Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2402.05524

Quantum algorithms for the Sylvester denumerant and the numerical semigroup membership problem

Joaquín Ossorio-Castillo, José M. Tornero

Published Feb 8, 2024• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Two quantum algorithms are presented, which tackle well--known problems in the context of numerical semigroups: the numerical semigroup membership problem (NSMP) and the Sylvester denumerant problem (SDP).
DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2402.05524

Related papers

Quantum álgorithms for the combinatorial invariants of numerical semigroups

Joaquín Ossorio-Castillo

It was back in spring 2014 when the author of this doctoral dissertation was finishing its master thesis, whose main objective was the understanding of Peter W. Shor’s most praised result, a quantum algorithm capable of factoring integers in polynomial time. During the development of this master thesis, me and my yet-tobe doctoral advisor studied the main aspects of quantum computing from a purely algebraic perspective. This research eventually evolved into a sufficiently thorough canvas capable of explaining the main aspects and features of the mentioned algorithm from within an undergraduate context. Just after its conclusion, we seated down and elaborated a research plan for a future Ph.D. thesis, which would expectantly involve quantum computing but also a branch of algebra whose apparently innocent definitions hide some really hard problems from a computational perspective: the theory of numerical semigroups. As will be seen later, the definition of numerical semigroup does not involve sophisticated knowledge from any somewhat obscure and distant branch of the tree of mathematics. Nonetheless, a number of combinatorial problems associated with these numerical semigroups are extremely hard to solve, even when the size of the input is relatively small. Some examples of these problems are the calculations of the Frobenius number, the Apéry set, and the Sylvester denumerant, all of them bearing the name of legendary mathematicians. This thesis is the result of our multiple attempts to tackle those combinatorial problems with the help of a hypothetical quantum computer. First, Chapter 2 is devoted to numerical semigroups and computational complexity theory, and is divided into three sections. In Section 2.1, we give the formal definition of a numerical semigroup, along with a description of the main problems involved with them. In Section 2.2, we sketch the fundamental concepts of complexity theory, in order to understand the true significance within the inherent hardness concealed in the resolution of those problems. Finally, in Section 2.3 we prove the computational complexity of the problems we aim to solve. Chapter 3 is the result of our outline of the theory of quantum computing. We give the basic definitions and concepts needed for understanding the particular place that quantum computers occupy in the world of Turing machines, and also the main elements that compose this particular model of computation: quantum bits and quantum entanglement. We also explain the two most common models of quantum computation, namely quantum circuits and adiabatic quantum computers. For all of them we give mathematical definitions, but always having in mind the physical experiments from which they stemmed. Chapter 4 is also about quantum computing, but from an algorithmical perspective. We present the most important quantum algorithms to date in a standardized way, explaining their context, their impact and consequences, while giving a mathematical proof of their correctness and worked-out examples. We begin with the early algorithms of Deutsch, Deutsch-Jozsa, and Simon, and then proceed to explain their importance in the dawn of quantum computation. Then, we describe the major landmarks: Shor’s factoring, Grover’s search, and quantum counting. Chapter 5 is the culmination of all previously explained concepts, as it includes the description of various quantum algorithms capable of solving the main problems inside the branch of numerical semigrops. We present quantum circuit algorithms for the Sylvester denumerant and the numerical semigroup membership, and adiabatic quantum algorithms for the Ap´ery Set and the Frobenius problem. We also describe a C++ library called numsem, specially developed within the context of this doctoral thesis and which helps us to study the computational hardness of all previously explained problems from a classical perspective. This thesis is intended to be autoconclusive at least in the main branches of mathematics in which it is supported; that is to say numerical semigroups, computational complexity theory, and quantum computation. Nevertheless, for the majority of concepts explained here we give references for the interested reader that wants to delve more into them.

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations

Quantum algorithms in group theory

M Batty, SL Braunstein, Andrew J. Duncan +1 more

We present a survey of quantum algorithms, primarily for an intended audience of pure mathematicians. We place an emphasis on algorithms involving group theory.

