arXiv:2506.05545

Towards objectivity of classical reference frames in quantum mechanics

Rafał Ćwiek, Jarosław K. Korbicz

Published Jun 5, 2025• 0 citations

Abstract

Recent advances in our understanding of foundations of quantum mechanics have shown that information can be made objective through quantum states. Such objectification processes, predicted e.g. in a variety of quantum open systems, must accompany any realistic quantum-to-classical transition mechanism in order to reproduce the objective character of the classical limit of our world. However, so far only examples of simple, unstructured information, such as a value of an observable, have been studied. In this work we show that a more complicated form of information, given by a Cartesian reference frame, can also be made (at least partially) objective in quantum mechanics. The non-trivial internal gauge structure of reference frames, given by the transformation group, leads to a more general form of objectivity, where all observers see the same but modulo their relative orientations, like it happens in modern understanding of geometry. This opens a way to extend quantum objectivity beyond simple scenarios and possibly link it to the foundations of modern geometry.

DOI: 10.48550/arxiv.2506.05545

Related papers

Quantum Reference Frames and Quantum Transformations

M. Toller

A quantum frame is defined by a material object subject to the laws of quantum mechanics. The present paper studies the relations between quantum frames, which in the classical case are described by elements of the Poincare' group. The possibility of using a suitable quantum group is examined, but some arguments are given which show that a different mathematical structure is necessary. Some simple examples in lower dimensional spacetimes are treated. They indicate the necessity of taking into account some "internal" degrees of freedom of the quantum frames, that can be disregarded in a classical treatment.

arXiv:gr-qc/9605052Nuovo cimento della Società italiana di fisica. A, Nuclei, particles and fieldsMay 24, 19965 citations

Operational Quantum Reference Frame Transformations

Titouan Carette, Jan Glowacki, Leon Loveridge

Quantum reference frames are needed in quantum theory for much the same reasons that reference frames are in classical theories: to manifest invariance in line with fundamental relativity principles and to provide a basis for the definition of observable quantities. Though around since the 1960s, and used in a wide range of applications, only recently has the means for transforming descriptions between different quantum reference frames been tackled in detail. In this work, we provide a general, operationally motivated framework for quantum reference frames and their transformations, holding for locally compact groups. The work is built around the notion of operational equivalence, in which quantum states that cannot be physically distinguished are identified. For example, we describe the collection of relative observables as a subspace of the algebra of invariants on the composite of system and frame, and from here the set of relative states is constructed through the identification of states which cannot be distinguished by relative observables. Through the notion of framed observables – the formation of joint observables of system and frame – of which the relative observables can be understood as examples, quantum reference frame transformations are then maps between equivalence classes of relative states which respect the framing. We give an explicit realisation in the setting that the initial frame admits a highly localized state with respect to the frame observable. The transformations are invertible exactly when the final frame also has such a localizability property. The procedure we present is in operational agreement with other recent inequivalent constructions on the domain of common applicability, but extends them in a number of ways, and weakens claims of entanglement generation through frame changes.

arXiv:2303.14002QuantumMar 27, 202522 citations

Relative subsystems and quantum reference frame transformations

Esteban Castro-Ruiz, Ognyan Oreshkov

Recently there has been much effort in developing a quantum generalisation of reference frame transformations. Despite important progress, a complete understanding of their principles is still lacking. Here we derive quantum reference frame transformations for a broad range of symmetry groups from first principles, using only standard quantum theory. Our framework, naturally based on incoherent rather than coherent group averaging, yields reversible transformations that only depend on the reference frames and system of interest. We find more general transformations than those studied so far, which are valid only in a restricted subspace. Our framework contains additional degrees of freedom in the form of an "extra particle", which carries information about the quantum features of reference frame states. We study the centrally extended Galilei group specifically, highlighting key differences from previous proposals.

Communications PhysicsApr 30, 202518 citations

Relative subsystems and quantum reference frame transformations

Esteban Castro-Ruiz, Ognyan Oreshkov

Recently there has been much effort in developing a quantum generalisation of reference frame transformations. Despite important progress, a complete understanding of their principles is still lacking. In particular, we argue that previous proposals could yield reversible transformations between arbitrary quantum reference frames only when applied to the whole universe. In contrast, here we derive quantum reference frame transformations from first principles, using only standard quantum theory. Our framework, naturally based on incoherent rather than coherent group averaging, yields reversible transformations that only depend on the reference frames and system of interest. We find more general transformations than those studied so far, which are valid only in a restricted subspace. Importantly, our framework contains additional degrees of freedom in the form of an "extra particle," which carries information about the quantum features of reference frame states. Our formalism is valid for a broad range of symmetry groups. We study the centrally extended Galilei group specifically, highlighting key differences from previous proposals.

arXiv:2110.13199Oct 25, 20214 citations

Towards a Quantum Erlangen Program

Matthew J. Lake

The classical Erlangen Program sought to classify metric spaces entirely in terms of their symmetries. In physical spacetimes, these symmetries define transformations between classical reference frames, yielding a one-to-one correspondence between frame transformations and the underlying geometry. More recently, the classical notion of an ideal frame has been extended to the quantum regime, by considering observers as embodied physical systems, subject to the laws of quantum mechanics. Here, we build on this approach, but outline an alternative definition of the term ‘quantum reference frame’, which differs somewhat from the mainstream view. We then show how the new definition can be used to construct a simple model of Planck-scale spacetime, which makes contact with existing quantum gravity phenomenology. Finally, we show how classical spacetime symmetries can be ‘mathematically preserved but operationally broken’ using the new model, suggesting that quantum spacetime may be classified, at least locally, in terms of transformations between quantised frames of reference. This work is based on a talk given at the 13th Bolyai–Gauss–Lobachevsky Conference on Non-Euclidean Geometry in Oujda, Morocco, in May 2025.

arXiv:2609.09167UniverseMar 16, 20261 citation

(Quantum) reference frames, relational observables, gauge reduction and physical interpretation

Thomas Thiemann

It is mandatory to know how to operationally define and translate a reference frame into mathematics, in order that a physical interpretation of theory calculations in terms of observational data is possible. The situation is particularly challenging for gauge systems such as General Relativity where spacetime coordinates are subject to spacetime diffeomorphisms considered as gauge transformations turning coordinates into non-observables. This motivates the idea of operationally defined (material) reference frames which specify coordinates in terms of matter or geometry reference fields leading to the concept of relational observables, relational reference frames and gauge reduction. Upon quantisation, all fields become operator valued distributions. Now new conceptual and technical questions arise such as: Should one reduce before or after quantisation and how are the reference fields quantised respectively in either route? Is a reference frame itself subject to quantisation and how are different quantum reference frames related? How does the gauge reduction fit into this, i.e. how can it be that a certain reference field is considered a non-observable in one reference frame and an observable in another which upon quantisation even displays fluctuations? How precisely are gauge dependent fields interpreted in terms of the relational observables in a given reference frame? What is the relative dynamics, e.g. how exactly are physical Hamiltonians of two relational reference frames related? The present conceptual work addresses these and related questions in a non-perturbative field theory context of sufficient generality to cover General Relativity coupled to standard matter. A central role is played by the concept of the relational reference frame transformation (RRFT) for which a general formula is derived and its properties are explored.

quant-pharXiv:2603.04072Mar 5, 2026