Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2501.03348

Ab initio calculations of erbium crystal field splittings in oxide hosts

Yogendra Limbu, Yueguang Shi, Joseph Sink, Tharnier O. Puel, Durga Paudyal, Michael E. Flatté

Published Jan 6, 2025• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present an effective ab initio method to calculate the crystal field coefficients of an erbium (Er3+) ion experiencing different local site symmetries in several wide-band-gap oxides, and then evaluate crystal field splittings of these Er3+ ions for their ground and excited states. The optical transitions between the ground state (Z) and excited state (Y) manifolds of the environmentally shielded 4f states of these Er3+ ions have wavelengths ~1.5 microns and thus have potential applications to quantum communications and quantum memories. These results are in excellent agreement with recent low-temperature measurements, provided the inadequate calculation of the 4f shell screening is adjusted by reducing the radial extent of the 4f wavefunctions by approximately a factor of 2.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2501.03348

Related papers

Enhancing erbium optical emission rate via high-throughput host crystal selection

Gregory D. Grant, Swarnabha Chattaraj, Chelsie Hadley +5 more

Erbium-doped solid-state crystals present an attractive platform for quantum communication, combining the telecom C-band spin–photon interface and long coherence times of erbium (Er3+) with the versatility of solid-state hosts. However, across commonly investigated materials, Er3+ is a “dim” ion, with low optical emission rates of kilohertz at most. This makes implementing quantum information transfer protocols (e.g., quantum teleportation) at usable rates a major challenge. One route to increasing Er3+ radiative rates is by careful selection of crystal hosts: the crystal field around an Er3+ ion may hybridize states of different parity, potentially increasing the radiative rate of its telecom transition. Here, using high-throughput computational methods, the radiative rates of Er3+ embedded in 9215 materials are estimated. The computation shows that careful host selection could increase Er3+ radiative rates by an order of magnitude compared to commonly studied hosts. Calculated results are compared with experimental radiative rates in a subset of materials, finding notable clustering but weak correlation. Nevertheless, the “brightest” candidates combined with suitable nanophotonics engineering could push Er3+-based quantum memories into the megahertz bandwidth regime.

Applied Physics Letters•Sep 7, 2026•0 citations

Crystal-Field Energy Levels of Trivalent Erbium Ion in Cubic Symmetry

Said Laachir, Mohamed Moussetad, R. Adhiri

This paper describes a scheme for the numerical calculation of crystal field (CF) energy levels and at the same time wave functions of the trivalent erbium ion in cubic symmetry. The 16-fold degenerate term 4I15=2 of the trivalent erbium ion splits into three Stark quartets Γ8 and two different doublets Γ6 and Γ7 (irreducible representations). The CF energy matrix of the Er3+ ion has been constructed and calculated from the complete diagonalization method, and the corresponding wave functions were used to calculate the ground state g-values. This method is outlined and illustrated by the examples of the Si:Er for comparison. The calculated g-factors are g = 6:8 and g = 6:0 for Γ6 and Γ7, respectively

Zeitschrift für Naturforschung A•Jul 1, 2011•4 citations

Distinguishing erbium dopants in Y2O3 by site symmetry: Ab initio theory of two spin-photon interfaces

Churna Bhandari, Cüneyt Şahin, Durga Paudyal +1 more

We present a first-principles study of the defect formation and electronic structure of erbium (Er)--doped yttria $({\mathrm{Y}}_{2}{\mathrm{O}}_{3})$. This is an emerging material for spin-photon interfaces in quantum information science due to the narrow-linewidth optical emission from Er dopants at standard telecommunication wavelengths and their potential for quantum memories and transducers. We calculate formation energies of neutral and negatively and positively charged Er dopants and find the charge-neutral configuration to be the most stable, consistent with experiment. Of the two substitutional sites of Er for Y, the ${C}_{2}$ (more relevant for quantum memories) and ${C}_{3i}$ (more relevant for quantum transduction), we identify the former as possessing the lowest formation energy. The electronic properties are calculated using the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof functional along with the Hubbard $U$ parameter and spin-orbit coupling, which yields a $\ensuremath{\sim}6\phantom{\rule{0.28em}{0ex}}{\ensuremath{\mu}}_{B}$ orbital and a $\ensuremath{\sim}3\phantom{\rule{0.28em}{0ex}}{\ensuremath{\mu}}_{B}$ spin magnetic moment, and 11 electrons in the Er $4f$ shell, confirming the formation of charge-neutral ${\mathrm{Er}}^{3+}$. This standard density functional theory approach underestimates the band gap of the host and lacks a first-principles justification for $U$. To overcome these issues we performed screened hybrid functional calculations, including a negative $U$ for the $4f$ orbitals, with mixing $(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ and screening $(w)$ parameters. These produced robust electronic features with slight modifications in the band gap and the $4f$ splittings depending on the choice of tuning parameters. We also computed the many-particle electronic excitation energies and compared them with experimental values from photoluminescence.

