Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2505.21455 · SciPost Physics Core

Pair binding and Hund’s rule breaking in high-symmetry fullerenes

Roman Rausch, Christoph Karrasch

Published Jan 20, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Highly-symmetric molecules often exhibit degenerate tight-binding states at the Fermi edge. This typically results in a magnetic ground state if small interactions are introduced in accordance with Hund’s rule. In some cases, Hund’s rule may be broken, which signals pair binding and goes hand-in-hand with an attractive pair-binding energy. We investigate pair binding and Hund’s rule breaking for the Hubbard model on high-symmetry fullerenes C _{20} 20 , C _{20} 20 , C _{40} 40 , and C _{60} 60 by using large-scale density-matrix renormalization group calculations. We exploit the SU(2) spin symmetry, the U(1) charge symmetry, and optionally the \mathbb{Z}_N ℤ N spatial rotation symmetry of the problem. For C _{20} 20 , our results agree well with available exact-diagonalization data, but our approach is numerically much cheaper. We find a Mott transition at U_c\sim2.2t U c ∼ 2.2 t , which is much smaller than the previously reported value of U_c\sim4.1t U c ∼ 4.1 t that was extrapolated from a few datapoints. We compute the pair-binding energy for arbitrary values of U U and observe that it remains overall repulsive. For larger fullerenes, we are not able to evaluate the pair binding energy with sufficient precision, but we can still investigate Hund’s rule breaking. For C _{28} 28 , we find that Hund’s rule is fulfilled with a magnetic spin-2 ground state that transitions to a spin-1 state at U_{c,1}\sim 5.4t U c , 1 ∼ 5.4 t before the eventual Mott transition to a spin singlet takes place at U_{c,2}\sim 11.6t U c , 2 ∼ 11.6 t . For C _{40} 40 , Hund’s rule is broken in the singlet ground state at half filling, but is restored if the system is doped with one electron. Hund’s ru

DOI
10.21468/scipostphyscore.9.1.003

Related papers

Extended Hubbard model on a C20molecule

Fei Lin, Erik Schwartz Sørensen, Catherine Kallin +1 more

The electronic correlations on a C 20 molecule, as described by an extended Hubbard Hamiltonian with a nearest-neighbor Coulomb interaction of strength V , are studied using quantum Monte Carlo and exact diagonalization methods. For electron-doped C 20 , it is known that pair binding arising from a purely electronic mechanism is absent within the standard Hubbard model ( V = 0). Here we show that this is also the case for hole doping for 0< U / t ≤3 and that, for both electron and hole doping, the effect of a non-zero V is to work against pair binding. We also study the magnetic properties of the neutral molecule, and find transitions between spin singlet and triplet ground states for either fixed U or V values. In addition, spin, charge and pairing correlation functions on C 20 are computed. The spin–spin and charge–charge correlations are very short-range, although a weak enhancement in the pairing correlation is observed for a distance equal to the molecular diameter.

arXiv:0706.0331•Journal of Physics Condensed Matter•Oct 11, 2007•8 citations

Pairing tendencies in a two-orbital Hubbard model in one dimension

N. D. Patel, Alberto Nocera, Gonzalo Álvarez +2 more

The recent discovery of superconductivity under high pressure in the ladder compound ${\mathrm{BaFe}}_{2}{\mathrm{S}}_{3}$ has opened a new field of research in iron-based superconductors with focus on quasi-one-dimensional geometries. In this publication, using the density matrix renormalization group technique, we study a two-orbital Hubbard model defined in one-dimensional chains. Our main result is the presence of hole binding tendencies at intermediate Hubbard $U$ repulsion and robust Hund coupling ${J}_{H}/U=0.25$. Binding does not occur either in weak coupling or at very strong coupling. The pair-pair correlations that are dominant near half-filling, or of similar strength as the charge and spin correlation channels, involve hole-pair operators that are spin singlets, use nearest-neighbor sites, and employ different orbitals for each hole. The Hund coupling strength, presence of robust magnetic moments, and antiferromagnetic correlations among them are important for the binding tendencies found here.

arXiv:1705.08780•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jul 31, 2017•30 citations

