Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2312.09218

Speed limits of two-qubit gates with qudits

Bora Basyildiz, Casey Jameson, Zhexuan Gong

Published Dec 14, 2023• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The speed of elementary quantum gates ultimately sets the limit on the speed at which quantum circuits can operate. For a fixed physical interaction strength between two qubits, the speed of any two-qubit gate is limited even with arbitrarily fast single-qubit gates. In this work, we explore the possibilities of speeding up two-qubit gates beyond such a limit by expanding our computational space outside the qubit subspace, which is experimentally relevant for qubits encoded in multi-level atoms or anharmonic oscillators. We identify an optimal theoretical bound for the speed limit of a two-qubit gate achieved using two qudits with a bounded interaction strength and arbitrarily fast single-qudit gates. In addition, we find an experimentally feasible protocol using two parametrically coupled superconducting transmons that achieves this theoretical speed limit in a non-trivial way. We also consider practical scenarios with limited single-qudit drive strengths and off-resonant transitions. For such scenarios, we develop an open-source, machine learning assisted, quantum optimal control algorithm that can achieve a speedup close to the theoretical limit with near-perfect gate fidelity. This work opens up a new avenue to speed up two-qubit gates when the physical interaction strength between qubits cannot be easily increased while extra states outside the qubit subspace can be well controlled.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2312.09218

Related papers

Implementing two-qubit gates at the quantum speed limit

J.E. Howard, Alexander Lidiak, Casey Jameson +8 more

The speed of elementary quantum gates, particularly two-qubit gates, ultimately sets the limit on the speed at which quantum circuits can operate. In this work, we experimentally demonstrate commonly used two-qubit gates at nearly the fastest possible speed allowed by the physical interaction strength between two superconducting transmon qubits. We achieve this quantum speed limit by implementing experimental gates designed using a machine-learning-inspired optimal control method. Importantly, our method only requires the single-qubit drive strength to be moderately larger than the interaction strength to achieve an arbitrary two-qubit gate close to its analytical speed limit with high fidelity. Thus the method is applicable to a variety of platforms, including those with comparable single-qubit and two-qubit gate speeds, or those with always-on interactions. We expect our method to offer significant speedups for non-native two-qubit gates that are typically achieved with a long sequence of single-qubit and native two-qubit gates.

arXiv:2206.07716•Physical Review Research•Dec 1, 2023•19 citations

Speed limits for two-qubit gates with weakly anharmonic qubits

Sahel Ashhab, Fumiki Yoshihara, Tomoko Fuse +3 more

We consider the implementation of two-qubit gates when the physical systems used to realize the qubits possess additional quantum states in the accessible energy range. We use optimal control theory to determine the maximum achievable gate speed for two-qubit gates in the qubit subspace of the many-level Hilbert space, and we analyze the effect of the additional quantum states on the gate speed. We identify two competing mechanisms. On one hand, higher energy levels are generally more strongly coupled to each other. Under suitable conditions, this stronger coupling can be utilized to make two-qubit gates significantly faster than the reference value based on simple qubits. On the other hand, a weak anharmonicity constrains the speed at which the system can be adequately controlled: according to the intuitive picture, faster operations require stronger control fields, which are more likely to excite higher levels in a weakly anharmonic system, which in turn leads to faster decoherence and uncontrolled leakage outside the qubit space. To account for this constraint, we modify the pulse optimization algorithm to avoid pulses that lead to appreciable population of the higher levels. In this case, we find that the presence of the higher levels can lead to a significant reduction in the maximum achievable gate speed. We also compare the optimal-control gate speeds with those obtained using the cross-resonance or selective-darkening gate protocol. We find that this protocol, with some parameter optimization, can be used to achieve a relatively fast implementation of the controlled-NOT gate. These results can help the search for optimized gate implementations in realistic quantum computing architectures, such as those based on superconducting circuits. They also provide guidelines for desirable conditions on anharmonicity that would allow optimal utilization of the higher levels to achieve fast quantum gates.