Physical Review Materials•Dec 27, 2023•4 citations

Spectroscopy, crystal-field, and transition intensity analyses of the C 3v (O 2− ) centre in Er 3+ doped CaF2 crystals

M. D. Moull, Jamin L.B. Martin, T.G.M. Newman +4 more

Erbium ions in crystals show considerable promise for the technologies that will form the backbone of future networked quantum information technology. Despite advances in leveraging erbium’s fibre-compatible infrared transition for classical and quantum applications, the transitions are, in general, not well understood. We present detailed absorption and laser site-selective spectroscopy of the C 3v (O 2 − ) centre in CaF 2 :Er 3 + as an interesting erbium site case study. The 4 I 15 / 2 Z 1 → 4 I 13 / 2 Y 1 transition has a low-temperature inhomogeneous linewidth of 1 GHz with hyperfine structure observable from the 167 Er isotope. A parametrized crystal-field Hamiltonian is fitted to 34 energy levels and the two ground state magnetic splitting factors. The wavefunctions are used to perform a transition intensity analysis and electric-dipole parameters are fitted to absorption oscillator strengths. Simulated spectra for the 4 I 11 / 2 → 4 I 15 / 2 and 4 I 13 / 2 → 4 I 15 / 2 inter-multiplet transitions are in excellent agreement with the experimentally measured spectra. The 4 I 13 / 2 excited state lifetime is 25.0 ms and the intensity calculation is in excellent agreement with this value. • Detailed spectroscopic study of the C 3v (O 2 − ) Centre in CaF 2 :Er 3 + . • Crystal-field fit to 34 energy levels and ground-state magnetic splitting. • Transition intensity analysis for the technologically relevant infrared transitions.

Optical Materials X•Sep 27, 2024•1 citation

Spectroscopy, Crystal-Field, and Transition Intensity Analyses of the C$_{\rm 3v}$(O$^{2-}$) Centre in Er$^{3+}$ Doped CaF$_{2}$ Crystals

M. D. Moull, Jamin L.B. Martin, Newman, T. G. M. +4 more

Erbium ions in crystals show considerable promise for the technologies that will form the backbone of future networked quantum information technology. Despite advances in leveraging erbium's fibre-compatible infrared transition for classical and quantum applications, the transitions are, in general, not well understood. We present detailed absorption and laser site-selective spectroscopy of the C$_{\rm 3v}$(O$^{2-}$) centre in CaF$_2$:Er$^{3+}$ as an interesting erbium site case study. The $^{4}$I$_{15/2}$Z$_1 \rightarrow {^{4}}$I$_{13/2}$Y$_1$ transition has a low-temperature inhomogeneous linewidth of 1 GHz with hyperfine structure observable from the $^{167}$Er isotope. A parametrized crystal-field Hamiltonian is fitted to 34 energy levels and the two ground state magnetic splitting factors. The wavefunctions are used to perform a transition intensity analysis and electric-dipole parameters are fitted to absorption oscillator strengths. Simulated spectra for the $^{4}$I$_{11/2}\rightarrow {^{4}}$I$_{15/2}$ and $^{4}$I$_{13/2} \rightarrow {^{4}}$I$_{15/2}$ inter-multiplet transitions are in excellent agreement with the experimentally measured spectra. The $^{4}$I$_{13/2}$ excited state lifetime is 25.0\,ms and the intensity calculation is in excellent agreement with this value.

arXiv:2409.15622•Sep 23, 2024•0 citations

Optical spectra and analysis of Er3+ in silicon with C, O, and N impurities

D. E. Wortman, Carole A. Morrison, John L. Bradshaw

Photoluminescence (PL) spectra of Er3+ in an Er-doped silicon film were recorded at 2 and 77 K over the wavelength range from 1.52 to 1.68 μm, which includes optical transitions between the Er3+ I13/24 and I15/24 manifolds. These spectra were then analyzed to determine the nature of the electrostatic field at the site of the Er ion that governs the ion’s optical behavior. The PL spectra were analyzed three different ways: by considering the Er3+ ions to be occupying sites of Td, C3, or D2d point group symmetry. Transition energies and magnetic dipole transition probabilities were calculated for each case by diagonalizing a Hamiltonian representing the free-ion and crystal-field interactions in a Russell–Saunders basis of states spanning the lowest 15 J multiplets of the 4f11 electronic configuration of Er3+. Crystal-field parameters were varied in each case to find the best agreement with the experiment. Our results showed that the site symmetry of the Er3+ ions most consistent with the data is D2d. For this case, the rms deviation between the experimental and calculated energy levels is 3.3 cm−1 with the calculated magnetic dipole transition probabilities in qualitative agreement with the experiment.

