Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2507.05054

Work and entropy of mixing in isolated quantum systems

Budhaditya Bhattacharjee, Rohit Kishan Ray, Dominik Šafránek

Published Jul 7, 2025• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The mixing of two different gases is one of the most common natural phenomena, with applications ranging from CO$_2$ capture to water purification. Traditionally, mixing is analyzed in the context of local thermal equilibrium, where systems exchange energy with a heat bath. Here, we study mixing in an isolated system with potentially non-equilibrium initial states, characterized solely by macroscopic observables. We identify the entropy of mixing as a special case of observational entropy within an observer-dependent framework, where both entropy and extractable work depend on the resolution of measurement. This approach naturally resolves the Gibbs mixing paradox in quantum systems: while an observer experiences a discontinuous increase in entropy upon learning of the existence of two particle types, this knowledge does not provide an advantage in work extraction if the types of particles remain operationally indistinguishable in their measurements. Finally, we derive a Landauer-like bound on the difference in energy extracted by two observers, where an "observational temperature" emerges, determined by the accessible information. These results provide a foundation for rigorously determining the energy required to unmix in non-equilibrium settings and extend beyond quantum systems, offering insights into the thermodynamics of isolated classical gases.

Related papers

Mixing indistinguishable systems leads to a quantum Gibbs paradox

Benjamin Yadin, Benjamin Morris, Gerardo Adesso

The classical Gibbs paradox concerns the entropy change upon mixing two gases. Whether an observer assigns an entropy increase to the process depends on their ability to distinguish the gases. A resolution is that an "ignorant" observer, who cannot distinguish the gases, has no way of extracting work by mixing them. Moving the thought experiment into the quantum realm, we reveal new and surprising behaviour: the ignorant observer can extract work from mixing different gases, even if the gases cannot be directly distinguished. Moreover, in the macroscopic limit, the quantum case diverges from the classical ideal gas: as much work can be extracted as if the gases were fully distinguishable. We show that the ignorant observer assigns more microstates to the system than found by naive counting in semiclassical statistical mechanics. This demonstrates the importance of accounting for the level of knowledge of an observer, and its implications for genuinely quantum modifications to thermodynamics.

arXiv:2006.12482•Nature Communications•Mar 5, 2021•9 citations

Explanation of the Gibbs paradox within the framework of quantum thermodynamics

ARMEN E. ALLAHVERDYAN, Theo M. Nieuwenhuizen

The issue of the Gibbs paradox is that when considering mixing of two gases within classical thermodynamics, the entropy of mixing appears to be a discontinuous function of the difference between the gases: it is finite for whatever small difference, but vanishes for identical gases. The resolution offered in the literature, with help of quantum mixing entropy, was later shown to be unsatisfactory precisely where it sought to resolve the paradox. Macroscopic thermodynamics, classical or quantum, is unsuitable for explaining the paradox, since it does not deal explicitly with the difference between the gases. The proper approach employs quantum thermodynamics, which deals with finite quantum systems coupled to a large bath and a macroscopic work source. Within quantum thermodynamics, entropy generally loses its dominant place and the target of the paradox is naturally shifted to a decrease of the maximally available work before and after mixing (mixing ergotropy). In contrast to entropy this is an unambiguous quantity. For almost identical gases the mixing ergotropy continuously goes to zero, thus resolving the paradox. In this approach the concept of "difference between the gases" gets a clear operational meaning related to the possibilities of controlling the involved quantum states. Difficulties which prevent resolutions of the paradox in its entropic formulation do not arise here. The mixing ergotropy has several counterintuitive features. It can increase when less precise operations are allowed. In the quantum situation (in contrast to the classical one) the mixing ergotropy can also increase when decreasing the degree of mixing between the gases or when decreasing their distinguishability. These points go against a direct association of physical irreversibility with lack of information.

