arXiv:2507.15544

Effectiveness of Hybrid Optimization Method for Quantum Annealing Machines

Shuta Kikuchi, Nozomu Togawa, Shu Tanaka

Published Jul 21, 2025• 0 citations

Abstract

To enhance the performance of quantum annealing machines, several methods have been proposed to reduce the number of spins by fixing spin values through preprocessing. We proposed a hybrid optimization method that combines a simulated annealing (SA)-based non-quantum-type Ising machine with a quantum annealing machine. However, its applicability remains unclear. Therefore, we evaluated the performance of the hybrid method on large-size Ising models and analyzed its characteristics. The results indicate that the hybrid method improves upon solutions obtained by the preprocessing SA, even if the Ising models cannot be embedded in the quantum annealing machine. We analyzed the method from three perspectives: preprocessing, spin-fixed sub-Ising model generation method, and the accuracy of the quantum annealing machine. From the viewpoint of the minimum energy gap, we found that solving the sub-Ising model with a quantum annealing machine results in a higher solution accuracy than solving the original Ising model. Additionally, we demonstrated that the number of fixed spins and the accuracy of the quantum annealing machine affect the dependency of the solution accuracy on the sub-Ising model size.

Related papers

Hybrid Optimization Method Using Simulated-Annealing-Based Ising Machine and Quantum Annealer

Shuta Kikuchi, Nozomu Togawa, Shu Tanaka

Ising machines have the potential to realize fast and highly accurate solvers for combinatorial optimization problems. They are classified based on their internal algorithms. Examples include simulated-annealing-based Ising machines (non-quantum-type Ising machines) and quantum-annealing-based Ising machines (quantum annealers). Herein we propose a hybrid optimization method, which utilizes the advantages of both types. In this hybrid optimization method, the preprocessing step is performed by solving the non-quantum-annealing Ising machine multiple times. Then sub-Ising models with a reduced size by spin fixing are solved using a quantum annealer. The performance of the hybrid optimization method is evaluated via simulations using Simulated Annealing (SA) as a non-quantum-type Ising machine and D-Wave Advantage as a quantum annealer. Additionally, we investigate the parameter dependence of the proposed hybrid optimization method. The hybrid optimization method outperforms the preprocessing SA and the quantum annealing machine alone in fully connected random Ising models.

arXiv:2306.06589Journal of the Physical Society of JapanNov 10, 20238 citations

Hybrid Iterative Annealing Method Using a Quantum Annealer and a Classical Computer and Its Evaluation

Keisuke Fukada, Tatsuhiko Shirai, Nozomu Togawa

A combinatorial optimization problem is the problem of minimizing the energy function among many combinations of variables, which is often difficult to solve with conventional classical computers. Recently, Ising machines, including quantum annealers, have gained attention as a promising architecture for efficiently solving combinatorial optimization problems. Among various methods for solving such problems using Ising machines, one prominent approach is the three-stage annealing method. The approach effectively solves a combinatorial optimization problem, utilizing an initial solution, but it performs the annealing process only once. Repeating the annealing process several times may enhance the solution more efficiently. In this paper, we propose a novel hybrid iterative annealing method that consists of an initial process using a classical computer, an annealing process using a quantum annealer, and a correction process/selection process using a classical computer. The proposed method repeats the annealing process and the correction process/selection process until the solution is sufficiently converged. In the experimental evaluations through the three types of typical combinatorial optimization problems, the proposed method shows improvements by up to 54.0% compared to the three-stage annealing method.

