Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2408.15351 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Charge pumps, boundary modes, and the necessity of unnecessary criticality

Abhishodh Prakash, S. A. Parameswaran

Published Dec 4, 2025• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We link the presence of “unnecessary” quantum critical surfaces within a single gapped phase of matter to the nontrivial topology of of gapped Hamiltonians that encircle the critical surface. We study a specific set of one-dimensional spin models where each such family forms a one-parameter loop in a two-dimensional phase diagram. Foliating the noncritical region by such loops identifies “radial” and “angular” coordinates in the phase diagram that respectively parametrize different families and different members of a single family. We show that each one-parameter family is a generalized Thouless charge pump, all with the same topological index, and hence the gapped phase undergoes one or more nontrivial boundary phase transitions as we vary the angular coordinate in a loop through members of one family. Tuning the radial coordinate generates loci of boundary critical points that terminate at the end points of the bulk unnecessary critical line within the gapped phase. We discuss broader implications of our results and possible extensions to higher dimensions.

DOI
10.1103/kztj-jcyc

Related papers

Quasi-Phases of Quantum Matter

Nick G. Jones, Paul Fendley, Nathanan Tantivasadakarn +1 more

Within quantum many-body phase diagrams, continuous transition lines can appear and then terminate. However, it has remained unclear whether the neighboring regimes can be meaningfully described as distinct phases, akin to water and vapour, since any sharp characterization would have to go beyond the usual notion of phases of matter. We answer this in the affirmative by introducing quasi-phases: gapped regimes near a critical point that are connected in the broader phase diagram, but not by any gapped path accessible from small perturbations of the critical theory. The physical consequences include interface modes between regimes in the same phase of matter. More striking still, describing both the extended critical line and the gapped path connecting the regimes requires a bigger multicritical parent theory. In spin-chain examples with continuous terminating lines with central charge $c=1$, we find multicritical $c=3/2$ and $c=9/5$ orbifolds describing so-called 'quotient symmetry protected' and 'representation symmetry protected' topological phenomena. While one-dimensional symmetry-protected topological phases are labeled by projective representation classes, these quasi-phases can have interface modes carrying higher-dimensional linear representations. We turn this into a constructive principle through a weakening of the Lieb-Schultz-Mattis anomaly. Supporting distinct quasi-phases makes an unnecessary critical point infrared-necessary, even if it is unnecessary at the ultraviolet scale. This condition is more restrictive than simply having a codimension-one critical line, revealing richer structure within phases of matter than their conventional classification suggests.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2610.40526•Oct 30, 2026•0 citations

Decoupling band topology from criticality in bosonic systems

Mariam Ughrelidze, Lorenza Viola, Emilio Cobanera

A new understanding of criticality in systems described by quadratic bosonic Hamiltonians (QBHs) ties the emergence of long-range correlations to boundaries of dynamical, not thermodynamical, stability in parameter space. This separation occurs because the solution of the Heisenberg equations of motion is determined by an auxiliary pseudo-Hermitian dynamical system. The boundary points of a region of dynamical stability can be either exceptional points, generically associated with long-range correlations, or Krein collisions, where correlations can be either long- or short-range. We investigate the interplay of this landscape of possibilities with band topology and boundary physics, by relying on both specific examples and general arguments. The examples stem from a two-parameter, thermodynamically unstable family of QBHs obtained from the bosonic Su-Schrieffer-Heeger model by breaking particle conservation while preserving a chiral pseudo-symmetry. As a function of an interpolation parameter, distinct regions emerge within a fixed dynamical-stability phase, which prove to be topologically trivial and nontrivial, respectively. The topological phase transition is a line of Krein collisions, which coincides with the closing of a band gap at zero and causes the localization length of the topologically mandated boundary zero modes to diverge before disappearing. We show that the chiral pseudo-symmetry induces, despite the broken particle-number symmetry, enough structure on its associated dynamical matrices to support a topological classification and a bulk-boundary correspondence, independently of dynamical stability. This strongly suggests that, for non-interacting bosons, topological physics extracted from basic index theory is insensitive to dynamical stability and, a posteriori, criticality.

