open problem in modern physics is why microscopic quantum objects can be at two places at once (i.e. a superposed quantum state) while macroscpoic classical object never show such a behaviour. Collapse models provides a quantitative answer for this problem and explain how macroscopic classical world emerges out of microscopic quantum world. A universal noise field is postulated in collapse models, inducing appropriate Brownian- motion corrections to standard quantum dynamics. The strength of collapse-driven Brownian fluctuations depend on: (i) the parameters characterizing the system (e.g., mass, size, density), and (ii) two phenomenological parameters defining the statistical properties of the collapse noise. The collapse-driven Brownian motion works such that microscopic systems behave quantum mechanically, while macroscopic objects are classical. At the intermediate mesocopic scale, collapse models predict deviations from standard quantum predictions. This issue has been subject of experimental tests. All experiments to date have been at the scales where collapse effects are negligible for all practical purposes. However, recent experimental progress in revealing quantum features of larger objects, increases the hope for testing at unprecedented scales where collapse models can be falsified. Current experiments are mainly focused on the preparation of macroscopic systems in a spatial quantum superposition state. The collapse effects would then manifest as loss of visibility in the observed inference pattern. However, one needs a quantum interference with single particles of mass ∼ 10 10 amu for a decisive test of collapse models. Creating such massive superpositionsis quite challenging, and beyond currectstate-of-the-art. Quite recently, an alternative approach has been proposed where the collapse manifests in the fluctuating properties of light interacting with the quantum system. The great advantage of this new approach is that here there is no need for the preparation of a quantum superposed state. It has been discussed that promising results can be revealed in the spectrum of light interacting with a radiation pressure-driven mechanical oscillator in a cavity optomechanics setting. Here, we review the theoretical modelling of the above optomechenical proposal. We discuss how collapse-driven Brownian motion modifies the spectrum. We quantify the collapse effect and explain how it depends on the parameters of the mechanical oscillator (e.g., mass, density, geometry).

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jul 3, 2015•2 citations

Probing spontaneous wave-function collapse with entangled levitating nanospheres

Jing Zhang, Tiancai Zhang, Jie Li

Wave-function collapse models are considered to be the modified theories of standard quantum mechanics at the macroscopic level. By introducing nonlinear stochastic terms in the Schr\"odinger equation, these models (different from standard quantum mechanics) predict that it is fundamentally impossible to prepare macroscopic systems in macroscopic superpositions. The validity of these models can only be examined by experiments, and hence efficient protocols for these kinds of experiments are greatly needed. Here we provide a protocol that is able to probe the postulated collapse effect by means of the entanglement of the center-of-mass motion of two nanospheres optically trapped in a Fabry-P\'erot cavity. We show that the collapse noise results in a large reduction of the steady-state entanglement, and the entanglement, with and without the collapse effect, shows distinguishable scalings with certain system parameters, which can be used to determine unambiguously the effect of these models.

arXiv:1611.09989•Physical Review A•Jan 30, 2017•22 citations

Experimental Signature of Gravitational Decoherence from a Minimal Semiclassical Extension A 1 Hz Target for Levitated Optomechanics

