Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2508.09844 · Scientific Reports

On the generalization limits of quantum generative adversarial networks with pure state generators

Jasmin Frkatovic, Akash Malemath, Ivan Kankeu, Yannick Werner, Matthias Tschöpe, Vítor Fortes Rey, Sungho Suh, Paul Lukowicz, Nikolaos E. Palaiodimopoulos, Maximilian Kiefer-Emmanouilidis

Published Jun 9, 2026• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate the capabilities of quantum generative adversarial networks (QGANs) in image generations tasks. Our analysis centers on fully quantum implementations of both the generator and discriminator. Through extensive numerical testing of current main architectures, we find that QGANs struggle to generalize across datasets, converging on merely the average representation of the training data. When the output of the generator is a pure-state, we analytically derive a lower bound for the discriminator quality given by the fidelity between the pure-state output of the generator and the target data distribution, thereby providing a theoretical explanation for the limitations observed in current models. Our findings reveal fundamental challenges in the generalization capabilities of existing quantum generative models. While our analysis focuses on QGANs, the results carry broader implications for the performance of related quantum generative models.

DOI
10.1038/s41598-026-54900-7

Related papers

Survey of Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (QGAN) to Generate Images

Mohammadsaleh Pajuhanfard, Rasoul Kiani, Victor S. Sheng

Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (QGANs) represent a useful development in quantum machine learning, using the particular properties of quantum mechanics to solve the challenges of data analysis and modeling. This paper brings up a general analysis of five QGAN architectures, focusing on their evolution, strengths, weaknesses, and limitations in noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. Primary methods like Entangling Quantum GAN (EQ-GAN) and Quantum state fidelity (QuGAN) concentrate on stability, convergence, and robust performance on small-scale datasets such as 2 × 2 grayscale images. Intermediate models such as Image Quantum GAN (IQGAN) and Experimental Quantum GAN (EXQGAN) provide new ideas like trainable encoders and patch-based sub-generators that are scalable to 8 × 8 datasets with increasing noise resilience. The most advanced method is Parameterized Quantum Wasserstein GAN (PQWGAN), which uses a hybrid quantum-classical structure to obtain high-resolution image processing for 28 × 28 grayscale datasets while trying to maintain parameter efficiency. This study explores, analyzes, and summarizes critical problems of QGANs, including accuracy, convergence, parameter efficiency, image quality, performance metrics, and training stability under noisy conditions. In addition, developing QGANs can generate and train parameters in quantum approximation optimization algorithms. One of the useful applications of QGAN is generating medical datasets that can generate medical images from limited datasets to train specific medical models for the recognition of diseases.

Mathematics•Dec 6, 2024•26 citations

Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (QGANs) for Data Augmentation

Jincheng Zhang

This paper investigates the application of Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (QGANs) to data augmentation for machine learning. Traditional Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) rely on classical neural networks, while this research explores leveraging quantum circuits as generators within a QGAN architecture. The core idea is to train a quantum generator to produce synthetic data samples, supplementing existing datasets with novel instances. The discriminator remains a classical neural network, tasked with distinguishing between real and generated data. We present a theoretical framework for this approach, outlining the mathematical formulation and key components. Specifically, we introduce the notation (x, s_1, s_2, ..., s_K) to represent data samples, generator states, and relevant parameters. The objective function for the QGAN is defined as minimizing the Jensen-Shannon divergence between the real and generated data distributions. The effectiveness of this approach is discussed, highlighting potential advantages and challenges. This work contributes to the emerging field of quantum machine learning and offers a novel strategy for improving the performance of machine learning models, particularly in scenarios with limited training data.

•Aug 31, 2026•0 citations

Towards a scalable discrete quantum generative adversarial neural network

Smit Chaudhary, Patrick Huembeli, Ian MacCormack +3 more

Abstract Quantum generative adversarial networks (QGANs) have been studied in the context of quantum machine learning for several years, but there has not been yet a proposal for a fully QGAN with both, a quantum generator and discriminator. We introduce a fully QGAN intended for use with binary data. The architecture incorporates several features found in other classical and quantum machine learning models, which up to this point had not been used in conjunction. In particular, we incorporate classical noise reuploading in the generator, auxiliary qubits in the discriminator to enhance expressivity, and a direct connection between the generator and discriminator circuits, obviating the need to access the generator’s probability distribution. We show that, as separate components, the generator and discriminator perform as desired. We empirically demonstrate the expressive power of our model on both synthetic data as well as low energy states of an Ising model. Our demonstrations suggest that the model is not only capable of reproducing discrete training data, but also of potentially generalizing from it.

