Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2408.06708 · Physical Review Letters

Experimental Realization of an Analog of Entanglement between Two Brownian Particles

L. Theerthagiri, Sergio Ciliberto

Published Jun 3, 2025• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We experimentally investigate the statistical properties of a classical analog of quantum entanglement between two Brownian particles connected by an elastic force and maintained at different temperatures through separate heat reservoirs. Uncertainty relations between coordinates and coarse-grained velocity can produce a phenomenon similar to quantum entanglement, where temperature plays the role of Planck's constant. The theoretical analysis matches the experimental results, confirming that the interconnected particles exhibit Brownian quantum-inspired classical correlation entanglement. This effect arises from a coarse-grained description of Brownian motion and vanishes at a finer resolution. The coarsening scale range is measured too.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.134.227101

Related papers

Brownian entanglement

ARMEN E. ALLAHVERDYAN, Andrei Yu. Khrennikov, Theo M. Nieuwenhuizen

For two classical Brownian particles an analog of continuous-variable quantum entanglement is presented: The common probability distribution of the two coordinates and the corresponding coarse-grained velocities cannot always be prepared via mixing of any factorized distributions referring to the two particles separately. This is possible for particles which have interacted in the past, but do not interact at present. Three factors are crucial for the effect: (1) separation of time scales of coordinate and momentum which motivates the definition of coarse-grained velocities; (2) the resulting uncertainty relations between the coordinate of the Brownian particle and the change of its coarse-grained velocity; (3) the fact that the coarse-grained velocity, though pertaining to a single Brownian particle, is defined on a common context of two particles. The Brownian entanglement is a consequence of a coarse-grained description and disappears for a finer resolution of the Brownian motion. Analogies with the quantum situation are discussed, as well as possibilities of experimental realization of the effect in examples of macroscopic Brownian motion.

arXiv:quant-ph/0412132•Physical Review A•Sep 6, 2005•41 citations

Brownian Motion: Classical and Semiclassical Entanglement

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We show that for two classical Brownian particles there exists an analog ofcontinuous-variable quantum entanglement: The common probability distributionof the two coordinates and the corresponding coarse-grained velocitiescannot be prepared via mixing of any factorized distributions referring tothe two particles in separate. This is possible for particles which interactedin the past, but do not interact in the present. Three factors are crucial forthe effect: (1) separation of time-scales of coordinate and momentum whichmotivates the definition of coarse-grained velocities; (2) the resulting uncertaintyrelations between the coordinate of the Brownian particle and thechange of its coarse-grained velocity; (3) the fact that the coarse-grained velocity,though pertaining to a single Brownian particle, is defined on a commoncontext of two particles. The Brownian entanglement is a consequenceof a coarse-grained description and disappears for a finer resolution of theBrownian motion. We discuss possibilities of its experimental realizations inexamples of macroscopic Brownian motion.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 28, 2024•0 citations

Thermodynamics of quantum Brownian motion with internal degrees of freedom: the role of entanglement in the strong-coupling quantum regime

Christian Hörhammer, H. Büttner

We study the influence of entanglement on the relation between the statistical entropy of an open quantum system and the heat exchanged with a low temperature environment. A model of quantum Brownian motion of the Caldeira–Leggett type—for which a violation of the Clausius inequality has been stated by Th M Nieuwenhuizen and A E Allahverdyan (2002 Phys. Rev. E 66 036102)—is re-examined and the results of the cited work are put into perspective. In order to address the problem from an information theoretical viewpoint a model of two coupled Brownian oscillators is formulated that can also be viewed as a continuum version of a two-qubit system. The influence of an additional internal coupling parameter on heat and entropy changes is described and the findings are compared to the case of a single Brownian particle.

arXiv:cond-mat/0408536•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Aug 3, 2005•24 citations