Yi Ning Chen

Laboratory-based experimental tests remain a central challenge in the study of the quantum-gravity interface. We present a quantitative, experimentally testable prediction for gravitationally induced quantum decoherence of spatial superpositions in levitated optomechanical systems. Starting from two independently well-tested physical elements—the quantum nature of material energy-momentum fluctuations (established in particle physics) and the linear response kernel of classical geometry (derived from the weak-field limit of general relativity and verified by gravitational-wave observations)—and supplementing them with a minimal extension postulate for superposition states, we obtain a rigid scaling law for the gravitational decoherence rate: \Gamma \sim G M^2 d^2 / (\hbar L^3) \cdot \Phi(l_*/L), where M is the mass of the object, d the spatial separation of the superposition branches, L the characteristic linear dimension, and \Phi a dimensionless function encoding the unknown ultraviolet cutoff scale l_* of the effective geometric noise. The structural form \Gamma \propto M^2 d^2 / L^3 contains no free adjustable parameters; the overall amplitude is set by the choice of l_*. Identifying l_* with the Planck length \ell_P = \sqrt{\hbar G / c^3}—the only known scale bridging quantum theory and gravity—yields \Phi \sim \mathcal{O}(1) and a specific numerical target. For current levitated nanoparticle experiments (M \sim 10^{-14}\,\text{kg}, d \sim 10^{-7}\,\text{m}, L \sim 10^{-6}\,\text{m}), this Planck-scale hypothesis predicts a decoherence rate of order 1\,\text{Hz}, placing it within the foreseeable sensitivity window of next-generation optomechanical setups. We discuss the exclusive physical signatures distinguishing this mechanism from environmental decoherence channels and outline explicit falsification conditions, providing experimental groups with a concrete target to probe the quantum-gravity interface in the laboratory.

•May 20, 2026•0 citations

Distinguishing a Two-Step Quantum–Classical Threshold from Collapse Models

Raghu Kulkarni

A model of the vacuum as a face-centered-cubic lattice predicts a two-step quantum–classical threshold, at 13.1 and 22.6 µg, from the hypothesis that a center-of-mass excitation stays coherent only while its reduced Compton wavelength is resolvable by the lattice. Collapse models also limit macroscopic coherence, so the two must be told apart by more than a scale. We derive three discriminators from the model's postulates and compute the counterpart in Diósi–Penrose collapse and in continuous spontaneous localization (CSL). The thresholds depend on total mass alone, while both collapse models depend on density. Below 13.1 µg the model predicts no intrinsic decoherence, where collapse takes 1 s for Diósi–Penrose and about a microsecond for CSL at its experimental bound, for 10⁻¹⁵ kg over 1 µm. The model predicts no measurable heating; read as position localization, its own rate scale would exceed the LISA Pathfinder bound by 66 orders of magnitude, so coherence loss above the threshold must be dephasing in the energy basis. If its effective mode mass is the relevant mass, a 16.2 µg mechanical cat state then bounds the irreversible coupling at 38 orders below its natural scale. A worked levitated-particle example and a public script complete the analysis.

•Oct 1, 2026•0 citations

Testing wave-function-collapse models using parametric heating of a trapped nanosphere

Daniel Goldwater, Mauro Paternostro, P. F. Barker

We propose a mechanism for testing the theory of collapse models such as continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) by examining the parametric heating rate of a trapped nanosphere. The random localizations of the center of mass for a given particle predicted by the CSL model can be understood as a stochastic force embodying a source of heating for the nanosphere. We show that by utilizing a Paul trap to levitate the particle and optical cooling, it is possible to reduce environmental decoherence to such a level that CSL dominates the dynamics and contributes the main source of heating. We show that this approach allows measurements to be made on the time scale of seconds and that the free parameter ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\mathrm{csl}}$ which characterizes the model ought to be testable to values as low as ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}12}$ Hz.

arXiv:1506.08782•Physical Review A•Jul 14, 2016•96 citations

Optomechanical Sensing of Spontaneous Wave-Function Collapse

Stefan Nimmrichter, Klaus Hornberger, Klemens Hammerer

Quantum experiments with nanomechanical oscillators are regarded as a test bed for hypothetical modifications of the Schrödinger equation, which predict a breakdown of the superposition principle and induce classical behavior at the macroscale. It is generally believed that the sensitivity to these unconventional effects grows with the mass of the mechanical quantum system. Here we show that the opposite is the case for optomechanical systems in the presence of generic noise sources, such as thermal and measurement noise. We determine conditions for distinguishing these decoherence processes from possible collapse-induced decoherence in continuous optomechanical force measurements.