arXiv:quant-ph/0507145•Physical Review E•Jun 14, 2006•26 citations

Quantum stochastic thermodynamics of macroscopic systems: an algebraic approach

Antoine Rignon-Bret, Cyril Elouard

We build a framework for the thermodynamics of macroscopic quantum systems. In contrast with approaches requiring access to the full density matrix, our framework relies on a coarse-grained description, based on measurement statistics of a few observables. When these observables commute, the outcomes define classical macrostates whose entropy is quantified by observational entropy, accounting for uncertainty about both the macrostate and the microstate within it. We extend this notion to non-commuting observables forming a subalgebra of the operator space, and use Jaynes' principle to define an algebra-dependent entropy interpolating between von Neumann and observational entropies. Given initial and final measurement sets, connected by internal and/or environment-induced dynamics, we derive a second law for the coarse-grained dynamics. Unlike formulations based on von Neumann entropy, our inequality captures irreversibility from both non-unitary environment-induced dynamics and internal equilibration. It takes the usual form of a positive entropy production when the system is initially at internal equilibrium, while correction terms capture nonequilibrium resources ignored by the coarse-graining. We also derive fluctuation theorems for coarse-grained thermodynamic quantities. Along a quasi-static path of measurement schemes, we identify quantum macroscopic notions of work and heat fulfilling the first and second laws, including an additional work contribution from manipulating the algebra to which the system is confined, through external constraints or quantum measurement backaction. Finally, we apply our framework to examples illustrating the impact of varying the coarse-graining scheme. Our approach unifies macroscopic and stochastic thermodynamics in a genuinely quantum framework, laying the basis for a versatile, experimentally friendly toolbox to analyze complex quantum dynamics.

quant-pharXiv:2607.09242•Jul 13, 2026•0 citations

Resolution of the Gibbs paradox via quantum thermodynamics

ARMEN E. ALLAHVERDYAN, Theo M. Nieuwenhuizen

The issue of the Gibbs paradox is that when considering the mixing of two gases within classical thermodynamics, the entropy of mixing is a discontinuous function of the difference between the gases: it is finite for no matter how small difference, but vanishes for identical gases. The resolution offered in literature with help of quantum mixing entropy was later on shown to be unsatisfactory precisely where it sought to resolve the paradox. Within quantum thermodynamics entropy looses its dominant place. It is argued that the target of the paradox is shifted to the decrease of the available work upon mixing (mixing work), which in contrast to entropy is an unambiguous quantity. For almost identical gases the mixing work continuously goes to zero, thus resolving the paradox. In this approach the concept of ``difference between the gases'' attains a clear operational meaning related to possibilities of controlling the involved quantum states. The difficulties which prevent the resolution of the paradox in its entropic formulation do not arise here. The mixing work can increase when less precise operations are allowed. In contrast to the classical situation, in the quantum case the amount of mixing work can also increase when decreasing the degree of mixing between the gases, or when decreasing their distinguishability. These points go against a direct quantitative association of physical irreversibility with lack of information.

•Jul 15, 2005•0 citations

Thermodynamics Beyond Equilibrium in Coherent Quantum Systems

Md Manirul Ali, Po-Wen Chen

A central open question in quantum thermodynamics is the identification of thermodynamic entropy away from equilibrium. Although thermodynamic entropy coincides with the von Neumann entropy for a Gibbs state at equilibrium, the thermodynamic role of quantum coherence generated during nonequilibrium evolution remains unclear. Here, we show that von Neumann entropy does not, in general, represent the thermodynamic entropy governing heat exchange in coherent nonequilibrium quantum systems. By integrating the resource theory of quantum coherence with thermodynamic principles, we develop a general framework for nonequilibrium quantum thermodynamics. We identify thermodynamic entropy with the energy entropy derived from energy-measurement statistics and introduce a dynamical temperature extending the equilibrium concept to nonequilibrium states. Consequently, we obtain an exact entropy-balance relation separating the entropy flux associated with heat exchange from the coherence-loss contribution to entropy production, establishing an operational connection between quantum coherence, heat flow, and total entropy change. Unlike approaches relying on equilibrium reference states or stationary Gibbs ensembles, our framework uses instantaneous dynamical quantities and remains valid throughout transient nonequilibrium evolution. It provides consistent dynamical definitions of temperature, work, heat, and free energy. Applying the formalism to an exactly solvable open quantum system, we show that the first and second laws hold throughout transient evolution and that equilibrium thermodynamics emerges dynamically in the weak-coupling long-time limit. Our results establish a unified framework for coherent nonequilibrium quantum thermodynamics and suggest opportunities for controlling heat dissipation through coherence engineering in quantum thermal technologies.

quant-pharXiv:2602.09074•APL Quantum•Feb 10, 2026•0 citations

Gibbs Paradox And Equivalence Relation Between Quantum Information And Work.

