arXiv:2501.09625 · Physical Review A

Thermodynamics of coherent energy exchanges between lasers and two-level systems

Ariane Soret, Massimiliano Esposito

Published Jun 2, 2025• 2 citations

Abstract

We study the quantum thermodynamics of a coherent macroscopic electromagnetic field (laser) coupled to a two-level system (qubit) near resonance, from weak- to strong-driving regimes. This combined system is, in turn, weakly coupled to a thermal radiation field and can be described by an autonomous quantum master equation. We show that the laser acts as an autonomous work source and that, in the macroscopic limit, the work produced is independent of the phase of the laser. Using the dressed qubit approach, we show that the variation of energy in the laser is not the work transferred to the dressed qubit, which is instead obtained from the ``dressed laser''---a coherent superposition of the laser and the qubit. Using a two-point measurement technique with counting fields, we obtain the full counting statistics for the work of the laser and dressed laser, and show that they satisfy the Crooks fluctuation theorems. We then use these theorems as criteria to investigate the thermodynamic consistency of quantum master equations, first in the autonomous setup for the combined system, then in the nonautonomous setup for the quantum system where the coherent field is eliminated and effectively described by a time-dependent external field. Treating the laser as an external field is known to yield expressions for the work which are in contradiction with quantum thermodynamics predictions in the strong-driving regime. We show that these inconsistencies stem from a confusion between the laser and dressed laser, and show how to correct them. We also derive a generalized Bloch master equation, thermodynamically consistent across all driving regimes, from which the Bloch and Floquet master equations can be obtained using additional approximations (of which we also examine the consistency).

DOI: 10.1103/physreva.111.062205

Related papers

Thermodynamics of optical Bloch equations

Cyril Elouard, David A. Herrera-Martí, Massimiliano Esposito +1 more

Abstract Optical Bloch equations (OBE) describe the coherent exchange of energy between a quantum bit (qubit) and a quasi-resonant driving field in the presence of a thermal bath. Despite it being an ubiquitous process in quantum technologies, a sound thermodynamic analysis is still missing. We hereby provide such an analysis, by deriving the relevant framework from first principles. We start from a complete microscopic description of the qubit-bath system where definitions of heat, work and entropy production are unambiguous. We trace out the bath and coarse-grain the resulting expressions in time, using a methodology similar to the derivation of the dynamical master equation, to derive closed expressions for the first and second law in terms of system properties. Long coarse graining times yield the Floquet Master equation and its already known thermodynamic description. Short coarse-graining times yield instead the OBE and a novel thermodynamic framework which explicitly depends on quantum coherences in the qubit’s energy basis which produce quantum signatures in the heat and entropy production flows. This allows us to characterize a genuinely quantum non-equilibrium situation, where the coherences created by the driving field are continuously erased by the bath. Our findings can be readily extended to larger open quantum systems. They carry the seeds for future thermodynamic analyses of quantum gates and the design of quantum engines in the strong coherent driving regime.

arXiv:2001.08033New Journal of PhysicsOct 1, 202038 citations

Markovian master equation and thermodynamics of a two-level system in a strong laser field

Krzysztof Szczygielski, David Gelbwaser-Klimovsky, Robert Alicki

The recently developed technique combining the weak-coupling limit with the Floquet formalism is applied to a model of a two-level atom driven by a strong laser field and weakly coupled to heat baths. First, the case of a single electromagnetic bath at zero temperature is discussed and the formula for resonance fluorescence is derived. The expression describes the well-known Mollow triplet, but its details differ from the standard ones based on additional simplifying assumptions. The second example describes the case of two thermal reservoirs: an electromagnetic one at finite temperature and the second dephasing one, which can be realized as a phononic or buffer gas reservoir. It is shown using the developed thermodynamical approach that the latter system can work in two regimes depending on the detuning sign: a heat pump transporting heat from the dephasing reservoir to an electromagnetic bath or heating both, always at the expense of work supplied by the laser field.

arXiv:1211.5665Physical Review EJan 17, 2013108 citations

Nonequilibrium energy transport in driven-dissipative quantum systems

Junran Kong, Yuwei Lu, Huan Liu +2 more

Nonequilibrium energy transport serves as one of fundamental problems in quantum thermodynamics and quantum technologies. Driven quantum master equation in the dressed picture provides an efficient way of investigating nonequilibrium energy flow in general driven-dissipative quantum systems, where the systems are simultaneously driven by the finite thermodynamic bias and coherent driving field. The validity and general applicability of driven quantum master equation is confirmed by comparing with Floquet master equation, by analyzing energy currents in generic spin and boson models. The additional driving phase reserved in system-reservoir interactions, will apparently modify microscopic energy exchange processes. The steady-state energy currents are dramatically enhanced, in particular near the resonant regimes. In contrast, the traditional dressed master equation yields distinct behaviors of the energy currents. We hope that the driven quantum master equation may provide an efficient utility for the control of quantum transport and thermodynamic performances in driven-dissipative nanodevices.