Non-Markovian dynamics, nonlocality, and entanglement in quantum Brownian motion

K. Shiokawa

The dynamical aspects of quantum Brownian motion at low temperatures are investigated. Exact calculations of quantum entanglement among two Brownian oscillators are given without invoking the Born-Markov or Born approximation widely used for the study of open systems. Nonlocality due to finite oscillator separation is studied. Our approach is applicable for arbitrary time scale, in particular suitable to probe the short-time regime at cold temperatures where many experiments on quantum information processing are performed. We study separability criteria based on the uncertainty relation, negativity, and entanglement of formation. We found a crossover behavior in a disentanglement process between quantum- and thermal-fluctuation-dominated regimes. The fluctuation-dissipation theorem is violated for two Brownian particles interacting with a common environment. The deviation from the relation originates in the interaction mediated by the environment, which drives two particles into a steady oscillatory state, preventing the system from thermalizing. Consequently there is a residual entanglement at low temperatures for arbitrary coupling strength. This entanglement is generated from the environment nonperturbatively even when two modes are not entangled initially. When the distance between two oscillators is varied, competition between entanglement induced from the environment and modified decoherence due to finite separation leads to the characteristic distance where entanglement is minimized.

arXiv:0809.1587•Physical Review A•Jan 9, 2009•16 citations

Environment-induced two-mode entanglement in quantum Brownian motion

Christian Hörhammer, H. Büttner

The time evolution of quantum correlations of entangled two-mode continuous variable states is examined in single-reservoir as well as two-reservoir models, representing noisy correlated or uncorrelated non-Markovian quantum channels. For this purpose the model of quantum Brownian motion is extended. Various separability criteria for Gaussian continuous variable systems are applied. In both types of reservoir models moderate non-Markovian effects prolong the separability time scales. However, in these models the properties of the stationary state may differ. In the two-reservoir model the initial entanglement is completely lost and both modes are finally uncorrelated. In a common reservoir both modes interact indirectly via the coupling to the same bath variables. Below a critical bath temperature entanglement between the two modes is preserved even in the steady state. A separability criterion is derived, which depends on the bath temperature and the response function of the open quantum system. Thus, the extended quantum Brownian motion model of a two-mode continuous variable system in a common reservoir provides an example of environment-induced entanglement.

arXiv:0708.2670•Physical Review A•Apr 4, 2008•57 citations

Thermal equilibrium of two quantum Brownian particles

D. Valente, A. O. Caldeira

The influence of the environment in the thermal equilibrium properties of a bipartite continuous variable quantum system is studied. The problem is treated within a system-plus-reservoir approach. The considered model reproduces the Brownian motion when the two particles are isolated and induces an effective interaction between them, depending on the choice of the spectral function of the bath. The coupling between the system and the environment guarantees the translational invariance of the system in the absence of an external potential. The entanglement between the particles is measured by the logarithmic negativity, which is shown to monotonically decrease with the increase of the temperature. A range of finite temperatures is found in which entanglement is still induced by the reservoir.

