Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2411.14445 · Optics Express

Quantum illumination using polarization-entangled photon pairs for enhanced object detection: comment

Artur Czerwiński, Jakub J. Borkowski

Published Apr 11, 2025• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The paper [Opt. Express32, 40150 (2024)10.1364/OE.531674] investigates quantum illumination using polarization-entangled photon pairs for object detection in noisy environments. In this comment, we identify errors in the mathematical model for photon loss, particularly in the treatment of quantum entanglement under lossy channels. We show that the claimed robustness of polarization entanglement to photon loss contradicts established principles in quantum information theory, rendering the conclusions on detecting low-reflectivity objects unsupported.

DOI
10.1364/oe.548099

Related papers

“Quantum illumination using polarization-entangled photon pairs for enhanced object detection: comment”: reply

Kanad Sengupta, K. Muhammed Shafi, Soumya Asokan +1 more

The Comment ( 10.1364/OE.548099 ) is related to the theoretical model in our paper, Opt. Express 32 , 40150 ( 2024 ) 10.1364/OE.531674 , used to describe the experimental result. The role of coincidence counting in our experiment is central; it serves as a crucial post-selection mechanism to isolate the most likely entangled photon pairs even when a significant fraction of photons are lost in one arm. To model the experimentally obtained results, in the paper two theoretical approaches were presented to model the photon loss, one to detect the presence of object (using the constant S value we get even when coincidence photon counts rate reduce) and the other to estimate the reflectivity of the object (normalized S value change with decrease in coincidence rate with reflectivity η ). From the Comment, we gather that the second approach we have used to model photon loss and post-select is incorrect. To make it clear and complete, we have extended the first approach of using the complete Kraus operator to describe the dynamics from which we can detect the object and also estimate the reflectivity of the object. It accurately captures the experimental construct and is consistent with the results obtained from the measurable quantities. The second approach, using Kraus like operator M , which is erroneous, will be redundant.

Optics Express•Aug 13, 2025•0 citations

Quantum illumination using polarization-entangled photon pairs for enhanced object detection

Kanad Sengupta, K. Muhammed Shafi, Soumya Asokan +1 more

Entangled light sources for illuminating objects offer advantages over conventional illumination methods by enhancing the detection sensitivity of reflecting objects. The core of the quantum advantage lies in effectively exploiting quantum correlations to isolate noise and detect objects with low reflectivity. This work experimentally demonstrates the benefits of using polarization-entangled photon pairs for quantum illumination and shows that the quantum correlation measure, using CHSH value and normalized CHSH value, is robust against losses, noise, and depolarization. We report the detection of objects with reflectivity (η) as low as 0.05 and an object submerged in noise with a signal-to-noise ratio of 0.003 using quantum correlation and residual quantum correlation measures, surpassing previous results. Additionally, we demonstrate that the normalized CHSH value aids in estimating the reflectivity of the detected object. Furthermore, we analyze the robustness of the correlation measure under photon attenuation in atmospheric conditions to show the practical feasibility of real-time applications.

arXiv:2401.10182•Optics Express•Sep 6, 2024•9 citations

Long distance quantum illumination and ranging using polarization entangled photon pairs in a lossy environment

Sujai Matta, Soumya Asokan, Sanchari Chakraborti +3 more

Using polarization entangled photon pairs, we demonstrate a robust scheme for quantum illumination and ranging in a lossy environment. Entangled photon pairs are generated in a Sagnac interferometer configuration, yielding high-visibility two-photon polarization entanglement with a measured CHSH parameter of $S =2.802\pm0.002$. One of the photons from the entangled pair is retained as idler and the other one is directed into either of the two paths, namely reference and probe, of which probe is sent toward a distant object through a lossy free-space channel, and the reflected photons are collected after round-trip free-space propagation over distances approaching $1$ km. Remarkably, strong correlations are observed with CHSH values $S >2.6$ even when only a few tens of probe photons are returned, confirming the robustness of polarization entanglement under long-distance free-space propagation. This work reports the robustness of encoding photons in different basis before it is sent towards the object and recovery of polarization entanglement even after a kilometer-scale scattering from the objects, establishing a practical foundation for scalable quantum-assisted object detection and ranging.

quant-pharXiv:2602.08947•Feb 10, 2026•0 citations

Quantum illumination using polarization-path entangled single photons for low reflectivity object detection in a noisy background: comment

Artur Czerwiński, Jakub J. Borkowski

Optics Express•Jul 2, 2026•0 citations

Quantum illumination using polarization-path entangled single photons for low reflectivity object detection in a noisy background

K. Muhammed Shafi, A. Padhye, C. M. Chandrashekar

Detecting object with low reflectivity embedded within a noisy background is a challenging task. Quantum correlations between pairs of quantum states of light, though are highly sensitive to background noise and losses, offer advantages over traditional illumination methods. Instead of using correlated photon pairs which are sensitive, we experimentally demonstrate the advantage of using heralded single-photons entangled in polarization and path degree of freedom for quantum illumination. In the study, the object of different reflectivity is placed along the path of the signal in a variable thermal background before taking the joint measurements and calculating the quantum correlations. We show the significant advantage of using non-interferometric measurements along the multiple paths for single photon to isolate the signal from the background noise and outperform in detecting and ranging the low reflectivity objects even when the signal-to-noise ratio is as low as 0.03. Decrease in visibility of polarization along the signal path also results in similar observations. This will have direct relevance to the development of single-photon based quantum LiDAR and quantum imaging.