arXiv:1405.2868•Physical Review Letters•Jul 10, 2014•131 citations
The transition from the quantum to the classical realm remains one of the most profound open questions in physics. While quantum theory predicts the existence of macroscopic superpositions, their apparent absence in the everyday world is attributed either to environmental decoherence or to an intrinsic mechanism for wave-function collapse. This work presents a quantitative and experimentally grounded framework for distinguishing these possibilities. We propose a levitated optomechanical platform capable of generating controllable Schrodinger-cat states in the center of mass motion of a dielectric nanosphere. A comprehensive master equation incorporates gas collisions, black-body radiation, and photon-recoil noise, establishing a calibrated environmental baseline. The Continuous Spontaneous Localization (CSL) model is embedded within the same framework, predicting a characteristic saturation of the decoherence rate with superposition size and a quadratic scaling with mass. A Bayesian inference protocol is outlined to discriminate collapse induced excess decoherence from environmental noise. Together these elements provide a concrete experimental blueprint for a decisive test of quantum linearity, either revealing new physics beyond standard quantum mechanics or setting the most stringent bounds to date on objective-collapse parameters.
An open problem in modern physics is why microscopic quantum objects can be at two places at once (i.e. a superposed quantum state) while macroscpoic classical object never show such a behaviour. Collapse models provides a quantitative answer for this problem and explain how macroscopic classical world emerges out of microscopic quantum world. A universal noise field is postulated in collapse models, inducing appropriate Brownian- motion corrections to standard quantum dynamics. The strength of collapse-driven Brownian fluctuations depend on: (i) the parameters characterizing the system (e.g., mass, size, density), and (ii) two phenomenological parameters defining the statistical properties of the collapse noise. The collapse-driven Brownian motion works such that microscopic systems behave quantum mechanically, while macroscopic objects are classical. At the intermediate mesocopic scale, collapse models predict deviations from standard quantum predictions. This issue has been subject of experimental tests. All experiments to date have been at the scales where collapse effects are negligible for all practical purposes. However, recent experimental progress in revealing quantum features of larger objects, increases the hope for testing at unprecedented scales where collapse models can be falsified. Current experiments are mainly focused on the preparation of macroscopic systems in a spatial quantum superposition state. The collapse effects would then manifest as loss of visibility in the observed inference pattern. However, one needs a quantum interference with single particles of mass ∼ 10 10 amu for a decisive test of collapse models. Creating such massive superpositionsis quite challenging, and beyond currectstate-of-the-art. Quite recently, an alternative approach has been proposed where the collapse manifests in the fluctuating properties of light interacting with the quantum system. The great advantage of this new approach is that here there is no need for the preparation of a quantum superposed state. It has been discussed that promising results can be revealed in the spectrum of light interacting with a radiation pressure-driven mechanical oscillator in a cavity optomechanics setting. Here, we review the theoretical modelling of the above optomechenical proposal. We discuss how collapse-driven Brownian motion modifies the spectrum. We quantify the collapse effect and explain how it depends on the parameters of the mechanical oscillator (e.g., mass, density, geometry).
Wave-function collapse models are considered to be the modified theories of standard quantum mechanics at the macroscopic level. By introducing nonlinear stochastic terms in the Schr\"odinger equation, these models (different from standard quantum mechanics) predict that it is fundamentally impossible to prepare macroscopic systems in macroscopic superpositions. The validity of these models can only be examined by experiments, and hence efficient protocols for these kinds of experiments are greatly needed. Here we provide a protocol that is able to probe the postulated collapse effect by means of the entanglement of the center-of-mass motion of two nanospheres optically trapped in a Fabry-P\'erot cavity. We show that the collapse noise results in a large reduction of the steady-state entanglement, and the entanglement, with and without the collapse effect, shows distinguishable scalings with certain system parameters, which can be used to determine unambiguously the effect of these models.