arXiv:2109.01469•Physical Review A•Apr 25, 2022•16 citations

Speed limits of two-qutrit gates

Bora Basyildiz, Zhexuan Gong, Sahel Ashhab

The speed of elementary quantum gates sets a limit on the speed at which quantum circuits can be applied and, as a result, the size of the computations that can be performed on a quantum computer. This limitation stems from the fact that present-day quantum hardware systems have finite coherence times that limit the total computation time. The speeds of qubit gates in various hardware settings have been well studied over the past few decades. The recent interest in multi-level quantum systems naturally creates a need for similar investigations of the speeds of multi-level or qudit gates. In this work, we perform an empirical study of the speed limit for the three-level or qutrit CZ gate. Our analysis focuses on a theoretical model for capacitively coupled superconducting transmons but can be extended to other systems. We generate CZ gate protocols using optimal control theory techniques and observe when the fidelity crosses certain thresholds. In addition to the empirical approach, we derive an analytical speed limit for the qutrit CZ gate using traditional quantum speed limit techniques. We compare the speed limits derived using these two different approaches and discuss the gap that remains between them. We also compare the time needed to implement the qutrit CZ gate with its qubit counterpart.

arXiv:2510.07742•Oct 9, 2025•0 citations

Speed limits for quantum gates with weakly anharmonic qubits

Sahel Ashhab, Fumiki Yoshihara, Tomoko Fuse +3 more

We consider the implementation of two-qubit gates when the physical systems used to realize the qubits are weakly anharmonic and therefore possess additional quantum states in the accessible energy range. We analyze the effect of the additional quantum states on the maximum achievable speed for quantum gates in the qubit state space. By calculating the minimum gate time using optimal control theory, we find that higher energy levels can help make two-qubit gates significantly faster than the reference value based on simple qubits. This speedup is a result of the higher coupling strength between higher energy levels. We then analyze the situation where the pulse optimization algorithm avoids pulses that excite the higher levels. We find that in this case the presence of the additional states can lead to a significant reduction in the maximum achievable gate speed. We also compare the optimal control gate times with those obtained using the cross-resonance/selective-darkening gate protocol. We find that the latter, with some parameter optimization, can be used to achieve a relatively fast implementation of the CNOT gate. These results can help the search for optimized gate implementations in realistic quantum computing architectures, such as those based on superconducting qubits. They also provide guidelines for desirable conditions on anharmonicity that would allow optimal utilization of the higher levels to achieve fast quantum gates.

•Sep 3, 2021•0 citations

Quantum Computing with Superconducting Circuits in the Picosecond Regime

Daoquan Zhu, Tuomas Jaako, Qiongyi He +1 more

We discuss the realization of a universal set of ultrafast single- and two-qubit operations with superconducting quantum circuits and investigate the most relevant physical and technical limitations that arise when pushing for faster and faster gates. With the help of numerical optimization techniques, we establish a fundamental bound on the minimal gate time, which is determined independently of the qubit design solely by its nonlinearity. In addition, important practical restrictions arise from the finite qubit transition frequency and the limited bandwidth of the control pulses. We show that, for highly anharmonic flux qubits and commercially available control electronics, elementary single- and two-qubit operations can be implemented in about 100 ps with residual gate errors below ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}4}$. Under the same conditions, we simulate the complete execution of a compressed version of Shor's algorithm for factoring the number 15 in about 1 ns. These results demonstrate that, compared to state-of-the-art implementations with transmon qubits, a hundredfold increase in the speed of gate operations with superconducting circuits is still feasible.

