Large amplitude mechanical coherent states and detection of weak nonlinearities in cavity optomechanics
Wenlin Li, Paolo Piergentili, Francesco Marzioni, M. Bonaldi, A. Borrielli, Enrico Serra, Francesco Marin, Francesco Marino, Nicola Malossi, Riccardo Natali, Giovanni Di Giuseppe, David Vitali
Abstract The generation of large-amplitude coherent states of a massive mechanical resonator, and their quantum-limited detection represent useful tools for quantum sensing and for testing fundamental physics theories. In fact, any weak perturbation may affect the coherent quantum evolution of the prepared state, providing a sensitive probe for such a perturbation. Here we consider a cavity optomechanical setup and the case of the detection of a weak mechanical nonlinearity. We consider different strategies, first focusing on the stationary dynamics in the presence of multiple tones driving the system, and then focusing on non-equilibrium dynamical strategies. These methods can be successfully applied for measuring Duffing-like material nonlinearities, or effective nonlinear corrections associated with quantum gravity theories.
Abstract The generation of large-amplitude coherent states of a massive mechanical resonator, and their quantum-limited detection represent useful tools for quantum sensing and for testing fundamental physics theories. In fact, any weak perturbation may affect the coherent quantum evolution of the prepared state, providing a sensitive probe for such a perturbation. Here we consider a cavity optomechanical setup and the case of the detection of a weak mechanical nonlinearity. We consider different strategies, first focusing on the stationary dynamics in the presence of multiple tones driving the system, and then focusing on non-equilibrium dynamical strategies. These methods can be successfully applied for measuring Duffing-like material nonlinearities, or effective nonlinear corrections associated with quantum gravity theories.
Cavity optomechanics has become an established and equally promising branch in quantum optics. Thanks to the interaction between matter and electromagnetic radiation, it has proved to be an optimal platform for a range of scopes, from weak force sensing to the study of non-classicality of mechanical motion. Besides, the capability to isolate genuine quantum features of the interaction represents a test ground to address many important questions regarding decoherence, quantum-to-classical transitions and the interface between quantum mechanics and gravity. The first part of the research embedded in this thesis is addressed towards the clear identification and characterisation of quantum features in optomechanics. The main model we will refer to is a deformable Fabry-P\'erot cavity where one of the two mirrors moves under the radiation pressure of light. After having properly assessed the quantum peculiarities of the system, and also having revised some intakes from past literature, we will focus on the study of mechanical non-linearities, as they have been proved to be a key resource to bring out and enhance quantum properties. These investigations provide the basis to eventually propose a method to deterministically prepare and measure macroscopic quantum superposition states of the movable mirror. Such massive quantum states play a key role to inspect the foundations of physics, e.g. to test the collapse of the wave function and phenomenological models of quantum gravity, as well as to develop new enhanced quantum technologies.
Cavity optomechanics originated from the research of interferometric detection of gravitational waves, and later became a fast-growing area of techniques and approaches ranging from the fields of atomic, molecular, and optical physics to nano-science and condensed matter physics as well. Recently, it focused on the exploration of operating mechanical oscillators deep in the quantum regime, with an interest ranging from quantum-classical interface tests to high-precision quantum metrology. In this paper, recent theoretical work of our group in the field of quantum measurement with cavity optomechanical systems is reviewed. We explore the quantum measurement theory and its applications with several unconventional cavity optomechanical schemes working in the quantum regime. This review covers the basics of quantum noises in the cavity optomechanical setups and the resulting standard quantum limit of precision displacement and force measurement. Three novel quantum measurement proposals based on the hybrid optomechanical system are introduced. First, we describe a quantum back-action insulated weak force sensor. It is realized by forming a quantum-mechanics-free subsystem with two optomechanical oscillators of reversed effective mass. Then we introduce a role-reversed atomic optomechanical system which enables the preparation and the quantum tomography of a variety of non-classical states of atoms. In this system, the cavity field acts as a mechanical oscillator driven by the radiation pressure force from an ultracold atomic field. In the end, we recommend a multimode optomechanical transducer that can detect intensities significantly below the single-photon level via adiabatic transfer of the microwave signal to the optical frequency domain. These proposals demonstrate the possible applications of optomechanical devices in understanding of quantum-classical crossover and in achieving quantum measurement limit.
The study of force sensitivity based on a cavity optomechanical system plays a prominent role in quantum precision measurement and provides an ideal platform for precision sensing technology. Here, we propose a scheme to enhance the force sensitivity of a dissipatively coupled optomechanical system by inducing Duffing nonlinearity. The numerical analysis shows that inducing Duffing nonlinearity significantly improves the force sensitivity compared to the system without Duffing nonlinearity, even surpassing the standard quantum limit (SQL) by more than five orders of magnitude. Moreover, we demonstrated that the sensitivity of force sensing is robust to temperature when Duffing nonlinearity is induced. More interestingly, the induction of Duffing nonlinearity broadens the detection bandwidth. At the same time, the detection frequency below the SQL also experiences a significant frequency shift with changes in the nonlinear amplitude. Our scheme not only holds potential for applications in quantum manipulation but also realizes macroscopic quantum effects.
