Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2501.17693 · Physical Review A

Ultimate bounds for precision of atomic clock frequency measurement: Rabi, Ramsey, and coherent-population-trapping techniques

Stefano Olivares, Salvatore Micalizio, Matteo G. A. Paris

Published Apr 22, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate the ultimate quantum limits to the achievable uncertainty in the estimation of the transition frequency between two atomic levels. We focus on Rabi, Ramsey, and coherent-population-trapping (CPT) techniques, which are widely employed in experiments. We prove that in the Rabi and Ramsey schemes, measuring the atomic population allows one to reach the minimum uncertainty, but for the CPT setup, a measurement involving the coherences between the levels results in a further improvement of the estimation. As a paradigmatic example of possible noises, the effect of cavity coupling fluctuations is considered in the Rabi and Ramsey scenarios. As a figure of merit, we assess the Fisher information of the population measurement and compare its value with the maximum one given by the quantum Fisher information, which is achieved by optimizing over all the possible measurements allowed by quantum mechanics.

DOI
10.1103/gk6v-7ghm

Related papers

Ramsey interferometry with arbitrary coherent-population-trapping pulse sequence

Ruihuan Fang, Chengyin Han, Bo Lü +2 more

Coherent-population trapping (CPT) is a multilevel quantum coherence phenomenon of promising applications in atomic clocks and magnetometers. In particular, multipulse CPT Ramsey interferometry is a powerful tool for improving the performance of CPT atomic clocks. Most studies on multipulse CPT Ramsey interferometry consider periodic pulse sequence and time-independent detuning. However, to further improve the accuracy and precision, one may modify the spectrum symmetry which involves a pulse sequence with time-dependent detuning or phase shift. Here we theoretically analyze the multipulse CPT Ramsey interferometry under arbitrary pulse sequences of time-dependent detuning and obtain a general analytical formula. Using our formula, we analyze the popular CPT Ramsey interferometry schemes such as two-pulse symmetric and antisymmetric spectroscopy and multipulse symmetric and antisymmetric spectroscopy. Under periodic pulses, we quantitatively obtain the influences of pulse width, pulse period, pulse number, and Rabi frequency. Furthermore, we examine the impact of CPT pulses and Rabi frequency on the light shift in both two-pulse and multipulse CPT Ramsey interference. Our theoretical results can guide the experimental design to improve the performance of atomic clocks via multipulse CPT Ramsey interferometry.

arXiv:2303.07118•Physical Review A•Oct 23, 2023•7 citations

Bayesian frequency metrology with optimal Ramsey interferometry in optical atomic clocks

Timm Kielinski, Klemens Hammerer

Frequency metrology is a cornerstone of modern precision measurements and optical atomic clocks have emerged as one of the most precise measurement devices. In this progress report, we explore various Ramsey interrogation schemes tailored to optical atomic clocks primarily limited by laser noise. To incorporate frequency fluctuations directly into the theoretical model, we consider a Bayesian framework. In this context, we review fundamental bounds arising in Bayesian estimation theory, which serve as a benchmark throughout this work. We investigate the trade-off between entanglement-enhanced sensitivity and robustness against laser noise in order to identify optimal initial states, measurement schemes and estimation strategies. Beside standard protocols based on coherent spin states, spin-squeezed states and Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states, we consider variational Ramsey protocols implemented via low-depth quantum circuits based on one-axis twisting operations to approach optimal stability. In particular, we review known and identify new optimal Ramsey interrogation schemes for a variety of scenarios, including different experimental platforms, ensemble sizes and regimes characterized by a wide range of interrogation durations and dead times. Hence, this work establishes a comprehensive theoretical framework for optimizing Ramsey interrogation schemes, providing guidance for the development of next-generation optical atomic clocks.

arXiv:2505.04287•Reports on Progress in Physics•Nov 19, 2025•1 citation

Two-step pulse observation for Raman–Ramsey coherent population trapping atomic clocks

Yuichiro Yano, Shigeyoshi Goka, Masatoshi Kajita

We propose a two-step pulse observation method to enhance the frequency stability of coherent population trapping (CPT) atomic clocks. The proposed method is a Raman–Ramsey scheme with low light intensity at resonance observation and provides a Ramsey-CPT resonance with both reduced frequency sensitivity to the light intensity and a high signal-to-noise ratio by reducing the repumping into a steady dark state. The resonance characteristics were calculated using density matrix analysis of a Λ-type three-level system that was modeled on the 133 Cs D 1 line, and the characteristics were also measured using a vertical-cavity surface-emitting laser and a Cs vapor cell.

