Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2407.11137

Perfect quantum reflection from a cliff: a potential unbounded from below

Rodrigo Silva

Published Jul 15, 2024• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We explain how a potential that is well-defined everywhere on the positive half-line, but is nowhere positive and diverges to $-\infty$ as $x\rightarrow 0^+$, can nevertheless confine a particle to the half-line and lead to well-defined dynamics. Such perfect reflection from a "cliff" potential is achieved by a purely dynamical mechanism, without the need to impose any boundary conditions at the edge. We discuss in detail the role of self-adjointness in ensuring dynamical closure at the quantum level, and advocate the principle that, when no boundary conditions or other physical data are given, the formal quantized Hamiltonian is most naturally defined on its maximal domain. We then construct an explicit cliff potential with the claimed properties, showing that the Hamiltonian is self-adjoint on this maximal domain and therefore defines a dynamically closed quantum system. Finally, we study its energy eigenstates, spectrum, and the phase shift associated with the reflection.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2407.11137

Related papers

A Multidimensional Extension of the Half-Line Problem in Quantum Mechanics and an Experimental-Setting Interpretation of Self-Adjoint Realization

hideo umihara

This research note proposes an experimental-setting interpretation of self-adjoint realization for boundary-sensitive quantum systems. The starting point is the standard operator-theoretic fact that a formal differential expression does not by itself define quantum dynamics. A Hamiltonian becomes a physical generator of unitary evolution only after a Hilbert space, an operator domain, and a self-adjoint realization have been specified. The note extends the ordinary half-line problem in quantum mechanics to a multidimensional setting in which the coordinate axes act as axial endpoint or boundary sets. A weighted Hilbert space is introduced, and the local radial behavior near an axis is reduced to an effective inverse-square potential problem. The endpoint classification is then described in terms of the usual limit-circle/limit-point distinction. In particular, the phrase “spectral inaccessibility” is used only as an interpretive term; the rigorous statement is endpoint classification, such as limit-point behavior. The main conceptual contribution is the proposal that, in boundary-sensitive effective systems, an experimental setup may participate not only in selecting a state, but also in defining the effective subsystem itself. In this viewpoint, the setup may help select the relevant effective Hilbert space, operator domain, and self-adjoint realization before a subsystem wave function is assigned. Schematically, the proposed viewpoint is \[\Psi_{\rm tot}\quad\longrightarrow\quad\left(\mathcal H_{\rm sys},H_{\rm eff}^{(\theta_{\rm app})},\psi_{\rm sys}\right).\] Here \(\theta_{\rm app}\) is not asserted to be determined by a universal theorem. It is regarded as a model-dependent effective parameter that may arise from the apparatus, boundary region, contact interaction, or environment after reduction to a low-energy subsystem description. The note also clarifies that the statement “no effective wave function has yet been defined” does not deny the possible existence of a total quantum state. Rather, it means that the reduced subsystem wave function is meaningful only after the effective subsystem, its Hilbert space, and its self-adjoint Hamiltonian have been selected. Finally, the note identifies an open problem: the concrete derivation of \[H_{\rm tot}\quad\longrightarrow\quadH_{\rm eff}^{(\theta_{\rm app})}\] from a full self-adjoint total Hamiltonian. This reduction is interpreted as a state-preparation and effective Hamiltonian-engineering problem, rather than merely a measurement-outcome problem. A concrete model of this reduction is left for future work.

•May 15, 2026•0 citations

On Robin boundary conditions and the Morse potential in quantum mechanics

B. Belchev, Mark A. Walton

The physical origin of Robin boundary conditions is investigated for wavefunctions at an infinite reflecting wall. We consider both Schrödinger and phase-space quantum mechanics (also known as deformation quantization) for this simple example of a contact interaction. A non-relativistic particle moving freely on the half-line is treated as moving on the full line in the presence of an infinite potential wall, realized as a limit of a Morse potential. We show that the wavefunctions for the Morse states can become those for a free particle on the half-line with Robin boundary conditions. However, Dirichlet boundary conditions (standard walls) are obtained unless a mass-dependent fine tuning (to a reflection resonance) is imposed. This phenomenon was already observed for piece-wise flat potentials, so it is not removed by smoothing. We argue that it explains why standard quantum walls are standard. Next we consider the Wigner functions (the symbols of both diagonal and off-diagonal density operator elements) of phase-space quantum mechanics. Taking the (fine-tuned) limit, we show that our Wigner functions do reduce to the expected ones on the half-line. This confirms that the Wigner transform should indeed be unmodified for this contact interaction.

