The vast majority of symmetry-protected topological (SPT) states are difficult to detect, which often leads to their misidentification as ordinary or topologically trivial phases. In this work, we propose a general framework for detecting these hidden topological states. We distinguish the ordinary matter state from the topological phase by exploiting the boundary effects in space (via surface behaviors on engineered edge) and time (via strange correlators) according to the principle of bulk-edge correspondence. As a concrete example, we study the dimerized spin-1/2 Heisenberg model on a square lattice using quantum Monte Carlo simulations, focusing on its paramagnetic dimer phase and edge states. The dimer phase has been widely regarded as topologically trivial due to its gapped edge state on conventional edges. However, the model can also be viewed as two-dimensional antiferromagnetically (AF) coupled usual ladders, which suggests an SPT state adiabatically connected to the one-dimensional Haldane phase. We resolve this puzzle and demonstrate that the dimer phase is indeed a quasi-one-dimensional SPT state by measuring generalized strange correlators introduced in this work and by showing that the nontrivial gapless edge state on a zigzag edge is ferromagnetically ordered, resulting from effective ferromagnetic interactions between degenerate spinons liberated on each side of the cut. Furthermore, we show that the ordered edge state gives rise to an extraordinary surface critical behavior at the (2+1)-dimensional O(3) bulk critical points of the model, which contradicts theoretical predictions based on classical-quantum mapping. Overall, we establish a standard detection method for uncovering topological phases that masquerade as ordinary states of matter.
The vast majority of symmetry-protected topological (SPT) states are difficult to detect, which often leads to their misidentification as ordinary or topologically trivial phases. In this work, we propose a general framework for detecting these hidden topological states. We distinguish the ordinary matter state from the topological phase by exploiting the boundary effects in space (via surface behaviors on engineered edge) and time (via strange correlators) according to the principle of bulk-edge correspondence. As a concrete example, we study the dimerized spin-1/2 Heisenberg model on a square lattice using quantum Monte Carlo simulations, focusing on its paramagnetic dimer phase and edge states. The dimer phase has been widely regarded as topologically trivial due to its gapped edge state on conventional edges. However, the model can also be viewed as two-dimensional antiferromagnetically (AF) coupled usual ladders, which suggests an SPT state adiabatically connected to the one-dimensional Haldane phase. We resolve this puzzle and demonstrate that the dimer phase is indeed a quasi-one-dimensional SPT state by measuring generalized strange correlators introduced in this work and by showing that the nontrivial gapless edge state on a zigzag edge is ferromagnetically ordered, resulting from effective ferromagnetic interactions between degenerate spinons liberated on each side of the cut. Furthermore, we show that the ordered edge state gives rise to an extraordinary surface critical behavior at the (2+1)-dimensional O(3) bulk critical points of the model, which contradicts theoretical predictions based on classical-quantum mapping. Overall, we establish a standard detection method for uncovering topological phases that masquerade as ordinary states of matter.
Distinguishing the nontrivial symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phase from the trivial insulator phase in the presence of electron-electron interaction is an urgent question to the study of topological insulators, due to the fact that most of the topological indices defined for free electron systems are very likely unsuitable for interacting cases. In this work, we demonstrate that the strange correlator is a sensitive diagnosis to detect SPT states in interacting systems. Employing large-scale quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations, we investigate the interaction-driven quantum phase transition in the Kane-Mele-Hubbard model. The transition from the quantum spin Hall insulator at weak interaction to an antiferromagnetic Mott insulator at strong interaction can be readily detected by the momentum space behavior of the strange correlator in single-particle, spin, and pairing sectors. The interaction effects on the symmetry-protected edge states in various sectors, i.e., the helical Luttinger liquid behavior, are well captured in the QMC measurements of strange correlators. Moreover, we demonstrate that the strange correlator is technically easier to implement in QMC and more robust in performance than other proposed numerical diagnoses for interacting topological states, as only static correlations are needed. The attempt in this work paves the way for using the strange correlator to study interaction-driven topological phase transitions in fermionic as well as bosonic systems.
Abstract Topology in quantum many-body systems has profoundly changed our understanding of quantum phases of matter. The model that has played an instrumental role in elucidating these effects is the antiferromagnetic spin-1 Haldane chain 1,2 . Its ground state is a disordered state, with symmetry-protected fourfold-degenerate edge states due to fractional spin excitations. In the bulk, it is characterized by vanishing two-point spin correlations, gapped excitations and a characteristic non-local order parameter 3,4 . More recently it has been understood that the Haldane chain forms a specific example of a more general classification scheme of symmetry-protected topological phases of matter, which is based on ideas connected to quantum information and entanglement 5–7 . Here, we realize a finite-temperature version of such a topological Haldane phase with Fermi–Hubbard ladders in an ultracold-atom quantum simulator. We directly reveal both edge and bulk properties of the system through the use of single-site and particle-resolved measurements, as well as non-local correlation functions. Continuously changing the Hubbard interaction strength of the system enables us to investigate the robustness of the phase to charge (density) fluctuations far from the regime of the Heisenberg model, using a novel correlator.