Laboratory-based experimental tests remain a central challenge in the study of the quantum-gravity interface. We present a quantitative, experimentally testable prediction for gravitationally induced quantum decoherence of spatial superpositions in levitated optomechanical systems. Starting from two independently well-tested physical elements—the quantum nature of material energy-momentum fluctuations (established in particle physics) and the linear response kernel of classical geometry (derived from the weak-field limit of general relativity and verified by gravitational-wave observations)—and supplementing them with a minimal extension postulate for superposition states, we obtain a rigid scaling law for the gravitational decoherence rate: \Gamma \sim G M^2 d^2 / (\hbar L^3) \cdot \Phi(l_*/L), where M is the mass of the object, d the spatial separation of the superposition branches, L the characteristic linear dimension, and \Phi a dimensionless function encoding the unknown ultraviolet cutoff scale l_* of the effective geometric noise. The structural form \Gamma \propto M^2 d^2 / L^3 contains no free adjustable parameters; the overall amplitude is set by the choice of l_*. Identifying l_* with the Planck length \ell_P = \sqrt{\hbar G / c^3}—the only known scale bridging quantum theory and gravity—yields \Phi \sim \mathcal{O}(1) and a specific numerical target. For current levitated nanoparticle experiments (M \sim 10^{-14}\,\text{kg}, d \sim 10^{-7}\,\text{m}, L \sim 10^{-6}\,\text{m}), this Planck-scale hypothesis predicts a decoherence rate of order 1\,\text{Hz}, placing it within the foreseeable sensitivity window of next-generation optomechanical setups. We discuss the exclusive physical signatures distinguishing this mechanism from environmental decoherence channels and outline explicit falsification conditions, providing experimental groups with a concrete target to probe the quantum-gravity interface in the laboratory.
A model of the vacuum as a face-centered-cubic lattice predicts a two-step quantum–classical threshold, at 13.1 and 22.6 µg, from the hypothesis that a center-of-mass excitation stays coherent only while its reduced Compton wavelength is resolvable by the lattice. Collapse models also limit macroscopic coherence, so the two must be told apart by more than a scale. We derive three discriminators from the model's postulates and compute the counterpart in Diósi–Penrose collapse and in continuous spontaneous localization (CSL). The thresholds depend on total mass alone, while both collapse models depend on density. Below 13.1 µg the model predicts no intrinsic decoherence, where collapse takes 1 s for Diósi–Penrose and about a microsecond for CSL at its experimental bound, for 10⁻¹⁵ kg over 1 µm. The model predicts no measurable heating; read as position localization, its own rate scale would exceed the LISA Pathfinder bound by 66 orders of magnitude, so coherence loss above the threshold must be dephasing in the energy basis. If its effective mode mass is the relevant mass, a 16.2 µg mechanical cat state then bounds the irreversible coupling at 38 orders below its natural scale. A worked levitated-particle example and a public script complete the analysis.
We propose a mechanism for testing the theory of collapse models such as continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) by examining the parametric heating rate of a trapped nanosphere. The random localizations of the center of mass for a given particle predicted by the CSL model can be understood as a stochastic force embodying a source of heating for the nanosphere. We show that by utilizing a Paul trap to levitate the particle and optical cooling, it is possible to reduce environmental decoherence to such a level that CSL dominates the dynamics and contributes the main source of heating. We show that this approach allows measurements to be made on the time scale of seconds and that the free parameter ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\mathrm{csl}}$ which characterizes the model ought to be testable to values as low as ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}12}$ Hz.
Quantum experiments with nanomechanical oscillators are regarded as a test bed for hypothetical modifications of the Schrödinger equation, which predict a breakdown of the superposition principle and induce classical behavior at the macroscale. It is generally believed that the sensitivity to these unconventional effects grows with the mass of the mechanical quantum system. Here we show that the opposite is the case for optomechanical systems in the presence of generic noise sources, such as thermal and measurement noise. We determine conditions for distinguishing these decoherence processes from possible collapse-induced decoherence in continuous optomechanical force measurements.