Excitonic phases in the two-orbital Hubbard model: Roles of Hund's rule coupling

Tatsuya Kaneko, Y. Ohta

Excitonic phases described by the quantum condensation of electron-hole pairs (or excitons) are studied in the two-orbital Hubbard model with the Hund's rule coupling J . Using the variational cluster approximation, we calculate the ground-state energy and order parameters, and show that the Hund's rule coupling always stabilizes the excitonic spin-density- wave state and destabilizes the excitonic charge-density-wave state. The pair coherence lengths calculated in the spin-singlet and spin-triplet states indicate that only the spin-triplet excitons are paired more tightly with increasing J . The single-particle spectrum and density of states are also calculated to clarify the characters of these excitonic density-wave states.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Mar 18, 2015•1 citation

Hund and anti-Hund rules in circular molecules

Marian Niţă, Mugurel Tolea, D. C. Marinescu +1 more

We study the validity of Hund's first rule for the spin multiplicity in circular molecules---made of real or artificial atoms such as quantum dots---by considering a perturbative approach in the Coulomb interaction in the extended Hubbard model with both on-site and long-range interactions. In this approximation, we show that an anti-Hund rule always defines the ground state in a molecule with $4N$ atoms at half-filling. In all other cases (i.e., number of atoms not a multiple of four, or a $4N$ molecule away from half-filling) both the singlet and the triplet outcomes are possible, as determined primarily by the total number of electrons in the system. In some instances, the Hund rule is always obeyed and the triplet ground state is realized mathematically for any values of the on-site and long-range interactions, while for other filling situations the singlet is also possible but only if the long-range interactions exceed a certain threshold, relatively to the on-site interaction.

arXiv:1711.06001•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 1, 2017•3 citations

Pair binding in small Hubbard-model molecules

Steven R. White, Sudip Chakravarty, Martin P. Gelfand +1 more

We calculate exact ground-state energies for small Hubbard-model clusters (molecules) and show that two electrons added to a molecule can experience an effective attraction despite their bare repulsive interaction (pair binding). This phenomenon takes place IonlyP for intermediate strength of the repulsive interactions, and on intermediate length scales. All the results are in qualitative agreement with those obtained using second-order perturbation theory up to surprisingly large values of the interactions and provide support for a purely electronic mechanism of superconductivity in doped ${\mathrm{C}}_{60}$.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Mar 1, 1992•65 citations

Exchange interaction as the source of pairing in correlated electron systems: a brief overview