arXiv:2209.13993•Quantum Science and Technology•Mar 16, 2023•14 citations

Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks for Synthetic Data Generation

Jincheng Zhang

This paper investigates the application of Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (QGANs) for the generation of synthetic data. Traditional Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) often face challenges in producing high-quality synthetic data, especially when dealing with complex data distributions. We propose a novel framework utilizing quantum circuits to construct both the generator and discriminator within a QGAN architecture. The core innovation lies in harnessing quantum superposition and interference during the adversarial training process to potentially improve the realism and diversity of the generated synthetic data. Our approach introduces a theoretical foundation and a conceptual design for QGANs, paving the way for future research and development in this emerging field. The primary goal is to demonstrate the potential benefits of incorporating quantum mechanical principles into the GAN framework, leading to enhanced synthetic data generation capabilities. The performance of a QGAN is expected to be superior to a classical GAN due to the unique properties of quantum systems.

•Sep 2, 2026•0 citations

Performance Comparison of Full and Hybrid QGANs for Particle Shower Simulation

Bancy Mbura Maranga

The use of quantum generative adversarial networks (qGANs) is based on an efficient approach that simulates high-energy particle showers using a reduced model complexity. In this study, we analyze complete and hybrid qGAN architectures for the creation of particle shower images and compare their training behavior, convergence and accuracy. The results show a stable training of the entire qGAN, which can generate the general parameters of the shower well. The hybrid design also exhibits competitive performance with the medium discriminator yielding the highest accuracy of all the tested configurations. However, with a lower or higher discriminator the decrease of performance is due to the imbalance between the capacity of the generator and discriminator. The results show that quantum models can be represented with a much smaller number of trainable parameters, and still capture the representational capabilities of classical models, something that can be studied in greater detail with larger models and more sophisticated physics-based metrics.

Elaris Computing Nexus•Sep 2, 2026•0 citations

Quantum generative adversarial networks with dual generators

Quangong Ma, Chaolong Hao, Nianwen Si +1 more

Abstract Quantum generative adversarial networks (QGANs) have demonstrated strong capabilities in tasks like synthetic data generation and detecting anomalies. Recent developments have increasingly integrated traditional machine learning techniques to boost the performance of QGANs. Motivated by this progress, we propose an innovative QGAN architecture that incorporates a classical learning component and employs a dual-generator design. Our approach improves upon the traditional hybrid quantum–classical GAN structure and introduces a redesigned loss function tailored for the new model. Experiments on multiple datasets indicate that our method surpasses previous techniques in image generation quality, achieving a 1.38% average reduction in Fréchet inception distance scores compared to the current state-of-the-art, and improvements of 6.52%, 0.36%, and 0.38% in structural similarity index, cosine similarity, and peak signal-to-noise ratio metrics, respectively. Additionally, our architecture supports the generation of larger images (up to 78 × 78 ), as verified on the CelebA dataset. Simulations conducted in noisy conditions further confirm the robustness and effectiveness of both the proposed architecture and loss function.

