Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2512.00875 · Science China Information Sciences

Efficient Self-Consistent Quantum Comb Tomography on the Product Stiefel Manifold

Xinlin He, Zetong Li, Congcong Zheng, Sixuan Li, Xutao Yu, Zaichen Zhang

quant-phSubmitted Nov 30, 2025• Announced Dec 2, 2025• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Characterizing non-Markovian quantum dynamics is currently hindered by the self-inconsistency and high computational complexity of existing quantum comb tomography (QCT) methods. In this work, we propose a self-consistent framework that unifies the quantum comb, instrument set, and initial states into a single geometric entity, termed as the Comb-Instrument-State (CIS) set. We demonstrate that the CIS set naturally resides on a product Stiefel manifold, allowing the tomography problem to be solved via efficient unconstrained Riemannian optimization while automatically preserving physical constraints. Numerical simulations confirm that our approach is computationally scalable and robust against gate definition errors, significantly outperforming conventional isometry-based QCT methods. Our work indicates the potential to efficiently learn quantum comb with fewer computational resources.

Related papers

Quantum Comb Tomography via Learning Isometries on Stiefel Manifold

Ze‐Tong Li, Xin-Lin He, Congcong Zheng +4 more

Explicit mathematical reconstructions of quantum combs play a significant role in developing quantum information science. However, tremendous parameter requirements and physical constraint implementations have become computationally nonignorable encumbrances. In this Letter, we propose an efficient method for quantum comb tomography by learning isometries on the Stiefel manifold via solving a series of unconstrained optimization problems with significantly fewer parameters. The stepwise isometry estimation shows the capability for providing information of the truncated quantum comb while processing the tomography. Remarkably, this method enables the dimension-reduced quantum comb tomography by reducing the ancillary dimensions of isometries with bounded error. As a result, our proposed method exhibits high accuracy and efficiency.

Physical Review Letters•Jan 10, 2025•4 citations

Quantum Network Tomography via Learning Isometries on Stiefel Manifold

Ze‐Tong Li, He, Xin-Lin, Congcong Zheng +4 more

Explicit mathematical reconstructions of quantum networks play a significant role in developing quantum information science. However, tremendous parameter requirements and physical constraint implementations have become computationally non-ignorable encumbrances. In this work, we propose an efficient method for quantum network tomography by learning isometries on the Stiefel manifold. Tasks of reconstructing quantum networks are tackled by solving a series of unconstrained optimization problems with significantly fewer parameters. The stepwise isometry estimation shows the capability for providing information of the truncated quantum network while processing the tomography. Remarkably, this method enables the dimension-reduced quantum network tomography by reducing the ancillary dimensions of isometries with bounded error. As a result, our proposed method exhibits high accuracy and efficiency.

arXiv:2404.06988•Apr 10, 2024•0 citations

Compressive Gate Set Tomography

Raphael Brieger, Ingo Roth, Martin Kliesch

Flexible characterization techniques that provide a detailed picture of the experimental imperfections under realistic assumptions are crucial to gain actionable advice in the development of quantum computers.Gate set tomography self-consistently extracts a complete tomographic description of the implementation of an entire set of quantum gates, as well as the initial state and measurement, from experimental data.It has become a standard tool for this task but comes with high requirements on the number of sequences and their design, making it already experimentally challenging for only two qubits.In this work, we show that low-rank approximations of gate sets can be obtained from significantly fewer gate sequences and that it is sufficient to draw them at random.This coherent noise characterization however still contains the crucial information for improving the implementation.To this end, we formulate the data processing problem of gate set tomography as a rank-constrained tensor completion problem.We provide an algorithm to solve this problem while respecting the usual positivity and normalization constraints of quantum mechanics.For this purpose, we combine methods from Riemannian optimization and machine learning and develop a saddle-free second-order geometrical optimization method on the complex Stiefel manifold.Besides the reduction in sequences, we numerically demonstrate that the algorithm does not rely on structured gate sets or an elaborate circuit design to robustly perform gate set tomography.Therefore, it is more flexible than traditional approaches.We also demonstrate how coherent errors in shadow estimation protocols can be mitigated using estimates from gate set tomography.