Józef Spałek

We address the question of real space pairing induced by exchange interaction, customarily associated with the presence of the broken-symmetry magnetism. For such mechanism of pairing, the appearance of superconductivity (or superfluidity) without magnetism presents itself still as a highly nontrivial problem and it seems, it can be practically realized only when the kinetic energy of individual-particle motion is comparable or even smaller than the magnitude of exchange interaction that takes place among strongly correlated fermions , where the kinetic exchange and/or the Hund's rule coupling can become relatively strong in the vicinity of the onset of the Mott insulating state. In that situation, the pairing arises from a coherent correlated pair motion rather than from a free motion of a tightly bound pair. We elaborate on this question in general terms, as well as provide selected results in the mean-field approximation in concrete situations.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jul 6, 2011•0 citations
Highly-symmetric molecules often exhibit degenerate tight-binding states at the Fermi edge. This typically results in a magnetic ground state if small interactions are introduced in accordance with Hund’s rule. In some cases, Hund’s rule may be broken, which signals pair binding and goes hand-in-hand with an attractive pair-binding energy. We investigate pair binding and Hund’s rule breaking for the Hubbard model on high-symmetry fullerenes C _{20} 20 , C _{20} 20 , C _{40} 40 , and C _{60} 60 by using large-scale density-matrix renormalization group calculations. We exploit the SU(2) spin symmetry, the U(1) charge symmetry, and optionally the \mathbb{Z}_N ℤ N spatial rotation symmetry of the problem. For C {20} 20 , our results agree well with available exact-diagonalization data, but our approach is numerically much cheaper. We find a Mott transition at U_c\sim2.2t U c ∼ 2.2 t , which is much smaller than the previously reported value of U_c\sim4.1t U c ∼ 4.1 t that was extrapolated from a few datapoints. We compute the pair-binding energy for arbitrary values of U U and observe that it remains overall repulsive. For larger fullerenes, we are not able to evaluate the pair binding energy with sufficient precision, but we can still investigate Hund’s rule breaking. For C {28} 28 , we find that Hund’s rule is fulfilled with a magnetic spin-2 ground state that transitions to a spin-1 state at U{c,1}\sim 5.4t U c , 1 ∼ 5.4 t before the eventual Mott transition to a spin singlet takes place at U{c,2}\sim 11.6t U c , 2 ∼ 11.6 t . For C _{40} 40 , Hund’s rule is broken in the singlet ground state at half filling, but is restored if the system is doped with one electron. Hund’s ru
The electronic correlations on a C 20 molecule, as described by an extended Hubbard Hamiltonian with a nearest-neighbor Coulomb interaction of strength V , are studied using quantum Monte Carlo and exact diagonalization methods. For electron-doped C 20 , it is known that pair binding arising from a purely electronic mechanism is absent within the standard Hubbard model ( V = 0). Here we show that this is also the case for hole doping for 0< U / t ≤3 and that, for both electron and hole doping, the effect of a non-zero V is to work against pair binding. We also study the magnetic properties of the neutral molecule, and find transitions between spin singlet and triplet ground states for either fixed U or V values. In addition, spin, charge and pairing correlation functions on C 20 are computed. The spin–spin and charge–charge correlations are very short-range, although a weak enhancement in the pairing correlation is observed for a distance equal to the molecular diameter.
The recent discovery of superconductivity under high pressure in the ladder compound BaFe2S3{\mathrm{BaFe}}_{2}{\mathrm{S}}_{3}BaFe2​S3​ has opened a new field of research in iron-based superconductors with focus on quasi-one-dimensional geometries. In this publication, using the density matrix renormalization group technique, we study a two-orbital Hubbard model defined in one-dimensional chains. Our main result is the presence of hole binding tendencies at intermediate Hubbard UUU repulsion and robust Hund coupling JH/U=0.25{J}_{H}/U=0.25JH​/U=0.25. Binding does not occur either in weak coupling or at very strong coupling. The pair-pair correlations that are dominant near half-filling, or of similar strength as the charge and spin correlation channels, involve hole-pair operators that are spin singlets, use nearest-neighbor sites, and employ different orbitals for each hole. The Hund coupling strength, presence of robust magnetic moments, and antiferromagnetic correlations among them are important for the binding tendencies found here.
Excitonic phases described by the quantum condensation of electron-hole pairs (or excitons) are studied in the two-orbital Hubbard model with the Hund's rule coupling J . Using the variational cluster approximation, we calculate the ground-state energy and order parameters, and show that the Hund's rule coupling always stabilizes the excitonic spin-density- wave state and destabilizes the excitonic charge-density-wave state. The pair coherence lengths calculated in the spin-singlet and spin-triplet states indicate that only the spin-triplet excitons are paired more tightly with increasing J . The single-particle spectrum and density of states are also calculated to clarify the characters of these excitonic density-wave states.
We study the validity of Hund's first rule for the spin multiplicity in circular molecules---made of real or artificial atoms such as quantum dots---by considering a perturbative approach in the Coulomb interaction in the extended Hubbard model with both on-site and long-range interactions. In this approximation, we show that an anti-Hund rule always defines the ground state in a molecule with 4N4N4N atoms at half-filling. In all other cases (i.e., number of atoms not a multiple of four, or a 4N4N4N molecule away from half-filling) both the singlet and the triplet outcomes are possible, as determined primarily by the total number of electrons in the system. In some instances, the Hund rule is always obeyed and the triplet ground state is realized mathematically for any values of the on-site and long-range interactions, while for other filling situations the singlet is also possible but only if the long-range interactions exceed a certain threshold, relatively to the on-site interaction.
We calculate exact ground-state energies for small Hubbard-model clusters (molecules) and show that two electrons added to a molecule can experience an effective attraction despite their bare repulsive interaction (pair binding). This phenomenon takes place IonlyP for intermediate strength of the repulsive interactions, and on intermediate length scales. All the results are in qualitative agreement with those obtained using second-order perturbation theory up to surprisingly large values of the interactions and provide support for a purely electronic mechanism of superconductivity in doped C60{\mathrm{C}}_{60}C60​.
We address the question of real space pairing induced by exchange interaction, customarily associated with the presence of the broken-symmetry magnetism. For such mechanism of pairing, the appearance of superconductivity (or superfluidity) without magnetism presents itself still as a highly nontrivial problem and it seems, it can be practically realized only when the kinetic energy of individual-particle motion is comparable or even smaller than the magnitude of exchange interaction that takes place among strongly correlated fermions , where the kinetic exchange and/or the Hund's rule coupling can become relatively strong in the vicinity of the onset of the Mott insulating state. In that situation, the pairing arises from a coherent correlated pair motion rather than from a free motion of a tightly bound pair. We elaborate on this question in general terms, as well as provide selected results in the mean-field approximation in concrete situations.