arXiv:1411.3779•Applied Physics Express•Dec 11, 2014•8 citations

Ramsey-CPT spectrum with the Faraday effect and its application to atomic clocks

Yuan Tian, Bo-Zhong Tan, Jing Yang +2 more

A method that obtains the Ramsey-coherent population trapping (CPT) spectrum with the Faraday effect is investigated. An experiment is implemented to detect the light polarization components generated from the Faraday effect. The experimental results agree with the theoretical calculations based on the Liouville equation. By comparing with the method without using the Faraday effect, the potential of this method for a CPT-based atomic clock is assessed. The results indicate that this method should improve the short-term frequency stability by several times.

Chinese Physics B•Jun 1, 2015•10 citations

Ramsey interferometry with cold atoms in coherent population trapping

Chengyin Han, Bo Lü, Chaohong Lee

The utilization of Ramsey interferometry via coherent population trapping (CPT), which enables the optical interrogation of microwave transitions without the reliance on microwave cavities, plays a crucial role in the advancement of compact and low-power quantum sensors. Particularly, high-resolution CPT-Ramsey spectroscopy of alkali-metal atoms has found extensive application in constructing miniaturized quantum sensors like atomic magnetometers and atomic clocks. Due to their well-defined environment and extended coherence time, cold atoms offer enhanced sensitivity and precision in CPT-Ramsey interferometry. This review comprehensively examines CPT-Ramsey interferometry with cold atoms, encompassing both conventional and multi-pulse techniques, and explores their potential applications in practical quantum sensors.

Advances in Physics X•Feb 23, 2024•6 citations

Ramsey Spectroscopy with Displaced Frequency Jumps

M. Shuker, J. W. Pollock, Rodolphe Boudot +4 more

Sophisticated Ramsey-based interrogation protocols using composite laser pulse sequences have been recently proposed to provide next-generation high-precision atomic clocks with a near perfect elimination of frequency shifts induced during the atom-probing field interaction. We propose here a simple alternative approach to the autobalanced Ramsey interrogation protocol and demonstrate its application to a cold-atom microwave clock based on coherent population trapping (CPT). The main originality of the method, based on two consecutive Ramsey sequences with different dark periods, is to sample the central Ramsey fringes with frequency jumps finely adjusted by an additional frequency-displacement concomitant parameter, scaling as the inverse of the dark period. The advantage of this displaced frequency-jump Ramsey method is that the local oscillator (LO) frequency is used as a single physical variable to control both servo loops of the sequence, simplifying its implementation and avoiding noise associated with controlling the LO phase. When tested using a CPT cold-atom clock, the DFJR scheme reduces the sensitivity of the clock frequency to variations of the light shifts by more than an order of magnitude compared with the standard Ramsey interrogation. This simple method can be applied in a wide variety of Ramsey-spectroscopy based applications including frequency metrology with CPT-based and optical atomic clocks, mass spectrometry, and precision spectroscopy.