quant-pharXiv:2603.29754Apr 1, 20260 citations

Thermodynamics of autonomous optical Bloch equations

Samyak Pratyush Prasad, Maria Maffei, Patrice A. Camati +2 more

Optical Bloch Equations (OBEs) are canonical equations of quantum open systems, that describe the dynamics of a classically driven atom coupled to a thermal bath. Their thermodynamics is highly relevant to establish fundamental energetic bounds of key quantum processes. A consistent framework is available in the regime where drives and baths can be treated classically, i.e. remain insensitive to the coupling with the atom. This regime, however, is not adapted to explore minimal energy costs, nor to measure atom-induced energy variations inside drives and baths – a key ability to directly measure and optimize work and heat exchanges. This calls for a new framework where the atomic back-action on drives and baths would be accounted for. Here we build such a framework suitable to analyze the situation where the atom, the drive and the bath form a joint autonomous system, the drive and the bath being parts of the same electromagnetic field. Our approach captures atom-field correlations at fundamental timescales, as well as the atomic back-action on the field. This allows us to define work-like (heat-like) flows as energy flows stemming from effective unitary dynamics induced by one system on the other (non-unitary dynamics induced by correlations). Time-integrated work-like and heat-like flows are shown to be directly measurable in the field, as changes of energy locked in the mean field and fluctuations, respectively. Our approach differs from standard open analyses by identifying an additional unitary contribution in the atom’s dynamics, the self-drive, and its energetic counterpart, the self-work, which yields a tighter expression of the second law. We quantitatively relate this tightening to the extra-knowledge about the field state as compared with usual treatments of the atom as an open system. Our autonomous framework deepens the current understanding of thermodynamics in the quantum regime and its potential for energy management at quantum scales. Its predictions can be probed in state-of-the-art quantum hardware, such as superconducting and photonic circuits.

arXiv:2404.09648SciPost PhysicsApr 15, 20262 citations

Stochastic thermodynamics of rapidly driven systems

Gregory Bulnes Cuetara, Andreas Engel, Massimiliano Esposito

We present the stochastic thermodynamics analysis of an open quantum system weakly coupled to multiple reservoirs and driven by a rapidly oscillating external field. The analysis is built on a modified stochastic master equation in the Floquet basis. Transition rates are shown to satisfy the local detailed balance involving the entropy flowing out of the reservoirs. The first and second law of thermodynamics are also identified at the trajectory level. Mechanical work is identified by means of initial and final projections on energy eigenstates of the system. We explicitly show that this two step measurement becomes unnecessary in the long time limit. A steady-state fluctuation theorem for the currents and rate of mechanical work is also established. This relation does not require the introduction of a time reversed external driving which is usually needed when considering systems subjected to time asymmetric external fields. This is understood as a consequence of the secular approximation applied in consistency with the large time scale separation between the fast driving oscillations and the slower relaxation dynamics induced by the environment. Our results are finally illustrated on a model describing a thermodynamic engine.

arXiv:1412.0283New Journal of PhysicsMay 6, 201558 citations

Quantum master equation with dissipators regularized by thermal fluctuations

Arnab Chakrabarti, Rangeet Bhattacharyya

We report an alternate formulation of the quantum master equation (QME) to describe the dynamics of a quantum system weakly coupled to a heat bath, in the presence of weak external driving. A key feature of this approach is the introduction of an explicit Hamiltonian to model the thermal fluctuations in the heat bath. We show that the resulting time coarse-grained dynamical equation for the quantum system has dissipators with a natural regulator, which emerges from an ensemble average over the fluctuations. Importantly, such regularized dissipators arise from the second-order contributions of both the external drive as well as the system-environment coupling. We show that the second-order drive terms, regularized to time-scales set by the fluctuations, result in dynamic drive-induced frequency shifts as well as drive-dependent relaxation phenomena. Considering the specific case of an ensemble of two-level systems, subjected to a linearly polarized external drive, we derive the modified Bloch Equations with such drive-dependent shift and damping terms. The resulting drive-induced frequency shifts converge to the known forms of dynamic frequency shifts, such as the Bloch-Siegert shift or the dynamic Stark shift, in appropriate limits. The Kramers-Kronig pairs of these frequency shifts - manifest as drive-dependent damping terms in the modified Bloch Equations and help explain the Redfield limit of free-induction-decay (FID) rates as well as the non-Bloch decay of Rabi oscillations in isotropic medium. Our method predicts correct orders of magnitudes of non-Bloch decay rates in isotropic medium as well as their observed temperature dependence. The QME reported here, correctly describes all known aspects of the driven-dissipative dynamics up to second-order of an open quantum system with appropriate thermal signatures and as such is expected to provide deeper insights into the study of quantum information processing on real systems.

Physical Review AJun 18, 201815 citations