arXiv:2112.05176•PRX Quantum•Mar 10, 2023•25 citations

Non-Markovian quantum gate set tomography

Ze‐Tong Li, Congcong Zheng, Fanxu Meng +4 more

Abstract Engineering quantum devices requires reliable characterization of the quantum system, including qubits, quantum operations (also known as instruments) and the quantum noise. Recently, quantum gate set tomography (GST) has emerged as a powerful technique for self-consistently describing quantum states, gates, and measurements. However, non-Markovian correlations between the quantum system and environment impact the reliability of GST. To address this, we propose a self-consistent operational framework called instrument set tomography (IST) for non-Markovian GST. Based on the stochastic quantum process, the instrument set describes instruments and system-environment (SE) correlations. We introduce a linear inversion IST (LIST) to describe instruments and SE correlations without physical constraints. The disharmony of linear relationships between instruments is detected. Furthermore, we propose a physically constrained statistical method based on the maximum likelihood estimation for IST (MLE-IST) with adjustable dimensions. MLE-IST shows significant flexibility in adapting to different types of devices, such as noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices, by adjusting the model and constraints. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness and necessity of simultaneously describing instruments and SE correlations. Specifically, the LIST and MLE-IST obtains significant improvement on average square error reduction in the imperfect implemented simulations by orders of −23.77 and −6.21, respectively, compared to their comparative methods. Remarkably, real-chip experiments indicate that a polynomial number of parameters with respect to the Markovian order are sufficient to characterize non-Markovian quantum noise in current NISQ devices. Consequently, IST provides an essential and self-consistent framework for characterizing, benchmarking, and developing quantum devices in terms of the instrument set.

arXiv:2307.14696•Quantum Science and Technology•Apr 11, 2024•6 citations

Fast Quantum Characterization via Riemannian Optimization

Daniel Volya, А. В. Никитин, Prabhat Mishra

Constrained optimization plays a crucial role in the fields of quantum physics and quantum information science and becomes especially challenging for high-dimensional complex structure problems. One specific issue is that of quantum process tomography, in which the goal is to retrieve the underlying quantum process based on a given set of measurement data. In this paper, we introduce a modified version of stochastic gradient descent on a Riemannian manifold that integrates recent advancements in numerical methods for Riemannian optimization. This approach inherently supports the physically driven constraints of a quantum process, takes advantage of state-of-the-art large-scale stochastic objective optimization, and has superior performance to traditional approaches such as maximum likelihood estimation and projected least squares. The data-driven approach enables accurate, order-of-magnitude faster results, and works with incomplete data. We demonstrate our approach on simulations of quantum processes and in hardware by characterizing an engineered process on quantum computers.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Sep 15, 2024•6 citations

Fast Quantum Process Tomography via Riemannian Gradient Descent

Daniel Volya, А. В. Никитин, Prabhat Mishra

Constrained optimization plays a crucial role in the fields of quantum physics and quantum information science and becomes especially challenging for high-dimensional complex structure problems. One specific issue is that of quantum process tomography, in which the goal is to retrieve the underlying quantum process based on a given set of measurement data. In this paper, we introduce a modified version of stochastic gradient descent on a Riemannian manifold that integrates recent advancements in numerical methods for Riemannian optimization. This approach inherently supports the physically driven constraints of a quantum process, takes advantage of state-of-the-art large-scale stochastic objective optimization, and has superior performance to traditional approaches such as maximum likelihood estimation and projected least squares. The data-driven approach enables accurate, order-of-magnitude faster results, and works with incomplete data. We demonstrate our approach on simulations of quantum processes and in hardware by characterizing an engineered process on quantum computers.

