We identify morphisms of strong profunctors as a categorification of quantum supermaps. These black-box generalisations of diagrams-with-holes are hence placed within the broader field of profunctor optics, as morphisms in the category of copresheaves on concrete networks. This enables the first construction of abstract logical connectives such as tensor products and negations for supermaps in a totally theory-independent setting. These logical connectives are found to be all that is needed to abstractly model the key structural features of the quantum theory of supermaps: black-box indefinite causal order, black-box definite causal order, and the factorisation of definitely causally ordered supermaps into concrete circuit diagrams. We demonstrate that at the heart of these factorisation theorems lies the Yoneda lemma and the notion of representability.
We identify morphisms of strong profunctors as a categorification of quantum supermaps. These black-box generalisations of diagrams-with-holes are hence placed within the broader field of profunctor optics, as morphisms in the category of copresheaves on concrete networks. This enables the first construction of abstract logical connectives such as tensor products and negations for supermaps in a totally theory-independent setting. These logical connectives are found to be all that is needed to abstractly model the key structural features of the quantum theory of supermaps: black-box indefinite causal order, black-box definite causal order, and the factorisation of definitely causally ordered supermaps into concrete circuit diagrams. We demonstrate that at the heart of these factorisation theorems lies the Yoneda lemma and the notion of representability.
Categorical supermaps generalise higher-order quantum operations from finite-dimensional quantum theory to arbitrary circuit theories. In this paper, we establish the Yoneda lemma for categorical supermaps, which states that whenever a physical theory has a suitable notion of channel-state duality, then categorical supermaps on that theory can be concretely represented in terms of that duality. This lemma eliminates any guesswork or ambiguity when defining the appropriate notion of supermap for these theories. As a concrete application, we show that the categorical supermaps on Boxworld are in general characterised by a physically well-motivated weaking of the recently proposed NSWSE principle for higher-order processes on boxworld. Furthermore, via the same Yoneda lemma we put forward a stable definition for supermaps in real quantum theory.
We explore the sense in which the existing constructions for higher-order maps on quantum theory based on causality constraints and compositionality constraints respectively, coincide. More precisely, we construct a functor F : Caus(C) -> StProf(C1) from higher-order causal categories to the category of strong profunctors over first-order causal processes that is lax-lax duoidal, full, faithful, and strongly closed whenever C is additive. When C = CP this embedding is furthermore strong on the sequencer for duoidal categories, expressing the possibility to interpret one-way signalling (but not general non-signalling) constraints in terms of the coend calculus for profunctors. We conclude that insofar as compositional constraints can be used to express causality constraints, the profunctorial approach generalises higher-order quantum theory to a construction over general symmetric monoidal categories.
Quantum supermaps are transformations that map quantum operations to quantum operations.It is known that quantum supermaps which respect a definite, predefined causal order between their input operations correspond to fixed-order quantum circuits, also called quantum combs.A systematic understanding of the physical interpretation of more general types of quantum supermaps-in particular, those incompatible with a definite causal structure-is however lacking.In this paper, we identify two types of circuits that naturally generalize the fixed-order case and that likewise correspond to distinct classes of quantum supermaps, which we fully characterize.We first introduce "quantum circuits with classical control of causal order," in which the order of operations is still well defined, but not necessarily fixed in advance: it can, in particular, be established dynamically, in a classically controlled manner, as the circuit is being used.We then consider "quantum circuits with quantum control of causal order," in which the order of operations is controlled coherently.The supermaps described by these classes of circuits are physically realizable, and the latter encompasses all known examples of physically realizable processes with indefinite causal order, including the celebrated "quantum switch."Interestingly, it also contains other examples arising from the combination of dynamical and coherent control of causal order, and we detail explicitly one such process.Nevertheless, we show that quantum circuits with quantum control of causal order can only generate "causal" correlations, compatible with a well-defined causal order.We furthermore extend our considerations to probabilistic circuits that produce also classical outcomes, and we demonstrate by an example how the characterizations derived in this work allow us to identify advantages for quantum information processing tasks that could be demonstrated in practice.
Quantum supermaps provide a framework in which higher order quantum processes can act on lower order quantum processes. In doing so, they enable the definition and analysis of new quantum protocols and causal structures. Recently, key features of quantum supermaps were captured through a general categorical framework, which led to a framework of higher order process theories (HOPT). The HOPT framework models lower and higher order transformations in a single unified theory, with its mathematical structure shown to coincide with the notion of a closed symmetric monoidal category. Here we provide an equivalent construction of the HOPT framework from four simple axioms of process-theoretic nature. We then use the HOPT framework to establish connections between foundational features such as causality, determinism and signalling, alongside exploring their interaction with the mathematical structure of *-autonomy.
Quantum theory challenges classical causal explanations for physical phenomena, calling for a quantum generalisation of causal structure. This thesis advances the study of causal decompositions, a research programme that aims to bridge two prominent, yet conceptually distinct types of structural assumption found across the quantum causality literature. The first is in terms of the global dependency relations between input and output systems of quantum transformations, which in the unitary case we shall refer to as causal structure; the second is in terms of the compositional structure of quantum circuits or networks. Concretely, a causal decomposition is a circuit representation of a unitary transformation in which no-influence relations that hold between its inputs and outputs are made manifest in the absence of paths through the circuit connecting them. Applications include translating between different quantum causal modelling frameworks; equipping a framework based on unitary causal structure with a local, bottom-up description via generalised autonomous causal mechanisms; and relating notions of compatibility between quantum transformations and relativistic causality. Whether causal decompositions always exist remains an open problem. The contributions of this thesis are threefold. First, we develop an order-theoretic account of circuit syntax and demonstrate that every circuit with a given input-output connectivity can be rewritten into a one of a canonical form given by the concept lattice construction from lattice theory. This systematises the search for causal decompositions by providing the shape of the quantum circuit one should look for. Second, we establish a combinatorial condition that fully characterises when causal decompositions into unitary quantum circuits exist without requiring the generalisation to routed quantum circuits prompted by earlier research. This solves a well-defined subproblem of the broader quest, and our proof, an interplay of order theory and operator algebra, lays a foundation for future extensions. Third, we detail the application to relativistic causality. Within a multipartite framework generalising existing literature, we emphasise that the mere lack of superluminal signalling through a quantum channel is not sufficient to conclude its realisability by dynamics that are locally consistent with relativity theory. We conjecture that, on the other hand, a lack of superluminal causal influences through its unitary dilations is sufficient—at least up to arbitrarily small errors. We demonstrate this in various special cases and show that the general statement reduces to the existence of a weak version of causal decompositions.
We provide a new characterisation of quantum supermaps in terms of an axiom that refers only to sequential and parallel composition. Consequently, we generalize quantum supermaps to arbitrary monoidal categories and operational probabilistic theories. We do so by providing a simple definition of locally-applicable transformation on a monoidal category. The definition can be rephrased in the language of category theory using the principle of naturality, and can be given an intuitive diagrammatic representation in terms of which all proofs are presented. In our main technical contribution, we use this diagrammatic representation to show that locally-applicable transformations on quantum channels are in one-to-one correspondence with deterministic quantum supermaps. This alternative characterization of quantum supermaps is proven to work for more general multiple-input supermaps such as the quantum switch and on arbitrary normal convex spaces of quantum channels such as those defined by satisfaction of signaling constraints.