Journal of Applied Physics•Sep 1, 1997•8 citations
We present an effective ab initio method to calculate the crystal field coefficients of an erbium (Er3+) ion experiencing different local site symmetries in several wide-band-gap oxides, and then evaluate crystal field splittings of these Er3+ ions for their ground and excited states. The optical transitions between the ground state (Z) and excited state (Y) manifolds of the environmentally shielded 4f states of these Er3+ ions have wavelengths ~1.5 microns and thus have potential applications to quantum communications and quantum memories. These results are in excellent agreement with recent low-temperature measurements, provided the inadequate calculation of the 4f shell screening is adjusted by reducing the radial extent of the 4f wavefunctions by approximately a factor of 2.
Erbium-doped solid-state crystals present an attractive platform for quantum communication, combining the telecom C-band spin–photon interface and long coherence times of erbium (Er3+) with the versatility of solid-state hosts. However, across commonly investigated materials, Er3+ is a “dim” ion, with low optical emission rates of kilohertz at most. This makes implementing quantum information transfer protocols (e.g., quantum teleportation) at usable rates a major challenge. One route to increasing Er3+ radiative rates is by careful selection of crystal hosts: the crystal field around an Er3+ ion may hybridize states of different parity, potentially increasing the radiative rate of its telecom transition. Here, using high-throughput computational methods, the radiative rates of Er3+ embedded in 9215 materials are estimated. The computation shows that careful host selection could increase Er3+ radiative rates by an order of magnitude compared to commonly studied hosts. Calculated results are compared with experimental radiative rates in a subset of materials, finding notable clustering but weak correlation. Nevertheless, the “brightest” candidates combined with suitable nanophotonics engineering could push Er3+-based quantum memories into the megahertz bandwidth regime.
This paper describes a scheme for the numerical calculation of crystal field (CF) energy levels and at the same time wave functions of the trivalent erbium ion in cubic symmetry. The 16-fold degenerate term 4I15=2 of the trivalent erbium ion splits into three Stark quartets Γ8 and two different doublets Γ6 and Γ7 (irreducible representations). The CF energy matrix of the Er3+ ion has been constructed and calculated from the complete diagonalization method, and the corresponding wave functions were used to calculate the ground state g-values. This method is outlined and illustrated by the examples of the Si:Er for comparison. The calculated g-factors are g = 6:8 and g = 6:0 for Γ6 and Γ7, respectively
We present a first-principles study of the defect formation and electronic structure of erbium (Er)--doped yttria (Y2O3)({\mathrm{Y}}_{2}{\mathrm{O}}_{3})(Y2​O3​). This is an emerging material for spin-photon interfaces in quantum information science due to the narrow-linewidth optical emission from Er dopants at standard telecommunication wavelengths and their potential for quantum memories and transducers. We calculate formation energies of neutral and negatively and positively charged Er dopants and find the charge-neutral configuration to be the most stable, consistent with experiment. Of the two substitutional sites of Er for Y, the C2{C}_{2}C2​ (more relevant for quantum memories) and C3i{C}_{3i}C3i​ (more relevant for quantum transduction), we identify the former as possessing the lowest formation energy. The electronic properties are calculated using the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof functional along with the Hubbard UUU parameter and spin-orbit coupling, which yields a $\ensuremath{\sim}6\phantom{\rule{0.28em}{0ex}}{\ensuremath{\mu}}_{B}$ orbital and a $\ensuremath{\sim}3\phantom{\rule{0.28em}{0ex}}{\ensuremath{\mu}}_{B}$ spin magnetic moment, and 11 electrons in the Er 4f4f4f shell, confirming the formation of charge-neutral Er3+{\mathrm{Er}}^{3+}Er3+. This standard density functional theory approach underestimates the band gap of the host and lacks a first-principles justification for UUU. To overcome these issues we performed screened hybrid functional calculations, including a negative UUU for the 4f4f4f orbitals, with mixing $(\ensuremath{\alpha})$ and screening (w)(w)(w) parameters. These produced robust electronic features with slight modifications in the band gap and the 4f4f4f splittings depending on the choice of tuning parameters. We also computed the many-particle electronic excitation energies and compared them with experimental values from photoluminescence.