arXiv:2101.05810•Physical Review Applied•Jul 9, 2021•18 citations

Parallelism for quantum computation with qudits

Dianne Prost O’Leary, Gavin K. Brennen, Stephen S. Bullock

Robust quantum computation with $d$-level quantum systems (qudits) poses two requirements: fast, parallel quantum gates and high-fidelity two-qudit gates. We first describe how to implement parallel single-qudit operations. It is by now well known that any single-qudit unitary can be decomposed into a sequence of Givens rotations on two-dimensional subspaces of the qudit state space. Using a coupling graph to represent physically allowed couplings between pairs of qudit states, we then show that the logical depth (time) of the parallel gate sequence is equal to the height of an associated tree. The implementation of a given unitary can then optimize the tradeoff between gate time and resources used. These ideas are illustrated for qudits encoded in the ground hyperfine states of the alkali-metal atoms $^{87}\mathrm{Rb}$ and $^{133}\mathrm{Cs}$. Second, we provide a protocol for implementing parallelized nonlocal two-qudit gates using the assistance of entangled qubit pairs. Using known protocols for qubit entanglement purification, this offers the possibility of high-fidelity two-qudit gates.

arXiv:quant-ph/0603081•Physical Review A•Sep 28, 2006•60 citations
The speed of elementary quantum gates ultimately sets the limit on the speed at which quantum circuits can operate. For a fixed physical interaction strength between two qubits, the speed of any two-qubit gate is limited even with arbitrarily fast single-qubit gates. In this work, we explore the possibilities of speeding up two-qubit gates beyond such a limit by expanding our computational space outside the qubit subspace, which is experimentally relevant for qubits encoded in multi-level atoms or anharmonic oscillators. We identify an optimal theoretical bound for the speed limit of a two-qubit gate achieved using two qudits with a bounded interaction strength and arbitrarily fast single-qudit gates. In addition, we find an experimentally feasible protocol using two parametrically coupled superconducting transmons that achieves this theoretical speed limit in a non-trivial way. We also consider practical scenarios with limited single-qudit drive strengths and off-resonant transitions. For such scenarios, we develop an open-source, machine learning assisted, quantum optimal control algorithm that can achieve a speedup close to the theoretical limit with near-perfect gate fidelity. This work opens up a new avenue to speed up two-qubit gates when the physical interaction strength between qubits cannot be easily increased while extra states outside the qubit subspace can be well controlled.
The speed of elementary quantum gates, particularly two-qubit gates, ultimately sets the limit on the speed at which quantum circuits can operate. In this work, we experimentally demonstrate commonly used two-qubit gates at nearly the fastest possible speed allowed by the physical interaction strength between two superconducting transmon qubits. We achieve this quantum speed limit by implementing experimental gates designed using a machine-learning-inspired optimal control method. Importantly, our method only requires the single-qubit drive strength to be moderately larger than the interaction strength to achieve an arbitrary two-qubit gate close to its analytical speed limit with high fidelity. Thus the method is applicable to a variety of platforms, including those with comparable single-qubit and two-qubit gate speeds, or those with always-on interactions. We expect our method to offer significant speedups for non-native two-qubit gates that are typically achieved with a long sequence of single-qubit and native two-qubit gates.
We consider the implementation of two-qubit gates when the physical systems used to realize the qubits possess additional quantum states in the accessible energy range. We use optimal control theory to determine the maximum achievable gate speed for two-qubit gates in the qubit subspace of the many-level Hilbert space, and we analyze the effect of the additional quantum states on the gate speed. We identify two competing mechanisms. On one hand, higher energy levels are generally more strongly coupled to each other. Under suitable conditions, this stronger coupling can be utilized to make two-qubit gates significantly faster than the reference value based on simple qubits. On the other hand, a weak anharmonicity constrains the speed at which the system can be adequately controlled: according to the intuitive picture, faster operations require stronger control fields, which are more likely to excite higher levels in a weakly anharmonic system, which in turn leads to faster decoherence and uncontrolled leakage outside the qubit space. To account for this constraint, we modify the pulse optimization algorithm to avoid pulses that lead to appreciable population of the higher levels. In this case, we find that the presence of the higher levels can lead to a significant reduction in the maximum achievable gate speed. We also compare the optimal-control gate speeds with those obtained using the cross-resonance or selective-darkening gate protocol. We find that this protocol, with some parameter optimization, can be used to achieve a relatively fast implementation of the controlled-NOT gate. These results can help the search for optimized gate implementations in realistic quantum computing architectures, such as those based on superconducting circuits. They also provide guidelines for desirable conditions on anharmonicity that would allow optimal utilization of the higher levels to achieve fast quantum gates.