quant-pharXiv:2607.01334•Journal of Applied Physics•Jul 3, 2026•2 citations

Topological Phenomena Protected by Diabolical Textures

Sayantan Mandal, Neelima Pulletikurty, Abhishodh Prakash

We present a new class of topological phenomena in inhomogeneous systems arising from the adiabatic spatial embedding of parametrized families of quantum states such as charge pumps and their generalizations. We demonstrate that each topologically distinct class of these ``diabolical textures" gives rise to distinct gapped states that are separated by ``trap-scaling" critical points, defect transitions, or intervening phases. Their phase diagrams exhibit versions of ``unnecessary criticality'' and ``multiversality,'' within a noninteracting setting. We demonstrate this in a one-dimensional Thouless pump texture trapping a charge and a two-dimensional class D texture trapping a Kitaev chain, including an analysis of their stability under weak symmetry-preserving perturbations and interactions. For systems in arbitrary spatial dimensions and global symmetries, we present a framework to systematically classify diabolical textures using Kitaev's $Ω$ spectrum conjecture.

arXiv:2605.30421•May 28, 2026•0 citations

Boundary-deconfined quantum criticality at transitions between symmetry-protected topological chains

Saranesh Prembabu, Ryan Thorngren, Ruben Verresen

Decades of research have revealed a deep understanding of topological quantum matter with protected edge modes. We report that even richer physics emerges when tuning between two topological phases of matter whose respective edge modes are incompatible. The frustration at the edge leads to novel boundary physics, such as symmetry-breaking phases with exotic non-Landau transitions---even when the edge is zero-dimensional. As a minimal case study, we consider spin chains with ${\mathbb{Z}}_{3}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{\mathbb{Z}}_{3}$ symmetry, exhibiting two nontrivial symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases. At the bulk 1+1D critical transition between these SPT phases, we find two stable 0+1D boundary phases, each spontaneously breaking one of the ${\mathbb{Z}}_{3}$ symmetries. Furthermore, we find that a single boundary parameter tunes a non-Landau boundary critical transition between these two phases. This constitutes a 0+1D version of an exotic phenomenon driven by charged vortex condensation known as deconfined quantum criticality. This work highlights the rich unexplored physics of criticality between nontrivial topological phases and provides insights into the burgeoning field of gapless topological phases.

arXiv:2208.12258•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 13, 2024•23 citations

Higher-dimensional generalizations of Berry curvature

Anton Kapustin, Lev Spodyneiko

A family of finite-dimensional quantum systems with a nondegenerate ground state gives rise to a closed two-form on the parameter space, the curvature of the Berry connection. Its integral over a surface detects the presence of degeneracy points inside the volume enclosed by the surface. We seek generalizations of the Berry curvature to gapped many-body systems in $D$ spatial dimensions which can detect gapless or degenerate points in the phase diagram of a system. Field theory predicts that in spatial dimension $D$ the analog of the Berry curvature is a closed $(D+2)$-form on the parameter space (the Wess-Zumino-Witten form). We construct such closed forms for arbitrary families of gapped interacting lattice systems in all dimensions. We show that whenever the integral of the Wess-Zumino-Witten form over a $(D+2)$-dimensional surface in the parameter space is nonzero, there must be gapless edge modes for at least one value of the parameters. These edge modes arise even when the bulk system is in a trivial phase for all values of the parameters and are protected by the nontrivial topology of the phase diagram.

arXiv:2001.03454•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 11, 2020•78 citations

Textured phase diagrams of featureless insulators

Sashank Singam, Nick G. Jones, Abhishodh Prakash

We study phase diagrams of charge-conserving ‘‘class A’’ noninteracting fermions, focusing on the trivial phase in various dimensions. Such phases are usually termed ‘‘featureless’’ to distinguish them from those others with either symmetry-broken or topological order. We show that the presence of nontrivial topological families of states, including charge pumps and their generalizations, results in phase diagrams being endowed with nontrivial topological textures that can be visualized through Berry phases and their higher-dimensional generalizations. We show that for noninteracting fermion systems with translation invariance, these ‘‘higher’’ Berry phases can be computed using integrals of non-Abelian Chern–Simons forms of the Berry–Bloch connection over momentum and parameter spaces. Singularities in these textures correspond to gap-closing loci of ‘‘diabolical points’’, which represent the obstruction to contracting topologically nontrivial families of states, and bulk-boundary correspondence results in a locus of robust boundary modes that terminate at the bulk diabolical points. In the presence of finite chemical potential, we argue that the edge modes are generically robust without any need for fine-tuning for two and higher dimensions, whereas in one dimension they are ‘‘estranged’’ in the phase diagram, i.e., appearing at different parameter values for different edges. We demonstrate our results by constructing several microscopic models of noninteracting fermions. We argue stability to interactions and explore proximate phase diagrams by mapping to continuum field theories.