•Dec 31, 2004•0 citations

Quantum Algorithms

Seyed Massoud Amini

We give a short overview of quantum algorithms. Some famous algorithms such as Deutsch-Jozsa and Simon are covered with more details. The directions for further development are addressed,

•Jun 1, 2009•0 citations

Quantum computation of discrete logarithms in semigroups

Andrew M. Childs, Gábor Ivanyos

Abstract We describe an efficient quantum algorithm for computing discrete logarithms in semigroups using Shor's algorithms for period finding and the discrete logarithm problem as subroutines. Thus proposed cryptosystems based on the presumed hardness of discrete logarithms in semigroups are insecure against quantum attacks. In contrast, we show that some generalizations of the discrete logarithm problem are hard in semigroups despite being easy in groups. We relate a shifted version of the discrete logarithm problem in semigroups to the dihedral hidden subgroup problem, and we show that the constructive membership problem with respect to k ≥ 2 generators in a black-box abelian semigroup of order N requires Θ ˜ ( N 1 2 - 1 2 k ) $\tilde{\Theta }(N^{\frac{1}{2}-\frac{1}{2k}})$ quantum queries.

arXiv:1310.6238•Journal of Mathematical Cryptology•Jul 8, 2014•32 citations

A Quantum NP Solver: NP in QP

Clarke, Thomas L.

A attempt at a quantum algorithm for solving NP problems is presented. Now withdrawn because some crucial operators were not unitary.

arXiv:quant-ph/9908080•Aug 27, 1999•0 citations

Quantum algorithms for a set of group theoretic problems

Stephen Fenner, Yong Zhang

We study two group theoretic problems, GROUP INTERSECTION and DOUBLE COSET MEMBERSHIP, in the setting of black-box groups, where DOUBLE COSET MEMBERSHIP generalizes a set of problems, including GROUP MEMBERSHIP, GROUP FACTORIZATION, and COSET INTERSECTION. No polynomial-time classical algorithms are known for these problems. We show that for solvable groups, there exist efficient quantum algorithms for GROUP INTERSECTION if one of the underlying solvable groups has a smoothly solvable commutator subgroup, and for DOUBLE COSET MEMBERSHIP if one of the underlying solvable groups is smoothly solvable. We also study the decision versions of STABILIZER and ORBIT COSET, which generalizes GROUP INTERSECTION and DOUBLE COSET MEMBERSHIP, respectively. We show that they reduce to ORBIT COSET under certain conditions. Finally, we show that DOUBLE COSET MEMBERSHIP and DOUBLE COSET NONMEMBERSHIP have zero knowledge proof systems.