arXiv:2404.18840•Apr 29, 2024•0 citations
Characterizing non-Markovian quantum dynamics is currently hindered by the self-inconsistency and high computational complexity of existing quantum comb tomography (QCT) methods. In this work, we propose a self-consistent framework that unifies the quantum comb, instrument set, and initial states into a single geometric entity, termed as the Comb-Instrument-State (CIS) set. We demonstrate that the CIS set naturally resides on a product Stiefel manifold, allowing the tomography problem to be solved via efficient unconstrained Riemannian optimization while automatically preserving physical constraints. Numerical simulations confirm that our approach is computationally scalable and robust against gate definition errors, significantly outperforming conventional isometry-based QCT methods. Our work indicates the potential to efficiently learn quantum comb with fewer computational resources.
Explicit mathematical reconstructions of quantum combs play a significant role in developing quantum information science. However, tremendous parameter requirements and physical constraint implementations have become computationally nonignorable encumbrances. In this Letter, we propose an efficient method for quantum comb tomography by learning isometries on the Stiefel manifold via solving a series of unconstrained optimization problems with significantly fewer parameters. The stepwise isometry estimation shows the capability for providing information of the truncated quantum comb while processing the tomography. Remarkably, this method enables the dimension-reduced quantum comb tomography by reducing the ancillary dimensions of isometries with bounded error. As a result, our proposed method exhibits high accuracy and efficiency.
Explicit mathematical reconstructions of quantum networks play a significant role in developing quantum information science. However, tremendous parameter requirements and physical constraint implementations have become computationally non-ignorable encumbrances. In this work, we propose an efficient method for quantum network tomography by learning isometries on the Stiefel manifold. Tasks of reconstructing quantum networks are tackled by solving a series of unconstrained optimization problems with significantly fewer parameters. The stepwise isometry estimation shows the capability for providing information of the truncated quantum network while processing the tomography. Remarkably, this method enables the dimension-reduced quantum network tomography by reducing the ancillary dimensions of isometries with bounded error. As a result, our proposed method exhibits high accuracy and efficiency.
Flexible characterization techniques that provide a detailed picture of the experimental imperfections under realistic assumptions are crucial to gain actionable advice in the development of quantum computers.Gate set tomography self-consistently extracts a complete tomographic description of the implementation of an entire set of quantum gates, as well as the initial state and measurement, from experimental data.It has become a standard tool for this task but comes with high requirements on the number of sequences and their design, making it already experimentally challenging for only two qubits.In this work, we show that low-rank approximations of gate sets can be obtained from significantly fewer gate sequences and that it is sufficient to draw them at random.This coherent noise characterization however still contains the crucial information for improving the implementation.To this end, we formulate the data processing problem of gate set tomography as a rank-constrained tensor completion problem.We provide an algorithm to solve this problem while respecting the usual positivity and normalization constraints of quantum mechanics.For this purpose, we combine methods from Riemannian optimization and machine learning and develop a saddle-free second-order geometrical optimization method on the complex Stiefel manifold.Besides the reduction in sequences, we numerically demonstrate that the algorithm does not rely on structured gate sets or an elaborate circuit design to robustly perform gate set tomography.Therefore, it is more flexible than traditional approaches.We also demonstrate how coherent errors in shadow estimation protocols can be mitigated using estimates from gate set tomography.
Abstract Engineering quantum devices requires reliable characterization of the quantum system, including qubits, quantum operations (also known as instruments) and the quantum noise. Recently, quantum gate set tomography (GST) has emerged as a powerful technique for self-consistently describing quantum states, gates, and measurements. However, non-Markovian correlations between the quantum system and environment impact the reliability of GST. To address this, we propose a self-consistent operational framework called instrument set tomography (IST) for non-Markovian GST. Based on the stochastic quantum process, the instrument set describes instruments and system-environment (SE) correlations. We introduce a linear inversion IST (LIST) to describe instruments and SE correlations without physical constraints. The disharmony of linear relationships between instruments is detected. Furthermore, we propose a physically constrained statistical method based on the maximum likelihood estimation for IST (MLE-IST) with adjustable dimensions. MLE-IST shows significant flexibility in adapting to different types of devices, such as noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices, by adjusting the model and constraints. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness and necessity of simultaneously describing instruments and SE correlations. Specifically, the LIST and MLE-IST obtains significant improvement on average square error reduction in the imperfect implemented simulations by orders of −23.77 and −6.21, respectively, compared to their comparative methods. Remarkably, real-chip experiments indicate that a polynomial number of parameters with respect to the Markovian order are sufficient to characterize non-Markovian quantum noise in current NISQ devices. Consequently, IST provides an essential and self-consistent framework for characterizing, benchmarking, and developing quantum devices in terms of the instrument set.
Constrained optimization plays a crucial role in the fields of quantum physics and quantum information science and becomes especially challenging for high-dimensional complex structure problems. One specific issue is that of quantum process tomography, in which the goal is to retrieve the underlying quantum process based on a given set of measurement data. In this paper, we introduce a modified version of stochastic gradient descent on a Riemannian manifold that integrates recent advancements in numerical methods for Riemannian optimization. This approach inherently supports the physically driven constraints of a quantum process, takes advantage of state-of-the-art large-scale stochastic objective optimization, and has superior performance to traditional approaches such as maximum likelihood estimation and projected least squares. The data-driven approach enables accurate, order-of-magnitude faster results, and works with incomplete data. We demonstrate our approach on simulations of quantum processes and in hardware by characterizing an engineered process on quantum computers.
Constrained optimization plays a crucial role in the fields of quantum physics and quantum information science and becomes especially challenging for high-dimensional complex structure problems. One specific issue is that of quantum process tomography, in which the goal is to retrieve the underlying quantum process based on a given set of measurement data. In this paper, we introduce a modified version of stochastic gradient descent on a Riemannian manifold that integrates recent advancements in numerical methods for Riemannian optimization. This approach inherently supports the physically driven constraints of a quantum process, takes advantage of state-of-the-art large-scale stochastic objective optimization, and has superior performance to traditional approaches such as maximum likelihood estimation and projected least squares. The data-driven approach enables accurate, order-of-magnitude faster results, and works with incomplete data. We demonstrate our approach on simulations of quantum processes and in hardware by characterizing an engineered process on quantum computers.