arXiv:2605.20339•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Oct 7, 2026•3 citations
We link the presence of “unnecessary” quantum critical surfaces within a single gapped phase of matter to the nontrivial topology of of gapped Hamiltonians that encircle the critical surface. We study a specific set of one-dimensional spin models where each such family forms a one-parameter loop in a two-dimensional phase diagram. Foliating the noncritical region by such loops identifies “radial” and “angular” coordinates in the phase diagram that respectively parametrize different families and different members of a single family. We show that each one-parameter family is a generalized Thouless charge pump, all with the same topological index, and hence the gapped phase undergoes one or more nontrivial boundary phase transitions as we vary the angular coordinate in a loop through members of one family. Tuning the radial coordinate generates loci of boundary critical points that terminate at the end points of the bulk unnecessary critical line within the gapped phase. We discuss broader implications of our results and possible extensions to higher dimensions.
Within quantum many-body phase diagrams, continuous transition lines can appear and then terminate. However, it has remained unclear whether the neighboring regimes can be meaningfully described as distinct phases, akin to water and vapour, since any sharp characterization would have to go beyond the usual notion of phases of matter. We answer this in the affirmative by introducing quasi-phases: gapped regimes near a critical point that are connected in the broader phase diagram, but not by any gapped path accessible from small perturbations of the critical theory. The physical consequences include interface modes between regimes in the same phase of matter. More striking still, describing both the extended critical line and the gapped path connecting the regimes requires a bigger multicritical parent theory. In spin-chain examples with continuous terminating lines with central charge c=1c=1c=1, we find multicritical c=3/2c=3/2c=3/2 and c=9/5c=9/5c=9/5 orbifolds describing so-called 'quotient symmetry protected' and 'representation symmetry protected' topological phenomena. While one-dimensional symmetry-protected topological phases are labeled by projective representation classes, these quasi-phases can have interface modes carrying higher-dimensional linear representations. We turn this into a constructive principle through a weakening of the Lieb-Schultz-Mattis anomaly. Supporting distinct quasi-phases makes an unnecessary critical point infrared-necessary, even if it is unnecessary at the ultraviolet scale. This condition is more restrictive than simply having a codimension-one critical line, revealing richer structure within phases of matter than their conventional classification suggests.
A new understanding of criticality in systems described by quadratic bosonic Hamiltonians (QBHs) ties the emergence of long-range correlations to boundaries of dynamical, not thermodynamical, stability in parameter space. This separation occurs because the solution of the Heisenberg equations of motion is determined by an auxiliary pseudo-Hermitian dynamical system. The boundary points of a region of dynamical stability can be either exceptional points, generically associated with long-range correlations, or Krein collisions, where correlations can be either long- or short-range. We investigate the interplay of this landscape of possibilities with band topology and boundary physics, by relying on both specific examples and general arguments. The examples stem from a two-parameter, thermodynamically unstable family of QBHs obtained from the bosonic Su-Schrieffer-Heeger model by breaking particle conservation while preserving a chiral pseudo-symmetry. As a function of an interpolation parameter, distinct regions emerge within a fixed dynamical-stability phase, which prove to be topologically trivial and nontrivial, respectively. The topological phase transition is a line of Krein collisions, which coincides with the closing of a band gap at zero and causes the localization length of the topologically mandated boundary zero modes to diverge before disappearing. We show that the chiral pseudo-symmetry induces, despite the broken particle-number symmetry, enough structure on its associated dynamical matrices to support a topological classification and a bulk-boundary correspondence, independently of dynamical stability. This strongly suggests that, for non-interacting bosons, topological physics extracted from basic index theory is insensitive to dynamical stability and, a posteriori, criticality.
