Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2409.16284 · International Journal of Quantum Information

Eavesdropping on the BB84 protocol using phase-covariant cloning: Experimental results

Brian Pigott, Elizabeth Campolongo, H. Routray, Alex Khan

Published Sep 12, 2025• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Though the BB84 protocol has provable security over a noiseless quantum channel, the security is not proven over current noisy technology. The level of tolerable error on such systems is still unclear, as is how much information about a raw key may be obtained by an eavesdropper. We develop a reproducible test to determine the security–or lack thereof–of the protocol in practice. This enables us to obtain an experimental estimate of the information that can be obtained using asymmetric phase-covariant cloning to eavesdrop on the BB84 protocol.

DOI
10.1142/s0219749925500285

Related papers

Proposal of an eavesdropping experiment for BB84 QKD protocol with 1→3 phase-covariant quantum doner

Yuta Okubo, Francesco Buscemi, Akihisa Tomita +1 more

We propose an experimental implementation of a particular attack against the BB84 quantum key distribution protocol, utilizing a 1→3 asymmetric phase‐covariant quantum cloning. Our eavesdropping strategy is numerically optimized to extract the information about the input state. The proposed cloning circuit is easily implementable with linear optics and its performances turn out to be well close to the optimum attack.

arXiv:0806.1778•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2009•2 citations

Optimality of the Asymmetric Economical phase-covariant Quantum Cloning

Jie-Lin Dai, Wen‐Hai Zhang

Quantum cloning can be reviewed as the optimal individual eavesdropping on quantum cryptography. Specifically, the optimal phase-covariant cloning is regarded as the optimal individual attack on the BB84 protocol. In this paper, by exploring Cerf s formalism, we prove the optimality of the asymmetric economical 1→2 phase-covariant quantum cloning in 2 dimensions working without ancilla. In proof, we derive another independent unitary transformation of this cloner. Our result covers previous contributions [Durt T, et al. Phys. Rev. A, 2004, 69:062316].

Journal of Atomic and Molecular Physics•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

Detection and Analysis of Eavesdropping Attacks on Quantum Key Distribution BB84 Protocol

Godala Madhu

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) provides an innovative approach for secure communication by utilizing the principles of quantum mechanics. Among various QKD protocols, the BB84 protocol remains the most widely studied and implemented due to its simplicity and theoretical security guarantees. However, practical implementations of BB84 are vulnerable to several eavesdropping attacks and channel imperfections. This paper presents a comprehensive study on the detection and analysis of eavesdropping attacks in the BB84 protocol. The work focuses on common attacks such as intercept-resend attack, photon-number splitting attack, Trojan horse attack, and phase-covariant cloning attack. The effect of these attacks on Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) is analyzed in detail. Simulation-based observations are discussed to demonstrate how QBER increases under malicious interference. The study further explores statistical methods for detecting eavesdropping and examines practical countermeasures including decoy states, privacy amplification, and error correction techniques. The paper concludes that BB84 remains robust against eavesdropping when proper detection and mitigation mechanisms are employed.

International Journal of Advanced Research in Science and Technology•Jun 1, 2026•0 citations

Stop Conditions of BB84 Protocol via a Depolarizing Channel (Quantum Cryptography)

Iyed Ben Slimen, Olfa Trabelsi, Houria Rezig +2 more

Abstract: BB84 (Bennett and Brassard 1984) is one of the well known protocols of quantum keys distribution. It is built to allow two interlocutors commonly called Alice and Bob to share two similar binary keys and to detect the eavesdropper presence (the eavesdropper is commonly called Eve). However, Eve presence in a disturbed environment causes errors to the sifted keys and decreases the amount of secure information between Alice and Bob. One of the most important stages in BB84 protocol is to decide by using error probability estimation if we can continue the protocol phases or no. Indeed, this decision is function of some factors like: what is the amount of information that we will lose in the error correction phase? What is the degree of errors detected in our sifted keys? What is the origin of these errors: Eve strategy or the channel disturbance? For these reasons, we will study in this study some conditions to stop BB84 protocol in the context of depolarizing channel. We implement two types of eavesdropping strategy: Intercept and Resend and Cloning Attack.