arXiv:1002.2139•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Feb 8, 2010•31 citations

Hearing the shape of a quantum boundary condition

Giuliano Angelone, Paolo Facchi A, Giuseppe Marmo

In this paper, we study the isospectrality problem for a free quantum particle confined in a ring with a junction, analyzing all the self-adjoint realizations of the corresponding Hamiltonian in terms of a boundary condition at the junction. In particular, by characterizing the energy spectrum in terms of a spectral function, we classify the self-adjoint realizations in two classes, identifying all the families of isospectral Hamiltonians. These two classes turn out to be discerned by the action of parity (i.e. space reflection), which plays a central role in our discussion.

arXiv:2204.10248•Modern Physics Letters A•Jun 7, 2022•8 citations

Self-Adjointness and the Renormalization of Singular Potentials

Sarang Gopalakrishnan, William Loinaz

Schrodinger operators with very singular potentials fail to produce reasonable spectra, because the usual boundary conditions are insufficient to make them self-adjoint. If one regularizes a singular potential at a length , the bound state energies diverge as → 0. A meaningful spectrum can be restored by picking a self-adjoint extension of the operator, by renormalizing the theory, or by allowing nonunitary time evolution. We show that renormalizations of the 1/r potential fall into two classes: those that are asymptotically equivalent to self-adjoint extensions, and those that reduce to treatments of delta functions. We also apply the apparatus of self-adjoint extensions and renormalization to clarify aspects of anomalous symmetry breaking, supersymmetric quantum mechanics, and one-dimensional quantum mechanics. Lines composed upon reading a thesis abstract by S. Gopalakrishnan Think a moment, dear reader, of that long-legged fly, The sprung meniscus underfoot, And what asymptotes invisible to well-trained eyes Still break the surface at its root. How a singular potential picks tight-bounded energy Apart till it no longer recognizes Its own mirrored face, its extensions, or symmetry; Unless one cautiously renormalizes. You have tried in these pensive pages to show the stuff Such theory’s made of, its quiddity When logic is applied to the diamond rough, And quantum notes ring purely. May Apollo’s clarity pierce through your reasoning And self-adjointed truth and fact Elevate your thought to that sense so pleasing When truth recovers nature’s pact.

•Jan 1, 2006•15 citations

The time-dependent Schrödinger equation: the need for the Hamiltonian to be self-adjoint

Vanilse S. Araujo, Francisco Antônio Bezerra Coutinho, F. Masafumi Toyama

We present some simple arguments to show that quantum mechanics operators are required to be self-adjoint. We emphasize that the very definition of a self-adjoint operator includes the prescription of a certain domain of the operator. We then use these concepts to revisit the solutions of the time-dependent Schroedinger equation of some well-known simple problems - the infinite square well, the finite square well, and the harmonic oscillator. We show that these elementary illustrations can be enriched by using more general boundary conditions, which are still compatible with self-adjointness. In particular, we show that a puzzling problem associated with the Hydrogen atom in one dimension can be clarified by applying the correct requirements of self-adjointness. We then come to Stone\'s theorem, which is the main topic of this paper, and which is shown to relate the usual definitions of a self-adjoint operator to the possibility of constructing well-defined solutions of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation.