Machine Learning Science and Technology•Sep 25, 2025•1 citation
We investigate the capabilities of quantum generative adversarial networks (QGANs) in image generations tasks. Our analysis centers on fully quantum implementations of both the generator and discriminator. Through extensive numerical testing of current main architectures, we find that QGANs struggle to generalize across datasets, converging on merely the average representation of the training data. When the output of the generator is a pure-state, we analytically derive a lower bound for the discriminator quality given by the fidelity between the pure-state output of the generator and the target data distribution, thereby providing a theoretical explanation for the limitations observed in current models. Our findings reveal fundamental challenges in the generalization capabilities of existing quantum generative models. While our analysis focuses on QGANs, the results carry broader implications for the performance of related quantum generative models.
Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (QGANs) represent a useful development in quantum machine learning, using the particular properties of quantum mechanics to solve the challenges of data analysis and modeling. This paper brings up a general analysis of five QGAN architectures, focusing on their evolution, strengths, weaknesses, and limitations in noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. Primary methods like Entangling Quantum GAN (EQ-GAN) and Quantum state fidelity (QuGAN) concentrate on stability, convergence, and robust performance on small-scale datasets such as 2 × 2 grayscale images. Intermediate models such as Image Quantum GAN (IQGAN) and Experimental Quantum GAN (EXQGAN) provide new ideas like trainable encoders and patch-based sub-generators that are scalable to 8 × 8 datasets with increasing noise resilience. The most advanced method is Parameterized Quantum Wasserstein GAN (PQWGAN), which uses a hybrid quantum-classical structure to obtain high-resolution image processing for 28 × 28 grayscale datasets while trying to maintain parameter efficiency. This study explores, analyzes, and summarizes critical problems of QGANs, including accuracy, convergence, parameter efficiency, image quality, performance metrics, and training stability under noisy conditions. In addition, developing QGANs can generate and train parameters in quantum approximation optimization algorithms. One of the useful applications of QGAN is generating medical datasets that can generate medical images from limited datasets to train specific medical models for the recognition of diseases.
This paper investigates the application of Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (QGANs) to data augmentation for machine learning. Traditional Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) rely on classical neural networks, while this research explores leveraging quantum circuits as generators within a QGAN architecture. The core idea is to train a quantum generator to produce synthetic data samples, supplementing existing datasets with novel instances. The discriminator remains a classical neural network, tasked with distinguishing between real and generated data. We present a theoretical framework for this approach, outlining the mathematical formulation and key components. Specifically, we introduce the notation (x, s_1, s_2, ..., s_K) to represent data samples, generator states, and relevant parameters. The objective function for the QGAN is defined as minimizing the Jensen-Shannon divergence between the real and generated data distributions. The effectiveness of this approach is discussed, highlighting potential advantages and challenges. This work contributes to the emerging field of quantum machine learning and offers a novel strategy for improving the performance of machine learning models, particularly in scenarios with limited training data.
Abstract Quantum generative adversarial networks (QGANs) have been studied in the context of quantum machine learning for several years, but there has not been yet a proposal for a fully QGAN with both, a quantum generator and discriminator. We introduce a fully QGAN intended for use with binary data. The architecture incorporates several features found in other classical and quantum machine learning models, which up to this point had not been used in conjunction. In particular, we incorporate classical noise reuploading in the generator, auxiliary qubits in the discriminator to enhance expressivity, and a direct connection between the generator and discriminator circuits, obviating the need to access the generator’s probability distribution. We show that, as separate components, the generator and discriminator perform as desired. We empirically demonstrate the expressive power of our model on both synthetic data as well as low energy states of an Ising model. Our demonstrations suggest that the model is not only capable of reproducing discrete training data, but also of potentially generalizing from it.
This paper investigates the application of Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (QGANs) for the generation of synthetic data. Traditional Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) often face challenges in producing high-quality synthetic data, especially when dealing with complex data distributions. We propose a novel framework utilizing quantum circuits to construct both the generator and discriminator within a QGAN architecture. The core innovation lies in harnessing quantum superposition and interference during the adversarial training process to potentially improve the realism and diversity of the generated synthetic data. Our approach introduces a theoretical foundation and a conceptual design for QGANs, paving the way for future research and development in this emerging field. The primary goal is to demonstrate the potential benefits of incorporating quantum mechanical principles into the GAN framework, leading to enhanced synthetic data generation capabilities. The performance of a QGAN is expected to be superior to a classical GAN due to the unique properties of quantum systems.
The use of quantum generative adversarial networks (qGANs) is based on an efficient approach that simulates high-energy particle showers using a reduced model complexity. In this study, we analyze complete and hybrid qGAN architectures for the creation of particle shower images and compare their training behavior, convergence and accuracy. The results show a stable training of the entire qGAN, which can generate the general parameters of the shower well. The hybrid design also exhibits competitive performance with the medium discriminator yielding the highest accuracy of all the tested configurations. However, with a lower or higher discriminator the decrease of performance is due to the imbalance between the capacity of the generator and discriminator. The results show that quantum models can be represented with a much smaller number of trainable parameters, and still capture the representational capabilities of classical models, something that can be studied in greater detail with larger models and more sophisticated physics-based metrics.
Abstract Quantum generative adversarial networks (QGANs) have demonstrated strong capabilities in tasks like synthetic data generation and detecting anomalies. Recent developments have increasingly integrated traditional machine learning techniques to boost the performance of QGANs. Motivated by this progress, we propose an innovative QGAN architecture that incorporates a classical learning component and employs a dual-generator design. Our approach improves upon the traditional hybrid quantum–classical GAN structure and introduces a redesigned loss function tailored for the new model. Experiments on multiple datasets indicate that our method surpasses previous techniques in image generation quality, achieving a 1.38% average reduction in Fréchet inception distance scores compared to the current state-of-the-art, and improvements of 6.52%, 0.36%, and 0.38% in structural similarity index, cosine similarity, and peak signal-to-noise ratio metrics, respectively. Additionally, our architecture supports the generation of larger images (up to 78 × 78 ), as verified on the CelebA dataset. Simulations conducted in noisy conditions further confirm the robustness and effectiveness of both the proposed architecture and loss function.