arXiv:quant-ph/0408150•Aug 24, 2004•1 citation
It was back in spring 2014 when the author of this doctoral dissertation was finishing its master thesis, whose main objective was the understanding of Peter W. Shor’s most praised result, a quantum algorithm capable of factoring integers in polynomial time. During the development of this master thesis, me and my yet-tobe doctoral advisor studied the main aspects of quantum computing from a purely algebraic perspective. This research eventually evolved into a sufficiently thorough canvas capable of explaining the main aspects and features of the mentioned algorithm from within an undergraduate context. Just after its conclusion, we seated down and elaborated a research plan for a future Ph.D. thesis, which would expectantly involve quantum computing but also a branch of algebra whose apparently innocent definitions hide some really hard problems from a computational perspective: the theory of numerical semigroups. As will be seen later, the definition of numerical semigroup does not involve sophisticated knowledge from any somewhat obscure and distant branch of the tree of mathematics. Nonetheless, a number of combinatorial problems associated with these numerical semigroups are extremely hard to solve, even when the size of the input is relatively small. Some examples of these problems are the calculations of the Frobenius number, the Apéry set, and the Sylvester denumerant, all of them bearing the name of legendary mathematicians. This thesis is the result of our multiple attempts to tackle those combinatorial problems with the help of a hypothetical quantum computer. First, Chapter 2 is devoted to numerical semigroups and computational complexity theory, and is divided into three sections. In Section 2.1, we give the formal definition of a numerical semigroup, along with a description of the main problems involved with them. In Section 2.2, we sketch the fundamental concepts of complexity theory, in order to understand the true significance within the inherent hardness concealed in the resolution of those problems. Finally, in Section 2.3 we prove the computational complexity of the problems we aim to solve. Chapter 3 is the result of our outline of the theory of quantum computing. We give the basic definitions and concepts needed for understanding the particular place that quantum computers occupy in the world of Turing machines, and also the main elements that compose this particular model of computation: quantum bits and quantum entanglement. We also explain the two most common models of quantum computation, namely quantum circuits and adiabatic quantum computers. For all of them we give mathematical definitions, but always having in mind the physical experiments from which they stemmed. Chapter 4 is also about quantum computing, but from an algorithmical perspective. We present the most important quantum algorithms to date in a standardized way, explaining their context, their impact and consequences, while giving a mathematical proof of their correctness and worked-out examples. We begin with the early algorithms of Deutsch, Deutsch-Jozsa, and Simon, and then proceed to explain their importance in the dawn of quantum computation. Then, we describe the major landmarks: Shor’s factoring, Grover’s search, and quantum counting. Chapter 5 is the culmination of all previously explained concepts, as it includes the description of various quantum algorithms capable of solving the main problems inside the branch of numerical semigrops. We present quantum circuit algorithms for the Sylvester denumerant and the numerical semigroup membership, and adiabatic quantum algorithms for the Ap´ery Set and the Frobenius problem. We also describe a C++ library called numsem, specially developed within the context of this doctoral thesis and which helps us to study the computational hardness of all previously explained problems from a classical perspective. This thesis is intended to be autoconclusive at least in the main branches of mathematics in which it is supported; that is to say numerical semigroups, computational complexity theory, and quantum computation. Nevertheless, for the majority of concepts explained here we give references for the interested reader that wants to delve more into them.
Abstract We describe an efficient quantum algorithm for computing discrete logarithms in semigroups using Shor's algorithms for period finding and the discrete logarithm problem as subroutines. Thus proposed cryptosystems based on the presumed hardness of discrete logarithms in semigroups are insecure against quantum attacks. In contrast, we show that some generalizations of the discrete logarithm problem are hard in semigroups despite being easy in groups. We relate a shifted version of the discrete logarithm problem in semigroups to the dihedral hidden subgroup problem, and we show that the constructive membership problem with respect to k ≥ 2 generators in a black-box abelian semigroup of order N requires Θ ˜ ( N 1 2 - 1 2 k ) Θ~(N12−12k)\tilde{\Theta }(N^{\frac{1}{2}-\frac{1}{2k}})Θ~(N21​−2k1​) quantum queries.
We study two group theoretic problems, GROUP INTERSECTION and DOUBLE COSET MEMBERSHIP, in the setting of black-box groups, where DOUBLE COSET MEMBERSHIP generalizes a set of problems, including GROUP MEMBERSHIP, GROUP FACTORIZATION, and COSET INTERSECTION. No polynomial-time classical algorithms are known for these problems. We show that for solvable groups, there exist efficient quantum algorithms for GROUP INTERSECTION if one of the underlying solvable groups has a smoothly solvable commutator subgroup, and for DOUBLE COSET MEMBERSHIP if one of the underlying solvable groups is smoothly solvable. We also study the decision versions of STABILIZER and ORBIT COSET, which generalizes GROUP INTERSECTION and DOUBLE COSET MEMBERSHIP, respectively. We show that they reduce to ORBIT COSET under certain conditions. Finally, we show that DOUBLE COSET MEMBERSHIP and DOUBLE COSET NONMEMBERSHIP have zero knowledge proof systems.