arXiv:1812.01703•Physical Review Letters•Mar 19, 2019•38 citations
We investigate the ultimate quantum limits to the achievable uncertainty in the estimation of the transition frequency between two atomic levels. We focus on Rabi, Ramsey, and coherent-population-trapping (CPT) techniques, which are widely employed in experiments. We prove that in the Rabi and Ramsey schemes, measuring the atomic population allows one to reach the minimum uncertainty, but for the CPT setup, a measurement involving the coherences between the levels results in a further improvement of the estimation. As a paradigmatic example of possible noises, the effect of cavity coupling fluctuations is considered in the Rabi and Ramsey scenarios. As a figure of merit, we assess the Fisher information of the population measurement and compare its value with the maximum one given by the quantum Fisher information, which is achieved by optimizing over all the possible measurements allowed by quantum mechanics.
Coherent-population trapping (CPT) is a multilevel quantum coherence phenomenon of promising applications in atomic clocks and magnetometers. In particular, multipulse CPT Ramsey interferometry is a powerful tool for improving the performance of CPT atomic clocks. Most studies on multipulse CPT Ramsey interferometry consider periodic pulse sequence and time-independent detuning. However, to further improve the accuracy and precision, one may modify the spectrum symmetry which involves a pulse sequence with time-dependent detuning or phase shift. Here we theoretically analyze the multipulse CPT Ramsey interferometry under arbitrary pulse sequences of time-dependent detuning and obtain a general analytical formula. Using our formula, we analyze the popular CPT Ramsey interferometry schemes such as two-pulse symmetric and antisymmetric spectroscopy and multipulse symmetric and antisymmetric spectroscopy. Under periodic pulses, we quantitatively obtain the influences of pulse width, pulse period, pulse number, and Rabi frequency. Furthermore, we examine the impact of CPT pulses and Rabi frequency on the light shift in both two-pulse and multipulse CPT Ramsey interference. Our theoretical results can guide the experimental design to improve the performance of atomic clocks via multipulse CPT Ramsey interferometry.
Frequency metrology is a cornerstone of modern precision measurements and optical atomic clocks have emerged as one of the most precise measurement devices. In this progress report, we explore various Ramsey interrogation schemes tailored to optical atomic clocks primarily limited by laser noise. To incorporate frequency fluctuations directly into the theoretical model, we consider a Bayesian framework. In this context, we review fundamental bounds arising in Bayesian estimation theory, which serve as a benchmark throughout this work. We investigate the trade-off between entanglement-enhanced sensitivity and robustness against laser noise in order to identify optimal initial states, measurement schemes and estimation strategies. Beside standard protocols based on coherent spin states, spin-squeezed states and Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states, we consider variational Ramsey protocols implemented via low-depth quantum circuits based on one-axis twisting operations to approach optimal stability. In particular, we review known and identify new optimal Ramsey interrogation schemes for a variety of scenarios, including different experimental platforms, ensemble sizes and regimes characterized by a wide range of interrogation durations and dead times. Hence, this work establishes a comprehensive theoretical framework for optimizing Ramsey interrogation schemes, providing guidance for the development of next-generation optical atomic clocks.
We propose a two-step pulse observation method to enhance the frequency stability of coherent population trapping (CPT) atomic clocks. The proposed method is a Raman–Ramsey scheme with low light intensity at resonance observation and provides a Ramsey-CPT resonance with both reduced frequency sensitivity to the light intensity and a high signal-to-noise ratio by reducing the repumping into a steady dark state. The resonance characteristics were calculated using density matrix analysis of a Λ-type three-level system that was modeled on the 133 Cs D 1 line, and the characteristics were also measured using a vertical-cavity surface-emitting laser and a Cs vapor cell.
A method that obtains the Ramsey-coherent population trapping (CPT) spectrum with the Faraday effect is investigated. An experiment is implemented to detect the light polarization components generated from the Faraday effect. The experimental results agree with the theoretical calculations based on the Liouville equation. By comparing with the method without using the Faraday effect, the potential of this method for a CPT-based atomic clock is assessed. The results indicate that this method should improve the short-term frequency stability by several times.
The utilization of Ramsey interferometry via coherent population trapping (CPT), which enables the optical interrogation of microwave transitions without the reliance on microwave cavities, plays a crucial role in the advancement of compact and low-power quantum sensors. Particularly, high-resolution CPT-Ramsey spectroscopy of alkali-metal atoms has found extensive application in constructing miniaturized quantum sensors like atomic magnetometers and atomic clocks. Due to their well-defined environment and extended coherence time, cold atoms offer enhanced sensitivity and precision in CPT-Ramsey interferometry. This review comprehensively examines CPT-Ramsey interferometry with cold atoms, encompassing both conventional and multi-pulse techniques, and explores their potential applications in practical quantum sensors.
Sophisticated Ramsey-based interrogation protocols using composite laser pulse sequences have been recently proposed to provide next-generation high-precision atomic clocks with a near perfect elimination of frequency shifts induced during the atom-probing field interaction. We propose here a simple alternative approach to the autobalanced Ramsey interrogation protocol and demonstrate its application to a cold-atom microwave clock based on coherent population trapping (CPT). The main originality of the method, based on two consecutive Ramsey sequences with different dark periods, is to sample the central Ramsey fringes with frequency jumps finely adjusted by an additional frequency-displacement concomitant parameter, scaling as the inverse of the dark period. The advantage of this displaced frequency-jump Ramsey method is that the local oscillator (LO) frequency is used as a single physical variable to control both servo loops of the sequence, simplifying its implementation and avoiding noise associated with controlling the LO phase. When tested using a CPT cold-atom clock, the DFJR scheme reduces the sensitivity of the clock frequency to variations of the light shifts by more than an order of magnitude compared with the standard Ramsey interrogation. This simple method can be applied in a wide variety of Ramsey-spectroscopy based applications including frequency metrology with CPT-based and optical atomic clocks, mass spectrometry, and precision spectroscopy.