We propose a sensing scheme for detecting weak forces that achieves Heisenberg-limited sensitivity without relying on entanglement or other non-classical resources. Our scheme utilizes coherent averaging across a chain of N optomechanical cavities, unidirectionally coupled via a laser beam. As the beam passes through the cavities, it accumulates phase shifts induced by a common external force acting on the mechanical elements. Remarkably, this fully classical approach achieves the sensitivity scaling typically associated with quantum-enhanced protocols, providing a robust and experimentally feasible route to precision sensing. Potential applications range from high-sensitivity gravitational field measurements at the Large Hadron Collider to probing dark matter interactions and detecting gravitational waves. This work opens a new pathway for leveraging coherent light-matter interactions for force sensing.
The field of cavity optomechanics is based on the coupling of optical cavities to mechanical degrees of freedom. Over the past two decades, it has led to remarkable and surprising discoveries. A cavity optomechanical system enabled the first observation of gravitational waves, a discovery awarded with the 2017 Nobel prize, confirming Einstein's 100-year-old prediction. It was also a cavity optomechanical system that has for the first time enabled ground state cooling of the motion of an object containing ~1012 atoms, and entanglement of mechanical oscillators of similar size. Moreover, cavity optomechanical systems have facilitated significant progress in precision-sensing technologies, with diverse applications such as biosensing, magnetometry, and many more.But this may only be the beginning. The field is still in its early days and experimental capabilities are improving fast. For instance, cavity optomechanical systems have the potential to test predicted signatures of quantum gravity such as modifications to the canonical commutator, short-distance modifications to Newtonian gravity, dark matter and dark energy, and even extra dimensions. In this sense, they form an economical platform with a short experimental turnover time, that can compete in its predictive power with mega-scale, multi-billion-dollar experiments such as the Large Hadron Collider.This thesis is dedicated to utilizing cavity optomechanics to explore the maybe most challenging and unexplored frontier in quantum mechanics: The dynamics of macroscopic quantum systems. Quantum physics, since its discovery in the early 20th century, has revolutionized our understanding of the microworld, but has long been thought to apply exclusively to extremely small objects. However, over the past decades, ever-larger quantum systems have emerged in laboratories around the world. On one hand, these are collective, macroscopic quantum phenomena such as superfluidity, superconductivity, and Bose-Einstein condensation. On the other hand, they are quantum states of relatively massive mechanical objects. While our understanding of the interplay of quantum mechanical and classical systems has greatly improved over the past decades, as described by theories of decoherence and open quantum systems, many basic questions about macroscopic quantum systems still remain unanswered. Quantum fluids such as Bose-Einstein condensates and superfluid helium are inherently hard to understand due to their complex dynamics, and difficult to probe experimentally due to the weakness of their interactions with the environment and their fragile nature. This is especially true in the strongly-interacting regime, which is, for instance, found in superfluid helium.Another long-standing, unanswered set of questions in quantum mechanics is related to the quantum measurement problem. What constitutes a quantum measurement? What happens if we engineer a quantum state that is large enough to be, in principle, part of our everyday world? What if we attempt to create a quantum superposition of a living being? Do the laws of physics even permit either of these scenarios?Cavity optomechanics is a unique and powerful platform to investigate macroscopic quantum systems. The extreme sensitivity of cavity optomechanical sensors in readout of mechanical motion makes them susceptible to minute quantum effects. The strong coupling between single photons and phonons in these systems allows engineering and measurement of quantum states of mechanical systems. Furthermore, most cavity optomechanical experiments are cryo-compatible and small in size, which allows integration with other quantum systems to be analyzed, such as superfluid helium.
An exciting scientific goal, common to many fields of research, is the development of ever-larger physical systems operating in the quantum regime. Relevant to this dissertation is the objective of preparing and observing a mechanical object in its motional quantum ground state. In order to sense the object's zero-point motion, the probe itself must have quantum-limited sensitivity. Cavity optomechanics, the interactions between light and a mechanical object inside an optical cavity, provides an elegant means to achieve the quantum regime. In this dissertation, I provide context to the successful cavity-based optical detection of the quantum-ground-state motion of atoms-based mechanical elements; mechanical elements, consisting of the collective center-of-mass (CM) motion of ultracold atomic ensembles and prepared inside a high-finesse Fabry-P'erot cavity, were dispersively probed with an average intracavity photon number as small as 0.1. I first show that cavity optomechanics emerges from the theory of cavity quantum electrodynamics when one takes into account the CM motion of one or many atoms within the cavity, and provide a simple theoretical framework to model optomechanical interactions. I then outline details regarding the apparatus and the experimental methods employed, highlighting certain fundamental aspects of optical detection along the way. Finally, I describe background information, both theoretical and experimental, to two published results on quantum cavity optomechanics that form the backbone of this dissertation. The first publication shows the observation of zero-point collective motion of several thousand atoms and quantum-limited measurement backaction on that observed motion. The second publication demonstrates that an array of near-ground-state collective atomic oscillators can be simultaneously prepared and probed, and that the motional state of one oscillator can be selectively addressed while preserving the near-zero-point motion of neighboring oscillators.