We present a new class of topological phenomena in inhomogeneous systems arising from the adiabatic spatial embedding of parametrized families of quantum states such as charge pumps and their generalizations. We demonstrate that each topologically distinct class of these ``diabolical textures" gives rise to distinct gapped states that are separated by ``trap-scaling" critical points, defect transitions, or intervening phases. Their phase diagrams exhibit versions of ``unnecessary criticality'' and ``multiversality,'' within a noninteracting setting. We demonstrate this in a one-dimensional Thouless pump texture trapping a charge and a two-dimensional class D texture trapping a Kitaev chain, including an analysis of their stability under weak symmetry-preserving perturbations and interactions. For systems in arbitrary spatial dimensions and global symmetries, we present a framework to systematically classify diabolical textures using Kitaev's ΩΩΩ spectrum conjecture.
Decades of research have revealed a deep understanding of topological quantum matter with protected edge modes. We report that even richer physics emerges when tuning between two topological phases of matter whose respective edge modes are incompatible. The frustration at the edge leads to novel boundary physics, such as symmetry-breaking phases with exotic non-Landau transitions---even when the edge is zero-dimensional. As a minimal case study, we consider spin chains with ${\mathbb{Z}}_{3}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{\mathbb{Z}}_{3}$ symmetry, exhibiting two nontrivial symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases. At the bulk 1+1D critical transition between these SPT phases, we find two stable 0+1D boundary phases, each spontaneously breaking one of the Z3{\mathbb{Z}}_{3}Z3​ symmetries. Furthermore, we find that a single boundary parameter tunes a non-Landau boundary critical transition between these two phases. This constitutes a 0+1D version of an exotic phenomenon driven by charged vortex condensation known as deconfined quantum criticality. This work highlights the rich unexplored physics of criticality between nontrivial topological phases and provides insights into the burgeoning field of gapless topological phases.
A family of finite-dimensional quantum systems with a nondegenerate ground state gives rise to a closed two-form on the parameter space, the curvature of the Berry connection. Its integral over a surface detects the presence of degeneracy points inside the volume enclosed by the surface. We seek generalizations of the Berry curvature to gapped many-body systems in DDD spatial dimensions which can detect gapless or degenerate points in the phase diagram of a system. Field theory predicts that in spatial dimension DDD the analog of the Berry curvature is a closed (D+2)(D+2)(D+2)-form on the parameter space (the Wess-Zumino-Witten form). We construct such closed forms for arbitrary families of gapped interacting lattice systems in all dimensions. We show that whenever the integral of the Wess-Zumino-Witten form over a (D+2)(D+2)(D+2)-dimensional surface in the parameter space is nonzero, there must be gapless edge modes for at least one value of the parameters. These edge modes arise even when the bulk system is in a trivial phase for all values of the parameters and are protected by the nontrivial topology of the phase diagram.
We study phase diagrams of charge-conserving ‘‘class A’’ noninteracting fermions, focusing on the trivial phase in various dimensions. Such phases are usually termed ‘‘featureless’’ to distinguish them from those others with either symmetry-broken or topological order. We show that the presence of nontrivial topological families of states, including charge pumps and their generalizations, results in phase diagrams being endowed with nontrivial topological textures that can be visualized through Berry phases and their higher-dimensional generalizations. We show that for noninteracting fermion systems with translation invariance, these ‘‘higher’’ Berry phases can be computed using integrals of non-Abelian Chern–Simons forms of the Berry–Bloch connection over momentum and parameter spaces. Singularities in these textures correspond to gap-closing loci of ‘‘diabolical points’’, which represent the obstruction to contracting topologically nontrivial families of states, and bulk-boundary correspondence results in a locus of robust boundary modes that terminate at the bulk diabolical points. In the presence of finite chemical potential, we argue that the edge modes are generically robust without any need for fine-tuning for two and higher dimensions, whereas in one dimension they are ‘‘estranged’’ in the phase diagram, i.e., appearing at different parameter values for different edges. We demonstrate our results by constructing several microscopic models of noninteracting fermions. We argue stability to interactions and explore proximate phase diagrams by mapping to continuum field theories.