Brazilian Journal of Physics•Mar 1, 2008•13 citations

Quantum reflection in the linearly downward potential

N Chamnan, Boonlit Krunavakarn

In this work, the motion of a particle in one dimension under the influence of the linearly downward potential well is studied within the context of the non-relativistic quantum mechanics. The attention is paid on the paradoxical phenomenon of the reflection of a particle that is in contrast between classical and quantum physics. Classically, the reflection effect occurs only at a potential barrier. To demonstrate such counter-intuitive phenomenon, the Schrödinger equation is solved to obtain the reflection coefficient in the scattering state by considering an incident particle that is represented by a monochromatic plane wave having an energy E > 0, propagates freely from left to right, pass through the potential well. The continuity conditions at boundaries give the desired result that is expressed in terms of the Airy functions which depends on the incident energy E, the strength jV 0 j and the range L of the well. The value of the reflection coefficient R lies in the interval 0 < R < 1, and its behavior is the decreasing function with respect to the range L.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Sep 1, 2017•1 citation
We explain how a potential that is well-defined everywhere on the positive half-line, but is nowhere positive and diverges to −∞-\infty−∞ as x→0+x\rightarrow 0^+x→0+, can nevertheless confine a particle to the half-line and lead to well-defined dynamics. Such perfect reflection from a "cliff" potential is achieved by a purely dynamical mechanism, without the need to impose any boundary conditions at the edge. We discuss in detail the role of self-adjointness in ensuring dynamical closure at the quantum level, and advocate the principle that, when no boundary conditions or other physical data are given, the formal quantized Hamiltonian is most naturally defined on its maximal domain. We then construct an explicit cliff potential with the claimed properties, showing that the Hamiltonian is self-adjoint on this maximal domain and therefore defines a dynamically closed quantum system. Finally, we study its energy eigenstates, spectrum, and the phase shift associated with the reflection.
This research note proposes an experimental-setting interpretation of self-adjoint realization for boundary-sensitive quantum systems. The starting point is the standard operator-theoretic fact that a formal differential expression does not by itself define quantum dynamics. A Hamiltonian becomes a physical generator of unitary evolution only after a Hilbert space, an operator domain, and a self-adjoint realization have been specified. The note extends the ordinary half-line problem in quantum mechanics to a multidimensional setting in which the coordinate axes act as axial endpoint or boundary sets. A weighted Hilbert space is introduced, and the local radial behavior near an axis is reduced to an effective inverse-square potential problem. The endpoint classification is then described in terms of the usual limit-circle/limit-point distinction. In particular, the phrase “spectral inaccessibility” is used only as an interpretive term; the rigorous statement is endpoint classification, such as limit-point behavior. The main conceptual contribution is the proposal that, in boundary-sensitive effective systems, an experimental setup may participate not only in selecting a state, but also in defining the effective subsystem itself. In this viewpoint, the setup may help select the relevant effective Hilbert space, operator domain, and self-adjoint realization before a subsystem wave function is assigned. Schematically, the proposed viewpoint is Ψtot⟶(Hsys,Heff(θapp),ψsys).\Psi_{\rm tot}\quad\longrightarrow\quad\left(\mathcal H_{\rm sys},H_{\rm eff}^{(\theta_{\rm app})},\psi_{\rm sys}\right).Ψtot​⟶(Hsys​,Heff(θapp​)​,ψsys​). Here θapp\theta_{\rm app}θapp​ is not asserted to be determined by a universal theorem. It is regarded as a model-dependent effective parameter that may arise from the apparatus, boundary region, contact interaction, or environment after reduction to a low-energy subsystem description. The note also clarifies that the statement “no effective wave function has yet been defined” does not deny the possible existence of a total quantum state. Rather, it means that the reduced subsystem wave function is meaningful only after the effective subsystem, its Hilbert space, and its self-adjoint Hamiltonian have been selected. Finally, the note identifies an open problem: the concrete derivation of \[H_{\rm tot}\quad\longrightarrow\quadH_{\rm eff}^{(\theta_{\rm app})}\] from a full self-adjoint total Hamiltonian. This reduction is interpreted as a state-preparation and effective Hamiltonian-engineering problem, rather than merely a measurement-outcome problem. A concrete model of this reduction is left for future work.