arXiv:0911.4894•Physical Review A•Jan 26, 2010•13 citations
We experimentally investigate the statistical properties of a classical analog of quantum entanglement between two Brownian particles connected by an elastic force and maintained at different temperatures through separate heat reservoirs. Uncertainty relations between coordinates and coarse-grained velocity can produce a phenomenon similar to quantum entanglement, where temperature plays the role of Planck's constant. The theoretical analysis matches the experimental results, confirming that the interconnected particles exhibit Brownian quantum-inspired classical correlation entanglement. This effect arises from a coarse-grained description of Brownian motion and vanishes at a finer resolution. The coarsening scale range is measured too.
For two classical Brownian particles an analog of continuous-variable quantum entanglement is presented: The common probability distribution of the two coordinates and the corresponding coarse-grained velocities cannot always be prepared via mixing of any factorized distributions referring to the two particles separately. This is possible for particles which have interacted in the past, but do not interact at present. Three factors are crucial for the effect: (1) separation of time scales of coordinate and momentum which motivates the definition of coarse-grained velocities; (2) the resulting uncertainty relations between the coordinate of the Brownian particle and the change of its coarse-grained velocity; (3) the fact that the coarse-grained velocity, though pertaining to a single Brownian particle, is defined on a common context of two particles. The Brownian entanglement is a consequence of a coarse-grained description and disappears for a finer resolution of the Brownian motion. Analogies with the quantum situation are discussed, as well as possibilities of experimental realization of the effect in examples of macroscopic Brownian motion.
We show that for two classical Brownian particles there exists an analog ofcontinuous-variable quantum entanglement: The common probability distributionof the two coordinates and the corresponding coarse-grained velocitiescannot be prepared via mixing of any factorized distributions referring tothe two particles in separate. This is possible for particles which interactedin the past, but do not interact in the present. Three factors are crucial forthe effect: (1) separation of time-scales of coordinate and momentum whichmotivates the definition of coarse-grained velocities; (2) the resulting uncertaintyrelations between the coordinate of the Brownian particle and thechange of its coarse-grained velocity; (3) the fact that the coarse-grained velocity,though pertaining to a single Brownian particle, is defined on a commoncontext of two particles. The Brownian entanglement is a consequenceof a coarse-grained description and disappears for a finer resolution of theBrownian motion. We discuss possibilities of its experimental realizations inexamples of macroscopic Brownian motion.
We study the influence of entanglement on the relation between the statistical entropy of an open quantum system and the heat exchanged with a low temperature environment. A model of quantum Brownian motion of the Caldeira–Leggett type—for which a violation of the Clausius inequality has been stated by Th M Nieuwenhuizen and A E Allahverdyan (2002 Phys. Rev. E 66 036102)—is re-examined and the results of the cited work are put into perspective. In order to address the problem from an information theoretical viewpoint a model of two coupled Brownian oscillators is formulated that can also be viewed as a continuum version of a two-qubit system. The influence of an additional internal coupling parameter on heat and entropy changes is described and the findings are compared to the case of a single Brownian particle.
The dynamical aspects of quantum Brownian motion at low temperatures are investigated. Exact calculations of quantum entanglement among two Brownian oscillators are given without invoking the Born-Markov or Born approximation widely used for the study of open systems. Nonlocality due to finite oscillator separation is studied. Our approach is applicable for arbitrary time scale, in particular suitable to probe the short-time regime at cold temperatures where many experiments on quantum information processing are performed. We study separability criteria based on the uncertainty relation, negativity, and entanglement of formation. We found a crossover behavior in a disentanglement process between quantum- and thermal-fluctuation-dominated regimes. The fluctuation-dissipation theorem is violated for two Brownian particles interacting with a common environment. The deviation from the relation originates in the interaction mediated by the environment, which drives two particles into a steady oscillatory state, preventing the system from thermalizing. Consequently there is a residual entanglement at low temperatures for arbitrary coupling strength. This entanglement is generated from the environment nonperturbatively even when two modes are not entangled initially. When the distance between two oscillators is varied, competition between entanglement induced from the environment and modified decoherence due to finite separation leads to the characteristic distance where entanglement is minimized.
The time evolution of quantum correlations of entangled two-mode continuous variable states is examined in single-reservoir as well as two-reservoir models, representing noisy correlated or uncorrelated non-Markovian quantum channels. For this purpose the model of quantum Brownian motion is extended. Various separability criteria for Gaussian continuous variable systems are applied. In both types of reservoir models moderate non-Markovian effects prolong the separability time scales. However, in these models the properties of the stationary state may differ. In the two-reservoir model the initial entanglement is completely lost and both modes are finally uncorrelated. In a common reservoir both modes interact indirectly via the coupling to the same bath variables. Below a critical bath temperature entanglement between the two modes is preserved even in the steady state. A separability criterion is derived, which depends on the bath temperature and the response function of the open quantum system. Thus, the extended quantum Brownian motion model of a two-mode continuous variable system in a common reservoir provides an example of environment-induced entanglement.
The influence of the environment in the thermal equilibrium properties of a bipartite continuous variable quantum system is studied. The problem is treated within a system-plus-reservoir approach. The considered model reproduces the Brownian motion when the two particles are isolated and induces an effective interaction between them, depending on the choice of the spectral function of the bath. The coupling between the system and the environment guarantees the translational invariance of the system in the absence of an external potential. The entanglement between the particles is measured by the logarithmic negativity, which is shown to monotonically decrease with the increase of the temperature. A range of finite temperatures is found in which entanglement is still induced by the reservoir.