Journal of Computer Science•Jun 1, 2007•11 citations

Experimental Eavesdropping Based on Optimal Quantum Cloning

Karol Bartkiewicz, Karel Lemr, Antonín Černoch +2 more

The security of quantum cryptography is guaranteed by the no-cloning theorem, which implies that an eavesdropper copying transmitted qubits in unknown states causes their disturbance. Nevertheless, in real cryptographic systems some level of disturbance has to be allowed to cover, e.g., transmission losses. An eavesdropper can attack such systems by replacing a noisy channel by a better one and by performing approximate cloning of transmitted qubits which disturb them but below the noise level assumed by legitimate users. We experimentally demonstrate such symmetric individual eavesdropping on the quantum key distribution protocols of Bennett and Brassard (BB84) and the trine-state spherical code of Renes (R04) with two-level probes prepared using a recently developed photonic multifunctional quantum cloner [Lemr et al., Phys. Rev. A 85, 050307(R) (2012)]. We demonstrated that our optimal cloning device with high-success rate makes the eavesdropping possible by hiding it in usual transmission losses. We believe that this experiment can stimulate the quest for other operational applications of quantum cloning.

arXiv:1206.0144•Physical Review Letters•Apr 24, 2013•53 citations

Optimal Individual Attacks against BB84

Raúl García−Patrón, Franco N. C. Wong, Jeffrey H. Shapiro

An economical version of asymmetric phase-covariant cloning is shown to provide an optimal individual attack on the BB84 protocol with error correction that can be physically simulated using deterministic single-photon two-qubit quantum logic.

International Conference on Quantum Information•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations
Though the BB84 protocol has provable security over a noiseless quantum channel, the security is not proven over current noisy technology. The level of tolerable error on such systems is still unclear, as is how much information about a raw key may be obtained by an eavesdropper. We develop a reproducible test to determine the security–or lack thereof–of the protocol in practice. This enables us to obtain an experimental estimate of the information that can be obtained using asymmetric phase-covariant cloning to eavesdrop on the BB84 protocol.
Quantum cloning can be reviewed as the optimal individual eavesdropping on quantum cryptography. Specifically, the optimal phase-covariant cloning is regarded as the optimal individual attack on the BB84 protocol. In this paper, by exploring Cerf s formalism, we prove the optimality of the asymmetric economical 1→2 phase-covariant quantum cloning in 2 dimensions working without ancilla. In proof, we derive another independent unitary transformation of this cloner. Our result covers previous contributions [Durt T, et al. Phys. Rev. A, 2004, 69:062316].
Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) provides an innovative approach for secure communication by utilizing the principles of quantum mechanics. Among various QKD protocols, the BB84 protocol remains the most widely studied and implemented due to its simplicity and theoretical security guarantees. However, practical implementations of BB84 are vulnerable to several eavesdropping attacks and channel imperfections. This paper presents a comprehensive study on the detection and analysis of eavesdropping attacks in the BB84 protocol. The work focuses on common attacks such as intercept-resend attack, photon-number splitting attack, Trojan horse attack, and phase-covariant cloning attack. The effect of these attacks on Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) is analyzed in detail. Simulation-based observations are discussed to demonstrate how QBER increases under malicious interference. The study further explores statistical methods for detecting eavesdropping and examines practical countermeasures including decoy states, privacy amplification, and error correction techniques. The paper concludes that BB84 remains robust against eavesdropping when proper detection and mitigation mechanisms are employed.
Abstract: BB84 (Bennett and Brassard 1984) is one of the well known protocols of quantum keys distribution. It is built to allow two interlocutors commonly called Alice and Bob to share two similar binary keys and to detect the eavesdropper presence (the eavesdropper is commonly called Eve). However, Eve presence in a disturbed environment causes errors to the sifted keys and decreases the amount of secure information between Alice and Bob. One of the most important stages in BB84 protocol is to decide by using error probability estimation if we can continue the protocol phases or no. Indeed, this decision is function of some factors like: what is the amount of information that we will lose in the error correction phase? What is the degree of errors detected in our sifted keys? What is the origin of these errors: Eve strategy or the channel disturbance? For these reasons, we will study in this study some conditions to stop BB84 protocol in the context of depolarizing channel. We implement two types of eavesdropping strategy: Intercept and Resend and Cloning Attack.
The security of quantum cryptography is guaranteed by the no-cloning theorem, which implies that an eavesdropper copying transmitted qubits in unknown states causes their disturbance. Nevertheless, in real cryptographic systems some level of disturbance has to be allowed to cover, e.g., transmission losses. An eavesdropper can attack such systems by replacing a noisy channel by a better one and by performing approximate cloning of transmitted qubits which disturb them but below the noise level assumed by legitimate users. We experimentally demonstrate such symmetric individual eavesdropping on the quantum key distribution protocols of Bennett and Brassard (BB84) and the trine-state spherical code of Renes (R04) with two-level probes prepared using a recently developed photonic multifunctional quantum cloner [Lemr et al., Phys. Rev. A 85, 050307(R) (2012)]. We demonstrated that our optimal cloning device with high-success rate makes the eavesdropping possible by hiding it in usual transmission losses. We believe that this experiment can stimulate the quest for other operational applications of quantum cloning.