The physical origin of Robin boundary conditions is investigated for wavefunctions at an infinite reflecting wall. We consider both Schrödinger and phase-space quantum mechanics (also known as deformation quantization) for this simple example of a contact interaction. A non-relativistic particle moving freely on the half-line is treated as moving on the full line in the presence of an infinite potential wall, realized as a limit of a Morse potential. We show that the wavefunctions for the Morse states can become those for a free particle on the half-line with Robin boundary conditions. However, Dirichlet boundary conditions (standard walls) are obtained unless a mass-dependent fine tuning (to a reflection resonance) is imposed. This phenomenon was already observed for piece-wise flat potentials, so it is not removed by smoothing. We argue that it explains why standard quantum walls are standard. Next we consider the Wigner functions (the symbols of both diagonal and off-diagonal density operator elements) of phase-space quantum mechanics. Taking the (fine-tuned) limit, we show that our Wigner functions do reduce to the expected ones on the half-line. This confirms that the Wigner transform should indeed be unmodified for this contact interaction.
In this paper, we study the isospectrality problem for a free quantum particle confined in a ring with a junction, analyzing all the self-adjoint realizations of the corresponding Hamiltonian in terms of a boundary condition at the junction. In particular, by characterizing the energy spectrum in terms of a spectral function, we classify the self-adjoint realizations in two classes, identifying all the families of isospectral Hamiltonians. These two classes turn out to be discerned by the action of parity (i.e. space reflection), which plays a central role in our discussion.
Schrodinger operators with very singular potentials fail to produce reasonable spectra, because the usual boundary conditions are insufficient to make them self-adjoint. If one regularizes a singular potential at a length , the bound state energies diverge as → 0. A meaningful spectrum can be restored by picking a self-adjoint extension of the operator, by renormalizing the theory, or by allowing nonunitary time evolution. We show that renormalizations of the 1/r potential fall into two classes: those that are asymptotically equivalent to self-adjoint extensions, and those that reduce to treatments of delta functions. We also apply the apparatus of self-adjoint extensions and renormalization to clarify aspects of anomalous symmetry breaking, supersymmetric quantum mechanics, and one-dimensional quantum mechanics. Lines composed upon reading a thesis abstract by S. Gopalakrishnan Think a moment, dear reader, of that long-legged fly, The sprung meniscus underfoot, And what asymptotes invisible to well-trained eyes Still break the surface at its root. How a singular potential picks tight-bounded energy Apart till it no longer recognizes Its own mirrored face, its extensions, or symmetry; Unless one cautiously renormalizes. You have tried in these pensive pages to show the stuff Such theory’s made of, its quiddity When logic is applied to the diamond rough, And quantum notes ring purely. May Apollo’s clarity pierce through your reasoning And self-adjointed truth and fact Elevate your thought to that sense so pleasing When truth recovers nature’s pact.
We present some simple arguments to show that quantum mechanics operators are required to be self-adjoint. We emphasize that the very definition of a self-adjoint operator includes the prescription of a certain domain of the operator. We then use these concepts to revisit the solutions of the time-dependent Schroedinger equation of some well-known simple problems - the infinite square well, the finite square well, and the harmonic oscillator. We show that these elementary illustrations can be enriched by using more general boundary conditions, which are still compatible with self-adjointness. In particular, we show that a puzzling problem associated with the Hydrogen atom in one dimension can be clarified by applying the correct requirements of self-adjointness. We then come to Stone\'s theorem, which is the main topic of this paper, and which is shown to relate the usual definitions of a self-adjoint operator to the possibility of constructing well-defined solutions of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation.
In this work, the motion of a particle in one dimension under the influence of the linearly downward potential well is studied within the context of the non-relativistic quantum mechanics. The attention is paid on the paradoxical phenomenon of the reflection of a particle that is in contrast between classical and quantum physics. Classically, the reflection effect occurs only at a potential barrier. To demonstrate such counter-intuitive phenomenon, the Schrödinger equation is solved to obtain the reflection coefficient in the scattering state by considering an incident particle that is represented by a monochromatic plane wave having an energy E > 0, propagates freely from left to right, pass through the potential well. The continuity conditions at boundaries give the desired result that is expressed in terms of the Airy functions which depends on the incident energy E, the strength jV 0 j and the range L of the well. The value of the reflection coefficient R lies in the interval 0 < R < 1, and its behavior is the decreasing function with respect to the range L.