arXiv:2303.05218•Optics Express•Aug 16, 2023•9 citations

Quantum Radar Through Entanglement‑Based Illumination: A Framework for Enhanced Target Detection

mark harrison, CP Nova

Quantum radar systems leverage entangled photon pairs to detect and identify targets in noisy or cluttered environments with sensitivity beyond classical limits. By transmitting one photon of an entangled pair toward a distant object while retaining its partner locally, the system exploits quantum correlations to improve signal discrimination, reduce noise susceptibility, and enhance detection probability. This paper outlines the physical principles, operational architecture, and performance advantages of entanglement‑based illumination, providing a clear foundation for future quantum‑enhanced sensing technologies.(If you want it shorter, longer, or more formal, tap: shorter paragraph, longer paragraph, more formal)

•Sep 18, 2026•0 citations
The paper [Opt. Express32, 40150 (2024)10.1364/OE.531674] investigates quantum illumination using polarization-entangled photon pairs for object detection in noisy environments. In this comment, we identify errors in the mathematical model for photon loss, particularly in the treatment of quantum entanglement under lossy channels. We show that the claimed robustness of polarization entanglement to photon loss contradicts established principles in quantum information theory, rendering the conclusions on detecting low-reflectivity objects unsupported.
The Comment ( 10.1364/OE.548099 ) is related to the theoretical model in our paper, Opt. Express 32 , 40150 ( 2024 ) 10.1364/OE.531674 , used to describe the experimental result. The role of coincidence counting in our experiment is central; it serves as a crucial post-selection mechanism to isolate the most likely entangled photon pairs even when a significant fraction of photons are lost in one arm. To model the experimentally obtained results, in the paper two theoretical approaches were presented to model the photon loss, one to detect the presence of object (using the constant S value we get even when coincidence photon counts rate reduce) and the other to estimate the reflectivity of the object (normalized S value change with decrease in coincidence rate with reflectivity η ). From the Comment, we gather that the second approach we have used to model photon loss and post-select is incorrect. To make it clear and complete, we have extended the first approach of using the complete Kraus operator to describe the dynamics from which we can detect the object and also estimate the reflectivity of the object. It accurately captures the experimental construct and is consistent with the results obtained from the measurable quantities. The second approach, using Kraus like operator M , which is erroneous, will be redundant.
Entangled light sources for illuminating objects offer advantages over conventional illumination methods by enhancing the detection sensitivity of reflecting objects. The core of the quantum advantage lies in effectively exploiting quantum correlations to isolate noise and detect objects with low reflectivity. This work experimentally demonstrates the benefits of using polarization-entangled photon pairs for quantum illumination and shows that the quantum correlation measure, using CHSH value and normalized CHSH value, is robust against losses, noise, and depolarization. We report the detection of objects with reflectivity (η) as low as 0.05 and an object submerged in noise with a signal-to-noise ratio of 0.003 using quantum correlation and residual quantum correlation measures, surpassing previous results. Additionally, we demonstrate that the normalized CHSH value aids in estimating the reflectivity of the detected object. Furthermore, we analyze the robustness of the correlation measure under photon attenuation in atmospheric conditions to show the practical feasibility of real-time applications.
Using polarization entangled photon pairs, we demonstrate a robust scheme for quantum illumination and ranging in a lossy environment. Entangled photon pairs are generated in a Sagnac interferometer configuration, yielding high-visibility two-photon polarization entanglement with a measured CHSH parameter of S=2.802±0.002S =2.802\pm0.002S=2.802±0.002. One of the photons from the entangled pair is retained as idler and the other one is directed into either of the two paths, namely reference and probe, of which probe is sent toward a distant object through a lossy free-space channel, and the reflected photons are collected after round-trip free-space propagation over distances approaching 111 km. Remarkably, strong correlations are observed with CHSH values S>2.6S >2.6S>2.6 even when only a few tens of probe photons are returned, confirming the robustness of polarization entanglement under long-distance free-space propagation. This work reports the robustness of encoding photons in different basis before it is sent towards the object and recovery of polarization entanglement even after a kilometer-scale scattering from the objects, establishing a practical foundation for scalable quantum-assisted object detection and ranging.
Detecting object with low reflectivity embedded within a noisy background is a challenging task. Quantum correlations between pairs of quantum states of light, though are highly sensitive to background noise and losses, offer advantages over traditional illumination methods. Instead of using correlated photon pairs which are sensitive, we experimentally demonstrate the advantage of using heralded single-photons entangled in polarization and path degree of freedom for quantum illumination. In the study, the object of different reflectivity is placed along the path of the signal in a variable thermal background before taking the joint measurements and calculating the quantum correlations. We show the significant advantage of using non-interferometric measurements along the multiple paths for single photon to isolate the signal from the background noise and outperform in detecting and ranging the low reflectivity objects even when the signal-to-noise ratio is as low as 0.03. Decrease in visibility of polarization along the signal path also results in similar observations. This will have direct relevance to the development of single-photon based quantum LiDAR and quantum imaging.
Quantum radar systems leverage entangled photon pairs to detect and identify targets in noisy or cluttered environments with sensitivity beyond classical limits. By transmitting one photon of an entangled pair toward a distant object while retaining its partner locally, the system exploits quantum correlations to improve signal discrimination, reduce noise susceptibility, and enhance detection probability. This paper outlines the physical principles, operational architecture, and performance advantages of entanglement‑based illumination, providing a clear foundation for future quantum‑enhanced sensing technologies.(If you want it shorter, longer, or more formal, tap: shorter paragraph, longer paragraph, more formal)