We employ strange correlators to detect 2D subsystem symmetry protected topological (SSPT) phases which are nontrivial topological phases protected by subsystem symmetries. Specifically, we analytically construct efficient strange correlators in the 2D cluster model in the presence of the uniform magnetic field and then perform the projector quantum Monte Carlo simulation within the quantum annealing scheme. We find that strange correlators show a long-range correlation in the SSPT phase, from which we define strange order parameters to characterize the topological phase transition between the SSPT phase at low fields and the trivial paramagnetic phase at high fields. Thus the detection of the fully localized zero modes on the 1D physical boundary of the SSPT phase has been transformed to the bulk correlation measurement about the local operators with the periodic boundary condition. We also find interesting spatial anisotropy of a strange correlator, which can be intrinsically traced back to the nature of spatial anisotropy of subsystem symmetries that protect SSPT order in the 2D cluster model. By simulating strange correlators, we, therefore, provide the first unbiased large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulation on the easy and efficient detection in the SSPT phase and open the avenue of the investigation of the subtle yet fundamental nature of the novel interacting topological phases.
``Strange'' correlators provide a tool to detect topological phases arising in many-body models by computing the matrix elements of suitably defined two-point correlations between the states under investigation and trivial reference states. Their effectiveness depends on the choice of the adopted operators. In this paper, we give a systematic procedure for this choice, discussing the advantages of choosing operators using the bulk-boundary correspondence of the systems under scrutiny. Via the scaling exponents, we directly relate the algebraic decay of the strange correlators with the scaling dimensions of gapless edge modes operators. We begin our analysis with lattice models hosting symmetry-protected topological phases and we analyze the sums of the strange correlators, pointing out that integrating their moduli substantially reduces cancellations and finite-size effects. We also analyze instances of systems hosting intrinsic topological order, as well as strange correlators between states with different nontrivial topologies. Our results for both translational and nontranslational invariant cases, and in the presence of on-site disorder and long-range couplings, extend the validity of the strange correlator approach for the diagnosis of topological phases of matter and indicate a general procedure for their optimal choice.
Symmetry protected topological (SPT) phase is a generalization of topological insulator (TI). Different from the intrinsic topological phase, e.g., the fractional quantum hall (FQH) phase, SPT phase is only distinguishable from a trivial disordered phase when certain symmetry is preserved. Indeed, SPT phase has a long history in 1D, and it has been shown that the well known Haldane phase of S=1 Heisenberg chain belongs to this class. However, in higher dimensions, most of the previous studies focus on free electron systems. Until very recently, it was realized that SPT phase also exists in interacting boson/spin systems in higher dimensions. In this talk, I will show that there is an interesting duality map between intrinsic topological phase and SPT phase. I will focus on a simple model that realizes an Ising paramagnet with gapless edge modes protected by Ising symmetry. The duality provides us a simple physical construction that distinguishes this system from a conventional paramagnet: we couple the system to a Z2 gauge field and then show that the flux excitations have different braiding statistics from that of a usual paramagnet. In addition, these braiding statistics directly implies the existence of protected edge modes. The duality map also provides us a complementary way to derive topological terms of SPT phases, which classify different SPT phases in bosonic systems. Finally, I will discuss the possible generalization for interacting fermion/electron systems.
Since the discovery of phase transitions driven by topological defects, the classification of phases of matter has been significantly extended beyond Ginzburg and Landau's paradigm of spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB). In particular, intrinsic and symmetry-protected topological (SPT) orders have been discovered in (mostly gapped) quantum many-body ground states. However, these are commonly viewed as zero-temperature phenomena, and their robustness in a gapless ground state or against thermal fluctuations remains challenging to tackle. Here we introduce an explicit construction for SPT-type states with hidden order associated with SSB: They feature (quasi-)long-range correlations along appropriate edges but short-range order in the bulk, ground state degeneracy associated with SSB, and nonlocal string order in the bulk. We apply our construction to predict two types of finite-temperature SPT transitions protected by 1-form symmetries in the Ising and BKT class, respectively, where the usual signs of criticality appear despite the absence of a diverging correlation length in the bulk. While the state featuring hidden Ising order is gapped, the other SPT state associated with the BKT-SPT transition has hidden U ( 1 ) or XY order and constitutes an intrinsically gapless SPT state, associated with a gapless Goldstone mode. Specifically, in this work we discuss spins with global Z 2 or U ( 1 ) symmetry coupled to link variables constituting a loop gas model with a 1-form symmetry. By mapping this system to an Ising-gauge theory, we demonstrate that one of the SPT phases we construct corresponds to the Higgs-SPT phase at T = 0 – which we show here to remain stable at finite temperature. Our work paves the way for a more systematic search for hidden order SPT phases, including in gapless systems, and raises the question if a natural (finite- T ) spin liquid candidate exists that realizes hidden order in the Higgs-SPT class.