Erbium ions in crystals show considerable promise for the technologies that will form the backbone of future networked quantum information technology. Despite advances in leveraging erbium’s fibre-compatible infrared transition for classical and quantum applications, the transitions are, in general, not well understood. We present detailed absorption and laser site-selective spectroscopy of the C 3v (O 2 − ) centre in CaF 2 :Er 3 + as an interesting erbium site case study. The 4 I 15 / 2 Z 1 → 4 I 13 / 2 Y 1 transition has a low-temperature inhomogeneous linewidth of 1 GHz with hyperfine structure observable from the 167 Er isotope. A parametrized crystal-field Hamiltonian is fitted to 34 energy levels and the two ground state magnetic splitting factors. The wavefunctions are used to perform a transition intensity analysis and electric-dipole parameters are fitted to absorption oscillator strengths. Simulated spectra for the 4 I 11 / 2 → 4 I 15 / 2 and 4 I 13 / 2 → 4 I 15 / 2 inter-multiplet transitions are in excellent agreement with the experimentally measured spectra. The 4 I 13 / 2 excited state lifetime is 25.0 ms and the intensity calculation is in excellent agreement with this value. • Detailed spectroscopic study of the C 3v (O 2 − ) Centre in CaF 2 :Er 3 + . • Crystal-field fit to 34 energy levels and ground-state magnetic splitting. • Transition intensity analysis for the technologically relevant infrared transitions.
Spectroscopy, Crystal-Field, and Transition Intensity Analyses of the C3v_{\rm 3v}3v​(O2−^{2-}2−) Centre in Er3+^{3+}3+ Doped CaF2_{2}2​ Crystals
Erbium ions in crystals show considerable promise for the technologies that will form the backbone of future networked quantum information technology. Despite advances in leveraging erbium's fibre-compatible infrared transition for classical and quantum applications, the transitions are, in general, not well understood. We present detailed absorption and laser site-selective spectroscopy of the C3v_{\rm 3v}3v​(O2−^{2-}2−) centre in CaF2_22​:Er3+^{3+}3+ as an interesting erbium site case study. The 4^{4}4I15/2_{15/2}15/2​Z1→4_1 \rightarrow {^{4}}1​→4I13/2_{13/2}13/2​Y1_11​ transition has a low-temperature inhomogeneous linewidth of 1 GHz with hyperfine structure observable from the 167^{167}167Er isotope. A parametrized crystal-field Hamiltonian is fitted to 34 energy levels and the two ground state magnetic splitting factors. The wavefunctions are used to perform a transition intensity analysis and electric-dipole parameters are fitted to absorption oscillator strengths. Simulated spectra for the 4^{4}4I11/2→4_{11/2}\rightarrow {^{4}}11/2​→4I15/2_{15/2}15/2​ and 4^{4}4I13/2→4_{13/2} \rightarrow {^{4}}13/2​→4I15/2_{15/2}15/2​ inter-multiplet transitions are in excellent agreement with the experimentally measured spectra. The 4^{4}4I13/2_{13/2}13/2​ excited state lifetime is 25.0\,ms and the intensity calculation is in excellent agreement with this value.
Photoluminescence (PL) spectra of Er3+ in an Er-doped silicon film were recorded at 2 and 77 K over the wavelength range from 1.52 to 1.68 μm, which includes optical transitions between the Er3+ I13/24 and I15/24 manifolds. These spectra were then analyzed to determine the nature of the electrostatic field at the site of the Er ion that governs the ion’s optical behavior. The PL spectra were analyzed three different ways: by considering the Er3+ ions to be occupying sites of Td, C3, or D2d point group symmetry. Transition energies and magnetic dipole transition probabilities were calculated for each case by diagonalizing a Hamiltonian representing the free-ion and crystal-field interactions in a Russell–Saunders basis of states spanning the lowest 15 J multiplets of the 4f11 electronic configuration of Er3+. Crystal-field parameters were varied in each case to find the best agreement with the experiment. Our results showed that the site symmetry of the Er3+ ions most consistent with the data is D2d. For this case, the rms deviation between the experimental and calculated energy levels is 3.3 cm−1 with the calculated magnetic dipole transition probabilities in qualitative agreement with the experiment.