Lev B. Levitin

The physical meaning of the entropy defect and information in quantum systems is analyzed in connection with Gibbs paradox and the M(uimLun work obtainable by use of a non-equilibrium system. The question is studied of the maximum amount of heat that can be converted into mechanical work in the process of isothermic mixing of two gases, whose molecules differ only in their quantum states, having non-commuting density matrices. It is shown that schemes for producing work that involve direct discrimination of nonorthogonal states (such as the method of semipermeable partitions) yield an amount of work that is determined not by the entropy ddect. but by the information in the system about its state, which reflects the fundamental irreversibility of the measurement process. An equivalence relation is suggested between quantum information and work.

Workshop on Physics and Computation (PhysComp)•Aug 24, 2005•6 citations
The mixing of two different gases is one of the most common natural phenomena, with applications ranging from CO2_22​ capture to water purification. Traditionally, mixing is analyzed in the context of local thermal equilibrium, where systems exchange energy with a heat bath. Here, we study mixing in an isolated system with potentially non-equilibrium initial states, characterized solely by macroscopic observables. We identify the entropy of mixing as a special case of observational entropy within an observer-dependent framework, where both entropy and extractable work depend on the resolution of measurement. This approach naturally resolves the Gibbs mixing paradox in quantum systems: while an observer experiences a discontinuous increase in entropy upon learning of the existence of two particle types, this knowledge does not provide an advantage in work extraction if the types of particles remain operationally indistinguishable in their measurements. Finally, we derive a Landauer-like bound on the difference in energy extracted by two observers, where an "observational temperature" emerges, determined by the accessible information. These results provide a foundation for rigorously determining the energy required to unmix in non-equilibrium settings and extend beyond quantum systems, offering insights into the thermodynamics of isolated classical gases.
The classical Gibbs paradox concerns the entropy change upon mixing two gases. Whether an observer assigns an entropy increase to the process depends on their ability to distinguish the gases. A resolution is that an "ignorant" observer, who cannot distinguish the gases, has no way of extracting work by mixing them. Moving the thought experiment into the quantum realm, we reveal new and surprising behaviour: the ignorant observer can extract work from mixing different gases, even if the gases cannot be directly distinguished. Moreover, in the macroscopic limit, the quantum case diverges from the classical ideal gas: as much work can be extracted as if the gases were fully distinguishable. We show that the ignorant observer assigns more microstates to the system than found by naive counting in semiclassical statistical mechanics. This demonstrates the importance of accounting for the level of knowledge of an observer, and its implications for genuinely quantum modifications to thermodynamics.
The issue of the Gibbs paradox is that when considering mixing of two gases within classical thermodynamics, the entropy of mixing appears to be a discontinuous function of the difference between the gases: it is finite for whatever small difference, but vanishes for identical gases. The resolution offered in the literature, with help of quantum mixing entropy, was later shown to be unsatisfactory precisely where it sought to resolve the paradox. Macroscopic thermodynamics, classical or quantum, is unsuitable for explaining the paradox, since it does not deal explicitly with the difference between the gases. The proper approach employs quantum thermodynamics, which deals with finite quantum systems coupled to a large bath and a macroscopic work source. Within quantum thermodynamics, entropy generally loses its dominant place and the target of the paradox is naturally shifted to a decrease of the maximally available work before and after mixing (mixing ergotropy). In contrast to entropy this is an unambiguous quantity. For almost identical gases the mixing ergotropy continuously goes to zero, thus resolving the paradox. In this approach the concept of "difference between the gases" gets a clear operational meaning related to the possibilities of controlling the involved quantum states. Difficulties which prevent resolutions of the paradox in its entropic formulation do not arise here. The mixing ergotropy has several counterintuitive features. It can increase when less precise operations are allowed. In the quantum situation (in contrast to the classical one) the mixing ergotropy can also increase when decreasing the degree of mixing between the gases or when decreasing their distinguishability. These points go against a direct association of physical irreversibility with lack of information.