IEICE Transactions on Fundamentals of Electronics Communications and Computer SciencesOct 7, 20240 citations

Hybrid Iterative Annealing Method Using a Quantum Annealer and a Classical Computer

Keisuke Fukada, Tatshuhiko Shirai, Nozomu Togawa

A combinatorial optimization problem is the problem of minimizing the energy function among many combinations of variables, which is often difficult to solve with conventional classical computers. Recently, Ising machines, including quantum annealers, have gained attention as a promising architecture for efficiently solving combinatorial optimization problems. Among various methods for solving such problems using Ising machines, one prominent approach is the three-stage annealing method. The approach effectively solves a combinatorial optimization problem, utilizing an initial solution, but it performs the annealing process only once. Repeating the annealing process several times may enhance the solution more efficiently. In this paper, we propose a novel hybrid iterative annealing method that consists of an initial process using a classical computer, an annealing process using a quantum annealer, and a correction process/selection process using a classical computer. The proposed method repeats the annealing process and the correction process/selection process until the solution is sufficiently converged. In the experimental evaluations through the two types of typical combinatorial optimization problems, the proposed method shows improvements by up to 50.5% compared to the three-stage annealing method.

International Conference on Consumer ElectronicsJan 6, 20242 citations

Physical Properties of Error Reduction Algorithms for Ising Machines

Kanta Hino, Shu Tanaka

Ising machines are expected to be dedicated computers that are capable of efficiently searching for good solutions to combinatorial optimization problems. When solving combinatorial optimization problems with an Ising machine, the objective function and constraints of the combinatorial optimization problems are expressed using the Ising model. Then, the low-energy states of the Ising model are searched by the internal algorithms of Ising machines. Typical internal algorithms are Simulated Annealing (SA) and Quantum Annealing (QA). Both algorithms exhibit stochastic behavior, so the final solution may contain errors. Therefore, it is an essential issue in the field of Ising machines to reduce errors as much as possible. A previous study proposed an error reduction method for QA machines, namely the Quantum Annealing Correction (QAC) model. This method reduces error by introducing penalty interaction and performing a specific decoding method. Building on these valuable insights, we proposed an alternative error reduction method, the stacked model. To verify the effectiveness, we examined on the relationship between the penalty interaction and the success probability of the QAC model and the stacked model on SA. The obtained results differ from the facts observed in QA. In summary, a decoding method different from the one considered effective in QA was found to be effective in SA. This result suggests that when considering an appropriate error reduction method, it is necessary to consider the internal algorithm of the Ising machine.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)Sep 15, 20242 citations

An Efficient Combined Bit-Width Reducing Method for Ising Models

Yuta Yachi, Masashi Tawada, Nozomu Togawa

Annealing machines such as quantum annealing machines and semiconductor-based annealing machines have been attracting attention as an efficient computing alternative for solving combinatorial optimization problems. They solve original combinatorial optimization problems by transforming them into a data structure called an Ising model. At that time, the bit-widths of the coefficients of the Ising model have to be kept within the range that an annealing machine can deal with. However, by reducing the Ising-model bit-widths, its minimum energy state, or ground state, may become different from that of the original one, and hence the targeted combinatorial optimization problem cannot be well solved. This paper proposes an effective method for reducing Ising model's bit-widths. The proposed method is composed of two processes: First, given an Ising model with large coefficient bit-widths, the shift method is applied to reduce its bit-widths roughly. Second, the spin-adding method is applied to further reduce its bit-widths to those that annealing machines can deal with. Without adding too many extra spins, we efficiently reduce the coefficient bit-widths of the original Ising model. Furthermore, the ground state before and after reducing the coefficient bit-widths is not much changed in most of the practical cases. Experimental evaluations demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method, compared to existing methods.

IEICE Transactions on Information and SystemsMar 31, 20234 citations

Advantages of Fixing Spins in Quantum Annealing

T Hattori, Hirotaka Irie, Tadashi Kadowaki +1 more

Quantum annealing can efficiently obtain solutions to combinatorial optimization problems. Size-reduction methods are used to treat large-scale combinatorial optimization problems that cannot be input directly into a quantum annealer because of its size limitation. Various size-reduction methods using fixing spins have been proposed as quantum-classical hybrid methods to obtain solutions. However, the high performance of these hybrid methods is yet to be clearly elucidated. In this study, we adopted a parameterized fixing spins method to verify the effects of fixing spins. The results revealed that setting the appropriate number of spins of the subproblem is crucial for obtaining a satisfactory solution, and the energy gap expansion is confirmed after fixing spins.

arXiv:2410.21924Journal of the Physical Society of JapanDec 20, 20244 citations