The speed of elementary quantum gates sets a limit on the speed at which quantum circuits can be applied and, as a result, the size of the computations that can be performed on a quantum computer. This limitation stems from the fact that present-day quantum hardware systems have finite coherence times that limit the total computation time. The speeds of qubit gates in various hardware settings have been well studied over the past few decades. The recent interest in multi-level quantum systems naturally creates a need for similar investigations of the speeds of multi-level or qudit gates. In this work, we perform an empirical study of the speed limit for the three-level or qutrit CZ gate. Our analysis focuses on a theoretical model for capacitively coupled superconducting transmons but can be extended to other systems. We generate CZ gate protocols using optimal control theory techniques and observe when the fidelity crosses certain thresholds. In addition to the empirical approach, we derive an analytical speed limit for the qutrit CZ gate using traditional quantum speed limit techniques. We compare the speed limits derived using these two different approaches and discuss the gap that remains between them. We also compare the time needed to implement the qutrit CZ gate with its qubit counterpart.
We consider the implementation of two-qubit gates when the physical systems used to realize the qubits are weakly anharmonic and therefore possess additional quantum states in the accessible energy range. We analyze the effect of the additional quantum states on the maximum achievable speed for quantum gates in the qubit state space. By calculating the minimum gate time using optimal control theory, we find that higher energy levels can help make two-qubit gates significantly faster than the reference value based on simple qubits. This speedup is a result of the higher coupling strength between higher energy levels. We then analyze the situation where the pulse optimization algorithm avoids pulses that excite the higher levels. We find that in this case the presence of the additional states can lead to a significant reduction in the maximum achievable gate speed. We also compare the optimal control gate times with those obtained using the cross-resonance/selective-darkening gate protocol. We find that the latter, with some parameter optimization, can be used to achieve a relatively fast implementation of the CNOT gate. These results can help the search for optimized gate implementations in realistic quantum computing architectures, such as those based on superconducting qubits. They also provide guidelines for desirable conditions on anharmonicity that would allow optimal utilization of the higher levels to achieve fast quantum gates.
We discuss the realization of a universal set of ultrafast single- and two-qubit operations with superconducting quantum circuits and investigate the most relevant physical and technical limitations that arise when pushing for faster and faster gates. With the help of numerical optimization techniques, we establish a fundamental bound on the minimal gate time, which is determined independently of the qubit design solely by its nonlinearity. In addition, important practical restrictions arise from the finite qubit transition frequency and the limited bandwidth of the control pulses. We show that, for highly anharmonic flux qubits and commercially available control electronics, elementary single- and two-qubit operations can be implemented in about 100 ps with residual gate errors below ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}4}$. Under the same conditions, we simulate the complete execution of a compressed version of Shor's algorithm for factoring the number 15 in about 1 ns. These results demonstrate that, compared to state-of-the-art implementations with transmon qubits, a hundredfold increase in the speed of gate operations with superconducting circuits is still feasible.
Robust quantum computation with ddd-level quantum systems (qudits) poses two requirements: fast, parallel quantum gates and high-fidelity two-qudit gates. We first describe how to implement parallel single-qudit operations. It is by now well known that any single-qudit unitary can be decomposed into a sequence of Givens rotations on two-dimensional subspaces of the qudit state space. Using a coupling graph to represent physically allowed couplings between pairs of qudit states, we then show that the logical depth (time) of the parallel gate sequence is equal to the height of an associated tree. The implementation of a given unitary can then optimize the tradeoff between gate time and resources used. These ideas are illustrated for qudits encoded in the ground hyperfine states of the alkali-metal atoms 87Rb^{87}\mathrm{Rb}87Rb and 133Cs^{133}\mathrm{Cs}133Cs. Second, we provide a protocol for implementing parallelized nonlocal two-qudit gates using the assistance of entangled qubit pairs. Using known protocols for qubit entanglement purification, this offers the possibility of high-fidelity two-qudit gates.