We build a framework for the thermodynamics of macroscopic quantum systems. In contrast with approaches requiring access to the full density matrix, our framework relies on a coarse-grained description, based on measurement statistics of a few observables. When these observables commute, the outcomes define classical macrostates whose entropy is quantified by observational entropy, accounting for uncertainty about both the macrostate and the microstate within it. We extend this notion to non-commuting observables forming a subalgebra of the operator space, and use Jaynes' principle to define an algebra-dependent entropy interpolating between von Neumann and observational entropies. Given initial and final measurement sets, connected by internal and/or environment-induced dynamics, we derive a second law for the coarse-grained dynamics. Unlike formulations based on von Neumann entropy, our inequality captures irreversibility from both non-unitary environment-induced dynamics and internal equilibration. It takes the usual form of a positive entropy production when the system is initially at internal equilibrium, while correction terms capture nonequilibrium resources ignored by the coarse-graining. We also derive fluctuation theorems for coarse-grained thermodynamic quantities. Along a quasi-static path of measurement schemes, we identify quantum macroscopic notions of work and heat fulfilling the first and second laws, including an additional work contribution from manipulating the algebra to which the system is confined, through external constraints or quantum measurement backaction. Finally, we apply our framework to examples illustrating the impact of varying the coarse-graining scheme. Our approach unifies macroscopic and stochastic thermodynamics in a genuinely quantum framework, laying the basis for a versatile, experimentally friendly toolbox to analyze complex quantum dynamics.
The issue of the Gibbs paradox is that when considering the mixing of two gases within classical thermodynamics, the entropy of mixing is a discontinuous function of the difference between the gases: it is finite for no matter how small difference, but vanishes for identical gases. The resolution offered in literature with help of quantum mixing entropy was later on shown to be unsatisfactory precisely where it sought to resolve the paradox. Within quantum thermodynamics entropy looses its dominant place. It is argued that the target of the paradox is shifted to the decrease of the available work upon mixing (mixing work), which in contrast to entropy is an unambiguous quantity. For almost identical gases the mixing work continuously goes to zero, thus resolving the paradox. In this approach the concept of ``difference between the gases'' attains a clear operational meaning related to possibilities of controlling the involved quantum states. The difficulties which prevent the resolution of the paradox in its entropic formulation do not arise here. The mixing work can increase when less precise operations are allowed. In contrast to the classical situation, in the quantum case the amount of mixing work can also increase when decreasing the degree of mixing between the gases, or when decreasing their distinguishability. These points go against a direct quantitative association of physical irreversibility with lack of information.
A central open question in quantum thermodynamics is the identification of thermodynamic entropy away from equilibrium. Although thermodynamic entropy coincides with the von Neumann entropy for a Gibbs state at equilibrium, the thermodynamic role of quantum coherence generated during nonequilibrium evolution remains unclear. Here, we show that von Neumann entropy does not, in general, represent the thermodynamic entropy governing heat exchange in coherent nonequilibrium quantum systems. By integrating the resource theory of quantum coherence with thermodynamic principles, we develop a general framework for nonequilibrium quantum thermodynamics. We identify thermodynamic entropy with the energy entropy derived from energy-measurement statistics and introduce a dynamical temperature extending the equilibrium concept to nonequilibrium states. Consequently, we obtain an exact entropy-balance relation separating the entropy flux associated with heat exchange from the coherence-loss contribution to entropy production, establishing an operational connection between quantum coherence, heat flow, and total entropy change. Unlike approaches relying on equilibrium reference states or stationary Gibbs ensembles, our framework uses instantaneous dynamical quantities and remains valid throughout transient nonequilibrium evolution. It provides consistent dynamical definitions of temperature, work, heat, and free energy. Applying the formalism to an exactly solvable open quantum system, we show that the first and second laws hold throughout transient evolution and that equilibrium thermodynamics emerges dynamically in the weak-coupling long-time limit. Our results establish a unified framework for coherent nonequilibrium quantum thermodynamics and suggest opportunities for controlling heat dissipation through coherence engineering in quantum thermal technologies.
The physical meaning of the entropy defect and information in quantum systems is analyzed in connection with Gibbs paradox and the M(uimLun work obtainable by use of a non-equilibrium system. The question is studied of the maximum amount of heat that can be converted into mechanical work in the process of isothermic mixing of two gases, whose molecules differ only in their quantum states, having non-commuting density matrices. It is shown that schemes for producing work that involve direct discrimination of nonorthogonal states (such as the method of semipermeable partitions) yield an amount of work that is determined not by the entropy ddect. but by the information in the system about its state, which reflects the fundamental irreversibility of the measurement process. An equivalence relation is suggested between quantum information and work.